# Design Grade 12 Paper 1 November 2024 NSC Memo (English)

> Grade 12 Design Paper 1 memorandum from the November 2024 NSC (English), 20 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.

- Page: https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2024-mg-eng/9820c703-6477-42b8-aaf5-c61bdc1b2e54
- Updated: 2026-10-29
- Subject: Design
- Grade: Grade 12
- Document type: Memorandum
- Year: 2024
- Exam period: November 2024 NSC
- Paper: 1
- Curriculum: CAPS
- Pages: 20

Breadcrumbs: [Home](https://www.hlayiso.com/) › [Library](https://www.hlayiso.com/library) › [Grade 12](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12) › [Design](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12/design) › [Design Grade 12 Paper 1 November 2024 NSC Memo (English)](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2024-mg-eng/9820c703-6477-42b8-aaf5-c61bdc1b2e54)

## About this document

Design · Grade 12 · November 2024 NSC · 2024. Memorandum. Read online or download the PDF.

Read it free online on the page above; download the PDF from there.

## Document text

Text extracted from the PDF. Layout, diagrams and tables may not survive extraction.

### Page 1

NATIONAL
                            SENIOR CERTIFICATE

                                    GRADE 12

                                    DESIGN P1

                                     (THEORY)

                                 NOVEMBER 2024

                             MARKING GUIDELINES

MARKS: 100

                     These marking guidelines consist of 20 pages.

Copyright reserved                                                   Please turn over

### Page 2

Design/P1                                       2                              DBE/November 2024
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

 SECTION A: DESIGN LITERACY

 QUESTION 1: 'UNSEEN' EXAMPLES [10 marks]
 Candidates answer EITHER QUESTION 1.1 OR QUESTION 1.2.

 1.   (Allocate a maximum of 2 marks for each bullet/aspect.)

 1.1.1         In the background of the textile design there is variety of floating, flat, organic,
         biomorphic shapes that remind one of the shapes created by a lava lamp. In
         front of these are interconnected shield-like or leaf-like shapes that form a vertical,
         chain-like, repetitive pattern creating a striking textile design.

         There are a variety of colours in the textile which are bold, bright and eye-
         catching. The warm, pure magenta dominates the design giving it a joyful,
         feminine or retro quality. Cool blues, green and purple contrast with the warm
         magenta pink creating an exciting and vibrant design. The inclusion of the
         neutral colours, white and black, adds contrast and emphasis to the design.

         The design reflects strong white cloisonnistic outlines. These white outlines
         separate the shapes in the foreground from the flat background and create a
         strong eye-catching contrast. The white contour lines create a vertically flowing,
         curvilinear movement. Inside the leaf-like shapes, spiky lines move horizontally
         and vertically, adding a decorative quality to the design.

         A dynamic rhythm is created by the repetition of the vibrant pink, blue and green
         colours. The repeated spiky lines in the foreground create an optical movement
         and a dynamic rhythm. The repetition of the organic pattern in the background
         and the foreground also adds to the rhythmic quality of the design.

 1.1.2         The stylised shield-like shapes remind one of African tribal shields. The
         thin, black repeated lines in the larger, shield-like shapes, remind us of animal
         horns or tusks. The sharp, thin, long thorns of African thorn trees and the rounded
         organic shape reminds one of pebbles. The thin, horizontal, spiky line patterns
         in the smaller, simplified, flat, shield-like shapes can also allude to African tribal
         body paint decoration and scarification.
         Credit any other valid statements.
              Q1.1 LEVEL               COGNITIVE SKILLS         WEIGHTINGS      QUESTIONS      MARKS
                                                                                                (10)
            Lower order     Remember, Recall, Recognise             30%            1.1.1         2
                            Understand, Explain, Describe                                        1
            Middle order    Apply, Implement, Organise              40%            1.1.1         4
            Higher order    Analyse, Compare, Interpret                            1.1.2         2
                            Evaluate, Reflect                       30%            1.1,1         1
                            Synthesise, Justify

                                                   OR
Copyright reserved                                                                  Please turn over

### Page 3

Design/P1                                        3                         DBE/November 2024
                                      NSC – Marking Guidelines

1.2   (Allocate a maximum of 2 marks for each bullet/aspect.)

1.2.1 Movement is created through the flexible, wavelike/twisted woven basket attached to
      the raku fired ceramic vessel through a unique juxtapositioning of materials. The
      extended repeated vertical lines of the vessel create a soft flowing movement. The
      cracks caused by the raku glaze technique create a dynamic, undulating (wave-like)
      movement.

       One of the most recognisable features of raku fired ceramics is the crackle glaze. The
       rapid cooling of the glazed pieces creates a network of fine cracks in the glaze, giving
       the surface a smooth but visually textured appearance. The woven basketry section
       of the vessel clearly shows a rough tactile texture. White dots also add to the tactile
       feel that contrast with the glazed smooth feel of the raku fired pot.

       The traditional form of the clay pot has been altered; it is split and extended by the
       addition of basket weaving from the rim of the ceramic base. The form becomes
       trumpet and flower-like, with the basketry fanning outwards at the top. The form is
       vertically split to create a focal point. This split form reveals a glowing orange interior
       colour created by the raku glaze.

       The vessel is eclectic in nature because it borrows from a variety of Eastern and
       African styles and cultures to create a new innovative design. The basketry is
       possibly inspired by African basketry and the raku glaze is found in Japan, an Eastern
       culture. The raised white dots found on the clay pot reference African tribal face
       painting and body scarification.

1.2.2 This vessel is not functional as it is cut open and will not be able to hold liquids. The
      purpose of this vessel is decorative as it makes a strong aesthetic statement and can
      be used to beautify an interior. Both the raku and basket weaving techniques are
      used as expressive media rather than to create a utilitarian object. Alternatively, the
      vessel could be considered to be functional as it could hold an arrangement of dried
      flowers and twigs.

