# History Grade 12 P1 NSC Supplementary 2014 Memo (English)

> Grade 12 History Paper 1 memorandum from the NSC Supplementary 2014 (English), 32 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.

- Page: https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p1-feb-march-2014-memo-eng/740934be-18d0-41ea-96bb-ac795eb67ad7
- Updated: 2026-09-27
- Subject: History
- Grade: Grade 12
- Document type: Memorandum
- Year: 2014
- Exam period: NSC Supplementary
- Paper: 1
- Curriculum: CAPS
- Pages: 32

Breadcrumbs: [Home](https://www.hlayiso.com/) › [Library](https://www.hlayiso.com/library) › [Grade 12](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12) › [History](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12/history) › [History Grade 12 P1 NSC Supplementary 2014 Memo (English)](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p1-feb-march-2014-memo-eng/740934be-18d0-41ea-96bb-ac795eb67ad7)

## About this document

History · Grade 12 · NSC Supplementary · 2014. Memorandum, 32 pages. Read online or download the PDF.

Read it free online on the page above; download the PDF from there.

## Document text

Text extracted from the PDF. Layout, diagrams and tables may not survive extraction.

### Page 1

Downloaded from hlayiso.com

                                  NATIONAL
                             SENIOR CERTIFICATE

                                   GRADE 12

                                    HISTORY P1

                             FEBRUARY/MARCH 2014

                                  MEMORANDUM

MARKS: 150

                       This memorandum consists of 32 pages.

Copyright reserved                                             Please turn over

### Page 2

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                    2                            DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                      NSC – Memorandum

1.      SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS

1.1          The following Learning Outcomes and Assessment Standards will be
             assessed in this question paper:

 LEARNING              ASSESSMENT STANDARDS
 OUTCOMES              THE ABILITY OF THE LEARNER TO:

 Learning              1. Formulate questions to analyse concepts for investigation within
 Outcome 1                the context of what is being studied. (Not for examination
                          purposes.)
 (Historical
 enquiry)              2. Access a variety of relevant sources of information in order to
                         carry out an investigation. (Not for examination purpose.)

                       3. Interpret and evaluate information and data from sources.

                       4. Engage with sources of information evaluating the usefulness of
                          the sources for the task, including stereotypes, subjectivity and
                          gaps in the evidence available to the learners.

 Learning              1. Analyse historical concepts as social constructs.
 Outcome 2             2. Examine and explain the dynamics of changing power relations
 (Historical              within the societies studied.
 concepts)             3. Compare and contrast interpretations and perspectives of
                          events, people's actions and changes in order to draw
                          independent conclusions about the actions or events.
 Learning              1. Identify when an interpretation of statistics may be controversial
 Outcome 3                and engage critically with the conclusions presented by the data.
 (Knowledge            2. Synthesise information to construct an original argument using
 construction             evidence to support the argument.
 and                   3. Sustain and defend a coherent and balanced argument with
 communication)           evidence provided and independently accessed.
                       4. Communicate knowledge and understanding in a variety of ways
                          including discussion (written and oral) debate, creating a piece of
                          historical writing using a variety of genres, research
                          assignments, graphics, oral presentation.

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 3

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                    3                           DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                      NSC – Memorandum

1.2          The following levels of questions were used to assess source-based
             questions:

                          LEVELS OF SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS

                            •   Extract relevant information and data from the sources.
                            •   Organise information logically.
 LEVEL 1 (L1)
                            •   Explain historical concepts.

                            • Categorise appropriate or relevant source of
                               information provided to answer the questions raised.
                            • Analyse the information and data gathered from a
 LEVEL 2 (L2)                 variety of sources.
                            • Evaluate the sources of information provided to
                               assess the appropriateness of the sources for the task.

