# Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC November 2020 Memo (English)

> Grade 12 Design Paper 1 memorandum from the NSC November Exam 2020 (English), 22 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.

- Page: https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2020-memo-eng/4557d936-063d-4754-b6a8-e25c4d279f64
- Updated: 2026-09-27
- Subject: Design
- Grade: Grade 12
- Document type: Memorandum
- Year: 2020
- Exam period: NSC November Exam
- Paper: 1
- Curriculum: CAPS
- Pages: 22

Breadcrumbs: [Home](https://www.hlayiso.com/) › [Library](https://www.hlayiso.com/library) › [Grade 12](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12) › [Design](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12/design) › [Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC November 2020 Memo (English)](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2020-memo-eng/4557d936-063d-4754-b6a8-e25c4d279f64)

## About this document

Design · Grade 12 · NSC November Exam · 2020. Memorandum, 22 pages. Read online or download the PDF.

Read it free online on the page above; download the PDF from there.

## Document text

Text extracted from the PDF. Layout, diagrams and tables may not survive extraction.

### Page 1

Downloaded from hlayiso.com

                             SENIOR CERTIFICATE/
                         NATIONAL SENIOR CERTIFICATE

                                     GRADE 12

                                      DESIGN P1

                                       (THEORY)

                                   NOVEMBER 2020

                               MARKING GUIDELINES

MARKS: 100

                      These marking guidelines consist of 22 pages.

Copyright reserved                                                    Please turn over

### Page 2

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                     2                        DBE/November 2020
                                  SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

SECTION A: DESIGN LITERACY

QUESTION 1: 'UNSEEN' EXAMPLES [10 marks]

Candidates answer EITHER QUESTION 1.1 OR QUESTION 1.2.

1.1 (Allocate a maximum of 2 marks for each bullet/aspect)

       The 2D wallpaper design in FIGURE A creates a 3D illusion of form due to the use of
       tonal variation and perspectival rendering of the tunnel and in each pyramid. These
       simulated forms are pure geometric pyramids that create a clean, mechanical feel.

       The wallpaper design creates the illusion of a tunnel-like space through the changing
       of the scale of the pyramid forms so that they appear to be receding. Placing the
       light source on the righthand side of the tunnel also helps to create this sense of
       space  that is emphasized by the tonal gradation. 

       The repetition of the pyramid forms on the two-dimensional wallpaper creates a
       zigzag rhythm. The repetition of the sweeping curves along which these pyramids
       are placed also add curvilinear rhythms to the design. 

       The monochromatic /achromatic colour scheme consists of a spectrum of whites and
       greys, creating a clean, calm and quiet atmosphere. Grey and white are neutral
       colours which also help to convey a modern feel. The light catches the different
       facets of the pyramid form in such a way that a range of greys are created that brings
       variety and life to the uniform white colour of the design. 

       The wallpaper design pattern makes use of an asymmetrical balance as the focal
       point is formed by the strong white light-source on the far right of the design. The
       weight or focus on the right is further emphasised by the contrast between the bright
       circle of light and the dark forms right next to it. 
       Credit any other valid statements.
        Q1.1 LEVEL           COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS   QUESTIONS       MARKS
                                                                                      (10)
        Lower order     Remember, Recall, Recognise         30%         1.1             2
                        Understand, Explain, Describe                                   1
        Middle order    Apply, Implement, Organise          40%         1.1             4
        Higher order    Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                     2
                        Evaluate, Reflect                   30%         1.1             1
                        Synthesise, Justify

                                                 OR

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 3

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                       3                        DBE/November 2020
                                    SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

1.2

  1.2.1 (Allocate 2 marks)
        Biomorphic implies that the chair design imitates nature and the form is
        borrowed from it. FIGURE B is biomorphic as the chair looks like intertwined
        organic roots of a plant featuring flower-like accents that imitate fungi.

  1.2.2 (Allocate 8 marks)
        (Allocate a maximum of 2 marks for each bullet/aspect)
        FIGURE B uses undulating, curvy and organic lines to define its structure.
        Thick, uneven lines are prominent on the legs and the backrest of the chair.

            The form of FIGURE B is organic, creating flowing movement. The form of
            the backrest is designed to emulate tree branches/coral. The form is bulky and
            does not resemble a conventional chair which gives the chair a dream-like,
            surreal and ghost- like quality. Disc-like forms emulate from the fungi
            simulated in the chair design.

            FIGURE B has a soft white colour that suggests comfort. The cream-
            yellowish fungus is placed haphazardly to create a sense of an organic
            structure. This creamy-yellow colour contrasts with the white and the shadows
            to add some variety.

            The backrest of the chair in FIGURE B has repeated vertical branch-like pointy
            outgrowths and is rendered with a smooth soft/hard textured feel. This
            contrasts with the rough/knobbly fungus-like pale cream-yellowish textures that
            create variety and visual interest.

      Credit any other valid statements.

        Q1.2 LEVEL            COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS   QUESTIONS      MARKS
                                                                                      (10)
        Lower order      Remember, Recall, Recognise         30%         1.2            2
                         Understand, Explain, Describe                                  1
        Middle order     Apply, Implement, Organise          40%         1.2            4
        Higher order     Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                    2
                         Evaluate, Reflect                   30%         1.2            1
                         Synthesise, Justify

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 4

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    4                           DBE/November 2020
                                 SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 2: COMMUNICATION THROUGH DESIGN [10 marks]

2.1.

