# Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC November 2018 Memo (English)

> Grade 12 Design Paper 1 memorandum from the NSC November Exam 2018 (English), 22 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.

- Page: https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2018-final-memo-eng/7d38596e-8011-4dbd-addb-c69766e3bc61
- Updated: 2026-09-27
- Subject: Design
- Grade: Grade 12
- Document type: Memorandum
- Year: 2018
- Exam period: NSC November Exam
- Paper: 1
- Curriculum: CAPS
- Pages: 22

Breadcrumbs: [Home](https://www.hlayiso.com/) › [Library](https://www.hlayiso.com/library) › [Grade 12](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12) › [Design](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12/design) › [Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC November 2018 Memo (English)](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2018-final-memo-eng/7d38596e-8011-4dbd-addb-c69766e3bc61)

## About this document

Design · Grade 12 · NSC November Exam · 2018. Memorandum, 22 pages. Read online or download the PDF.

Read it free online on the page above; download the PDF from there.

## Document text

Text extracted from the PDF. Layout, diagrams and tables may not survive extraction.

### Page 1

Downloaded from hlayiso.com

                                    NATIONAL
                               SENIOR CERTIFICATE

                                       GRADE 12

                                      DESIGN P1

                                       (THEORY)

                                   NOVEMBER 2018

                               MARKING GUIDELINES

MARKS: 100

                      These marking guidelines consist of 22 pages.

Copyright reserves                                                    Please turn over

### Page 2

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                     2                            DBE/November 2018
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

SECTION A: DESIGN LITERACY

'UNSEEN' EXAMPLES

ANSWER EITHER QUESTION 1.1 OR QUESTION 1.2.
QUESTION 1 [10 Marks]

1.1 1.1.1 (Allocate 8 marks)

             Colour: The poster in FIGURE A uses a polychromatic scheme consisting of
             bold, warm rusts, olive-green, lime-green and a cool grey-blue creating a fun
             and joyful mood.  These colours echo the poster's title which instructs the
             viewer to 'have fun on foot'.  The colourful images are placed on white
             clouds which heightens their richness.  The whiteness of the clouds speaks
             of purity and freshness.  The white may also be symbolic of the lightness
             (weight-wise) of the sandal. 

             Contrast: The figurative images on the white cloud background are detailed
             and outlined making them stand out.  They contrast with the plain, flat, light
             olive-green background and light turquoise abstract, geometric patterns,
             images of rainbows and scribbly curvilinear patterns.  This contrast
             activates the surface and conveys a sense of festivity.  The designer's use
             of different mediums – the photographed suede and leather of the Tsonga
             Tslops contrast with the cartoon-like illustrations. A further contrast is seen
             in the use of large, three-dimensional typography and smaller, flat or two-
             dimensional words.  The left hand side of the poster has natural images
             (elephant, tree, bird, aloe plant) which contrasts with the right hand side of
             the poster which has mostly man made items (traditional vessels, sandal and
             traditional hat worn by the woman).  The large size of the sandal in the
             middle ground, contrasts with the medium size of the typography in the
             foreground and the small illustrations in the background. Therefore
             highlighting the sandal in the poster. 

             Focal Point: The main focal point is the Tsonga Tslops sandal because it is
             the largest image  and it is in the middle of the composition.  The poster
             used a real photograph of the Tsonga Tslops sandal and the textural
             qualities of the suede and leather that draws your attention.  The bold dark
             brown colour of the sandal is emphasized as it contrasts with the white
             clouds and the bright lime-green of the background. 

             Unity: In FIGURE A, unity is created by the repeated use of rust, olive
             greens, sea green, chocolate brown, grey-blue and white colours. The
             repetition of geometric decorations  and black outlines also unify the work.
              The white clouds on multiple levels hold and unify all the images.  The
             Tsonga Tslops sandal also touches all the clouds and images thus creating
             unity of motifs.  The overlapping of objects unites the illustration. 
Copyright reserved

### Page 3

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                            3                        DBE/November 2018
                                          NSC – Marking Guidelines

     1.1.2 (Allocate 2 marks)
           'Unity in diversity' is achieved in this poster because cultural symbols that
           come from the different cultural groups in South Africa have been used.
           The cultural symbols include the aloe plant which is a sacred plant used in
           communication with the ancestors,  the elephant which is a symbol of
           strength and wisdom to the South African,  the traditional African vessels
           which are often used to store water, beer or fresh produce from the field or
           market and  the Zulu woman dressed in the traditional hat (isicholo) worn
           by married women.  The different symbols signifying the different cultural
           groups in the poster come together on the group of fluffy clouds, in therefore
           the clouds can be seen to represent the unity of the multitude of diverse
           cultural groups in South Africa. 
           Some learners may also argue that the poster only refers to a few
           mainstream cultures and therefore does not express 'unity in diversity'. 

             Credit must be given to any other valid statements.

     Q.1.1               COGNITIVE SKILLS               WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
    LEVEL                                                                    (10)
Lower Order          Remember, Recall, Recognise                      1.1.1           2
                                                             30%
                     Understand, Explain, Describe                    1.1.1           1

Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise              40%      1.1.1           3
                                                                      1.1.2           1
Higher Order         Analyse, Interpret                               1.1.1           2

                     Reflect, Judge                          30%      1.1.2           1

                     Synthesis

                                        OR
1.2 [Allocate a maximum of 2 marks per design term for a total of 10 marks]

      • BIOMIMICRY
        The seat and legs of the chair are organic in form to ensure comfort.  The
        bottom of the hind leg to the top of the back rest emulates the form and
        structure of a reptile from tail to head and helps to strengthen the structure. 
        The cabriole legs mimic the short, stubby curved legs of reptiles. 