                            •   Interpret and evaluate information and data from the
                                sources.
                            •   Engage with sources of information evaluating the
                                usefulness of the sources for the task taking into account
                                stereotypes, subjectivity and gaps in the evidence
                                available.
                            •   Analyse historical concepts as social constructs.
                            •   Examine and explain the dynamics of changing power
 LEVEL 3 (L3)
                                relations within the aspects of societies studied.
                            •   Compare and contrast interpretations and perspectives of
                                peoples' actions or events and changes to draw
                                independent conclusions about the actions or events.
                            •   Identify when an interpretation of statistics may be
                                controversial and engage critically with the conclusions
                                presented by the data.

1.3          The following table indicates how to assess source-based questions:

   •   In the marking of source-based questions credit needs to be given to any other
       valid and relevant viewpoints, arguments, evidence or examples.

   • In the allocation of marks emphasis should be placed on how the requirements of
     the question have been addressed.

   •   In the marking guideline the requirements of the question (skills that need to be
       addressed) as well as the level of the question are indicated in italics.

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 4

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                    4                           DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                      NSC – Memorandum

2.      EXTENDED WRITING

2.1          The extended writing questions focus on one of the following levels:

                               LEVELS OF QUESTIONS
 Level 1
   •   Discuss or describe according to a given line of argument set out in the extended
       writing question.
  •    Plan and construct an argument based on evidence, using the evidence to
       reach a conclusion.
 Level 2
  •    Synthesise information to construct an original argument using evidence to
       support the argument.
  •    Sustain and defend a coherent and balanced argument with evidence.
  •    Write clearly and coherently in constructing the argument.

2.2          Marking of extended writing

    •   MARKERS MUST BE AWARE THAT THE CONTENT OF THE ANSWER WILL BE
        GUIDED BY THE TEXTBOOKS IN USE AT THE PARTICULAR CENTRE.

    •   CANDIDATES MAY HAVE ANY OTHER RELEVANT INTRODUCTION AND/OR
        CONCLUSION THAN THOSE INCLUDED IN A SPECIFIC EXTENDED WRITING
        MARKING GUIDELINE FOR A SPECIFIC ESSAY.

    •   WHEN ASSESSING OPEN-ENDED SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS, LEARNERS
        SHOULD BE CREDITED FOR ANY OTHER RELEVANT RESPONSES.

Global assessment of extended writing

The extended writing will be assessed holistically (globally). This approach requires the
educator to score the overall product as a whole, without scoring the component parts
separately. This approach encourages the learner to offer an individual opinion by
using of selected factual evidence to support an argument. The learner will not be
required to simply regurgitate 'facts' in order to achieve a high mark. This approach
discourages learners from preparing 'model' answers and reproducing them without
taking into account the specific requirements of the question. Holistic extended writing
marking credits learners' opinions supported by evidence. Holistic assessment, unlike
content based marking, does not penalise language inadequacies as the emphasis is
on the following:

•       The construction of argument
•       The appropriate selection of factual evidence to support such argument and
•       The learner's interpretation of the question

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 5

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                            5                                   DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                              NSC – Memorandum

Assessment procedures of extended writing
1.    Keep the synopsis in mind when assessing extended writing.
2.    During the first reading of the extended writing ticks need to be awarded for a relevant
      introduction (indicated by a bullet in marking guideline/ memorandum) each of the
      main points/aspects that is properly contextualised (also indicated by bullets in the marking
      guideline/ memorandum) and a relevant conclusion (indicated by a bullet in marking
      guideline/ memorandum) e.g. in an answer where there are 5 main points there will be
      7 ticks.
3.    The following additional symbols can also be used:
•                Introduction, main aspects and conclusion not properly contextualised
•                Wrong statement
•                Irrelevant statement                             |
                                                                  |
                                                                  |
                                                                  |

•                    Repetition                                              R

•                    Analysis                                                A√

•                    Interpretation                                          1√
4.           The matrix

4.1          Use of analytical matrix in the marking of extended writing (refer to page 6) In the marking of
             extended writing with reference to page 6 the given criteria shown in the matrix should be
             used. In assessing the extended writing note should be taken of both the content and
             presentation. At the point of intersection of the content and presentation based on the seven
             competency levels, a mark should be awarded.