2.1.1 (Allocate 4 marks)
      The young boy is wearing a T-shirt featuring the scientist Einstein, this stereotypes
      boys as intelligent.  Alternatively, the image of the man on the boy’s T-shirt with
      his tongue sticking out is playful and teasing, very typical of boy-like behaviour. 
      The text beside him reading: 'The Little Scholar. Your future starts here,' also
      stereotypes him as an active scholar with a bright academic future.  The use of
      blue, green and black colours on this clothing are stereotypical colours used to
      identify boys with that is associated with masculinity. 

       The silver, glittery kitten ear headband with the accompanying text stating: 'The
       Social Butterfly: Chambray shirts + logo sweaters are the talk of the playground'
       tells us that the young girl is stereotyped as being preoccupied by socially
       accepted fashion trends.  She is portrayed/stereotyped as an empty-headed
       social butterfly.  This is emphasised by the glittering kitty princess crown and
       emphasised by her demure pose against the wall while she flaunts her designer
       'logo styles' model outfit.  The soft cream and pink colours of her jersey are also
       stereotypical colours used to identify girls with.  The boy’s cheeky pose is active
       and playful, typical of boys of that age.  By contrast the young girl’s pose is
       passive, stereotypical of society’s views on the way girls should behave. 
       The advert stereotypes children as being white and having blonde hair. 
       The boy and the girl come across as androgynous and the stereotype is focussed
       on the difference between the nerd and the socialite

2.1.2 (Allocate 2 marks)
      The advert in FIGURE C can be considered to be irresponsible in that it can be
      described as 'sexist'. It encourages the social construct that girls should aspire to
      be social butterflies and boys scholars or academics. This counteracts the
      current social drive for all girls/women to be afforded equal opportunities in
      education, to be independent and to be able to make a strong economic
      contribution in all sectors. The advert only refers to one racial grouping and is
      therefore not inclusive. 

2.2    (Allocate 4 marks)

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 5

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                     5                         DBE/November 2020
                                  SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

       The first symbol is the Afro comb, which symbolises a celebration of black
       identity and honour. The Afro comb is also symbolic of the Afro hairstyle which in
       modern day South Africa is a symbol of the return to self-love and a protest against
       hair straighteners and weaves. The Afro hairstyle can also be seen as symbolising
       the Black Panther movement in the 70s in America. Any of the above symbols or
       the clenched fist may represent the #BlackLivesMatter movement. 

       A second symbol is the colour orange  which is associated with the orange
       clothing worn by prisoners in South Africa. Fela Kuti was at some point jailed for
       voicing his views on African consciousness and human rights violations through his
       music.

       A third symbol is the clutched fist  which is associated with black power in the
       fight against oppression. It also symbolises unity and black consciousness for the
       oppressed. 

       A fourth symbol is the morphed Afro comb with images of the fist and facial images
       of legendary activist which can symbolise African consciousness and a collective
       political, historical, social, religious and cultural identity.

       Credit any other valid statements.

        Q2 LEVEL            COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS   QUESTIONS        MARKS
                                                                                      (10)
        Lower order    Remember, Recall, Recognise         30%          2.2             1
                       Understand, Explain, Describe                   2.1.1            2
        Middle order   Apply, Implement, Organise          40%         2.1.2            2
                                                                        2.2             2
        Higher order   Analyse, Compare, Interpret                      2.2             1
                       Evaluate, Reflect                   30%
                       Synthesise, Justify                             2.1.1            2

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 6

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                     6                          DBE/November 2020
                                  SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 3 [10 marks]
Answer EITHER QUESTION 3.1 OR QUESTION 3.2.
3.1    [10 marks] (Allocate a maximum of 2 marks for each bullet/aspect)

       The materials of the main frame of FIGURE E consist mainly of a soft bendable
       silver wire that is used to shape and form the structure giving it a strong linear
       quality. The beads, a traditional African material, are used to imitate the colour
       of the car. Alternatively, FIGURE F is made of solid cast iron and uses imitation
       diamanté to imitate the colour which gives it a cheap, bling status.
       In FIGURE E the repeated circular wire lines on the wheels create a repetitive,
       circular pattern. The repeated orange beaded lines create a more rigid,
       striped pattern. In contrast, the repeated imitation diamanté on FIGURE F
       creates a solid, dense surface with a tactile pattern.
       The form in FIGURE E is quite open due to the linear wire construction method
       and expresses transparency and lightness, whereas the form of FIGURE F is
       more solid and heavy. The curved lines on FIGURE F create an aerodynamic
       form  whereas the form of FIGURE E is more block-like.
       FIGURE F is kitsch as it is covered in a skin of shiny, cheap imitation
       diamanté. In comparison FIGURE E stays true to its roots by using authentic
       traditional bead work and wire. FIGURE E is usually found in museum shops
       and craft markets aimed for the tourist market, whereas FIGURE F is mass
       produced and found in department stores for everyone to have access which
       enhances its kitsch status. Alternatively FIGURE E could be classified as being
       kitsch as it is seen in most craft markets across South Africa. 
       FIGURE E is influenced by African wire crafts produced with hand-crafted
       technologies. FIGURE F, by comparison shows the influence of industrial
       manufacturing techniques of the western world in the 1970's and onwards.
       FIGURE E's inspiration came from boys not having toys and a need to create
       alternative solutions. In contrast FIGURE F is inspired by a consumerist 'bling'
       life-style where children have access to all kinds of toys. Alternatively FIGURE
       E could have been influenced by the Arts and Crafts movement because of being
       hand-crafted and FIGURE F  by the Art Deco movement due to the expensive
       material as well as the adornment used on a fast, aerodynamic car. 
       Credit any other valid statements.
       NOTE: A maximum of ONLY 3 marks may be allocated for tabular
       comparison responses. Use cognitive levels as guidelines. A maximum of
       ONLY 6 marks may be allocated for two separate essays.
        Q3.1 LEVEL          COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS   QUESTIONS        MARKS
                                                                                      (10)
        Lower order    Remember, Recall, Recognise         30%           3.1            1
                       Understand, Explain, Describe                                    2
        Middle order   Apply, Implement, Organise          40%           3.1            4
        Higher order   Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                      1
                       Evaluate, Reflect                   30%           3.1
                       Synthesise, Justify                                              2
                                              OR