      • ERGONOMICS
        The chair reflects the form and proportions of the human body to ensure that it
        supports the human body in a comfortable and safe manner. The height of
        the chair will allow the average person to sit with their feet firmly on the ground
        with their legs bent at the knee at a 45 degree angle. 

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 4

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                            4                     DBE/November 2018
                                          NSC – Marking Guidelines

      • FORM
        In FIGURE B, the chair's form is considered amorphous because it is organic
         and lacks the conventional rectangular form normally associated with a
        chair, a seat with four legs. Instead the chair has three legs and the sitting
        area has a more organic form. The back rest is also amorphous in character
        that shows undulating form reminiscent of carved stone or replicating the form
        of reptile skin. 

      • TEXTURE
        The texture of FIGURE B is actual and tactile.  The back of the chair is
        rough and knobbly and crafted to create a scale-like texture that resembles a
        crocodile reptile. In contrast, the seating area is smooth and polished,
        reminiscent of bone, to assure comfort.

      • BALANCE
        The chair is asymmetrically balanced when viewed from the side profile. This
        enhances the aesthetic experience of the design.  The chair appears to be
        unbalanced with the weight not being proportionally distributed.  If the chair
        is viewed from the front, it appears to be symmetrically balanced with the left
        hand side being a mirror image of the right hand side.  The chair is balanced
        because of the back leg which is thicker. 

         Credit must be given to any other valid statements

     Q.1.2               COGNITIVE SKILLS               WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
    LEVEL                                                                    (10)
Lower Order          Remember, Recall, Recognise                     1.2           1
                                                             30%
                     Understand, Explain, Describe,                  1.2           2
                     Classify

Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise              40%     1.2           4

Higher Order         Analyse, Interpret                              1.2           1

                     Reflect, Judge                          30%     1.2           1

                     Synthesis, Justify                              1.2           1

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 5

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                      5                          DBE/November 2018
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

COMMUNICATION THROUGH DESIGN
QUESTION 2 [10 marks]
2.1 (Allocate 6 marks)

     Images with symbolic meaning include but not restricted to:

      •     The Protea  can be seen to symbolise the natural beauty of South Africa as
            it is our national flower.
      •     The 'Kaapse Klopse' singer in the front is both a symbol of the Cape Malay
            cultural identity and of festivities and celebration of Cape Town. 
      •     The image of Table Mountain  with the sun setting behind is a symbol of the
            wonders of the world as it has been voted one of the Seven Wonders of the
            World. It also is a symbol of South Africa's natural beauty.
      •     The bunch of grapes  symbolises the wine industry in South Africa. 
      •     The Aids ribbon symbolises aids awareness and community
            consciousness.
      •     The Madiba  shirt symbolises pride in the African heritage.
            The circle of pattern around Mandela's head could be seen as a halo and
            gives him a saintly quality.
      •     Mandela is a symbol of peace.  He brought unity and peace to South Africa.
            
      •     The penguin , which symbolises endangered species. 
2.2 Credit must be given to any other valid statements.

     (Allocate 2 marks)
     The colours of the shirt are rich, bright and varied communicating a rich spirit and
     also appear to be a celebration of life. The contrast between the monochromatic
     head of Mandela and the shirt intensifies the brightness of the shirt which draws
     attention to Mandela’s unique dress sense.  The sepia colours used to portray
     Mandela lend a seriousness and gravity to his person,  juxtaposed against the
     colourful shirt that embraces fun and frivolity. 

2.3 (Allocate 2 marks)
    The poster in FIGURE C could be seen to be biased in favour of the Western
    Cape as only the cultures and natural beauty of that province is portrayed. 
    None of the other cultural symbols and natural beauties from other provinces is
    portrayed.  Mandela is perceived as an inclusive figure that promotes cultural
    diversity and should be visually represented as such. The use of Mandela to
    represent our country is also biased as there are other heroes that can justly
    represent our country.  The halo above Mandela’s head is biased as it portrays
    him as a saintly individual, although Mandela was a human being prone to human
    weaknesses.  There is a gender and race imbalance; there are only males
    (Mandela and the man with the umbrella) not including the whole rainbow nation.
     

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 6

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                           6                     DBE/November 2018
                                         NSC – Marking Guidelines

     Credit must be given to any other valid statements.

     Q.2                 COGNITIVE SKILLS              WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
    LEVEL                                                                   (10)
Lower Order          Remember, Recall, Recognise,                   2.1           2
                     Name                                   30%

                     Understand, Explain, Describe,                 2.1           1
                     Classify

Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise             40%     2.1           3
                                                                    2.2           1
Higher Order         Analyse, Compare, Interpret                    2.2           1

                     Evaluate, Reflect, Judge               30%     2.3           2

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 7

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    7                           DBE/November 2018
                                  NSC – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 3 [10 marks]

ANSWER EITHER QUESTION 3.1 OR QUESTION 3.2.

3.1 Allocate 10 marks in total

     Both the teapot forms in FIGURE D and E are three-dimensional. Hennie Meyer's
     Teapot (FIG D) is, organic, curvilinear and sensual  whereas the form of the
     teapot in FIGURE E is geometric, abstract and machine-like.  Meyer's teapot is
     an embellished form that conceals its function whereas Brandt's teapot is
     minimalist revealing its function.  Brandt's teapot is typical of Bauhaus products
     as the form is guided by the 'Form Follows Function' concept.  As opposed to
     Meyer's that has a busy surface pattern and form.

     Hennie Meyer's Postmodernist Teapot is produced by hand and each teapot he
     creates is unique and different.  This production method and use of ceramic clay
     lends itself to the visibility of finger-marks and imperfections. Marianne Brandt's
     teapot is mass-produced by a machine.  There are no imperfections visible as
     the product is carefully investigated afterwards for any defects. Both teapots are a
     clear reflection of exquisite craftsmanship and unique production methods created
     with different techniques. 