             4.1.1        The first reading of extended writing will be to determine to what extent the main
                          aspects have been covered and to determine the content level
                          (on the matrix).

                                                                      C           LEVEL 4

                          The second reading of extended writing will relate to the level (on the matrix) of
                          presentation.

                                                                      C           LEVEL 4
                                                                      P           LEVEL 5

                          Allocate an overall mark with the use of the matrix.

                                                                C            LEVEL 4
                                                                                            18-19
                                                                P            LEVEL 5

4.2          Use of holistic rubric in the marking of extended writing (refer to page 7)
             The given rubric which takes into account both content and presentation should be used in
             the marking of extended writing

                                                               C and P      LEVEL 5         18 - 20

Copyright reserved                                                                              Please turn over

### Page 6

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                                       6                                            DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                                         NSC – Memorandum

Grade 12 ANALYTICAL MATRIX FOR EXTENDED WRITING: TOTAL MARKS: 30
                      LEVEL 7          LEVEL 6            LEVEL 5           LEVEL 4          LEVEL 3            LEVEL 2         LEVEL 1
PRESENTATION          Very well        Well planned       Well planned      Planned and      Shows some         Attempts to     Little analysis
                      planned and      and structured.    and structured.   constructed an   evidence of a      structure the   and historical
                      structured.      Synthesis of       Constructed a     argument.        planned and        answer.         explanation.
                      Good             information        clear             Evidence used    constructed        Largely         No structure in
                      synthesis of     Constructed an     argument.         to support       argument.          descriptive/    answer.
                      information.     original well -    Conclusions       argument.        Some               some attempt
                      Constructed an   balanced,          drawn from        Conclusion       evidence used      at developing
                      argument         independent        evidence.         reached based    to support         an argument.
CONTENT               Well balanced    argument.          Evidence used     on evidence.     argument.
                      argument.        Evidence used      to support        Writing          Conclusion not
                      Sustained and    to defend the      argument.         structured.      clearly
                      defended the     argument.          Reached                            supported by
                      argument                            independent                        evidence.
                      throughout.                         conclusion.
                                                          Evidence used
                                                          to support
                                                          conclusion.
LEVEL 7
Question has
been fully
answered.
Content                   27-30            24-26
selection fully
relevant to line of
argument.
LEVEL 6
Question has
been answered.
Content                   24-26              23               21-22
selection
relevant to a line
of argument.
LEVEL 5
Question
answered to a
great extent.                              21-22                20              18-19
Content
adequately
covered and
relevant.
LEVEL 4
Question
recognisable in
answer.                                                       18-19               17             15-16
Some omissions/
irrelevant
content
selection.
LEVEL 3
Content
selection does
not always                                                                      15-16              14               12-13
relate.
Omissions in
coverage.
LEVEL 2
Sparse content.
Question                                                                                         12-13                11              9-10
inadequately
addressed.
LEVEL 1
Question not
answered.                                                                                                            9-10             0-8
Inadequate
content.
Totally irrelevant.

Copyright reserved                                                                                                 Please turn over

### Page 7

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                          7                                        DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                            NSC – Memorandum

