# Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC June 2018 Memo (English)

> Grade 12 Design Paper 1 memorandum from the NSC June Exam 2018 (English), 18 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.

- Page: https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-may-june-2018-memo-eng/5a423c49-54d7-4176-bf99-5fc43153c434
- Updated: 2026-09-27
- Subject: Design
- Grade: Grade 12
- Document type: Memorandum
- Year: 2018
- Exam period: NSC June Exam
- Paper: 1
- Curriculum: CAPS
- Pages: 18

Breadcrumbs: [Home](https://www.hlayiso.com/) › [Library](https://www.hlayiso.com/library) › [Grade 12](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12) › [Design](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12/design) › [Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC June 2018 Memo (English)](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-may-june-2018-memo-eng/5a423c49-54d7-4176-bf99-5fc43153c434)

## About this document

Design · Grade 12 · NSC June Exam · 2018. Memorandum, 18 pages. Read online or download the PDF.

Read it free online on the page above; download the PDF from there.

## Document text

Text extracted from the PDF. Layout, diagrams and tables may not survive extraction.

### Page 1

Downloaded from hlayiso.com

                     SENIOR CERTIFICATE EXAMINATIONS

                                      DESIGN P1

                                       (THEORY)

                                          2018

                               MARKING GUIDELINES

                                                                       MARKS: 100

                      These marking guidelines consist of 18 pages.

Copyright reserved                                                    Please turn over

### Page 2

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                           2                                      DBE/2018
                                         SCE – Marking Guidelines

SECTION A: DESIGN LITERACY
QUESTION 1: 'UNSEEN' EXAMPLES [10 marks]
Answer EITHER QUESTION 1.1 OR QUESTION 1.2.
1.1         (Allocate a maximum of 2 marks for each bullet/aspect)

            The use of material in this pendant is an unusual combination of copper and
            brass materials that have been forged into contrasting forms.  The material has
            been exposed to heat to make it malleable in order to stretch and shape the
            metal by beating it on a metal block or a mandrel.  The copper has been
            treated to create a patina that makes it appear leather-like to suggest the idea of
            a corset.  The turquoise stone adds variety and contrast in creating a striking
            design. 
            The bronze, copper and turquoise pendant is possibly inspired by the human
            form.  The bronze wire lacing effect in the copper is reminiscent of a woman's
            corset and the blue, oval, turquoise stone implies a human head.  The stone is
            attached to the pendant with a brass piece that looks like the neck and spine of a
            woman. The two curved brass pieces that attach to a chain that fastens around
            the neck could be inspired by clavicle bones. 
            The forging of the metal allows the designer/jeweller to create contrasting forms.
            The organic, copper form that resembles a corset contrasts with the mechanical
            simplified forms in brass resembling the body of a woman.  The repetition of
            the oval form of the stone in the oval loops that attach to the chain creates a
            sense of rhythm.  The form of the pendant as a whole is functional and will
            hang comfortably around the neck of the wearer.
            The focal point is the turquoise stone. Its contrasting oval shape attracts the eye
            immediately.  Additionally, it is the only cool colour in the warm yellow and red
            colour scheme created by the metals.  The horizontally curved line leads the
            eye to the stone. The vertical line of brass that holds the turquoise stone leads
            the eye up to the stone. .
            The cool blue colour of stone contrasts with the warm, yellow brass and red
            copper metals.  The copper has been treated to produce a warm red patina. 
            The warm, yellow brass and red copper metals create a sense of unity.                     [10]
       Q.1.1                                                                              MARKS
                              COGNITIVE SKILLS               WEIGHTING    QUESTIONS
      LEVEL                                                                                (10)
                     Remember, Recall, Recognise                              1.1            2
Lower Order                                                         30%
                     Understand, Explain, Describe                            1.1            1
Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise                     40%       1.1            4
                     Analyse, Interpret                                       1.1            1
Higher Order         Reflect, Judge                                 30%       1.1            1
                     Synthesis                                                1.1            1

                                                      OR

Copyright reserved                                                                  Please turn over

### Page 3

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                            3                                   DBE/2018
                                          SCE – Marking Guidelines

1.2         [Allocate a maximum of 2 marks per design term for a total of 10 marks]