       Credit any other valid statements.

             Q1.2 LEVEL             COGNITIVE SKILLS       WEIGHTINGS    QUESTIONS     MARKS
                                                                                        (10)
            Lower order    Remember, Recall, Recognise           30%        1.2.1         2
                           Understand, Explain, Describe                                  1
            Middle order   Apply, Implement, Organise            40%        1.2.1         4
            Higher order   Analyse, Compare, Interpret                      1.2.2         2
                           Evaluate, Reflect                     30%        1.2.1         1
                           Synthesise, Justify

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 4

Design/P1                                      4                           DBE/November 2024
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

 QUESTION 2: COMMUNICATION THROUGH DESIGN [10 marks]

 2.1 (Allocate 4 marks.)

      The message of the poster is that gender stereotyping is dangerous and imposed on
      young, impressionable children. The images of the small children holding teddy bears,
      appear vulnerable against the large, looming, evil and ominous looking black image of
      a figure which is behind the two little children. The text contained in the hands refers
      to gender stereotypes of boys (e.g. tough, manly) and girls (e.g. kind, ladylike); it
      describes what characteristics are expected from them. The text is contained in
      shapes that create the image of large, overpowering, claw like nails reaching in a
      threatening fashion towards the small images of the children. The words drawn in the
                                                                       

      hand on the right shows words like tough, manly, forceful, aggressive, etc. and
      reinforces the character expectation of males, whereas the words used for the female
      hand, i.e. ladylike, dumb, crazy, simple, etc. reinforce the stereotypical character of
      females. The white sans serif text at the bottom of the poster contrasts with the black
      landscape and draws your attention to the two small white images of the children.

 2.2 (Allocate 6 marks. A maximum of 2 marks for each bullet/aspect.)

      The form in FIGURE D is influenced by a traditional amaZulu hat (IsiCholo) worn by a
      women to indicate that she is married. The hairstyle in FIGURE E is influenced by
      the 1960s urban western Pop culture and is a fashion statement making the wearer
      glamorous and stylish in appearance.

      The form of the hairstyle in FIGURE D looks like a tall, wide funnel with a flat top and
      is static. It is a strong, geometric, cylindrical form giving the married woman a majestic
      quality. The form of the beehive hairstyle in FIGURE E is also tall, organic,
      voluminous and imposing, but it is softer and more organic/voluminous than FIGURE
      D.

      The tactile texture of the hairstyle in FIGURE D is coarse and stiff and embellished
      with a border of smooth, shiny beads. The variety of textures creates an interesting,
      decorative hairstyle design. The convoluted hairstyle in FIGURE E has a smooth and
      silky texture, and hairspray has been used to set the rigid beehive form.

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 5

Design/P1                                       5                        DBE/November 2024
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

      NOTE: A maximum of ONLY 2 marks may be allocated for tabular
      comparison responses. A maximum of 4 marks may be allocated where
      candidates present two separate comparisons that show substantial and
      relevant statements. Use the cognitive levels as a guideline for your marking.

      Credit any other valid statements.

            Q2 LEVEL            COGNITIVE SKILLS        WEIGHTINGS   QUESTIONS       MARKS
                                                                                      (10)
       Lower order     Remember, Recall, Recognise          30%         2.1            2
                       Understand, Explain, Describe                    2.1            1
       Middle order    Apply, Implement, Organise           40%         2.1            1
                                                                        2.2            2

       Higher order    Analyse, Compare, Interpret                      2.2            2
                       Evaluate, Reflect                    30%         2.2            2
                       Synthesise, Justify

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 6

Design/P1                                     6                          DBE/November 2024
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

 QUESTION 3 [10 marks]

 NOTE: Only two examples (3.1 and 3.3) will be discussed for these marking guidelines.

3.1 (Allocate a maximum of 2 marks per bullet/aspect for a total of 10 marks.)

      The Panathenaic Stadium of Athens was inspired by the patron goddess Athena, and
      the need to host the various performances and competitions/combats of the
      Panathenaic festival which were held every four years. In contrast, the new Marques
      de Riscal hotel was influenced by the twisted forms of grape vine tendrils and
      branches. The pink, gold and silver coloured canopies are inspired by the colours of
      wine and the fragmented, chaotic character of the Deconstructivist movement. It is
      influenced by Gehry's previous Guggenheim art gallery in Bilbao, Spain, which served
      as a catalyst to place Bilbao on the cultural map of Europe. Similarly, the Marqués de
      Riscal hotel and winery complex also opens up new possibilities for the future of the
      small town of Elciego.

      The ancient Panathenaic Stadium is built from a locally available, natural marble-
      coloured stone called poros which is a lightweight, soft limestone that was widely used
      in construction and statues of Ancient Greece. Tiers of stone benches were arranged
      around the track. In contrast, the Marques de Riscal makes use of modern high-tech
      materials in the construction process. Reinforced concrete, which is clad in sandstone,
      is used for the main parts of the building. The bulk of the building consists of many
      different sweeping, steel canopies anchored by steel columns. The canopies are lined
      with titanium and colours of gold, pink and a polished mirror finish.

      The Panathenaic Stadium does not show any organic forms but is created around the
      sunken rounded rectangular form of the athletic track with surrounding tiered seats
      constructed into the sloping sides of the ravine. The undulating forms of the
      canopies of the Marques de Riscal hotel create an explosion of colour and a sense of
      movement, and the vertically receding floor plan gives the overall form of the building
      a pyramid-like appearance. The undulating organic forms are interrupted with
      rectilinear ones clad in natural blonde sandstone which create a relationship with the
      surrounding buildings of the area.