GRADE 12 HOLISTIC RUBRIC TO ASSESS AN ESSAY USING SOURCES AND OWN KNOWLEDGE.
TOTAL MARKS: 30
LEVEL                If the candidate has demonstrated all or most of the skills listed in a particular level, she/he will
                     be awarded a mark relevant to the category.
7                    Consistently focuses on topic – demonstrates a logical and coherent progress towards a conclusion
Outstanding          Clearly comprehends the sources
80–100%              Uses all or most of the sources and own knowledge
24–30                Selects relevant sources
                     Quotes selectively
                     Groups sources (not essential but should not merely list sources)
     [Excellent]     Demonstrates a setting of sources in background understanding
                     If appropriate, deals fully with counter-argument
                     Refers appropriately to relevancy, bias, accuracy, limitation of sources
                     Expresses him/herself clearly
                     Concludes essay with clear focus on topic – takes a stand (i.e. reaches an independent conclusion)
6                    Makes a good effort to focus consistently on the topic but, at times, argument loses some focus
Meritorious          Clearly comprehends the sources
70–79%               Uses all or most of the sources and own knowledge
21–23                Selects relevant sources
                     Quotes selectively
                     Good use of relevant evidence from the sources.
    [Very Good]      Good attempt to consider counter-argument
                     Good attempt to refer to relevancy, bias, accuracy, limitation of source
                     Expression good
                     Concludes essay with clear focus on topic – takes a stand (i.e. reaches an independent conclusion)
5                    Makes an effort to focus on the topic but argument has lapses in focus
Substantial          Comprehends most of the sources
60–69%               Uses most of the sources and own knowledge
18–20                Selects relevant sources
                     Expression good but with lapses
                     Perhaps, lacking some depth of overall-focus, or does not make reference to one or more relevant
        [Good]       sources
                     If appropriate, makes an attempt to consider counter-argument
                     Rather superficial or no attempt to refer to relevancy, bias, accuracy, limitation of sources
                     Makes an attempt to take a stand (focuses on limitations, etc.) in reaching an independent
                     conclusion
4                    Makes some effort to focus on the topic but argument has many lapses in focus
Moderate             Moderate comprehension of most of the sources
50–59%               Moderate use of relevant evidence from the sources and own knowledge
15–17                Moderate attempt to consider counter-argument
                     Moderate attempt to refer to relevancy, bias, accuracy, limitation of sources
   [Satisfactory]    Expression is satisfactory
                     Makes an attempt to take a stand but there are serious inconsistencies with making links with the rest
                     of the essay
                     Essay might have a tendency to list sources and 'tag' on focus
3                    Little attempt to focus on the topic
Adequate             Little comprehension of the sources
40–49%               Struggles to select relevant information from the sources and own knowledge
12–14                No quotes – or generally irrelevant
                     Makes little effort to consider counter-arguments
        [Fair]       Mainly characterised by listing of sources
                     No attempt to refer to relevancy, bias, accuracy of sources
                     Expression poor
                     Makes a poor attempt to take a stand. (i.e. battles to reach an independent conclusion)
2                    Unable to focus on the topic
Elementary           Unable to identify relevant sources and limited use of own knowledge
30–39%               No quotes – or generally irrelevant
09–11                Makes no effort to consider counter-argument
                     Essay characterised by listing of sources
        [Weak]       No attempt to refer to relevancy, bias, accuracy of sources
                     Expression very poor
                     Makes a very poor attempt to take a stand – if at all
1                    No attempt to focus on the topic
Not Achieved         Uses no sources
0–29%                Does not use own knowledge
0–8                  Completely irrelevant
      [Poor]         Copies directly from the sources
                     Answer extremely poor

Copyright reserved                                                                                 Please turn over

### Page 8

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                   8                            DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                     NSC – Memorandum

QUESTION 1:          HOW DID THE CUBAN MISSILE CRISIS INTENSIFY COLD
                     WAR TENSIONS BETWEEN THE USSR AND THE USA IN
                     THE 1960s?

1.1          1.1.1   [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1A – L2 – LO1 (AS3)]

                     •   The world would think that the USSR was equal to USA
                     •   The USA placed missiles in Turkey therefore the USSR
                         wanted to counteract this                         (2 x 2) (4)           (4)

             1.1.2   Explanation of historical concept from Source 1A – L1 – LO1(AS3);
                     LO2 (AS2)]
                     • It is a political system where the government takes control of
                         the means of production
                     Any other relevant response                             (any 1 x 2)         (2)

                     [Interpretation and evaluation of evidence from Source 1A – L3 –
                     LO1 (AS3); LO2 (AS3)]

                     •   Did not want the USA to know about the missile deployment in
                         Cuba
                     •   Did not want to create alarm
                     •   Any other relevant response                        (any 2 x 2)          (4)