     Hennie Meyer's teapot is made from clay, a medium that is pliable, relatively
     cheap and readily available.  After the teapot is made and decorated it is fired in
     a kiln to make the clay impermeable. The medium is fragile and breakable. 
     Marianne Brandt's teapot, on the other hand, is made from stainless steel and
     black ebony wood to create a strong, durable, shiny, smooth product, hence the
     title 'Silver and Ebony'.  These materials are heat resistant and able to keep the
     tea warm for a longer period.  The chrome silver colour will not fade over time
     and the teapot only needs to be cleaned with soap and water – no polishing is
     needed. The designer follows the 'Truth to Materials' philosophy. 

     Hennie Meyer's teapot is highly ornate. A variety of patterns and textures are used
     to decorate the bulk of the teapot's body giving it a complex and rich surface. The
     patterns and textures are applied by hand creating an earthy character. Marianne
     Brandt's machine-produced teapot is void of any decoration and is more
     impersonal, focusing on the quality of the materials. 

     Hennie Meyer's teapot is clearly inspired by nature. The teapot resembles a plant
     or a bird's beak.  The decorations are inspired by African geometric patterns and
     naïve childlike drawings.  The eclectic form and decorations of the teapot are Art
     Deco, Aztec zig-zag or Postmodernist inspired.  The product is layered, pluralistic
     and complex.  Marianne Brandt's teapot is clearly inspired by Bauhaus machine
     aesthetics. The teapot integrates many Bauhaus and De Stijl characteristics, for
     example the cold and impersonal Dutch philosophy of mathematical order (in
     combining geometric forms) is evident. 

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 8

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                            8                         DBE/November 2018
                                          NSC – Marking Guidelines

     Credit must be given to any other valid statements.
     NOTE: A maximum of ONLY 3 marks may be allocated for tabular
     comparison responses. Use the cognitive level grid as a guideline for your
     marking

    Q.3.1                COGNITIVE SKILLS                 WEIGHTING   QUESTIONS     MARKS
   LEVEL                                                                             (10)

Lower Order          Remember, Recall, Recognise                         3.1            1
                                                             30%
                     Understand, Explain, Describe                       3.1            2

Middle Order Apply, Implement, Organise                      40%         3.1            4

Higher Order Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                 3.1            1

                     Evaluate, Reflect                       30%         3.1            1

                     Create, Synthesise                                  3.1            1

                                                     OR
3.2 [10 marks]

           (Allocate 4 marks)
     3.2.1 The Temple of Hercules in FIGURE G has a geometrical circular structure
           with a cylindrical stone cella which is an inner chamber that is surrounded by
           a circular colonnade of Corinthian pillars that orbit around it.  The
           structure of the Bosjes chapel in FIGURE F is based on a square glass
           chamber which is dominated by a floating, organic concrete shell roof
           structure that undulates above the glass walls. 

             The tall columns of FIGURE G give the structure a lofty appearance which
             is enhanced by the structure of the cylindrical pointed roof.  The
             structure of the body of FIGURE F is in the form of a cube of transparent
             glass which is contrasted by a concrete roof that rises and falls in a sinuous
             undulating form giving the impression of freedom, reminding one of a bird in
             flight or a stingray swimming. 
Copyright reserved                                                                Please turn over

### Page 9

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    9                           DBE/November 2018
                                  NSC – Marking Guidelines

             The Roman temple of Hercules in FIGURE G shows strong Greek
             influences as it is purported to have been designed by the Greek architect
             Hermodoras of Salamina during the latter part of the 2nd century BCE and it
             is a monopteros - a round temple of Greek 'peripteral' design completely
             encircled by a colonnade.  The South African countryside influences the
             design of FIGURE F designed by Steyns' studio in 2016. Surrounded by
             majestic mountains the sinuous roof mimics a bird in flight and dramatically
             affords views of the surrounding mountains through the glazed/glass walls of
             the chapel.  Inspired by the manner in which the Cape Dutch Manor
             houses set up a dialogue with their environment through their typical
             undulating gables and white washed walls, the bright white canopy of the
             Bosjes chapel creates a sculptural relationship with the mountains.  In
             FIGURE G Roman design is influenced and is an evolution of previous
             styles and successfully combines new innovation and materials with existing
             design elements from civilizations they conquered. 

             NOTE: A maximum of ONLY 1 mark may be allocated to tabular
             comparison responses.

           (Allocate 6 marks)
     3.2.2 The material used in FIGURE F for the undulating roof is cast concrete
           which creates a free-flowing space.  This advanced technology allows
           the concrete shell to appear simple, unifying and as structurally efficient as
           possible.  The roof also becomes the walls/columns with the use of
           parabolic and hyperbolic arches.  The Temple of Hercules, in FIGURE G,
           makes use of a classical Greek building material, Pentelic marble which is
           mined near Athens in Greece. At the time of construction Pentelic marble
           was one of the more expensive building materials and was rarely used for
           large projects.  The columns, entablature and cella walls were all
           constructed with Pentelic marble blocks whilst the inner cella walls were
           lined with tufa and stucco. Tufa is a variety of limestone formed when
           carbonate minerals precipitate out of ambient temperature water and stucco
           is a form of plaster.  The construction of the building makes use of typical
           1st century Roman architectural technology. This is evident in the
           construction of the capitals that are made from two separate pieces. A
           single block is used to carve the base and plinth of the column and the base
           is integrated into the first step of the podium. 