      The Panathenaic Stadium is situated in a ravine and was built to honour the patron
      goddess of Athens, the cultural centre of Greece. It was possibly built over a pre-
      existing sport facility and upgraded with stone seating for the 'privileged few' whereas
      previously spectators would have sat on the natural slopes on the side of the stadium.
      The Marques de Riscal is situated on the site of a long-standing wine farm in the Riojas
      area which is famous for its wine production. The height of the avant- garde building
      does not surpass that of the church bell tower in the small city of Elciego so as to
      preserve the identity of this small agricultural population of the La Rioja region.

Copyright reserved                                                          Please turn over

### Page 7

Design/P1                                      7                           DBE/November 2024
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

      The Panathenaic Stadium was built specifically to host the Panathenaea Games,
      mainly used for athletic competitions but its running track was also a place where,
      during cult festivals, wild animals were slaughtered and gladiator's fought. The
      Marques de Riscal winery complex functions as a space for the production of wine as
      well as a space for leisure and has become a tourism site of note within the important
      historical wine producing area of Rioja. The complex produces and cares for studies
      involved in the process of wine making as well as providing a venue for wine tasting.
      The hotel contains a restaurant, exclusive suites, meeting/conference rooms and a
      specialised shop that sells products related to the winery.

                                                  OR

3.2   The candidate is required to write an essay by comparing any a Classical
      building/structure with a contemporary building that they have studied by referring to
      the given bullets. Allocate 2 marks per bullet. Credit any valid statements.

                                                  OR

3.3   A CLASSICAL OR CLASSICALLY INSPIRED BUILDING/STRUCTURE COMPARED
      WITH AN INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE SYSTEMS (IKS) BUILDING/STRUCTURE

      The Pantheon is compared with the iSwati beehive hut:

      The influences of Classical Greek architecture is evident in the exterior of the
      Pantheon which borrows much from the exterior of the Parthenon in Athens. This
      influence can be seen in the Pantheon's use of a pediment and the Corinthian capitals
      used on the columns of the porch; however, the domed main building is more Roman
      in style. The iSwati hut functions as a manifestation of the eSwatini identity and is
      inspired by the need for protection and their traditions in their cultural beliefs as well
      as the natural materials that were readily available in their environment.

      The material used to construct the circular building of the Pantheon is brick and
      concrete; the exterior was originally clad with marble stucco to match the porch.
      These heavy, strong, and grand materials successfully communicated the importance
      of the Roman emperor and empire. The iSwati hut is constructed entirely from
      natural materials which are specifically selected according to their building
      properties. The sustainable building method and materials makes use of dried
      thatching grass which is harvested from the immediate environment and a sapling
      framework bound with twine.

      Both the Pantheon and the iSwati hut are constructed on a circular base and make
      use of the dome as a dominant form. The iSwati hut is constructed with a central
      sapling trunk which acts as the main support. Once the framework has been
      constructed, it is thatched with grass to form a beehive. The materials and
      construction technology make the hut stable, warm in winter and cool in summer.
      The dome of the Pantheon is constructed using an innovative, new construction
      technique which allowed for the dimensions of the interior height and the diameter of
      the dome to be the same. The span of the dome remains the largest unreinforced
      dome ever constructed and is proof of the Roman engineering expertise.

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 8

Design/P1                                      8                            DBE/November 2024
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

      The weight of the dome is reduced by five rings of 28 coffers which reduce in size as
      they rise towards the oculus. The oculus at the dome's apex and the entry door are
      the only natural sources of light in the interior. Throughout the day, light from the oculus
      moves around this space in a reverse sundial effect: marking time with light rather than
      shadow. The oculus also offers cooling and ventilation; during storms, a drainage
      system below the floor handles rain falling through the oculus.

      The iSwati beehive hut is one of the few cultures that create decorative patterns in the
      thatching grass; bound tufts and twine patterns are created to frame the low
      entrance. Similarly the Pantheon is decorated on the exterior of the building by
      sixteen monolithic columns on the porch. The columns and decorative capitals are
      made with Egyptian granite, and the bases are carved from white Greek
      marble. The interior walls and floor are decorated in marble and gilt and the exterior
      of the Pantheon was originally decorated with marble stucco.

      The structure of the Classical building, the Pantheon, reflects its function. The name,
      structure of the porch and pediment decoration suggest the original function of the
      building was a temple. It was designed as a place from where the emperor could
      make public appearances and housed statues of the many gods of the Roman
      pantheistic society. When viewing the iSwati beehive hut, the structure also reveals
      its function: the thick thatching grass provides protection from the harsh climate and
      the low entrance provided protection from enemies as they would have to stoop in a
      vulnerable position to gain entrance to the hut.

      Credit must be given to any other valid statements or a comparison of a
      Classical or Classically inspired building/structure with any contemporary
      building or a comparison of a Classical or Classically inspired building/
      structure with any Indigenous Knowledge Systems (IKS) building/structure that
      the candidate has studied.

      NOTE: A maximum of ONLY 3 marks may be allocated for tabular comparison
      responses. A maximum of 7 marks may be allocated where candidates present
      two separate essays that show substantial and relevant statements. Use
      cognitive levels as a guideline for your marking.