1.2          1.2.1   [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1B – L2 – LO1 (AS3)]

                     •   Make the American public aware about the deployment of
                         missiles in Cuba
                     •   International news about Soviet deployment of missiles to
                         Cuba                                              (1 x 3)               (3)

             1.2.2   [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1B – L2 – LO1 (AS3)]

                     •   The Cuban Missile crisis became world news
                     •   Kennedy would put up a blockade to prevent Soviet missiles
                         from entering Cuba
                     •   Public support for Kennedy's actions
                         Any other relevant response                        (2 x 2)              (4)

             1.2.3   [Interpretation and analysis of evidence from Source 1B – L2 –
                     LO1(AS3,4)]

                     •   American citizens became scared/concerned
                     •   Americans started stocking up food
                     •   American children were trained on how to react in time of crisis
                     •   Understood the need for support
                     •   Any other relevant response                          (any 1 x 2)        (2)

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 9

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                   9                            DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                     NSC – Memorandum

             1.2.4   Interpretation of evidence of Source 1B – L3 – LO1(AS3,4)]

                     •   The USA decided to impose a blockade on missiles entering
                         Cuba
                     •   These missiles posed a serious threat to the USA's sovereign
                         independence
                     •   These missiles encroached on the physical space of the USA
                     •   Any other relevant response                     (any 1 x 2)             (2)

             1.2.5   [Analysing of evidence from Source 1B – L2 – LO1 (AS3,4)]

                     •   Torricelli viewed it as a 'vivid experience' (real)
                     •   He found it scary at the thought that a nuclear war could start
                     •   His parents were prepared for a war
                     •   Any other relevant response                          (any 2 x 2)        (4)

             1.2.6   [Comparing of evidence from Source 1B – L3 – LO1 (AS3,4)]

                     •   Both sources depict the threat of war
                     •   Both sources indicate the blockade of Soviet ships
                     •   The visual source indicates it became world news and the
                         written source reports that it became world news over the
                         television
                     •   Any other relevant response                       (any 2 x 2)           (4)

1.3          1.3.1   [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1C – L2 – LO1 (AS3)]
                     • Kennedy had to implement his ultimatum because Khrushchev
                          was not prepared to back down
                     • Kennedy knew if Khrushchev would not listen it could lead to a
                          disaster/nuclear war
                     • Any other relevant response                          (any 1 x 2)          (2)

             1.3.2   [Extraction of relevant evidence from Source 1C – L1 – LO1 (AS3)]

                     •   To end all work on missile sites in Cuba
                     •   To make the offensive weapons inoperable                 (2 x 1)        (2)

1.3          1.3.3   [Evaluate the reliability of the evidence from Source 1C – L3 – LO1
                     (AS3); LO2 (AS1)]

                     Reliable because:
                     • This letter was written by Kennedy during the Cuban Missile
                         Crisis
                     • The information in the letter support the information in other
                         sources
                     • The information is fairly accurate
                     Any other relevant response                          (any 2 x 2)            (4)

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 10

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                       10                           DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                         NSC – Memorandum

1.4          [Interpretation, analysis and synthesis of evidence from all sources-
             L3 – LO1 (AS3 and 4); LO2 (AS1, 2 and 3); LO3 (AS1, 2, 3 and 4)]

             Candidates must explain its usefulness to a historian. In answering this
             question, candidates need to show that the source is relevant to the
             investigation and reliable by interrogating its provenance (origin).