             Inspired by the ancient Greek monopteroi or round temple which was a
             circular colonnade supporting a roof but without any walls, FIGURE G
             functioned as the Roman temple of Hercules.  This obscured the view of
             the idol contained within the temple and functioned as a more protective
             private space. In contrast to this confined space of the Bosjes Chapel,
             FIGURE F functions as a protective space that embraces the congregation
             through transparent glass walls allowing for an uncluttered view throughout
             the chapel. FIGURE F would also appeal to a broader cross section of a
             modern society in contrast to FIGURE G which was more exclusive in
             function by only including a smaller section of the population. 

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 10

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                           10                        DBE/November 2018
                                          NSC – Marking Guidelines

             Credit must be given to any other valid statements or a comparison of
             a classical and contemporary building that the candidate has studied.

             NOTE: A maximum of ONLY 3 marks may be allocated to tabular
             comparison responses. Use the cognitive level grid as a guideline for
             your marking.

    Q.3.2                   COGNITIVE SKILLS                   WEIGHTING   QUESTIONS          MARKS
   LEVEL                                                                                       (10)
Lower Order          Remember, Recall, Recognise                              3.2.1               2
                                                                     30%
                     Understand, Explain, Describe, Classify                  3.2.2               1

Middle Order Apply, Implement, Organise                              40%      3.2.2               4

Higher Order Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                      3.2.1               2

                     Evaluate, Reflect                               30%

                     Create, Synthesise, Justify                              3.2.2               1

                                                                           TOTAL SECTION A: 30

Copyright reserved                                                                    Please turn over

### Page 11

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    11                           DBE/November 2018
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

SECTION B: DESIGN HISTORY

QUESTION 4 [30 marks]

4.1    Allocate 20 marks in total)
       (Allocate 10 marks for each movement. Please note that only one mark
       can be allocated for the name of a designer and product for each
       movement. Please use the cognitive level grid as a guideline for your
       marking.)

       This marking guideline supplies an answer for the following two possibilities:
       SCANDINAVIAN DESIGN AND BAUHAUS

       Candidates may choose any two movements as long as their statements are
       justified and relate to the quote.
       Candidates could, for example, choose Scandinavian Design that reflect the quote
       in FIGURE H.
       Scandinavian designers aim to create functional products that are well crafted
       and well finished  and at the same time they aim to create aesthetically pleasing,
       beautiful products that reflect elegance, fun and simplicity.  Scandinavian Design
       can therefore be seen to fit with the quotation in FIGURE H.
       The organic forms of their designs as well as the use of light wood as a material
       show the influence of nature.  The use of simple, functional designs with clean
       lines and smooth surfaces reflects the influence of the machine aesthetic of the
       Bauhaus and Modernism.  The influence of Surrealist artists like Miro can be
       seen in the flattening of organic forms into abstract, biomorphic shapes that add
       an element of fun to the design.  This careful choice of influences to link with
       their aims is further proof that these designers are not just interested in the
       functionality of their products but also in their aesthetic appeal. 
       Forms are simple and organic with smooth surfaces and clean lines expressing
       modernity and lightness.  Other characteristics include colours that are neutral
       and calm or bright, cheerful, bold and fresh.  Textiles make use of bold, stylised
       flower motifs and patterns.  New materials dominate such as fibreglass, rubber,
       plastic, vinyl, plywood, aluminium and chrome in their need to create low-cost
       solutions to modern needs. 

       Arne Jacobsen's 'Ant Chair'  is an example of Scandinavian Design's use of
       modern materials. It is manufactured from a single piece of laminated wood and its
       legs are from chrome.  Its curvilinear outline and biomorphic, ant- inspired shape
       reflects their interest in using nature as inspiration.  The chair is carefully
       planned to be functional but at the same time stylish and elegant. 
       Candidates could choose Bauhaus design that reflects the quote in FIGURE I.

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 12

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                           12                        DBE/November 2018
                                          NSC – Marking Guidelines

       Bauhaus designers clearly reject 'confusion and clutter' in their aim to create
       simple and functional designs that reflect the machine age.  Bauhaus design can
       therefore be seen to fit with the quotation in FIGURE I. The school aimed to train
       craftsman-designers to design functional, aesthetically pleasing products for mass-
       production.  They believed that form should follow function and that any
       unnecessary detail would detract from the expression of the function of a product.
        Their 'truth to materials' philosophy can be seen in their use of unpainted,
       exposed materials like steel, e.g. steel tubing on a chair. 

       Bauhaus design is influenced by the De Stijl belief in eliminating all non-essential
       characteristics or 'clutter' in order to find the most essential forms, lines and
       colours.  Paul Cezanne's flattening of form to geometric facets  and the
       Constructivists use of geometric abstraction and belief in maximum reduction are
       also influences on Bauhaus. 

       Like De Stijl, Bauhaus designers favoured basic, pure, geometric forms, straight
       lines and smooth surfaces to create impersonal, machine-like products.  Colours
       are reduced to the primary colours (yellow, red and blue) and the neutral colours
       (black, grey and white) to support the general aim of simplicity. 

       Wilhelm Wagenfeldt's 'Bauhaus lamp'  is a good example of an 'uncluttered'
       Bauhaus design as it is made up of only geometric forms and shapes (the main
       body of the lampshade is a perfect half sphere, the base is a perfect circular disc
       and the leg is a cylinder tube).  The surface is smooth and unadorned exposing
       the function of the lamp clearly.  The silver of the stainless steel, the white of the
       frosted shade and the clear glass are all neutral colours exuding calmness. The
       clear glass contrast with the frosted white and silver adding some drama. 

       Credit must be given to any other valid statements.