            Q3. LEVEL          COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS     QUESTIONS       MARKS
                                                                                          (10)
       Lower order       Remember, Recall, Recognise           30%       3.1, 3.2, 3.3     1
                         Understand, Explain, Describe                                     2
       Middle order      Apply, Implement, Organise            40%       3.1, 3.2, 3.3     4
       Higher order      Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                       1
                         Evaluate, Reflect                     30%       3.1, 3.2, 3.3     2
                         Synthesise, Justify

                                                                       TOTAL SECTION A:              30

Copyright reserved                                                              Please turn over

### Page 9

Design/P1                                     9                          DBE/November 2024
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

 SECTION B: DESIGN HISTORY
 QUESTION 4 [30 marks]
 4.1 Allocate 20 marks in total.
     Allocate 10 marks for each movement: 5 marks in total for aims, influences
     and characteristics; 2 marks for a discussion of the design example, 1 mark
     for the name of a designer and design and 2 marks for reference to the
     statement in the context of the design movement. The answer must be written in
     full sentences, with each fact substantiated listing must be avoided.
      NOTE: ONLY ONE mark can be allocated for the name of a designer and
      design of each movement. Use the cognitive levels as guidelines.

      These marking guidelines supply an answer for the following two possibilities:
      •     ARTS AND CRAFTS MOVEMENT
      •     BAUHAUS
      THE ARTS AND CRAFTS MOVEMENT
      Relevance of the statement
      The Arts and Craft Movement produced good designs because the form was
      determined by function, e.g. joins were left visible and became part of the exterior
      design and aesthetics of the product. The aesthetic value of the products were also
      important – decoration was used to enhance the basic design.
      Discuss the aims, influences and stylistic characteristics
      One of the main aims of the Arts and Crafts movement was to provide an alternative
      to the fussy over-decorated mass-produced goods of the 19th century. They aimed
      to re-establish the value and involvement of the skilled craftsman and designer to
      improve the quality of the design. The production of quality handmade goods was
      encouraged as opposed to mass-produced low-quality products. Products had to be
      simple and function well. Ornamentation was kept to the minimum on furniture, but
      stylised images from nature ensured the aesthetic appeal of surface designs on
      textiles, carpets, wall hangings and ceramics.
      The Arts and Crafts movement was influenced by the organic lines and shapes of
      leaves, plants and birds resulting in aesthetically pleasing curvilinear surface designs
      full of movement. The use of unadorned local stone, exposed roof beams and
      floorboards reflecting the natural grain of wood, influenced by the Rustic English
      Cottage style's use of natural materials, added to the aesthetically pleasing quality of
      these designs. The Gothic styles' emphasis on order, function and simplicity was
      another influence. Their interest in the Medieval Gothic style also led to the use of
      mythological creatures such as dragons as subject matter and the use of medieval
      design motifs like the trefoil and the quatrefoil.
      Characteristically shapes on surface designs were flat and organic with clear outlines
      forming controlled curvilinear rhythms. These surface designs consisted mostly of
      symmetrically balanced compositions stabilising the movement and conveying an
      overall sense of order. Flat areas of rich, bold colours were used in different shades
      of blue, yellow and red, often reminiscent of Gothic stained glass windows. These
      were at times combined with earth tones.
      One example of the Arts and Crafts movement is the Library Table by Gustave
      Stickley.

Copyright reserved                                                          Please turn over

### Page 10

Design/P1                                    10                          DBE/November 2024
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

      The Library Table is both functional and aesthetically pleasing. The table is sturdy and
      simple, but at the same time decorative due to the hexagonal shaped top, the textured
      leather covering and the row of studs holding the cover in place. Typical of the Arts
      and Crafts movement is the use of wood, a natural material, as well as of exposed joins
      to reflect the hand of the craftsman. Also typical is the fact that the wood has been
      left unpainted to reveal the natural patterns formed by the grain of the wood.

      BAUHAUS
      Relevance of the statement
      The Bauhaus created good designs that were functional and mass-produced, but at
      the same time aesthetically pleasing. They believed that function should determine
      form. All surface decoration was rejected and the beauty of products lay in perfectly
      balanced, pure, geometric forms, clean lines and smooth textures. 

      Discuss the aims, influences and stylistic characteristics
      The Bauhaus aimed to bring design back into contact with everyday life by reuniting
      aesthetic and functional design. They wanted to narrow the gap between artist and
      craftsman by founding the Bauhaus School.

      The Bauhaus was influenced by the Cubists' striving for essential simplicity through
      the reduction of forms to simple, geometric shapes. They were also influenced by the
      machine-age and believed that their designs should be geometric, with clean edges
      and smooth surfaces, reflecting this machine aesthetic.

      The Bauhaus characteristically made use of pure geometric forms like cubes, cones
      and spheres that conveyed calmness and stability. The outlines of these forms were
      clear and precise reminiscent of machinery. Materials are modern and mostly
      machine-produced such as concrete, reinforced concrete, reinforced glass, and steel,
      giving products and buildings an industrial look. Surfaces are unadorned, smooth
      and sleek, placing the attention on the structure and function of the design. Extreme
      simplicity, the use of quality materials and beautifully finished surfaces ensured the
      aesthetic appeal of these designs.

      An example of a Bauhaus design that reflects both functionality and aesthetic appeal
      are the Bauhaus Nesting Tables by Joseph Albers.

Copyright reserved                                                          Please turn over

### Page 11

Design/P1                                      11                             DBE/November 2024
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

      The four tables are functional in that they can be fitted into each other to form one unit
      to save space in an area where space is a concern. Each one of the four tables can
      be used for a variety of other functions, e.g. as a little desk, to serve tea from, put drinks
      on, etc. Each table in this set of four tables is a perfect, mechanical-looking, cube-
      like form, typical of Bauhaus design. Straight, slender wooden lines frame the front
      and back of the table top and continue downwards to form the legs. The table top
      forms a solid rectangle and the legs surround a rectangular space. The repetition of
      rectangles results in a very unified, ordered and balanced design, which are also typical
      characteristics of Bauhaus designs. The glass tops are lacquered on the underside
      in shades of minty green, yellow, orange and blue to add a fun aspect to a living-room.
      