             SOURCE 1B (Visual and Written Source)

             This source is useful because:

             •   The visual source is relevant because the date (23 October 1962) shows
                 us that it was published at the time of the Cuban Missile Crisis
             •   The visual source shows us that it became world news
             •   The visual source is a relevant because it deals directly with the Cuban
                 Missile Crisis
             •   The visual source is an accurate source because it can be corroborated
                 with other sources about the Cuban Missile Crisis
             •   The written source confirms the newspaper headlines by quoting Senator
                 Torricelli
             •   Any other relevant response

             Use the following rubric to allocate a mark:

                          • Uses evidence in an elementary manner e.g.
                            shows little or no understanding of explaining
                            why Source 1B would be most useful to a
         LEVEL 1            historian writing about the Cuban Missile                MARKS: 0–2
                            Crisis
                          • Uses evidence partially to report on topic or
                            cannot report on the topic
                          • Evidence is mostly relevant and relates to a great
                            extent to the topic e.g. shows an understanding
                            of explaining why Source 1B would be most
         LEVEL 2                                                                     MARKS: 3–5
                            useful to a historian writing about the Cuban
                            Missile Crisis
                          • Uses evidence in a very basic manner
                          • Uses relevant evidence e.g. demonstrates a
                            thorough understanding of explaining why
                            Source 1B would be most useful to a historian
         LEVEL 3            writing about the Cuban Missile Crisis                   MARKS: 6–8
                          • Uses evidence very effectively in an organised
                            paragraph that shows an understanding of the
                            topic
                                                                                                        (8)

Copyright reserved                                                                   Please turn over

### Page 11

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                   11                          DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                     NSC – Memorandum

1.5          EXTENDED WRITING

             1.5.1   [Plan and construct an argument based on evidence using
                     analytical and interpretative skills - L1 – LO1 (AS 3 and 4); LO2
                     (AS1, 2 and 3); LO3 (AS1, 2, 3 and 4)

                     SYNOPSIS
                     Candidates need to discuss how the Cuban Missile Crisis
                     intensified Cold War tensions in Cuba in the 1960s.

                     MAIN ASPECTS
                     Candidates should include the following aspects in their response:

                     •   Introduction: Candidates should indicate the reasons for the
                         increased tensions between the USSR and the USA in the
                         1960s.

                     ELABORATION
                     • Brief background information on the Cold War tension between
                        the USSR and the USA
                     • Khrushchev willing to support Cuba in order to spread
                        communism
                     • Tensions heightened as USA suffered a diplomatic
                        embarrassment over Cuba's invasion of the Bay of Pigs
                     • Reconnaissance photographs revealed that USSR missiles
                        were deployed in Cuba
                     • Kennedy reacted by imposing a quarantine of all USSR ships
                        carrying missiles to Cuba
                     • Khrushchev rejected the USA's blockade of Soviet ships to
                        Cuba
                     • Soviet Union admitted to missiles but claimed it was for
                        defensive purposes only
                     • Soviet Union asked the USA to remove missiles from Turkey,
                        then only will it remove missiles from Cuba
                     • Tensions increased as an American spy plane was shot down
                        over Cuba
                     • Missiles in Cuba were removed and sites dismantled under
                        United Nations supervision
                     • Hotline was set up between the White House and Kremlin and
                        a Nuclear Test Ban Treaty was signed
                     • Any other relevant response

                     •   Conclusion: Candidates need to tie up the discussion with a
                         relevant conclusion.                                                    (30)

Use the matrix on page 6 in this document to assess this extended writing

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 12

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                   12                          DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                     NSC – Memorandum

             1.5.2   Synthesise information to construct an original argument using
                     evidence from the sources and own knowledge to support the
                     argument -
                     L2 – LO1 (AS 3 and 4); LO2 (AS1, 2 and 3); LO3 (AS1, 2, 3 and 4)]

                     SYNOPSIS
                     In answering this question, candidates need to explain to what
                     extent they support the following statement: Why shouldn't the
                     Soviet Union have the right to do the same as America? In
                     answering the question they need to support their argument with
                     relevant evidence.