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 7

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    7                           DBE/November 2020
                                 SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

3.2    [10 marks]

       A contemporary transport company, Transport for London invited proposals to
       improve pedestrian links across the Thames River in 2013. Heatherwick Studio
       proposed an idea for a new pedestrian 'London Garden Bridge' (FIGURE H)
       across the River Thames. The aim was for the proposed bridge to connect North
       and South London with the added bonus of a garden within the city. London is
       one of the greenest cities of its size in the world; this new terrain aimed to add to
       London's already rich and diverse horticultural heritage by including many
       indigenous river edge plant species. A similar, but Classical structure is the Pont
       du Gard, FIGURE G, a bridge that spans the Gardon River in Remoulins, in
       southern France. Built in the 1st century CE by the Romans as part of the Nîmes
       aqueduct its aim was to span the Gardon River and channel water to the city of
       Nîmes from a spring at Uzés.The entire Nîmes aqueduct is 50 km long; a
       technologically advanced structure that is estimated to have carried 200 000
       cubic meters of water to the fountains, baths and homes of the citizens of Nîmes
       every day. The Pont du Gard, FIGURE G, is the highest of all Roman aqueduct
       bridge structures ever built.

       A testimony to the advanced technology and construction techniques of the
       Romans, the Pont du Gard remained in use until the 6th century; a lack of
       maintenance after the 4th century meant that it became increasingly clogged by
       mineral deposits and debris that eventually choked off the flow of water.  By
       contrast, despite the ground- breaking technology that was meant to be used for
       the construction of the contemporary London Garden Bridge, it was never
       built.

       The aim of the contemporary London Garden Bridge, FIGURE H, was to
       increase and encourage interaction between the South and North Banks and
       provide new walking routes to and from Covent Garden and Soho. The planned
       structure of an elevated London garden would have been a safe and easy terrain
       for London's many commuters and visitors to cross the river; it would also have
       made areas along its length for pedestrians to stop and enjoy the remarkable river
       setting and unparalleled views of the city and to serve as a free public space.
       The terrain that the Classical, Pont du Gard aqueduct spanned was very
       carefully surveyed by the Roman engineers of the time. Because of the uneven
       terrain between the origin, the spring in Uzés and the city of Nîmes, the aqueduct
       followed a long, winding route that was mostly underground but needed a bridge
       across the gorge of the Gardon River.

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 8

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                     8                          DBE/November 2020
                                  SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

       The Pont du Gard (FIGURE G) was constructed with three tiers of arches,
       stands 48.8 m high, and descends a mere 2.5 centimetres – a gradient of only 1 in
       18,241 – while the whole aqueduct descends in height by only 12.6 m over its
       entire length (50km), which is indicative of the great construction precision that
       Roman designers were able to achieve using the technology of the time.

       In order to support the 1,000 cubic metres of earth needed for the garden on The
       London Garden Bridge, (FIGURE H), Heatherwick planned to construct what
       appeared to be two enormous metal planters: like upturned hands, which catered
       for a range of half to two meters deep flower/plant beds, so that plants and trees
       roots can have sufficient space. The material that was proposed to clad the
       bridge was cupronickel, a copper- like material, which is highly resistant to
       corrosion. Typically used for mechanical equipment and ship propellers,
       cupronickel was to be roll-bonded to the bridge's structural steel a technology
       whereby an inseparable skin is created. The proposed 367 metre London Bridge
       was to be coated in the corrosion-resistant copper-nickel alloy material from its
       feet on the river bed up to the underside of the bridge deck.

       By contrast the material used to construct the Classical Pont du Gard (FIGURE
       G) bridge was quarried stone blocks. These stone blocks could weigh up to
       6 tons each. Despite the fact that the Romans were already using concrete, a
       material invented by them, to reinforce and hold structures together, the blocks
       were so precisely cut that they fitted together by friction alone. The use of mortar
       or clamps was eliminated.

       Credit must be given to any other valid statements or a comparison of a
       Classical and contemporary building that the candidate has studied.

       NOTE: A maximum of ONLY 3 marks may be allocated for tabular
       comparison responses. Use cognitive levels as guidelines.

        Q3.2 LEVEL          COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS   QUESTIONS        MARKS
                                                                                      (10)
        Lower order    Remember, Recall, Recognise         30%           3.2            1
                       Understand, Explain, Describe                                    2
        Middle order   Apply, Implement, Organise          40%           3.2            4
        Higher order   Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                      1
                       Evaluate, Reflect                   30%           3.2            2
                       Synthesise, Justify

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 9

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    9                            DBE/November 2020
                                 SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

SECTION B: DESIGN HISTORY

QUESTION 4 [30 marks]

4.1   Allocate 20 marks in total.
      Allocate 10 marks for each movement. Note that ONLY ONE mark can be
      allocated for the name of a designer and product of each movement. Use the
      cognitive levels as guidelines.