    Q.4.1                   COGNITIVE SKILLS                   WEIGHTING   QUESTIONS        MARKS
   LEVEL                                                                                     (20)
Lower Order          Remember, Recall, Recognise, Name                        4.1               2
                                                                     30%
                     Understand, Explain, Describe, Classify                  4.1               4

Middle Order Apply, Implement, Organise                              40%      4.1               8

Higher Order Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                      4.1               2

                     Evaluate, Reflect                               30%      4.1               1

                     Create, Synthesise, Justify                              4.1               3

Copyright reserved                                                                  Please turn over

### Page 13

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                          13                       DBE/November 2018
                                         NSC – Marking Guidelines

4.2 [10 marks]

     The Art Nouveau book cover in FIGURE J reflects the influences of the intricate,
     intertwining lines of Viking stone carving as well as Viking imagery , whereas the
     Modernist book cover in FIGURE K reflects the influences of the Machine Age's
     use of straight lines, geometric shapes and smooth, undecorated surfaces. 
     Like the Arts and Crafts movement, Art Nouveau also aims to establish close links
     between the artist and craftsman and to transfer the quality of handmade products
     to their designs.  The embossed, intricate details on the book cover in FIGURE J
     reflect a handmade quality.  Modernist designers, on the other hand, aim to
     create aesthetically pleasing designs that are simple, abstract and 'geometricised'
     for mass-production by machine.  This aim is evident in the Modernist book cover
     where forms are abstract, simple, machine-like and impersonal. 
     The rich and exotic use of colour in FIGURE J is typical of Art Nouveau.  The
     background is a dusky dark blue with a rich gold decorative swirling pattern
     embossed on it.  The Modernist book cover in FIGURE K uses a steel grey
     background and the red and white geometric linear image creates a strong
     contrast. 
     The lines on the Art Nouveau book cover are typical of Art Nouveau as they are
     curvilinear and organic creating a highly decorative, rhythmic surface pattern.  In
     contrast, the lines on the Modernist book cover are straight, sharp, geometric and
     clean, which convey control and machine-like rigidity.  The lines of the Art
     Nouveau book cover have a feminine feel with whiplash fluidity whereas the
     Modernist book design lines are more masculine, machine-like. 
     The shapes of the Art Nouveau book cover are organic and flattened, simplified
     and stylized, reflecting the influence of Japanese art.  The shapes of the
     Modernist book cover are also simplified but they are abstract instead of
     representational like those on the Art Nouveau book cover.  The Modernist book
     cover makes use of perspectival lines to create optical illusions of three-
     dimensional form as opposed to the flat shapes of the Art Nouveau book cover. 

     Q.4.2                COGNITIVE SKILLS              WEIGHTING QUESTIONS         MARKS
    LEVEL                                                                            (10)
Lower Order          Remember, Recall, Recognise,                     4.2               1
                     Name                                    30%

                     Understand, Explain, Describe,                   4.2               2
                     Classify
Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise              40%      4.2               4

                     Analyse, Compare, Interpret                      4.2               1
Higher Order         Evaluate, Reflect, Judge                         4.2               1
                                                             30%
                     Create, Synthesise, Justify                      4.2               1

                                                                    TOTAL SECTION B: 30
Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 14

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    14                           DBE/November 2018
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

SECTION C: SOCIO-CULTURAL/ENVIRONMENTAL AND SUSTAINABLE CONTEXT

QUESTION 5 [20 marks]

ANSWER EITHER QUESTION 5.1 OR QUESTION 5.2.

5.1 [20 marks]

     5.1.1    (Allocate 6 marks)

              (Allocate 2 marks)
              •    COMPOSITION
              The arrangement of the object is formal. It is large and centrally placed
              within a simple symmetrical grid of two blocks emphasising the meaning.
               The poster is vertically split to emphasise different realities: violence
              versus passiveness.  The object becomes a focal point in drawing the
              viewer's attention on violence. The composition is asymmetrical leading
              the eye from left to right, from the handle of the gun horizontally towards
              the loud speaker.  The curve of the trigger, leads the eye towards the
              typography in the middle of the poster. 

              (Allocate 2 marks)
              •    SYMBOLISM
              The revolver symbolises war and violence whilst the loudspeaker
              symbolises peace and nonviolence through the medium of speech.  The
              colour scheme of the object of war (the revolver) is dark, dreary and
              depressing symbolising the devastation of war on society  whereas the
              loudspeaker is light and bright symbolising hope and a voice.

              (Allocate 2 marks)
              •    USE OF IMAGERY
              Juxtaposing images are used in the poster.  The size of the images is
              exaggerated, particularly with the size of the revolver that is manipulated
              to fit and merge with the loudspeaker. Both images are relevant in
              highlighting the message of the poster with the revolver representing war
              and violence and the loudspeaker representing a voice and peace. 

              Credit any other valid statements.

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 15

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    15                            DBE/November 2018
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

     5.1.2    Allocate 14 marks in total
              (Allocate 7 marks per case study)
              Allocate 1 mark for the name of the designer and the name of the
              product.

              ONE CONTEMPORARY              SOUTH      AFRICAN      DESIGNER/DESIGN
              GROUP:

              The Growbag, by Bonsela, (South Africa), 2015 is a unique outdoor
              planter that offers an easy and attractive way to grow your own
              vegetables, herbs, plants and succulents, regardless of the size of the
              garden, balcony, driveway or wall and roof space.

              Growbag has partnered with Soil for Life to start the Grow to Life
              Programme to teach communities who live in harsh environments with
              limited space and resources various techniques of growing their own
              organic gardens using water wise and low cost methods.  Through these
              gardens their families are ensured adequate nutrition combating the
              sociocultural problem of hunger. Statistics indicate that 14 million people
              go to bed hungry in South Africa. The Growbag and Soil for Life initiative
              also encourages communities in their Grow to Life programme to
              generate an income from their gardens.  In this way they address
              poverty and impart entrepreneurial skills to unemployed individuals. 
              Each Growbag is individually handmade hence the manufacturing of the
              Growbag also empowers individuals by creating employment.