                     MAIN ASPECTS
                     Candidates should include the following aspects in their response:

                     •   Introduction: Candidates should explain to what extent they
                         support the statement and indicate how they intend supporting
                         their line of argument.
                     ELABORATION
                     • Khrushchev wanted to counter the US's deployment of
                        missiles in Turkey
                     • Khrushchev decided to challenge the US's deployment of
                        missiles in Turkey
                     • Khrushchev therefore decided to deploy in missiles to Cuba
                     • Reconnaissance photographs revealed the stockpiling of
                        Soviet missiles in Cuba
                     • Key members of the military and the Cabinet were notified
                        about the missiles
                     • Kennedy met at White House with Sovereign Foreign Minister
                        Gromyko who said that there were no missiles in Cuba
                     • Members of EXCOMM (Executive Committee of the National
                        Security Council) recommend a blockade of Cuba
                     • Televised speech to American people by President Kennedy
                     • World reacts and debate begins in the UN
                     • Quarantine goes into effect and Soviet ships stop or turn
                        around rather than cross the quarantine line
                     • A showdown occurs at the UN Security Council
                     • Kennedy responds with a letter saying that the only way out of
                        the crisis is to remove missiles
                     • The crisis comes to an end
                     • Any other relevant response
                     Conclusion: Candidates should tie up their argument.                       (30)
                                                                                                [75]

                     Use the matrix on page 7 in this document to assess this
                     extended writing

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 13

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                    13                           DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                      NSC – Memorandum

QUESTION 2:          DID JULIUS NYERERE'S POLICY OF UJAMAA TRANSFORM
                     TANZANIA IN THE 1960s?

2.1          2.1.1    [Extraction of evidence from Source 2A – L1 – LO1 (AS3)]
                       • Human equality
                       • Citizens would achieve full control over their own affairs
                       • Public ownership/control of the economy
                       • Make the country socialist                            (any 2 x 1)         (2)

             2.1.2    [Explaining a historical concept from Source 2A – L1 – LO2 (AS1)]
                      • The government took over businesses or industries from
                          private ownership in order to operate it for the benefit of the
                          people
                      • Any other relevant answer                                 (1 x 2)          (2)

             2.1.3    [Selection of evidence from Source 2A to determine usefulness –
                      L3 – LO1 (AS4); LO2 (AS3); LO3 (AS2 and 3)]

                      •   It highlights the news worthiness of Nyerere's election
                          president of Tanganyika (Tanzania)
                      •   Historians would have the date when Nyerere was elected
                          president of Tanganyika (Tanzania)
                      •   The event of the elections in Tanganyika (Tanzania) appeared
                          in a famous international magazine
                      •   The magazine depicted the elected as president of
                          Tanganyika (Tanzania)
                      •   Any other relevant answer                             (2 x 2)            (4)

             2.1.4    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2A – L2 – LO1 (AS3)]

                      •   As the president of an independent Tanganyika (Tanzania)
                      •   As the president who led Tanganyika from colonialism to
                          independence
                      •   Time magazine referred to Nyerere as a leader who
                          implemented new policies in Tanganyika (Tanzania)
                      •   Nyerere was the first black president of Tanganyika (Tanzania)
                      •   Any other relevant response                            (2 x 2)           (4)

             2.1.5    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2A – L2 – LO1 (AS3)]

                      •   The news worthiness of Nyerere's election as president
                          Tanganyika (Tanzania)
                      •   He was the first democratically elected black president of
                          Tanganyika (Tanzania)
                      •   Any other relevant response                     (any 1 x 2)              (2)

Copyright reserved                                                              Please turn over

### Page 14

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                   14                           DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                     NSC – Memorandum

             2.1.6   [Comparing evidence from the Visual with the Written Source in
                     Source 2A – L3 – LO1 (AS3); LO2 (AS3); LO3 (AS2)]

                     •   Visual source show Nyerere was elected as president of
                         Tanzania
                     • Written source focuses on his address to parliament as
                         president Tanzania
                     Any other relevant answer                           (2 x 2)                 (4)

2.2          2.2.1   [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2B – L2 – LO1 (AS3)]

                     •   The rural majority received technical support
                     •   They received potable water, electricity, schools and clinics
                     •   The government tried to improve the standard and quality of
                         life of the rural majority
                     •   The government developed the agriculture the majority of
                         farmers could benefit
                     •   Any other relevant answer                            (any 2 x 2)        (4)