      This marking guideline supplies an answer for the following two possibilities:
       DE STIJL
       BAROQUE

      DE STIJL
      The De Stijl movement aimed to reduce their designs to what they considered the
      essentials of art, i.e. straight vertical and horizontal line, the square and the
      rectangle, the three primary colours and the neutrals. They believed that
      designers need to get rid of everything that is not essential. They aimed to create
      clarity, calm, certainty and order through simplification. They believed that
      geometric abstraction to attain balance, harmony, order, logic and purity was of
      utmost importance.

      De Stijl design was influenced by the Dutch tradition of logic, clarity, severity and
      mathematical order. They were also influenced by Cubism where painters broke
      down form into geometric facets that emphasized the flatness of the picture plane
      and emphasizes the square and the rectangle. The Cubists also aimed to reduce
      and simplify form.

      De Stijl works are characteristically very simple and totally abstract conveying only
      the essentials. Straight vertical lines are balanced with straight horizontal lines to
      create stability. Rectangular and square shapes are carefully arranged to create a
      perfect balance. The colours are reduced to the primaries, red, blue and yellow
      and to the neutrals, white, black and grey and exude a sense of purity and clarity.
      Surfaces are smooth, also conveying calmness.

      AN EXAMPLE OF DE STIJL DESIGN:
      Gerrit Rietveld 'Schröder 1924 
      This house is clearly simplified to essential geometric planes that form a careful
      balance of vertical and horizontal lines. Certain components are deliberately
      detached creating the idea that they are gliding past each other in harmony. 
      The colour has been reduced to mainly white, grey and black. These neutral colours
      convey a still feeling. A few accents of blue, red and yellow add contrast and
      life.

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 10

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    10                        DBE/November 2020
                                  SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

      BAROQUE
      Instead of deleting detail in order to achieve simplicity and the essential, Baroque
      design is a celebration of surface decoration and details.  The Catholic Church
      aimed to use Baroque art to get their message across to illiterate people. They
      wanted to use dramatic imagery and exaggerated motion and decoration to evoke
      strong religious feelings and in doing so to control their subjects.
      The Baroque style is influenced by the Counter-Reformation and the Catholic faith
      as it glorified both the power and influence of the Catholic Church and the
      monarchy.
      Characteristically Baroque designs are emotional and move away from the
      Renaissance focus on logic and reason. Their designs are full of theatrical drama,
      energy, excitement, tension and grandeur. Compositions are dynamic and there
      is a lot of interplay between light and shadow. Designs make use of strongly
      contrasting colours and luxurious, expensive materials such as marble, gilding and
      bronze to excite and overwhelm the viewer.
      Interiors are dramatic combinations of architecture, sculpture, silver, silks, rich
      tapestries and luxurious finishes. Both buildings and furniture show angels,
      cupids, saints, sculptures, figurines and fountains.  Buildings are colossal with
      dramatic proportions and consist of many colonnades, domes and a bold play of
      volumes and voids. Large curved and swirling forms, twisted columns, grand
      stairways as well as complicated and elaborate decorations all contribute to
      overwhelm the senses.
      AN EXAMPLE OF BAROQUE DESIGN:
      The Baldacchino of St Peter's Basilica in Rome (1623–1634) by Bernini
      This Baldacchino is a very busy, detailed and ornate structure which clearly does
      not aim to reduce elements to the essentials. It is intended to mark, in a
      monumental way, the place of Saint Peter's tomb. The fact that it is a very large
      structure, consisting of various complex elements is typical of Baroque designs, a
      canopy rests upon four huge twisting columns each of which stands on a high
      marble plinth. These columns support a cornice which curves inwards in the middle
      of each side. Above this, four twice life size angels stand at the corners. Behind
      them four large volutes rise up to a second smaller cornice which in turn supports
      the gilded cross on a sphere, a symbol of the world redeemed by Christianity. The
      four helical columns are 20 metres high. Under the canopy is the high altar of the
      basilica as well as a radiant sun that symbolically shines down on the Pope as he
      leads the service. The monumentality, grandeur, decorative swirls and rich colour
      all work together to make this design full of dramatic emotion rather than calm
      simplicity.
      A maximum of ONLY 7 marks per movement may be allocated for responses
      that do not refer to the statement.
      Credit any other valid statements
        Q4.1LEVEL           COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS   QUESTIONS      MARKS
                                                                                    (20)
        Lower order    Remember, Recall, Recognise         30%         4.1            2
                       Understand, Explain, Describe                                  4
        Middle order   Apply, Implement, Organise          40%         4.1            8
        Higher order   Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                    2
                       Evaluate, Reflect                   30%         4.1            4
                       Synthesise, Justify
Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 11

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                   11                           DBE/November 2020
                                 SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

4.2   [10 marks] (Allocate a maximum of 2 marks for each bullet/aspect.)