            The composition is made up of many organic lines that could be inspired by the
            Art Nouveau movement's whiplash line.  The curvilinear lines that create
            frames around the mealies derived from the shape of the fibres at the top of each
            mealie and the shape of the mealie-meal bag.  The diamond shape created by
            the lines produces a very dynamic half drop pattern. 
            Variation in tone is created in the design by the rendering technique used on the
            subject matter. A shading technique of fine lines is used to create
            3-dimensionality and variation in tone as the highlighted motifs appear to be
            realistic on a flat dark background.  The shading technique contrasts with the
            flat green background and simplified silhouettes of flying eagles and wings. 
            This contrast also creates a dynamic pattern surface. 
             The subject matter of the wallpaper could possibly be inspired by the Arts
            and Crafts movement that used the everyday fauna and flora  British designers
            found themselves surrounded by subject matter – like strawberries and small
            birds that lived in hedges. Similarly, the South African designer, Quagga, uses as
            subject matter the fauna and flora of South Africa, i.e. a mealie cob grown mostly
            in the Free State and acorns found in the Cape.  The small brown birds of the
            Arts and Crafts movement that live in shrubs are substituted by the South African
            bird of prey, an eagle.  Bags of mealie-meal, a staple diet for many South
            Africans, show the true South African influence. 
            The lines around the mirror image of the mealies and single large acorns create a
            symmetrical balance. The same balance occurs within the mirror image of the
            bags of mealie-meal that are framed with a curving whiplash line.  The
            wallpaper has a drop repeat overall pattern made up of smaller symmetrically
            balanced units.  This symmetrical balance stabilises the movement created by
            all the organic lines. 
            Rhythm is created by the repetition of the pattern units.  The shape of the
            mealie kernels is repeated with the small dots that diminish in size, enclosed
            between the double outline at the top of the mealies, also creating a rhythm. 
            The alternating direction and size of oak tree leaves that are arranged diagonally
            create a rhythmic vertically arranged pattern.                                          [10]
       Q.1.2                                                                                MARKS
                              COGNITIVE SKILLS                 WEIGHTING   QUESTIONS
      LEVEL                                                                                  (10)
                     Remember, Recall, Recognise                               1.2             1
Lower Order                                                          30%
                     Understand, Explain, Describe, Classify                   1.2             2
Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise                      40%       1.2             4
                     Analyse, Interpret                                        1.2             1
Higher Order         Reflect, Judge                                  30%       1.2             1
                     Synthesis, Justify                                        1.2             1

Copyright reserved                                                                Please turn over

### Page 4

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                           4                                        DBE/2018
                                         SCE – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 2: COMMUNICATION THROUGH DESIGN [10 marks]

2.1         (Allocate 6 marks)
            The fist  placed above Mandela's head is a symbol of power and resistance. 
            The white doves  in the two top corners above the bullets are symbols of love
            and peace.  The ballot box  with paper with a cross on, in the rectangle in
            the middle of the top quarter of the poster, is a symbol of democracy.  The
            horns  jutting out on either side above the images of Mandela and Charlize
            could be symbols of Africa with the kudu being so abundant in Africa.  The red
            hearts  placed next to the bullets are symbols of love.  The cranes  in each
            corner at the bottom of the poster could symbolise development and industry. 
            Black and white hands  holding each other symbolise unity and harmony
            between the two races. 
            Credit must be given to any other valid symbols and their meanings.                          (6)

2.2         (Allocate 4 marks)
            The poster reflects 'cultural diversity' as it makes use of images and symbols
            that refer to various races, cultures and subcultures that form part of the broader
            community of South Africa.  The round discs with triangular patterns refer to the
            earrings of the Zulu culture and the image of Charlize Theron could refer to the
            Western culture.  Kwaito is a form of music that belongs to a specific subculture
            in South Africa.  Various images refer to the different races that form part of our
            society, for example, the black and white hands holding each other and the white
            faces emerging from a sky with clouds above the head of Mandela.  The poster
            puts all these images together to form a balanced and unified whole. The
            message communicated is that unity can be achieved even though South Africa
            is culturally so diverse.  The fact that these images are placed to form a
            symmetrical whole conveys a sense of order and balance.  The use of bright
            colours, like yellow, red, green and blue communicate happiness and vibrancy. 
            Credit must be given to any other valid statements.                                          (4)
                                                                                                         [10]

       Q.2                                                                                      MARKS
                              COGNITIVE SKILLS                 WEIGHTING   QUESTIONS
      LEVEL                                                                                      (10)
                     Remember, Recall, Recognise, Name                          2.1                3
Lower Order                                                         30%
                     Understand, Explain, Describe, Classify
                                                                                2.1                3
Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise                     40%
                                                                                2.2                1
                     Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                2.2                3
Higher Order                                                        30%
                     Evaluate, Reflect, Judge

Copyright reserved                                                                    Please turn over

### Page 5

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                          5                                        DBE/2018
                                        SCE – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 3 [10 marks]
Answer EITHER QUESTION 3.1 OR QUESTION 3.2.
3.1         [10 marks] (Allocate a maximum of 2 marks for each bullet/aspect)

            FIGURE D is possibly influenced by the geometric lines, forms and patterns of
            other traditional African wooden carved products and sculptures (credit can also
            be given if learners refer to the use of geometric lines by the Art Nouveau
            designer, Mackintosh),  whereas FIGURE E's lines and shapes are reminiscent
            of the curvilinear lines used in Victorian and Art Nouveau combs.
            Both combs are used to decorate the hair.  FIGURE D also functions as a
            ceremonial gift to acknowledge an imminent wedding  whilst FIGURE E is worn
            as decoration during a wedding and other occasions, like a matric dance
            function.  The shiny quality of FIGURE E signifies that it is probably used for
            smart evening functions. 
            The texture in FIGURE D is a combination of smooth and tactile surface detail.
             The horizontal bands show inscribed/engraved texture that contrasts with the
            smooth surface texture of the vertical 'bristles' of the comb that create a dramatic
            contrast.  The variety of materials used in FIGURE E show tactile texture
            conveying lively movement and femininity.  The smoothness of the pearls
            contrasts with the diamond encrusted, rough texture of the decorative curvilinear
            motifs. 
            FIGURE D combines rigid, horizontal, stylised, incised diamond decorative
            patterns with vertical, twirling, knotted strips,  whereas FIGURE E uses of
            glittering, diamond-like stones and shiny pearls to form organic, leaf-like spiralling
            decorative patterns.  FIGURE D is simplified and geometric in comparison to
            the complex, 'over the top' glitter appeal of FIGURE E. 
            FIGURE D is carved out of wood which gives it an organic, handcrafted character
             whereas FIGURE E consists of synthetic materials, like plastic, synthetic
            pearls and imitation diamonds typical of costume jewellery.  FIGURE D has a
            durable quality whereas FIGURE E seems more fragile and breakable. 
            Credit must be given to any other valid statements.
            NOTE: A maximum of ONLY 3 marks may be allocated for tabular comparison
            responses. Use the cognitive levels as guidelines.                                          [10]
       Q.3.1                                                                              MARKS
                         COGNITIVE SKILLS             WEIGHTING        QUESTIONS
      LEVEL                                                                                (10)
                     Remember, Recall, Recognise                            3.1              1
Lower Order                                               30%
                     Understand, Explain, Describe                          3.1              2
Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise           40%               3.1              4
                     Analyse, Compare, Interpret                            3.1              2
Higher Order         Evaluate, Reflect                    30%
                     Create, Synthesise                                     3.1               1
                                               OR