      Credit any other valid statements.
            Q4.1 LEVEL          COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS      QUESTIONS MARKS
                                                                                      (20)
      Lower order         Remember, Recall, Recognise           30%           4.1       2
                          Understand, Explain, Describe                                 4
      Middle order        Apply, Implement, Organise            40%           4.1       8
      Higher order        Analyse, Compare, Interpret                                   2
                          Evaluate, Reflect                     30%           4.1       4
                          Synthesise, Justify

 4.2 [10 marks] (Allocate a maximum of 2 marks for each bullet/aspect.)

      The ring in FIGURE H reflects the Deconstructivist's aim to fragment forms in order to
      explore parts rather than to create harmony, unity and balance. In contrast the Art
      Nouveau ring in FIGURE I aims to repeat the sensual forms and lines of nature to
      create rhythmic unity.

      The Deconstructivist ring is clearly influenced by the interest of Cubism in fragmenting
      objects into geometric lines and shapes, whereas the Art Nouveau ring shows the
      influence of organic forms of nature such as peacocks. The Deconstructivist ring is
      large, cluttered and spiky, showing the influence of the Anti-Design movement's
      questioning of conventional standards of beauty, whereas the Art Nouveau ring
      consists of soothing, smooth, swirling surfaces and forms.

      The Deconstructivist ring is cut up by many criss-crossing, straight, diagonal lines,
      typical of Deconstructivist designs, resulting in sharp, broken movements. In
      comparison the whiplash line created by the flowing, sensuous outline of the peacock
      head and neck which wrap around the Art Nouveau ring, is more continuous and
      swirling.

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 12

Design/P1                                      12                          DBE/November 2024
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

      A flowing rhythm is created by the repeated, curved peacock heads in FIGURE I that
      sinuously wrap around the central gemstone. An outward radiating rhythm is created
      by the repetition of the fanlike lines and circles on top of the peacock heads. In
      contrast, a chaotic rhythm is created by the straight, angular, haphazard placed lines
      in FIGURE H.

      Ergonomics (comfort to the wearer) is clearly not one of the main aims of the
      Deconstructivist ring as it must be quite heavy on the finger and its protruding lines will
      hook into many things whilst moving the hand and finger. The Art Nouveau ring
      seems lighter and more comfortable to wear. The peacock crown feathers extend on
      either side of the centre of the ring along the finger which will make them less likely to
      hook into things,  the ring is very uncomfortable on the finger.

      Credit any other valid statements.

      NOTE: A maximum of ONLY 3 marks may be allocated for tabular
      comparison responses. A maximum of 7 marks may be allocated where
      candidates present two separate essays that show substantial and relevant
      statements. Use cognitive levels as a guideline for your marking.

            Q4.2 LEVEL         COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS    QUESTIONS       MARKS
                                                                                         (10)
       Lower order       Remember, Recall,                      30%          4.2          2
                         Recognise
                         Understand, Explain,                                             1
       Middle order      Describe
                         Apply, Implement, Organise             40%         4.2           4
       Higher order      Analyse, Compare, Interpret
                         Evaluate, Reflect                      30%         4.2            2
                         Synthesise, Justify                                               1

                                                                       TOTAL SECTION B:             30

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 13

Design/P1                                    13                          DBE/November 2024
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

 SECTION C:          DESIGN IN A SOCIOCULTURAL/ENVIRONMENTAL AND SUSTAINABLE
                     CONTEXT

QUESTION 5 [20 marks]

Answer EITHER QUESTION 5.1 OR QUESTION 5.2.

5.1

5.1.1    (Allocate 4 marks.)
          A positive feature of the staircase design, is the smooth rise of each step which
          appears low and comfortable to use. The staircase allows for inclusive access;
          abled and people with disabilities can use the same staircase simultaneously. A
          negative feature of the staircase design is that there is a shortage of handrails and
          this could lead to people falling down. The sharp turns in the ramps could be
          hazardous for wheelchairs resulting in accidents. The steep incline/decline of the
          ramp without speed humps could be quite physically challenging and dangerous.

         Credit any other valid answers.

5.1.2    (Allocate 16 marks.)
          Allocate 16 marks in total, 8 marks per case study: 1 mark for the name of a
          designer and design, 5 marks for a discussion of the aims, materials and
          techniques and 2 marks for a discussion of the design example and how it
          addresses socio-cultural issues.

         ONE SOUTH AFRICAN CONTEMPORARY SOCIOCULTURAL DESIGNER/
         DESIGN GROUP:

         Name of the designer/design group and design product
         FIRE Station Soweto by Rodney Eksteen in association with Jeanne Homer and
         Jocelin Flank.

         Discuss the aims, materials and techniques of this designer
         Rodney Eksteen, a 25-year member of the fire service in South Africa, partnered with
         Associate Professor of Architecture Jeanne Homer and Jocelin Flank of Oklahoma
         State University, to design a fire station in the Johannesburg area that serves as
         more than just a fire station. It aimed to provide the services and duties of a fire
         station that not only belonged to the community of Soweto, but also bridged the gap
         between fire service personnel and citizens. The design aimed to help both sides
         believe that they are partners in the care and well-being of their

Copyright reserved                                                          Please turn over

### Page 14

Design/P1                                     14                           DBE/November 2024
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

         community. The materials and techniques used for this building are
         unconventional in style, using a steel frame, concrete roof glass and aluminium skin
         to allow maximum natural light into the building. Solar panels are used to generate
         electricity and makes the building energy-saving and sustainable. A minimal use of
         heavy traditional brick and mortar is used on the walls.