      The inspiration of Scandinavian textiles, and its use of stylized, brightly coloured
      organic shapes can be seen in FIGURE I's simplified floral surface pattern. In
      contrast to this use of figurative imagery, FIGURE J could have been inspired by
      the fragmentation and geometric abstraction of movements like Cubism and
      Constructivism. This emphasis of FIGURE I on child-like imagery also shows the
      influence of the 1960's Hippie movement. The undermining of the conventions of
      fashion in FIGURE J show the influence of Dada and Futurism on Deconstructivism.
       This dress reflects the rebellious attitude of the Grunge movement,  whereas
      the floral motifs of FIGURE I are also reminiscent of the curvilinear floral motifs on
      Oriental designs. The Hippie movement's emphasis on peace can be seen in the
      soft colours and shapes of FIGURE I. FIGURE J appears by contrast more chaotic
      than FIGURE I.
      FIGURE I uses a wide range of bright, artificial colours that convey a light-hearted
      atmosphere. In contrast, FIGURE J uses strong red, black and white to create a
      harsher, austere effect. The bright, varied, flat colours in FIGURE I reminds one
      of the psychedelic colour use of the Hippie movement, whereas the harsh colours
      of FIGURE J seem to relate more to the monochromatic, freely applied colours of
      Abstract Expressionism.
      The outline of the dress in FIGURE I is soft, sensual and flowing, suggesting the
      curved female body. The outline of the dress in FIGURE J is however, jagged and
      fragmented and doesn't follow the form of the female. The lines on the floral
      motifs (FIGURE I) form curvilinear rhythms, whereas the lines in FIGURE J are
      angular and harsh to create a machine-like feel.
      The dress in FIGURE I is made from a soft, smooth and silky textured fabric giving
      it a luxurious and feminine feel. In contrast the dress in FIGURE J is constructed
      from hard and stiff plastic making it appear industrial and masculine. The fabric
      used in FIGURE I appears thin and light, whereas FIGURE J makes use of
      layering of solid, thick plastic to create a heavy, armour-like shiny textured
      garment.
      The flower motifs in FIGURE I are filled with organic, flowing linear surface
      patterns. In contrast, the surface pattern on FIGURE J, is formed by abstract
      splashes of colour reminiscent of the paintings of Jackson Pollock. The repetition
      of the circular flower shapes creates a rhythmic circular pattern, whereas the
      repetition of torn, angular pieces of plastic in FIGURE J creates an informal grid
      pattern. 

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 12

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                     12                            DBE/November 2020
                                   SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

      Credit any other valid statements.
      NOTE: A maximum of ONLY 3 marks may be allocated for tabular comparison
      responses. Use cognitive levels as guidelines. A maximum of ONLY 6 marks
      may be allocated for two separate essays.
       Q4.2 LEVEL          COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS   QUESTIONS       MARKS(10)
       Lower order    Remember, Recall, Recognise        30%          4.2               2
                      Understand, Explain, Describe                                     1
       Middle order   Apply, Implement, Organise         40%          4.2               4
       Higher order   Analyse, Compare, Interpret
                      Evaluate, Reflect                  30%          4.2               2
                      Synthesise, Justify                                               1

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 13

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                   13                           DBE/November 2020
                                 SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

SECTION C: DESIGN IN A SOCIO-CULTURAL/ENVIRONMENTAL AND
          SUSTAINABLE CONTEXT

QUESTION 5 [20 marks]

Answer EITHER QUESTION 5.1 OR QUESTION 5.2.

5.1

5.1.1 (Allocate 2 marks)
      The term 'shock tactics' refers to an advertising/marketing strategy, which uses
      shocking imagery to grab the viewer's attention in order to promote services or a
      product.  Shock tactics are employed in the design of the tomato sauce sachet in
      such a way that it shocks and surprises the consumer when the sachet is torn open,
      giving the impression of a severed bleeding limb. This leaves a lasting impression
      on the consumer. These consumers will inform others about the campaign against
      landmines and therefore more people will hear of the campaign than initially
      anticipated. 

5.1.2 (Allocate 4 marks)
     Drunk driving is a prevalent problem in society. Not only do those who drink and
     drive endanger their lives, they also endanger the lives of other users of the road. I
     would make use of pictures taken at the aftermath of an accident caused by drunk
     driving, with scattered bodies and injured individuals to shock the viewer. In this
     way creating an awareness of the dangers of drunk driving and promoting safe
     practices on the road. Placing the billboard in high traffic areas will lead to more
     people seeing the billboard with the hope of educating more people not to drink and
     drive.

      Izinyokanyoka (electric cable thieves), electric cable theft is a problem most
      prevalent in society. Electric cables are stolen to be sold at scrapyards as raw
      copper for a handsome monetary compensation. In my digital billboard I would use
      a video clip of an individual illegally disconnecting and stealing electric cables and
      subsequently being electrocuted, capturing the few moments after the electrocution
      whereby evidence of smoke and burned flesh is apparent. Screams of agony to
      create awareness of the dangers of the practice can be added to the video.
      Credit may be given to learners who describe by using visuals or an illustration. This
      must be accompanied by annotations.
      Credit any other valid statements.

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 14

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                   14                            DBE/November 2020
                                 SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

5.1.3 Allocate 14 marks in total, 7 marks per case study.
      Allocate 1 mark for the name of the designer and the name of design
      product.

       ONE CONTEMPORARY SOUTH AFRICAN DESIGNER/DESIGN GROUP

    Name of a designer/design group/design company and one design product:
     Tutu Tester by Anna van Esch

    The social issue that is addressed:
     The Tutu tester is a mobile clinic that delivers healthcare services in remote
     poverty stricken rural and township areas. Around a fifth of South Africans
     between the ages of 15-49 have HIV. Communities most vulnerable to HIV and TB
     are remote and densely populated. According to the 2016 annual survey, about
     16% of women aged 15-19 have begun childbearing. Some of these girls have to
     drop out of school, the Tutu tester is essential to lowering this number and giving
     women the power of choice over their bodies. The communities residing in these
     remote areas often cannot afford the transportation fares to access primary health
     services often housed in normal government day clinics.

      An analysis of the design and an explanation of how it addresses the social
       issue:
       The Tutu Tester is a colourful medically equipped truck with a bright signature
       rainbow banner. Since its inception in 2008 the Tutu Tester has seen an excess of
       35 000 patients. The mobile clinic focuses on making healthcare accessible to
       township communities while at the same time addressing lifestyle diseases. The
       truck is fitted with care diagnostics, enabling its trained staff to conduct immediate
       HIV and Tuberculosis (TB) testing as well as diabetes and high blood pressure
       testing for free. The mobile clinic also advises patients about their Body Mass
       Index (BMI) and conducts breast and testicular cancer examination. Tutu tester
       also provides family planning services empowering women on their choices
       regarding childbearing. The Tutu Tester operates in the areas from
       Masiphumelele in Noordhoek through to Khayelitsha nearby schools or malls in the
       Western Cape where healthcare services are inadequate.