Copyright reserved                                                                   Please turn over

### Page 6

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                         6                                        DBE/2018
                                       SCE – Marking Guidelines

3.2         [10 marks] (Allocate a maximum of 2 marks for each bullet/aspect.)

            The function of the contemporary Synagogue in Mainz, seen in FIGURE G, is
            not at first evident as it is an unconventional, unique and modern structure which
            does not refer to traditional temple forms in any way.  The temple of Bacchus in
            FIGURE F, on the other hand, is a familiar temple form and it is clearly a religious
            space in which to worship.  FIGURE G combines public functions with religious
            functions. The orientation of the building in FIGURE G towards the East allows
            for two squares or open spaces to be created: an internal community garden
            functions as a place for recreation and celebration and a public square in front of
            the main entrance, facing towards the city centre, creates an open space for the
            neighbourhood within a densely built-up urban area.  This synagogue complex
            in FIGURE G also functions as a place for adult education and a Hebrew school
            for children. The absence of any kind of gating or barriers means that it functions
            as a truly public space that is used for everyday activities, rare for a religious
            building, especially for a synagogue, in Germany. 
            The monumental, rectangular, simple structure of FIGURE F is situated on an
            immense raised plaza.  The entablature rests on forty-two 19 m high, upright,
            unfluted Corinthian columns, banded together with iron, creating a typically
            classical structure dominated by horizontals and verticals.  The structure of
            FIGURE G is, on the other hand, far more complex consisting of a very jagged
            and angular façade.  The form is abstractly based on the Hebrew word for
            blessing and is curved around the public courtyard.  The structure uses a
            perspectival play of three-dimensionality using multiple perspectives with the
            windows representing their vanishing points. 
            A variety of natural materials were used in the structure of FIGURE F. The
            columns, bases and capitals are made of limestone while the shafts are made of
            polished red Egyptian granite that supports the richly carved entablature.  On
            the inside, the cella is decorated with Corinthian 'half-columns' flanking two levels
            of niches on each side, containing mosaic scenes of the birth and life of Bacchus.
            It is thought that the columns were erected in a rough state and only rounded off
            and polished once in place.  The spatial quality of FIGURE G is enhanced by
            the use of repeated strips of transparent green ceramic tiles, which reflects the
            changing light conditions of its surroundings and creates a wide array of hues
            and shades. 
Copyright reserved                                                                  Please turn over

### Page 7

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                            7                                      DBE/2018
                                          SCE – Marking Guidelines

            The basilica style temple of Bacchus in FIGURE F, situated within the temple
            complex of Baalbek is one of the best preserved and grandest Roman temple
            ruins in the world. Influenced by the Ancient Greek and Mycenae architecture it
            is thought to have been constructed between 50 and 250 CE.  The alternating
            high and low pointed shape of the Mainz Synagogue in FIGURE G is inspired by
            Hebrew writing and its relationship to space.  In order to integrate this Jewish
            community centre (synagogue) into the residential neighbourhood of the Mainzer
            Neustadt that dates back to the late 19th century, the architect is also influenced
            by the use of a 'perimeter block pattern or enclosed courtyard' (Perimeter
            Building/Blockrandbebauung) which is a dominant architectural style in this urban
            area.  Its jagged, fragmented structure also reflects the influence of the
            Deconstructivists' use of unstable, geometric fragmentation. 

            The temple of Bacchus is known for its impressive dimensions, richly decorated
            stone work and monumental gate with Bacchic styled figures.  Enriched by
            some of the most refined reliefs and sculpture to survive from antiquity, the
            decorative stone carving on the architrave and frieze include rows of lions and
            bulls, which were motifs symbolically associated with the two deities. Its
            ornamentation served as an influential model for Neoclassical architecture in the
            18th century.  The technology needed to create the architrave structure is
            evidence of the Roman engineering capabilities. Blocks weighing from 66 tons to
            100 tons were raised 19m above ground level using cranes and earthen banks to
            roll the blocks of limestone into position.  The decoration of the synagogue in
            FIGURE G is far more uniform and simple than that of the temple in FIGURE F.
             The surface is covered completely in strips of glazed ceramic tiles. This
            surface as well as the various angles of the walls creates a visually exciting
            decorative, rippled and three-dimensional effect. 