         Analyse ONE example explaining how this design addresses sociocultural
         issue(s)
         In the past, fire stations were built more as warehouses than as parts of
         communities. They resembled military installations with barred windows and gates
         and served as storage for fire equipment and personnel. Other than the response
         of fire stations to emergencies, there was little to no interaction between fire service
         personnel and citizens. This fire station is open plan and full of light, inviting the
         public to enter it. It is no longer a structure that represents an authoritarian
         government – it reaches out to the public and creates a bridge between the
         government and the public.

         ONE INTERNATIONAL DESIGNER/DESIGN GROUP

         Name of the designer/design group and their design product
         Homeless Studio by the University of Southern California's School of Architecture.

         Analyse the aims, materials and techniques of this designer
         In response to a growing concern around the issue of homeless people, the University
         of Southern California's School of Architecture created the Homeless Studio, a
         student project that aims to alleviate the crisis of the homeless. Developed in
         conjunction with Madworkshop (a non-profit organisation and architecture design
         group), the Homeless Studio developed holistic solutions to tackle the issue of
         homelessness. 

         Fabricated with materials like plywood, Perspex and aluminium, the shelters are
         meant to be light and easy to move around. The shelter comes in different shape
         and sizes but allows space for one person to sleep. Each design addresses the
         need for its occupant's security, privacy, and shelter from the elements. This project
         allows for the physical creation of their prototypes, which included a 30-bed shelter
         that will become a prototype shelter for the homeless. The designers delivered their
         finished structures to homeless people around the city.

         Discuss ONE example explaining how this design addresses sociocultural
         issue(s)
         Designers addressed the social issue of homelessness by creating this collection of
         temporary, moveable, modular and expandable structures that can keep the
         homeless off the street, while refusing reliance on government intervention.

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 15

Design/P1                                        15                         DBE/November 2024
                                       NSC – Marking Guidelines

         The Homeless Studio's plan allows the group of designers to participate in hands-
         on fabrication workshops and undertake real-life case studies with local residents
         who are experiencing homelessness.

         Credit any other valid statements.
             Q5.1 LEVEL          COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS   QUESTIONS       MARKS
                                                                                          (20)
            Lower order    Remember, Recall, Recognise            30%    5.1.1 + 5.1.2    1+1
                           Understand, Explain, Describe                 5.1.1 + 5.1.2    1+3

            Middle order   Apply, Implement, Organise             40%       5.1.1           2
                                                                            5.1.2           6

            Higher order   Analyse, Compare, Interpret                      5.1.2           2
                           Evaluate, Reflect                      30%       5.1.2           4
                           Synthesise, Justify

5.2
5.2.1   (Allocate 2 marks.)
         In FIGURE K, the Bird's Nest pool gazebo is constructed by making use of
         indigenous craft techniques such as basket weaving, hut and kraal construction.
         International and local tourists who visit the lodge are exposed to Botswana's
         traditional craft heritage that is seen in the gazebo design. The potential of these
         indigenous craft techniques elevates the status of design as it merges the 'old'
         (traditional) with the 'new' (modern). This also helps to give tourists a unique,
         authentic African experience.

5.2.2   (Allocate 8 marks.): 1 mark for the traditional craft/indigenous cultural
        community, 5 marks for a discussion of the materials, methods and
        processes and 2 marks for the social value and function of the craft.

         Name of ONE traditional craft/indigenous cultural community that produced
         the traditional craft:
         IsiZulu Ceramics.
         The materials, methods and processes used to create the traditional craft:
         The coiling technique is used to make Zulu pots. The main materials are red and
         dark clay, which is gathered from the mountains and is ground to a fine powder on a
         grinding stone. This powder is then dried until it has reached the right consistency
         or suitable degree of plasticity. The walls of the vessel are gradually built up from
         a circular base. Careful attention is paid to symmetry and correct width of walls.
         Inner and outer walls are shaped and burnished with a piece of calabash, stone or
         metal tool. Once completed, the pot is covered with blankets and placed in a hut
         until leather hard and then dried outside for seven days. There are two main Zulu
         decoration techniques, i.e. applied and carved decoration. Applied decoration is
         done by attaching small clay balls onto pots (Intsumpa) or exerting pressure from
         inside the pot to create outer protrusions. Carved decorations inscribed onto the
         pot create repetitive patterns. Zulus made use of pit firing. Pots are placed in a
         shallow pit and covered with dry aloe leaves and wood, which is then set alight.
         Pots intended for eating and drinking undergo a second firing using cakes of dry cow
         dung. Pots emerge from the second firing possessing with a black face, which is
         rubbed with gooseberry leaves, a small flattened stone and animal fat giving them a
         glossy, slick and black finish.

Copyright reserved                                                              Please turn over

### Page 16

Design/P1                                     16                           DBE/November 2024
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

         The social value and function of the craft:
         The main functions of these pottery vessels were to cook and serve meat, cereals
         and vegetables. Brew, serve and drink sorghum beer. Transport and store water,
         administer medicines, burn incense as part of ceremonies aimed at venerating and
         communicating with the ancestors. Most potters today make vessels for brewing,
         serving and drinking sorghum beer (utshwala), and a series of smaller serving and
         eating vessels for consuming uphuto, a maize-based porridge, and amasi. Shapes
         and sizes vary according to their function – the largest pot is the undecorated 'imbiza',
         a pot used for cooking and holding up to 40 litres of traditional beer. Drinking pots
         have an urn-shape with a cylindrical funnel, which prevents spillage and facilitates
         pouring. The 'umancishane', a smaller pot, indicates to a visitor that has received
         beer in it, that a short stay only is expected. 

         Credit any other valid statements.

5.2.3      (Allocate 10 marks): 1 mark for the name of the designer/design group and
         their product(s), 6 marks for aims, influences and materials and 3 marks on
         how traditional techniques/methods and materials have been applied to the
         relevant contemporary design.