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 15

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    15                           DBE/November 2020
                                  SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

        ONE INTERNATIONAL DESIGNER/DESIGN GROUP

        Name of a designer/design group/design company and one design product:
         Heatherwick Studio and the Nanyang Technological University (NTU) in
         Singapore, 2015.

       The social issue that is addressed:
        In the information age, the most important commodity on a campus is the creation
        of social spaces to meet and bump into and learn from each other.

         Since the advent of the internet and low-cost computers, there has been a distinct
         shift in how students approach educational facilities. The digital revolution, the
         most important function of this new university building is to nurture togetherness
         and sociability, so that students can meet entrepreneurs, scientists or colleagues
         in a space that encourages collaboration. The outcome is a structure that
         interweaves both social and learning spaces to create a dynamic environment.
         Another inspiration for the New Learning Hub was a wish to break down the
         traditional square forward-facing classrooms with a clear front and hierarchy, and
         move to a corner-less space, where teachers and students mix on an equal
         basis. Each of these tutorial rooms faces the large shared central space,
         allowing students to continually feel connected to all the other activities going on
         in the building.

         The rooms open into the shared circulation space around the atrium, interspersed
         with informal garden terraces, allowing students to be visually connected while
         also leaving space to 'hang out'. The new Learning Hub provides an exciting mix
         of learning, community and recreational spaces for all inhabitants of the building
         to interact. Bringing people and their ideas together, NTU can spark future
         innovations and new dialogues that increasingly happen when disciplines
         collaborate.

        An analysis of the design and an explanation of how it addresses the social
         issue:
          Instead of the traditional educational building with kilometres of corridors the
          university asked for a unique design that is better suited to contemporary ways of
          learning. The hub's form is dictated by its function, and the lack of corridors
          unifies the 56 tutorial rooms. Students can enter from 360 degrees around into
          a large central space which links all the separate towers together. Twelve
          tapering towers create a large public central atrium to provide space for fifty-six
          tutorial rooms. Each tower is made up of a stack of classrooms which build up
          gradually, with gardens on selected floors. The new-generation smart classrooms
          promote more interactive small group teaching and active learning. The flexible
          format of the rooms allows lecturers to better engage with their students,

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 16

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                     16                          DBE/November 2020
                                   SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

         and for students to easily collaborate with each other. With soaring Singapore
         temperatures it was important to maintain the students' comfort whilst achieving a
         sustainable energy usage. The building's open and accessible atrium is
         naturally ventilated, maximising air circulation around the towers of tutorial rooms
         and allowing students to feel cool.

         The primary challenge was to make the choice of concrete feel beautiful. This
         resulted on the concrete stair and elevator cores being embedded with 700
         specially commissioned drawings, three-dimensionally cast into the concrete,
         referencing everything from science to art and literature. Overlapping images,
         specially commissioned from illustrator Sara Fanelli, are deliberately ambiguous
         thought triggers, designed to leave space for the imagination. The curved
         facade panels are cast with a unique horizontal pattern. The building's various
         raw treatments of concrete have been handmade from wet clay.

         Credit any other valid statements.

       Q5.1 LEVEL            COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS   QUESTIONS         MARKS
                                                                                        (20)
       Lower order     Remember, Recall, Recognise          30%          5.1.1            2
                       Understand, Explain, Describe                     5.1.3            4
       Middle order    Apply, Implement, Organise           40%          5.1.2            2
                                                                         5.1.3            6
       Higher order    Analyse, Compare, Interpret                       5.1.2            2
                       Evaluate, Reflect                    30%          5.1.3            2
                       Synthesise, Justify                               5.1.3            2

5.2

5.2.1 (Allocate 4 marks)
      The Dokter and Misses furniture piece (FIGURE L) is a contemporary interpretation
      of traditional African furniture (FIGURE M). This can be seen in its use of geometric
      pattern and bright colours and its block-like form. Whilst these patterns are
      painted on the wood, traditional African furniture makes use of high and low relief
      carvings to form pattern. Traditional furniture (FIGURE M) is mostly carved from
      a single piece of wood, whereas contemporary furniture is manufactured from
      several pieces of wood. In this case processed supa wood is used to give
      FIGURE L a smooth, clean and trendy look, whereas the carving used to create
      traditional furniture (FIGURE M) creates a more personal and hand-made feel.
      Contemporary interpretations of traditional crafts often use synthetic paint for the
      patterns and the surface is varnished with lacquer to create a shiny, machine-like,
      smooth surface. Traditional crafts such as the stool in FIGURE M use raw wood,
      which is burnished and polished with animal fats to create a more organic feel.

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 17

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    17                           DBE/November 2020
                                  SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

5.2.2 (Allocate 6 marks)
    History/Origins
      The traditional beehive huts are known as iQukwane. Traditional isiZulu hut craft
      forms part of the hut/rondavel indigenous knowledge and historically forms part of
      the traditional isiZulu Beehive Huts monument buildings and precincts.