              The Growbag is made out of reinforced, old billboard vinyl skins that are
              durable and hence long lasting. Extra growing and storage space is also
              provided by the side pockets. The Growbag is donated to
              underprivileged communities in Cape Town. The Growbag project
              eradicates hunger caused by the inaccessibility of land for subsistence
              farming, in impoverished communities i.e. informal settlements and
              townships. Growbag addresses the above mentioned sociocultural
              concerns by providing a flexible, lightweight gardening solution.

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 16

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                     16                            DBE/November 2018
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

              ONE CONTEMPORARY INTERNATIONAL DESIGNER/DESIGN
              GROUP:

              GravityLight by, Jim and Martin of SkunkWorks projects, designed in
              2009, Kenya.

              GravityLight is a low-cost solar light that uses energy from a falling weight
              to illuminate homes that are off-grid and living on less than R40 a day.
              The light is a revolutionary new approach to storing energy and creating
              illumination. GravityLight was created as a sustainable alternative to
              paraffin lamps. The light combines kinetic and potential energy, by
              connecting an elevated weight — filled with rocks or sand — to a pulley
              system that slowly powers a generator as the weight falls to the ground. It
              takes only 3 seconds to lift the weight which powers an LED bulb,
              creating 30 minutes of light on its descent.

              Because the Gravitylight provides an alternative to the paraffin light, it
              eliminates the health dangers and environmental drawbacks caused by
              paraffin lamps. The use of paraffin causes 3% of the world's CO 2
              emissions and is a significant source of black carbon, which impacts on
              the environment. The smoke from the use of paraffin lamps also causes
              respiratory problems, which is equivalent to smoking two packets of
              cigarettes a day.  The fumes also cause eye infections and cataracts.
              Accidental paraffin poisoning also has potentially fatal consequences,
              particularly for children. Using paraffin inside homes can lead to
              devastating fires and burns. Burning paraffin also comes with a financial
              burden that can consume 10 to 20% of a household's income.

              The GravityLight Foundation boosts the local economy by creating a
              sustainable demand for clean, safe lighting solutions. Through the field
              sales team and working with local partners in Kenya, GravityLight
              supports Kenyans to earn a living and learn new skills by selling
              GravityLights. Because there are no running costs after the initial low
              cost purchase, GravityLight has the potential to lift people out of poverty,
              allowing them to use the money they have saved to buy more effective
              lighting systems in the future.

              The project was initially self-funded by NLE and then by Lagos State, it
              later received research funds from Heinrich Boll Stiftung as well as funds
              for its construction from the UNDP/Federal Ministry of Environment Africa
              Adaptation Programme (AAP).

Copyright reserved                                                              Please turn over

### Page 17

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                           17                       DBE/November 2018
                                          NSC – Marking Guidelines

              Credit any other valid statements.

    Q.5.1                 COGNITIVE SKILLS                 WEIGHTING   QUESTIONS       MARKS
   LEVEL                                                                                (20)
Lower Order          Remember, Recall, Recognise,                         5.1.1            2
                     Name                                      30%

                     Understand, Explain, Describe,                       5.1.2            4
                     Classify

Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise                40%        5.1.1            4
                                                                          5.1.2            4
Higher Order         Analyse, Compare, Interpret                          5.1.2            3

                                                               30%        5.1.2            2
                     Evaluate, Reflect, Judge

                     Create, Synthesise, Justify                          5.1.2            1

                                                      OR

5.2 [20 marks]

     5.2.1 (Allocate 2 marks)
           The role of indigenous craft in modern day society is to pay homage to
           indigenous cultures because many indigenous crafts are embedded in
           traditional cultural practices. The use of indigenous crafts in modern day
           society also assists in the continuation of or passing down of knowledge
           and skills from one generation to another.  The continued practice of
           traditional crafts in modern day society also helps people to connect and
           express their cultural identities.

     5.2.2 (Allocate 8 marks)
           Learners can discuss any indigenous craft, e.g. Ndebele House Painting

             The Ndebele people were formidable warriors who often subdued the
             smaller chiefdom's and assimilated them into Ndebele society.
             Intermarriages ensued and cultural exchanges happened. It is believed
             that early Ndebele house structure and house-painting strategies came
             into being as a result of the abovementioned intercultural marriages. 
             The initial wall art designs and symbolic forms were derived from Ndebele
             beadwork forms and pattern motifs. Consequently, after the Ndebele
             people were defeated by the Boer farmers in the Boer war in the twentieth
             century, the Ndebele also started using the expressive symbols in their
             wall paintings to secretly communicate with each other. These
             messages were not interceded by the Boer because they were thought to
             be just a form of cultural art and hence decorative and harmless.

Copyright reserved                                                                Please turn over

### Page 18

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    18                             DBE/November 2018
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

             Ndebele house painting is done by women and the craft is passed down
             from one generation to the next. Usually, the outside gates of the
             household, front walls, side walls and interior of the home is painted.
             Traditionally, a well painted house serves as a form of communication
             conveying the role and social status of the female of that household.

             In the context of the above discussion Ndebele house painting is
             significant as an expression of traditional continuity and cultural resistance
             against colonisation. It is also a way of passing down heritage
             knowledge and traditional customs from one generation to the next.

             Prior to the introduction of acrylic pigments in South Africa in the 1940s,
             only natural pigments were used in Ndebele house paintings. These
             included monochrome ochres, browns, black and limestone whitewash.
             The walls where then subsequently seasonally repainted, after the
             summer rainfalls had washed and eroded away the natural pigments.
             The women applied the pigments to the wall using just their fingers.