         Name of design/design group and their product(s):
         Vase Telewire Light by Mash T Studio 

         General aims, influences and characteristics of the designer/design group's work:
         Mash T Studio's mission centres around preserving the essence of traditional
         artisanal craftsmanship  by fusing technology and these crafts, to create a
         contemporary design aesthetic. They draw from the rich South African cultural
         heritage to inspire modern design. This approach allows them to breathe new life
         into traditional designs, techniques and objects, ensuring their relevance in today's
         society so that they are not forgotten. Traditional materials such as beads and
         telephone wire are used to form these modern, unexpected new forms.

         Mash T Studio collaborates closely with traditional craftspeople to weave South
         African stories into their diverse range of products, ranging from lighting to furniture,
          e.g. The Hlabisa bench, which was created as a collaboration with Houtlander
         and master weaver Beauty Ngxongo.

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 17

Design/P1                                        17                         DBE/November 2024
                                       NSC – Marking Guidelines

         A discussion of how traditional techniques/methods have been applied to the
         contemporary design:
         The Vase Telewire scooby pendant lamp, part of the Alfred light range, is an
         example of a contemporary design that adapts traditional South African crafts, i.e.
         basket weaving and telephone wire weaving to create beautiful products that fit into
         a contemporary design. The pendant lamp is made up of two basket-like forms that
         meet in the middle. The top half flares open towards the top resembling a wide basket
         and the bottom half forms a more tubular-formed downward-facing basket form.
         The combination of two basket forms results in a new, unexpected contemporary
         form.

         These light fittings were created in collaboration with master telewire weaver, Bab'
         Alfred Ntuli and Elizabeth Joubert of Tin Lab Designs. Inspired by the practice seen
         as early as the 1960s where Zulu night watchmen started weaving scraps of
         telephone wire around their traditional sticks, these ceiling lights add a modern twist
         to an age-old tradition, with a distinctive aesthetic to any interior.

         Credit any other valid statements.

         NO marks should be given for repetition of designer(s) and their work used in
         this question paper.

            Q5.2 LEVEL           COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS   QUESTIONS        MARKS
                                                                                            (20)
            Lower order    Remember, Recall,                      30%    5.2.1 + 5.2.2     1+2
                           Recognise
                           Understand, Explain,                              5.2.3          3
            Middle order   Describe
                           Apply, Implement, Organise             40%    5.2.1 + 5.2.2     1+3
                                                                            + 5.2.3         +4
            Higher order   Analyse, Compare, Interpret                       5.2.2           3
                           Evaluate, Reflect                      30%        5.2.3           1
                           Synthesise, Justify                               5.2.3           2

Copyright reserved                                                              Please turn over

### Page 18

Design/P1                                    18                          DBE/November 2024
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 6 [20 marks]

6.1 (Allocate 4 marks.)

      Fashion designer Katekani Moreku believes in the recycling and upcycling of discarded
      materials for his fashion designs. Katekani is able to transform local, popular items
      such as maize meal bags, brightly coloured, striped plastic table cloths, natural woven
      baskets and shweshwe fabric into sustainable fashion. Katekani finds unconventional
      materials and discarded items at charity stores which he transforms into trendy new
      fashion designs for the current generation. Katekani emphasises that upcycling
      discarded clothing and objects is cost-effective. By upcycling, he feels empowered to
      express his personality and unique signature style in his range which combines textures
      and brightly coloured fabrics, this makes his sustainable fashion range anything but
      conventional, uniform or basic. Moreku additionally adds that our current generation
      must begin to create awareness of the importance of upcycling and recycling so that our
      future generations will be able to reduce the amount of pollution.

      Credit any other valid statements.

6.2 (Allocate 16 marks.)
    Allocate 16 marks in total, 8 marks per case study: 1 mark for the name of
    designer and design, 5 marks for a discussion of the aims, materials and
    processes and 2 marks for a discussion of the design example and how it
    addresses environmental concerns.

      Name of the designer/design group and ONE of their designs: Waste to Wonder
      Pavilion by Architecture Studio theMAAK: a transformed public space using upcycled
      Tetra Pak waste (South Africa), 2019.

      Aims, materials and processes used:
      The primary aim of the architect firm theMAAK is to use a hands-on approach in an
      attempt to empower and educate the community in Langa (a low-income area in Cape
      Town) to understand what 'waste' is and how to utilise it to their benefit. Another aim
      is to encourage a dynamic 'culture for the use of public spaces' in developing
      communities. The team hopes that the project will create a positive response from the
      community and world-class architecture will be provided for those that need it most.

Copyright reserved                                                          Please turn over

### Page 19

Design/P1                                    19                           DBE/November 2024
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

      The theme was to create a temporary Wonder Pavilion structure. With the help of
      theMaak the community made a Wonder Pavilion using Tetra-Pak packaging material
      (recycled milk cartons). The inside of the Tetra-Pak packaging is a heavy-duty, tough
      paper that is water repellent, which makes it durable and suitable for a temporary
      canopy.

      The process theMAAK followed, was a collaboration with like-minded people from
      different backgrounds, and who had different skills from Langa. Ideas were exchanged,
      shared and creatives were given the opportunity to learn from each other. Through
      this collaboration, theMaak helped the community to make quality environmental
      designs more accessible and inclusive.

      An analysis of the design, explaining why it is sustainable and addresses
      environmental concerns:

      The Waste to Wonder Pavilion is a swooping, modular canopy design creating an
      origami-netting, architectural pattern and/or structure using the inside white part of the
      milk cartons. The pavilion clearly shows how Tetra-Pak waste can be used to build a
      pavilion and make the community aware of the 'aesthetic and material potential of
      waste'. The reuse and upcycling of Tetra-Pak creates a sustainable design that
      addresses environmental concerns. Through education and shared information,
      fewer milk cartons end up in landfills or on the streets of Langa and the surrounding
      areas. This upcycling initiative provides beautiful public infrastructure, made possible
      through collaboration and encourages the community to be responsible and mindful of
      their environment.

      INTERNATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGNER

      Name of the designer/design group and ONE of their designs:
      Zero Waste Pop-up Restaurant by Linda Bergroth (Manhattan fair), 2018.

      Aims, materials and processes:
      The temporary, four day Zero-Waste Pop-up Restaurant, builds on the concept created
      by Helsinki's Restaurant, Nolla, and its main aim is to create the 'first zero-waste
      restaurant in Manhattan'. Linda Bergroth designed the pop-up restaurant, based on her
      Scandinavian background. Its aims are to use foods that would normally be discarded,
      and to reject non-sustainable packaging.  They worked with designers, engineers
      and architects to rethink waste management and water efficiency.

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 20

Design/P1                                    20                          DBE/November 2024
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

      The material used to build the pop-up restaurant is recycled Tetra Pak – a packaging
      material commonly used for milk cartons and food packaging. Chef Luka Balac said,
      'our dishes at Zero Waste Pop-up Restaurant are made from local and organic
      ingredients as well as commonly overlooked by-products and all leftovers are
      composted. Sustainable food packaging, biodegradable solutions and lately material
      innovations are considered.' The wall panels of the pop-up restaurant are fabricated
      in batches by ReWall in Iowa, and take their colour from whichever products are
      processed at the time. Staying true to the materials, the surfaces have a mottled
      silver-blue tone from afar, while the text and barcodes from the packaging are visible
      when looked at up close. The pop-up restaurant and products are designed to create
      a fun visual experience, an intimate dining experience, and the recycled Tetra-Pak
      creates an environment with excellent acoustics.

      An analysis of the design, explaining why it is sustainable and addresses
      environmental concerns:
      The Zero Waste Pop-up Restaurant is an excellent example of a circular economy, in
      which resources are kept and reused for as long as possible. This differs from a linear
      economy where materials and products are made, used and then discarded. The
      pop-up event also included workshops and talks on the circular economy and zero-waste
      fashion. This design urges people to rethink our lifestyle, eating habits and the
      materials we use. The philosophy behind this design should be our goal – reduce
      waste and help to maintain the natural environment for generations to come. We need
      to be responsible and make the right choices. The Zero Waste Pop-up Restaurant
      is a truly sustainable design made entirely from recycled and recyclable materials –
      furnishings and tableware were also 100% recyclable and inspired by sustainable iconic
      Scandinavian styles.

      Credit any other valid statements.

            Q6 LEVEL        COGNITIVE SKILLS           WEIGHTINGS    QUESTIONS      MARKS
                                                                                      (20)
      Lower order      Remember, Recall, Recognise        30%          6.1 + 6.2     2+2
                       Understand, Explain, Describe                      6.2         2
      Middle order     Apply, Implement, Organise         40%             6.1         2
                                                                          6.2          6
      Higher order     Analyse, Compare, Interpret                         6          2
                       Evaluate, Reflect                  30%              .          2
                       Synthesise, Justify                                 2          2
                                                                           6
                                                                    TOTAL. SECTION C:           40
                                                                           2
                                                                       GRAND
                                                                           6
                                                                                 TOTAL:         100
                                                                           .
                                                                           2

Copyright reserved

## Related documents

- [Design P1 Nov 2024 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2024-eng/3f0bd4c5-8226-45ef-87fa-5c9996cba696) — Design · QP · 2024 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2024 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2024-afr/6958913b-f502-40d3-8387-1f0a78a3ed25) — Design · QP · 2024 · Afr
- [Design P2 Nov 2024 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p2-nov-2024-afr/ecee5a5f-3ae2-4005-b20d-556b11b83d24) — Design · QP · 2024 · Afr
- [Design P2 Nov 2024 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p2-nov-2024-eng/e3c099fa-b074-4932-aa7e-cbc7e78a1e3e) — Design · QP · 2024 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2020 Memo Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2020-memo-eng/4557d936-063d-4754-b6a8-e25c4d279f64) — Design · Memo · 2020 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2019 Memo Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-nov-2019-memo-eng/897e5c02-af3d-4258-9c23-310678ff22eb) — Design · Memo · 2019 · Eng

## More from Grade 12 Design

- [Gr 12 Des ATP 2023-24](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/gr-12-des-atp-2023-24/0fd522c6-2d5a-4c5b-9e0b-06e7b199eb25) — ATP
- [Design P1 May-June 2025 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-may-june-2025-afr/e35d300a-db4f-4a06-ba8a-6f659dbd37ad) — QP · 2025 · Afr
- [Design P1 Nov 2025 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12-design-2025-nsc-november-exam-question-paper-paper-1/3f14a710-b913-44a8-ade1-31e4d395f557) — QP · 2025 · Eng
- [Design P1 Nov 2025 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12-design-2025-nsc-november-exam-question-paper-paper-1/47ba80e3-12dd-4fd4-8302-34e3b97a6b9a) — QP · 2025 · Afr
- [Design P1 May-June 2023 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-may-june-2023-eng/57419a61-fb49-40b2-9cc2-0779cf909a9b) — QP · 2023 · Eng
- [Design P1 May-June 2023 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/design-p1-may-june-2023-afr/9c7d1a75-a2c5-4801-8176-43ad428bcc49) — QP · 2023 · Afr

## Collection

- [Grade 12 past papers](https://www.hlayiso.com/grade-12/past-papers)

---

Hlayiso: free CAPS and IEB past papers, memos, notes and study guides for South African learners. When citing, link the page URL above, not a PDF or /api/ URL.