            Credit must be given to any other valid statements or a comparison of a
            Classical and contemporary building that the candidate has studied.
            NOTE: A maximum of ONLY 3 marks may be allocated to tabular comparison
            responses. Use the cognitive levels as guidelines.

     Q.3.2                                                                                   MARKS
                              COGNITIVE SKILLS                 WEIGHTING   QUESTIONS
    LEVEL                                                                                     (10)
                     Remember, Recall, Recognise                               3.2              1
Lower Order                                                          30%
                     Understand, Explain, Describe, Classify                   3.2              2
Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise                      40%       3.2              4
                     Analyse, Compare, Interpret                               3.2              1
Higher Order         Evaluate, Reflect                               30%       3.2              1
                     Create, Synthesise, Justify                               3.2              1

                                                                           TOTAL SECTION A:             30

Copyright reserved                                                                   Please turn over

### Page 8

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                         8                                          DBE/2018
                                       SCE – Marking Guidelines

SECTION B: DESIGN HISTORY

QUESTION 4 [30 marks]

4.1         Allocate 20 marks in total.
            Allocate 10 marks for each movement. Note that ONLY ONE mark can be
            allocated for the name of a designer and product of each movement.
            Use the cognitive levels as guidelines.

            This marking guideline supplies an answer for the following two possibilities:

            •   Neo-Classicism
            •   Deconstructivism

            Neo-Classical designs aim to create simplified and ordered buildings or
            products that are balanced, calm and stable.  They are influenced by the
            Classical ideals of the Greek and Roman eras.  The designs reflect a revival of
            Classical building elements such as the column, colonnade, arch, pediment,
            entablature and portico.  The aim is to use these elements to create
            harmonious, ordered structures that exude a sense of control, clarity and dignity.
             Neo-Classical design is a deliberate reaction to the excesses of Rococo
            design. The focus is now on ideals of virtue, honour, moral principles and
            responsibility. 

            Characteristic of this movement is the depiction of medallions, vine leaves,
            scrolls, Classic vases, natural elements and characters from ancient mythology,
            such as sphinxes and griffins.  Typical of Neo-Classical buildings is the fact that
            they are mostly white which adds to the sense of purity and stillness.  Columns
            are tall – almost to the full height of the building and repetition of these columns
            and colonnades is extreme, adding a sense of grandeur.  Compositions are
            symmetrically balanced with an emphasis on proportion. 

            The USA Congress building by Thornton, Latrobe and Bulfinch,  America,
            1793–1830, expresses this simplicity and clarity very well.  It has a
            completely white exterior, typical of Neo-Classicism, exuding calmness and
            purity.  The design has an impressive dome and possesses an oculus similar to
            the Pantheon. Typical of Neo-Classicism is the repetition of tall columns and
            colonnades conveying order and stability. 

Copyright reserved                                                                 Please turn over

### Page 9

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                            9                                       DBE/2018
                                          SCE – Marking Guidelines

            Deconstructivist designs aim to subvert traditional ways of seeing and
            depicting.  They aim to pull things apart and to investigate the relationships
            between the different components of a building or product.  Their works are
            distorted, fragmented and re-assembled to illuminate new relationships which
            appear unstable and disrupted.  The viewer is invited to find meaning in chaos,
            imbalance and disintegration.  These designs exaggerate and dramatise. 

            Deconstructivism influence grew out of the writings of the French philosopher,
            Jacques Derrida, and his theory of deconstruction which states that
            deconstruction is evident at all levels of life and is the result of the interaction of
            opposites which exists in an unstable environment. Other influences on
            Deconstructivist designs are the faceting of Cubism as well as the faceting,
            geometrising and emphasis on dynamism of Futurism. The exploring of
            meaning to be found in non-aesthetic materials of Dada is another influence. 
            Deconstructivism rejects the functionalism of Modernism as cold and
            impersonal. Instead of an authoritarian design formula, creativity, variety and
            individuality are emphasised. 

            Characteristic of Deconstructivism is the use of displaced and distorted,
            angular, geometric forms creating a sense of dynamism and visual chaos.  The
            overall form is fragmented, conveying uncertainty, unease or disruption.  The
            structure rejects pure function and traditional ideas of harmony, unity and
            stability. 

            An example of Deconstructivism is Frank Gehry's 'Foundation Louis Vuitton
            Contemporary Art and Performance Space'.  The building appears as a
            series of planes of steel and glass that have been pulled apart to reveal what lies
            beneath the surface.  The planes lie in different directions, in line with the
            Deconstructivist theory of interaction of opposites, to reflect a naturally unstable
            environment.  This adds to the feeling of movement and space within the
            design.  Twelve separate 'sails' encase the building, obscuring its function. 
            In this way the design rejects pure function and the traditional ideas of harmony,
            unity and stability.  The building has been described as a 'cathedral of light' and
            a 'glass cloud'.                                                                            (20)

     Q.4.1                                                                                     MARKS
                              COGNITIVE SKILLS                 WEIGHTING       QUESTIONS
    LEVEL                                                                                       (20)
                     Remember, Recall, Recognise, Name                             4.1            2
Lower Order                                                          30%
                     Understand, Explain, Describe, Classify                       4.1            4
Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise                      40%           4.1            8
                     Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                   4.1            2
Higher Order         Evaluate, Reflect                               30%           4.1            1
                     Create, Synthesise, Justify                                   4.1            3

Copyright reserved                                                                    Please turn over

### Page 10

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                           10                                    DBE/2018
                                          SCE – Marking Guidelines

4.2         [10 marks] (Allocate a maximum of 2 marks for each bullet/aspect.)