             A description of ONE work, as well as the name(s) of the cultural
             group/craftsperson that produced it.

             Allocate 1 mark to the name of the indigenous cultural
             group/craftsperson
             Ndebele wall paintings 
             Ester Mahlangu's traditional wall paintings at the Mahlangu household in
             KwaNdebele, are characterised by symbolic geometric shapes with bold
             black cloissonistic outlines.  The flat geometric shapes are in a variety of
             colours ranging from red, dark red browns, sky blue, deep blue, white,
             yellow gold, green and the occasional pink.  The combination of the
             geometric shapes, primary and complementary colour schemes create a
             rhythmic pattern on the surface of the wall.  These wall paintings were
             used to secretly communicate information and knowledge about various
             issues dealing with resistance, colonialism, tradition and heritage. 

     5.2.3 (Allocate 10 marks)
           Allocate 1 mark only for the name of the designer and name of
           product.
           Ashanti Design lampshades by Robert Walker. 
           Ashanti Designs in Cape Town by Robert Walker aims to celebrate and
           pay tribute to traditional crafts in a contemporary way. Ashanti Designs'
           design ethic is heavily influenced African heritage, a sustainable design
           ethic and biomorphic forms.
           The materials and technique used to construct the Ashanti Designs'
           lampshades are heavily influenced by Zulu basketry. Particularly, two
           varieties of the Zulu baskets, the lidded variety that is mainly used for
           storage and the flat ones that are used for chaffing wheat. Traditionally
           these baskets were decorated using elaborate arrangement of geometric
           motifs to create unique zigzag patterns.

Copyright reserved                                                              Please turn over

### Page 19

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                           19                        DBE/November 2018
                                          NSC – Marking Guidelines

             Characteristically these lampshades are created using pliable materials
             such as, soft branches, grass, palm fronds, fibres, raffia, fibrous tree and
             plant roots.  These materials are then hand manipulated using the
             plaiting, twining and chequer board weaving techniques to create the
             lampshade. 
             Socio-culturally, Ashanti Designs empower craftsmen in rural areas by
             selling their products that teaches these craftsmen valuable
             entrepreneurial skills. Ashanti Designs also seeks to promote and
             preserve African Heritage by using African traditional craft techniques to
             create products that have a function and hence a place in contemporary
             South Africa.

    Q.5.2                   COGNITIVE SKILLS                   WEIGHTING   QUESTIONS          MARKS
   LEVEL                                                                                       (20)
Lower Order          Remember, Recall, Recognise, Name                        5.2.2                2
                                                                     30%      5.2.3                4
                     Understand, Explain, Describe, Classify

Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise                      40%      5.2.2                4
                                                                              5.2.3                4

Higher Order         Analyse, Compare, Interpret                              5.2.1                2

                                                                     30%      5.2.2                2
                     Evaluate, Reflect

                     Create, Synthesise, Justify                              5.2.3                2

Copyright reserved                                                                    Please turn over

### Page 20

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                     20                             DBE/November 2018
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 6

6.1 [20 marks]

     6.1.1 (Allocate 4 marks)

             The poster aims to inform the public/tourist of the damaging effect that
             plastic waste has on our environment – in this case, specifically in relation
             to elephants.
             The elephant appears to be strangled by the twisted plastic bottle looking
             like a helpless victim. The plastic bottle is depicted much larger than the
             elephant, overpowering it. This shows the destructive power of plastic –
             even though in reality it is a small lightweight bottle, its caustic properties
             are so destructive that it can destroy one of the biggest animals in Africa.
             The text 'Time is running out for them, not for plastic' is in a simple, san
             serif type, bringing the direct, emotive message successfully across in a
             dreary grey colour.

             The discarded plastic water bottle is squashed to resemble an hourglass
             and the elephant becomes a symbol of life slipping away because of
             pollution. The large, empty grey monochromatic background makes
             reference to a damaged earth which is polluted, dirty, and barren leaving
             humanity with a bleak future.

     6.1.2 (Allocate 2 marks)
           To recycle means to make new products from non-biodegradable
           materials that could potentially damage the environment and in so doing
           prevent them from being discarded on landfills or polluting the earth.  By
           recycling these materials, the amount of new material production is cut
           down, resulting in less energy consumption and less carbon dioxide and
           other toxic fumes or gases being released into the atmosphere.  To up-
           cycle means to adapt and elevate existing materials and products that are
           no longer in use. Up-cycle implies that the material and product can
           function again in another context with a different and a higher purpose. 

                                                  OR

             Upcycling is energy efficient process, involving the reusing of waste
             without destroying it in order to form something new. Recycling takes
             waste products breaks them down then forms them into something new. 

             Credit any other valid statements.

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 21

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                  21                           DBE/November 2018
                                 NSC – Marking Guidelines

6.2 Allocate 14 marks in total
    (Allocate 7 marks per case study)
    Allocate 1 mark for the name of the designer and the name of the product.

     EXAMPLE OF A SOUTH AFRICAN DESIGNER:

     Heath Nash, Don't complain, what you see is what you get, South Africa, 2011.
     Don't complain, what you see is what you get is collaboration between Nash and
     local Zimbabwean artisans that resulted in a colourful and vibrant use of local
     resources combined with local craft traditions.

     The aim of the plastic bottle shades created by Nash is to create shaded areas
     under which people can congregate, sit, relax and talk to each other. They can
     also be used for public kiosks from which vendors can sell flowers and
     refreshments. The shades were designed to integrate well with the existing
     architectural elements of the urban Harare landscape.

     Nash's design process involves an exploration of waste materials, plastic bottles
     of all shapes, colours and sizes. Scrap metal and wood is also utilised. A roof
     is constructed from a metal frame that is secured with wire to keep the plastic
     bottles together. In some instances, the frame is constructed from wood and
     metal scraps and aluminium cans are cut and woven to create textural
     coverings.