      Materials and Techniques
       The role of isiZulu men in the society is to collect the outer sticks and place them in
       a circle on the ground. The women then bind and thatch the structure using
       braided split reeds and grass. A central sapling tree trunk acts as a support and
       the door is made low so that one has to stoop before entering. After the frame is
       complete, it is thatched with grass. Cow-dung and termite clay is mixed to a thick
       consistency and spread to form the floor which sets rock hard and may be polished
       to a mirror-like finish using a polishing stone. The same material is used to form
       a raised hearth near the central pole. The materials and the process make the hut
       stable, warm in winter and cool in summer. Smoke from the fire escapes out the
       door or through the thatch that has the effect of constantly fumigating the hut of
       insects.

      Functions
       The huts are hierarchically arranged in a circular kraal formation. The isiZulu term
       is umuzi and consists of two concentric fences of thorn trunks. The huts are
       located inside the outer fence and the cattle in the inner circle with a smaller
       enclosure there for the calves.

       The cattle are kept in the middle protected from wild predators. The isiZulu society
       lives as a close- knit community with a central hearth where all cooking is done by
       the women.

       The kraal is usually built on a slight slope with the main entrance at the lower end.
       This enables rainwater to clean the cattle kraal, the ground dries quickly and any
       foe has to fight uphill.

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 18

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                    18                           DBE/November 2020
                                  SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

       Small huts on poles act as storage huts or watchtowers. The largest hut, opposite
       the entrance, is that of the chief's mother. The chief's hut is to the right, the first
       wife is to the right of the chief's mother, and the second wife is to the left of the
       chief's hut, the third wife to the right of the first wife and so on. The unmarried
       girls live on the left of the entrance, the unmarried boys, to the right. The two elder
       sons inspect visitors and guard the entrance around the clock. Visitors are either
       rejected, expected to wait for an appropriate time or welcome in immediately
       depending on their relation to the family. Those that are allowed in experience
       the siyakuleka ikhaya display where the gatekeeper sings the praises of the chief.
       The function of gatekeeper is also very useful in another way in that he will assume
       the role of chief on his father's death and will be familiar with all those who visited
       his father and their treatment. White flags over a kraal mean that an engagement
       is imminent whilst red/white flags over a bridegroom's kraal indicate that he has to
       go through tears and longing (red) to reach the love of his sweetheart.

       Credit any other valid statements.

5.2.3 (Allocate 10 marks)

      Name the designer/design group and ONE design product:
       Nicholas Plewman Architects in association with Michaelis Boyd Associates,
       Sandibe Okavango Safari Lodge,  Okavanga Delta, Botswana, 2015.

      Aims of the designer/design group
       One main aim of the architects was that the lodge had to be wholly built of
       ultimately bio-degradable materials and 70 % of the lodge had to be of sustainable
       origin. They strived to have minimal to zero physical impact of any sort on the site,
       fauna and flora. They also aimed for the final building to appear to have grown
       organically from its site.

      Influences on the designer/design group
       The natural, organically shaped lodge is influenced by the biomorphic forms of
       animals that use their shell as part of their shelter or birds that weave shelters from
       the organic materials in their environment. The architects chose the pangolin –
       Africa's armadillo –as a specific motif because of its shy, elusive, and completely
       harmless nature and its ability to curl up. The curved exposed beams of the
       lodge also imitates the ribcage of animal carcasses. Another possible reference for
       the exposed beams could be elephant tusks and the domed form of the grass roof
       that resembles a tortoise shell.

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 19

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                     19                         DBE/November 2020
                                   SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

      Analysis of the design, explaining how it is an adaptation and continuation of
       the indigenous craft technique.
       The lodge structure is unique and modern, but its structure incorporates various
       local craft knowledge techniques found in and around Botswana. The lodge is
       built almost entirely of wood. Laminated pine beams create curvilinear forms that
       seem to have taken their inspiration from the inverted boat layers of butt jointed
       pine planks, but also from the skeletal frame of a basket and of traditional huts.
       External screen walls and balustrades are fashioned from an interlocking mat of
       eucalyptus laths woven onto stiff wire. Reference here could be traditional basket
       weaving techniques. The entrance of the dome is reminiscent of traditional Zulu
       hut architecture. These traditional craft techniques form part of the structure of
       the building that unifies the building with local heritage and ensures the
       continuation of this knowledge.

       Credit any other valid statements.

       NO marks should be given for repetition of designer(s) and their work used
       in this question paper.

       Q5.2 LEVEL            COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS   QUESTIONS       MARKS
                                                                                      (20)
       Lower order     Remember, Recall, Recognise          30%          5.2.1          2
                       Understand, Explain, Describe                 5.2.2 + 5.2.3    2+2
       Middle order    Apply, Implement, Organise           40%          5.2.1          2
                                                                     5.2.2 + 5.2.3    3+3
       Higher order    Analyse, Compare, Interpret                   5.2.2 + 5.2.3    2+2
                       Evaluate, Reflect                    30%      5.2.2 + 5.2.3    1+1
                       Synthesise, Justify

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 20

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                   20                           DBE/November 2020
                                 SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 6 [20 marks]

6.1

6.1.1 (Allocate 3 marks)
      Vertical forests simulated through this building increase biodiversity. They help to
      set up an urban ecosystem where a different kind of vegetation creates a vertical
      environment which can also be colonised by birds and insects, and therefore
      becomes both a magnet for and a symbol of the spontaneous re-colonisation of the
      city by vegetation and by animal life.

       Vertical forests help to build a micro-climate and to filter dust particles which are
       present in the urban environment. The diversity of the plants helps to create
       humidity and absorbs CO2 and dust. It produces oxygen, protects people and
       houses from harmful sunrays and from acoustic pollution.

       Vertical forests are an anti-sprawl measure which aims to control and reduce urban
       expansion. If we think of them in terms of urban densification, each tower of the
       vertical forest is equivalent to an area of urban sprawl of family houses and
       buildings of up to 50,000 square metres.
       Credit any other valid statement/s that refers to how the building promote/s a
       healthy environment.