            Both cars are inspired by the machine-age.  The sleek, elongated form of the
            Bugatti type 57 shows Art Deco's interest in Machine Age, streamlined forms 
            and the Cadillac Eldorado's use of fins seems to be inspired by the Modernist's
            interest in the use of fish forms to depict speed. 

            Art Deco designers aim to create escapist, glamorous, luxury items.  The
            Bugatti Type 57 clearly reflects this aim as it is a large, luxury car designed for
            comfortable travel.  The Cadillac Eldorado is also a luxury car but the Pop Era's
            aim to reflect the popular, everyday culture of the time can be seen in the fact
            that it is exudes a less serious, more fun mood than the Bugatti. 

            The Bugatti is made up of long, sleek curvilinear lines that help to depict both
            speed and elegance.  The Cadillac Eldorado's lines are also long and
            streamlined but they do not end in bulbous curves – instead, they are more
            angular and sharp exuding energy and fun. 

            The forms of the Bugatti Type 57 car are solid and heavy contributing to its
            grand and powerful appearance  whereas the forms of the Eldorado Cadillac
            are more linear, rectangular and light.  The bulbous, curving bonnet of the
            Bugatti could be inspired by the organic forms of Art Nouveau as well as by the
            teardrop forms resulting from the study of aero-dynamics.  The Cadillac, on the
            other hand, consists of flatter, rectangular forms possibly inspired by the Machine
            Age. 

            The Bugatti's deep red and cream colour-scheme is typical of Art Deco's use of
            dramatic, theatrical colour and exudes pomp and splendour.  The pale pink of
            the Cadillac, on the other hand, is light-hearted.  It is reminiscent of ice-cream
            and popular plastic products and reflects the Pop Era's love for the new, artificial
            range of colours that became possible in paint production. 

            Credit must be given to any other valid statements.
            NOTE: A maximum of ONLY 3 marks may be allocated for tabular comparison
            responses. Use the cognitive levels as guidelines.                                        (10)
    Q.4.2                     COGNITIVE SKILLS                  WEIGHTING      QUESTIONS      MARKS
   LEVEL                                                                                       (10)
 Lower Order         Remember, Recall, Recognise, Name               30%           4.2           1
                     Understand, Explain, Describe, Classify                       4.2           2
 Middle Order        Apply, Implement, Organise                      40%           4.2           4
 Higher Order        Analyse, Compare, Interpret                     30%           4.2           1
                     Evaluate, Reflect, Judge                                      4.2           1
                     Create, Synthesise, Justify                                   4.2           1

                                                                            TOTAL SECTION B:          30

Copyright reserved                                                                 Please turn over

### Page 11

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                       11                                        DBE/2018
                                      SCE – Marking Guidelines

SECTION C:           DESIGN   IN  A   SOCIOCULTURAL/ENVIRONMENTAL                         AND
                     SUSTAINABLE CONTEXT
QUESTION 5 [20 marks]
Answer EITHER QUESTION 5.1 OR QUESTION 5.2.
5.1         5.1.1     (Allocate 6 marks)

                       • Use of imagery (Allocate 2 marks)
                      The social message in the posters above is communicated effectively
                       by the images of emaciated models, portrayed in poses similar to
                       those used by models in high end fashion magazines.  The Masai
                       models pose with expensive superficial products associated with
                       Western daily life that are not a necessity in their day to day living. 
                       The use of font (words written) allows easy understanding of the
                       message. 
                       • Colour (Allocate 2 marks)
                       The Masai models are set against a brown, dreary, barren landscape
                       that depicts drought and may also suggest famine.  The products
                       that the Masai models are holding on display are catching the eye
                       because of the shiny and sparkling yellow light reflected by the sun on
                       the plastic material of the sunglasses  and the plastic lid of the
                       aftershave.  The use of colour in the message (the words) stands
                       out. 
                       • Use of juxtaposition (Allocate 2 marks)
                       The models pose with expensive bling products associated with a
                       fashionable glamorous Westernised existence. However, the Masai
                       models show physical signs of poverty and malnourishment.  The
                       contrast between the monetary value of the fashion items that the
                       models pose with and that of common basic necessities (clean water,
                       shelter and food) is further emphasised by the written caption.  This
                       highlights the difference in terms of what money is spent on in first
                       world countries and what that kind of financial facility might mean in
                       third world countries. 
                       Credit any other valid statements.                                             (6)

Copyright reserved                                                                 Please turn over

### Page 12

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                      12                                       DBE/2018
                                     SCE – Marking Guidelines

            5.1.2     Allocate 14 marks in total, 7 marks per case study.
                      Allocate 1 mark for the name of the designer and the name of the
                      product.
                      ONE CONTEMPORARY SOUTH AFRICAN DESIGNER/DESIGN
                      GROUP