     The shades are an example of the type of products Nash designs using discarded
     material deemed to be rubbish. This project uses bottles that are washed and
     cut, the unused excess pieces are sent back to the recyclers. The project helps
     to clean the environment and to reduce the carbon footprint.

     EXAMPLE OF AN INTERNATIONAL DESIGNER:

     Ocean sole turns flip-flop pollution into art and functional products, for
     example key holders in the shape of fish or life-size cows and lion heads.  The
     material Ocean Sole uses is discarded flip flops which they have removed from
     the ocean and waterways in Kenya. This has provided a steady income to over
     150 low-income Kenyans. They aim to promote conservation of our oceans. 
     Their aim is to give back to society and change the lives of many through
     education, income and meals. 

Copyright reserved                                                          Please turn over

### Page 22

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                           22                      DBE/November 2018
                                          NSC – Marking Guidelines

       Ten per cent of their revenue is donated to marine conservation programmes.
       Ocean Sole makes fun art so that people, companies and charities will
       remember that the Ocean needs to be clean from pollution. Their pieces
       remind people of the trash found in the oceans and waterways that is killing
       human and marine life in its journey from the dumps to the beaches. 

       The material source is readily available in that in emerging warm-climate
       markets, billions of cheap flip-flops are made for the feet of the poor every day.
        These flip-flops are worn for a year, at the most and then after many repairs
       are discarded into dumpsites that ultimately seep into our Earth's waterways and
       then into our oceans.  The mass of discarded flip-flops pile up and block
       waterways of fresh water and then make their way to our oceans, killing
       everything in their way.  Tons of flip-flop pollution is washing up onto the
       beaches everyday creating an environmental disaster for the marine eco-system
       and local communities. Using discarded flip flops is a sustainable practice for
       reducing pollution. 

       Ocean Sole Founder Julie Church, was inspired by the toys children were
       making out of discarded flip-flops and encouraged mothers to collect, wash, and
       cut the discarded flip-flops.  The process she designed was to heat various
       colours of flip-flops into a malleable state and then press them into moulds. This
       process creates colourful products such as key rings and fun art sculptures e.g.
       the head of a lion and even a life size cow. 

       A company was established to promote 'trade not aid' to raise awareness of flip-
       flop pollution. This year Ocean Sole has transformed over 50 tons of discarded
       and lost flip-flops that were found in the ocean and on land and up-cycled them
       into artworks.

    Q.6                   COGNITIVE SKILLS                WEIGHTING   QUESTIONS    MARKS
   LEVEL                                                                            (20)
Lower Order          Remember, Recall, Recognise,                        6.1.1         2
                     Name                                      30%

                     Understand, xExplain, Describe,                     6.1.2         1
                     Classify                                             6.2          3

Middle Order         Apply, Implement, Organise                40%       6.1.1         2
                                                                         6.1.2         1
                                                                          6.2          5
Higher Order         Analyse, Compare, Interpret

                     Evaluate, Reflect, Judge                  30%       6.2           2

                     Create, Synthesise, Justify                         6.2           4

                                                                      TOTAL SECTION C: 40
                                                                         GRAND TOTAL: 100

Copyright reserved

## Related documents

- [Design P1 Nov 2018 FINAL Memo Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2018-final-memo-afr/bc30bd03-407d-4fec-ae72-a424eff53b59) — Design · Memo · 2018 · Afr
- [Design P1 Nov 2018 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2018-afr/169b2964-39b3-4515-b57f-66898ced700e) — Design · QP · 2018 · Afr
- [Design P1 Nov 2018 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2018-eng/0b1b788b-b2c9-49d9-8650-eb8fe7721c37) — Design · QP · 2018 · Eng
- [DESIGN P1 GR12 MEMO SEPT2018 Afrikaans](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-gr12-memo-sept2018-afrikaans/9f429249-e5ba-4d49-a678-895047ecaf8a) — Design · Memo · 2018 · Afr
- [DESIGN P1 GR12 MEMO SEPT2018 English](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-gr12-memo-sept2018-english/4692b2c3-52de-4a8b-9723-d1c7c2b48ee9) — Design · Memo · 2018 · Eng
- [Design P1 May June 2018 Memo Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-may-june-2018-memo-eng/5a423c49-54d7-4176-bf99-5fc43153c434) — Design · Memo · 2018 · Eng

## More from Grade 12 Design

- [Gr 12 Des ATP 2023-24](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/gr-12-des-atp-2023-24/0fd522c6-2d5a-4c5b-9e0b-06e7b199eb25) — ATP
- [Design P1 May-June 2025 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-may-june-2025-afr/e35d300a-db4f-4a06-ba8a-6f659dbd37ad) — QP · 2025 · Afr
- [Design P1 Nov 2025 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12-design-2025-nsc-november-exam-question-paper-paper-1/3f14a710-b913-44a8-ade1-31e4d395f557) — QP · 2025 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2025 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12-design-2025-nsc-november-exam-question-paper-paper-1/47ba80e3-12dd-4fd4-8302-34e3b97a6b9a) — QP · 2025 · Afr
- [Design P1 Nov 2024 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2024-eng/3f0bd4c5-8226-45ef-87fa-5c9996cba696) — QP · 2024 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2024 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2024-afr/6958913b-f502-40d3-8387-1f0a78a3ed25) — QP · 2024 · Afr

## Collection

- [Grade 12 past papers](https://www.hlayiso.com/grade-12/past-papers)

---

Hlayiso: free CAPS and IEB past papers, memos, notes and study guides for South African learners. When citing, link the page URL above, not a PDF or /api/ URL.