 6.1.2 (Allocate 3 marks)
      Effective Recycling
      Inventive methods need to be developed that will transform how we take care of
      our waste. One method is to reward homeowners for recycling with weighable
      recyclables, in which sanitation workers weigh the recycle bin and provide
      compensation based on weight to incentivise energy efficient ways of removing
      waste.

       Invest in renewable energy
       Solar, wind, geothermal, low-impact hydro and biofuels are sources of renewable
       energy. A policy of granting energy tax credits to companies who buy 'green
       power' would incentivise buildings to choose sustainable sources of energy.

       Install ventilation system
       Installing a ventilation system can reduce the need for air conditioning, which can
       keep your carbon footprint and electricity bill low. Replace your windows
       with fibre glass and wood frames, add improved insulation and high thermal mass
       ceilings to circulate the air. These small details add up to improve the quality of
       your workplace, buildings and cities.

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 21

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1                                       21                            DBE/November 2020
                                     SC/NSC – Marking Guidelines

          Green Lifestyle
          The use of energy efficient LED light bulbs. LED lights do not emit as much heat as
          incandescent or fluorescent light bulbs which gives them a longer life span,
          consequently cutting maintenance costs. These bulbs can also be used for street
          lights and traffic lights.
          Credit any other valid statements

6.2       Allocate 14 marks in total, 7 marks per case study.
          Allocate 1 mark for the name of the designer and the name of design
          product

          ONE CONTEMPORARY SOUTH AFRICAN DESIGNER/DESIGN GROUP

         Name of the designer and design
          Suzanne Lambert, Vukheta Mukhari and Han Beushausen designed the Bio-
          brick.

         The environmental issues that have been addressed
          The urine brick is an innovative solution to waste recovery and upcycling. The
          urine brick is significant because it will provide an alternative form of calcium
          phosphate, a key ingredient in fertilisers used for commercial farming worldwide.
          Commercial farming is pivotal to the economy and food supply in the country.
          The development is also good news for the environment and global warming as
          bio-bricks are made in moulds at room temperature. Regular bricks are kiln-fired
          at temperatures around 1400°C and produce vast quantities of carbon dioxide.

         An analysis of the design and an explanation of how it addresses the
          environmental issue.
          Chemically speaking, urine is liquid gold. It contains nitrogen, phosphorus and
          potassium. Some 97% of the phosphorus present in the urine can be converted
          into calcium-phosphate, the key ingredient in fertilisers that underpin commercial
          farming worldwide. This is significant because the world's natural phosphate
          reserves are running dry. Additionally, the bio-brick has the potential to be 40 per
          cent stronger than a traditional limestone brick. The longer the bacteria is allowed
          to make the cement the stronger the brick becomes.

          First, urine is collected in novel fertiliser-producing urinals and used to make a solid
          fertiliser. The remaining liquid is then used in the biological process to grow the
          bio-brick. The bio-bricks go through a natural chemical process, a procedure
          called microbial carbonate precipitation. Loose sand is colonised with bacteria
          that produce urea, which is an enzyme. Through a complex chemical reaction,
          urea breaks down to form urine and produce calcium carbonate.

Copyright reserved                                                                Please turn over

Text truncated here. Open the document page to read the rest.

## Related documents

- [Design P1 Nov 2019 Memo Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2019-memo-eng/897e5c02-af3d-4258-9c23-310678ff22eb) — Design · Memo · 2019 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2019 Memo Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2019-memo-afr/c292473a-3cdf-4c69-af4e-eff39790b65a) — Design · Memo · 2019 · Afr
- [Design P1 Nov 2018 FINAL Memo Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2018-final-memo-eng/7d38596e-8011-4dbd-addb-c69766e3bc61) — Design · Memo · 2018 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2018 FINAL Memo Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2018-final-memo-afr/bc30bd03-407d-4fec-ae72-a424eff53b59) — Design · Memo · 2018 · Afr
- [Design P1 Nov 2017 Memo Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2017-memo-eng/f5d8441f-5f2c-49d8-ab92-8da621e89e48) — Design · Memo · 2017 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2017 Memo Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2017-memo-afr/05878128-7eb2-4f90-8a89-c8a7327dbca5) — Design · Memo · 2017 · Afr

## More from Grade 12 Design

- [Gr 12 Des ATP 2023-24](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/gr-12-des-atp-2023-24/0fd522c6-2d5a-4c5b-9e0b-06e7b199eb25) — ATP
- [Design P1 May-June 2025 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-may-june-2025-afr/e35d300a-db4f-4a06-ba8a-6f659dbd37ad) — QP · 2025 · Afr
- [Design P1 Nov 2025 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12-design-2025-nsc-november-exam-question-paper-paper-1/3f14a710-b913-44a8-ade1-31e4d395f557) — QP · 2025 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2025 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12-design-2025-nsc-november-exam-question-paper-paper-1/47ba80e3-12dd-4fd4-8302-34e3b97a6b9a) — QP · 2025 · Afr
- [Design P1 Nov 2024 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2024-eng/3f0bd4c5-8226-45ef-87fa-5c9996cba696) — QP · 2024 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2024 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2024-afr/6958913b-f502-40d3-8387-1f0a78a3ed25) — QP · 2024 · Afr

## Collection

- [Grade 12 past papers](https://www.hlayiso.com/grade-12/past-papers)

---

Hlayiso: free CAPS and IEB past papers, memos, notes and study guides for South African learners. When citing, link the page URL above, not a PDF or /api/ URL.