                     • Aims that relate to the concept of sociocultural design
                     Aims of the Lumkani fire alarm is to address/alleviate/improve issues
                     in society that affect the quality of peoples' lives.  The Lumkani fire
                     alarm is designed for the informal settlements of South Africa, where
                     crowded conditions and open fires used for cooking can result in
                     house fires.  Fires can easily spread from house to house,
                     devastating and displacing entire communities. 
                     • Name and discuss a designer/design group and ONE of
                        his/her/their products that reflects social responsibility
                     Lumkani Fire Alarm by Socio Tech Institute 
                     The Lumkani fire alarm was designed in 2015 by SocioTech Institute.
                     It has a cellular and radio network built in, which alerts neighbours
                     within a 60-metre radius of the location of the fire, through an audio
                     alarm and SMS messages, so the community can respond quickly to
                     extinguish a fire.  Shelters and shacks in informal settlements are
                     built by hand out of readily available materials that are often highly
                     flammable.  In addition, these shacks are also often built very close
                     together, hence creating optimal conditions for the rapid spreading of
                     a fire.  Because of the unplanned nature of informal settlements,
                     these communities are also rarely mapped out making it exceptionally
                     difficult for rescue services to identify the affected places and respond
                     promptly to a fire. 
                      ONE INTERNATIONAL DESIGNER/DESIGN GROUP

                     • Aims that relate to the concept of sociocultural design
                      Vestergaard LifeStraw is developed to filter out virtually all of the
                      microbiological contaminants that make water unsafe to drink.  The
                      technology is a personal 'straw-like' filter. It helps people in
                      developing countries who do not have running water piped in from
                      municipal sources and also gives access to safe water in emergency
                      settings following natural disasters when water is contaminated. 

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 13

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                           13                                      DBE/2018
                                          SCE – Marking Guidelines

                         • Name and discuss a designer/design group and ONE of
                            his/her/their products that reflects social responsibility
                         Lifestraw by Vestergaard 
                         The LifeStraw was developed by Vestergaard in 1994. It is a filter that
                         can remove Guinea worm larvae from water it is contaminating. This
                         cloth filter later evolved into a more effective pipe form in 1999. 
                         Today more than 37 million LifeStraw Guinea Worm filters have
                         contributed to the near-eradication of the disease. 
                         The LifeStraw team is committed to redefining the safe drinking water
                         space through technology innovation and product quality and design.
                          In doing so, our work is driving sustainable access to safe drinking
                         water by engaging governments, donors, and individual consumers to
                         understand the problem and become an active part of the solution. 
                         Vestergaard recognised that, while the LifeStraw technology was
                         effective for many uses, innovation around product design was
                         important to meet the needs of different groups of people.  In 2008,
                         LifeStraw technology was adapted for in-home use and the LifeStraw
                         Family water purifier was developed to purify larger volumes of
                         water. 
                         The LifeStraw portfolio has continued to evolve to include the high-
                         volume LifeStraw Community purifier for institutional settings like
                         schools and clinics (introduced in 2013),  the LifeStraw Go refillable
                         water bottle (2014) and LifeStraw Mission, a high-volume, collapsible
                         bag ideal for campsites, group hikes and expeditions launched in
                         2015. 
                         A portion of the proceeds of consumer sales for any LifeStraw product
                         anywhere in the world goes toward the purchase of LifeStraw
                         Community purifiers which are distributed to schools in developing
                         communities.  As a result, each consumer purchase provides one
                         school child in a developing community with safe water for an entire
                         school year. 
                         LifeStraw is ideal for hiking, backpacking, camping, travel and
                         emergency preparedness.  The straw-style filter design lets you turn
                         up to 1 000 litres of contaminated water into safe drinking water. 
                         It lets you drink directly from streams and lakes or from any container.
                          Uses advanced hollow fibre membrane technology to filter up to
                         264 gallons or 1 000 litres of water to 0,2 microns. It removes
                         99,9999% of waterborne bacteria, including E. coli and salmonella
                         and 99,9% waterborne protozoa, including Giardia and
                         Cryptosporidium. 
                                                                                                       (14)
                         Credit any other valid statements.
                                                                                                       [20]
    Q.5.1                      COGNITIVE SKILLS                      WEIGHTING   QUESTIONS     MARKS
   LEVEL                                                                                        (20)
 Lower Order         Remember, Recall, Recognise, Name                 30%          5.1.1         2
                     Understand, Explain, Describe, Classify                        5.1.2         4
 Middle Order        Apply, Implement, Organise                        40%          5.1.1         4
                                                                                    5.1.2         4
 Higher Order        Analyse, Compare, Interpret                       30%          5.1.2         3
                     Evaluate, Reflect, Judge                                       5.1.2         2
                     Create, Synthesise, Justify                                    5.1.2         1

Copyright reserved                                                                  Please turn over

### Page 14

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                       14                                           DBE/2018
                                      SCE – Marking Guidelines

                                                 OR

5.2         5.2.1     (Allocate 10 marks, 2 marks per requirement)

                      XHOSA BEADWORK
                      • History and social functions
                      Beadwork is used in African society as a means of social
                      differentiation; used to portray the social role, life stage, spiritual state
                      or marital status of the wearer within his/her community.  Beaded
                      objects also form an important part of traditional African dress and for
                      special occasions such as weddings and festivals. 
                      • Materials, methods and processes
                      The materials utilised in traditional Xhosa beadwork are animal sinew
                      and glass beads of which the white beads were favoured.  Pins
                      used to attach the finished product to the garment are also used. 
                      Generally the brick or diamond stitching method is used to create
                      precise, geometric patterns and shapes. 
                      • A discussion of ONE example and the name(s) of the
                         indigenous cultural community or craftsperson that produced
                         it.
                      The keeper-of-the-heart necklace by the Xhosa cultural community. 
                      The keeper-of-the-heart necklace is a small beaded panel necklace
                      commonly worn by Xhosa women around their necks communicating
                      how they feel about themselves.  The necklace has a front square
                      or rectangular panel on which there appears a stylised human figure
                      in coded form.  The pose of the stylised figure tells us that the
                      wearer considers themselves to be either hardworking, a good dancer
                      and in some instances too old to dance.  The keeper-of-the-heart
                      necklace is sometimes also worn by men, indicating that the wife is
                      either a good dancer, hard worker or a good housekeeper. 
                      • The value of practising this craft in contemporary South Africa
                      Practising traditional craft in contemporary South Africa helps to keep
                      the craft alive and in this way preserves African traditional practices
                      and culture.  The practice also creates economic prospects for the
                      designer and also gives the designer an opportunity to empower
                      his/her community.  This is achieved by imparting skills to the
                      community that can potentially improve the economic situation of the
                      community. 
                      Credit any other valid statements.                                                (10)

Copyright reserved                                                                   Please turn over

### Page 15

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                           15                                       DBE/2018
                                          SCE – Marking Guidelines

            5.2.2        (Allocate 10 marks)

                         • Name of designer/group and his/her/their design product(s)
                         Xhosa-inspired beadwork iPhone case, Vukile Batyi and Laduma
                         Ngxokolo 
                         • A discussion of how traditional techniques/methods and
                            material have been applied to contemporary design. Refer to
                            specific examples to support your statements
                         The Xhosa beadwork-inspired iPhone case cover is designed using
                         glass beads, drawing on traditional beading techniques to create a
                         21st century ubiquitous accessory.  iPhone cases are as popular as
                         the iPhone itself.  iPhone cases are a fashionable add-on that
                         shields iPhones from screen and moisture damage.  Inspired by his
                         late aunt, Batyi draws on traditional beading skills to create one-of-a-
                         kind, bright and bold designs for the South African and international
                         market. 
                         • Discuss whether this/these product(s) make(s) a sociocultural
                            contribution
                         The patterns in which the beads have been laid out are predominantly
                         used in and found in Xhosa culture.  The use of a traditional
                         technique to adorn and protect a technological gadget creates a
                         contrast of opposites, a new age digital accessory decorated and
                         protected by an old fashioned handmade element.  The use of
                         Xhosa-inspired patterns for a contemporary design is a way of
                         celebrating previously marginalised societies by acknowledging the
                         contribution to the design world.  Traditional designers whose work
                         influenced these covers can be paid royalties for the designs thus
                         creating jobs for people from a traditional background.  Durable               (10)
                         traditional Xhosa beadwork technique is used by local skilled South             [20]
                         African artisans, thus providing a platform for them to sell their quality
                         items to local and international buyers. 

     Q.5.2                                                                                      MARKS
                              COGNITIVE SKILLS                  WEIGHTING       QUESTIONS
    LEVEL                                                                                        (20)
                                                                                    5.2.1          2
                     Remember, Recall, Recognise, Name
                                                                                    5.2.2          1
Lower Order                                                          30%
                                                                                    5.2.1          2
                     Understand, Explain, Describe, Classify
                                                                                    5.2.2          1
                                                                                    5.2.1          4
Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise                      40%
                                                                                    5.2.2          4
                     Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                    5.2.2          2
Higher Order         Evaluate, Reflect                               30%            5.2.1          2
                     Create, Synthesise, Justify                                    5.2.2          2

Copyright reserved                                                                    Please turn over

### Page 16

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                       16                                      DBE/2018
                                      SCE – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 6 [20 marks]

6.1         6.1.1      (Allocate 4 marks)
                       The environmental warning in FIGURE K warns people of the dangers
                       caused by plastic pollution of the ocean.  The poster creates
                       awareness of the impact of plastic pollution on the environment of the
                       sea. This affects the quality of the water supply contained in the
                       ocean, as well as the lifespan of ocean animals and marine plants. 
                       In humans, plastic pollution can result in severe reactions and illness
                       through physical contact or ingestion of water or food from the ocean.
                        The strength of the message is enhanced with the use of a font
                       which is bold, sans serif and uppercase.  The image of delicious
                       sushi rolls where plastic replaces the seaweed strongly highlights the
                       message of environmental pollution getting out of hand. 
                       Credit any other valid statements.                                           (4)

            6.1.2      (Allocate 2 marks)
                       Yes, visually shocking images in a poster campaign can impact on
                       and change people's perceptions of,  for example the impact of
                       pollution could encourage them to change their habits after seeing
                       shocking images. 
                                                         OR
                       No, poster campaigns are sometimes not effective in bringing about a
                       change in people's behaviour, because people forget the message of
                       the poster as soon as they walk away from it.  Out of sight, out of
                       mind is often the people's reaction.  Legislation should be tightened
                       in various countries to enforce stricter laws regarding issues that
                       impact the environment. 
                       Credit any other valid statements.                                           (2)

6.2         (Allocate 14 marks in total, 7 marks per case study)

            EXAMPLE OF A SOUTH AFRICAN ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGNER/DESIGN
            GROUP

            Name of the design company: ZETU, name of the shoe: Izimbadada 
            The owner of ZETU, a company that manufacturers shoes in rural KwaZulu-
            Natal, and a shoe designer, Reggie Xaba, aims to be fashionable, stylish and
            edgy whilst embracing their Africaness.  Izimbadada shoes were made popular
            by Mbaqanga and Maskandi (South African music genres with rural Zulu roots)
            musicians who prefer them for their durability when performing Zulu dancing. 
            The design of the shoe is inspired by the familiar African surroundings, like the
            dusty terrains of KwaZulu-Natal, the bustling streets of Johannesburg, Lagos,
            and Nairobi or of any other African city. 

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 17

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                        17                                        DBE/2018
                                       SCE – Marking Guidelines

            These rubber sandals, made entirely from the tread of old tyres were originally
            worn by people from rural areas who moved to cities to settle in hostels, but has
            since penetrated the broader spectrum of society as a fashion item.  The shoes
            are made heavy and sturdy because Zulu dancing involves a lot of hard stomping
            that is quite hard on the feet.  The lighter versions of the traditional handcrafted
            sandal use modern materials and cutting methods and are decorated with trendy
            and original patterns.  While the sandals have a distinguishable sole made from
            car tyres, designs differ and are often custom-made according to the buyer's
            request.  The sandals are comfortable and trendy, with a re-imagined aesthetic
            of traditional wear.  This can include cow hide embellished straps to straps that
            are beaded or embroidered. 

            The creation of these products helps the environment to be cleaner as they are
            manufactured from waste material.  These tyres were supposed to be disposed
            on the landfills but instead they have received a new life as shoes.  The rubber
            salvaged from the tyres also reduces the carbon footprint on the environment. 
            Tyres are non-renewable resources  with the majority of people and the
            commercial transportation industries discarding their old tyres in landfills. The use
            of these tyres as materials in the design of products helps minimise waste and
            the negative impact on the environment. 

            EXAMPLE OF AN INTERNATIONAL DESIGNER
            (Allocate 7 marks per case study)

            Name of the designer: Laurence Brabant, name of the product: Cold Cuts 
            The Cold Cuts collection by Laurence Brabant takes recycled wine bottles and
            turns them into serving ware and glasses.  Their aim is to produce
            unpretentious discreet designs through sophisticated, functional, simple objects.
             The wine bottles are cut and chamfered. Laurence Brabant, uses renewable
            woods like beech and cork to craft the handles. 
            All Laurence Brabant Editions are handmade in their studio.  No moulds or
            modifications are used. Each piece is unique being made in one go that requires
            seasoned skill and concentration.  A recycled wine bottle is chosen as a
            material, for it enables Laurence to produce designs that were otherwise limited
            by pipe blowing.  These pieces are heat-resistant and deceivingly durable.
            Laurence Brabant has managed to create some unique designs that stand out
            from ordinary recycled bottles. Brabant created unique kitchen utensils like some
            classy wine glasses and some cute and attractive glasses and more. 

Copyright reserved                                                                  Please turn over

Text truncated here. Open the document page to read the rest.

## Related documents

- [Design P1 May June 2018 Memo Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-may-june-2018-memo-afr/6a172732-7328-4649-b8c5-6e279c606f73) — Design · Memo · 2018 · Afr
- [Design P1 May June 2018 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-may-june-2018-afr/03c4bac8-306f-4032-91bb-67f8dd0d185e) — Design · QP · 2018 · Afr
- [Design P1 May June 2018 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-may-june-2018-eng/52ea804b-0b18-4587-aec2-d9a283c0970e) — Design · QP · 2018 · Eng
- [DESIGN P1 GR12 MEMO SEPT2018 Afrikaans](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-gr12-memo-sept2018-afrikaans/9f429249-e5ba-4d49-a678-895047ecaf8a) — Design · Memo · 2018 · Afr
- [DESIGN P1 GR12 MEMO SEPT2018 English](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-gr12-memo-sept2018-english/4692b2c3-52de-4a8b-9723-d1c7c2b48ee9) — Design · Memo · 2018 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2018 FINAL Memo Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2018-final-memo-eng/7d38596e-8011-4dbd-addb-c69766e3bc61) — Design · Memo · 2018 · Eng

## More from Grade 12 Design

- [Gr 12 Des ATP 2023-24](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/gr-12-des-atp-2023-24/0fd522c6-2d5a-4c5b-9e0b-06e7b199eb25) — ATP
- [Design P1 May-June 2025 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-may-june-2025-afr/e35d300a-db4f-4a06-ba8a-6f659dbd37ad) — QP · 2025 · Afr
- [Design P1 Nov 2025 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12-design-2025-nsc-november-exam-question-paper-paper-1/3f14a710-b913-44a8-ade1-31e4d395f557) — QP · 2025 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2025 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12-design-2025-nsc-november-exam-question-paper-paper-1/47ba80e3-12dd-4fd4-8302-34e3b97a6b9a) — QP · 2025 · Afr
- [Design P1 Nov 2024 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2024-eng/3f0bd4c5-8226-45ef-87fa-5c9996cba696) — QP · 2024 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2024 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2024-afr/6958913b-f502-40d3-8387-1f0a78a3ed25) — QP · 2024 · Afr

## Collection

- [Grade 12 past papers](https://www.hlayiso.com/grade-12/past-papers)

---

Hlayiso: free CAPS and IEB past papers, memos, notes and study guides for South African learners. When citing, link the page URL above, not a PDF or /api/ URL.