             2.2.2   [Extraction of evidence from Source 2B – L1 – LO1 (AS3)]

                     •   Regrouping of people into villages
                     •   Hard work
                     •   Self-reliance
                     •   Development of agriculture                          (any 2 x 1)         (2)

             2.2.3   [Ascertaining the limitation of Source 2B - L3 – LO1 (AS3.4);LO2
                     (AS2,3); LO3 (AS2,3)]

                     •   This was the view of an American journalist
                     •   The views of ordinary Tanzanian farmers were absent
                     •   It is a Western point of view
                     •   Any other relevant answer                           (1 x 3)             (3)

2.3          2.3.1   [Interpretation and evaluation of information from Source 2C - L2 –
                     LO1 (AS3); LO2 (AS2)]

                     The majority of farmers did not want to work on ujamaa farms
                     (communal)
                     • They preferred to work for themselves
                     • They concluded that there were no benefits on ujamaa farms
                     • Productivity on ujamaa farms was low
                     • Any other relevant answer                             (1 x 2)             (2)

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 15

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                     15                            DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                       NSC – Memorandum

             2.3.2     [Interpretation and evaluation of information from Source 2C - L2 –
                       LO1 (AS3); LO2 (AS2)]

                       Candidates can select either ACCURATE or INACCURATE and
                       support their answer with relevant evidence.

                       ACCURATE

                       •   Nyerere's views on the reasons why ujamaa failed can be
                           trusted
                       •   It is a first-hand experience as to why his socialist policies
                           failed
                       •   It is a first-hand experience as to why people refused to settle
                           in ujamaa villages
                       •   Any other relevant response

                       INACCURATE

                       •   Ujamaa encouraged Tanzanians to work co-operatively
                       •   Community self-help initiatives in villages improved
                       •   Communal production in agriculture prospered in some
                           ujamaa villages
                       •   Co-operative shops, village busses and schools were run
                           through self-help institutions
                       •   The quality of life for the rural poor improved greatly
                       •   Any other relevant answer                               (2 x 2)          (4)

2.4          [Comparing evidence from Source 2B and 2C – L3 – LO1 (AS3); LO2 (AS3);
             LO3 (AS2)

             •   Source 2B is written from a Western perspective while
                 Source 2C is written from an African perspective
             •   Source 2B states that ujamaa villages was a success while
                 Source 2C states that ujamaa villages was a failure
             •   Any other relevant answer                                           (2 x 2)        (4)

2.5          [Interpretation, analysis and synthesis of evidence from all sources-L3 – LO1
             (AS3 and 4); LO2 (AS1, 2 and 3); LO3 (AS1, 2, 3 and 4)]

             Candidates must include effects of both the positive and negative effects
             of ujamaa and support their answer with relevant evidence.

             NEGATIVES EFFECTS OF UJAMAA

             •   Rural Tanzanians were unwilling to leave their ancestral land for new
                 areas/land
             •   Rural Tanzanians were 'forced' into collectivisation/ villagisation

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 16

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                      16                            DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                        NSC – Memorandum

             • Rural Tanzanians refused to work on collective farms
             • Agricultural production fell
             • Very little capital was invested in building villages
             • Poor management of ujamaa villages
             • Ujamaa led to decreased agricultural production resulting in poverty
             • There was a shortage of basic commodities in villages
             • By 1980 Tanzania became more reliant on the imports of goods
             Any other relevant answer

             POSITIVE EFFECTS OF UJAMAA

             •   Tanzanians had improved access to health care
             •   They had free access to primary education
             •   Tanzania had the highest level of literacy in Africa by the 1980s
             •   Tanzanians farmers were exposed to the mechanisation of farming
             •   Tap water, electricity and clinics were introduced in the rural areas
             •   Any other relevant answer

             Use the following rubric to allocate a mark:

                          • Uses evidence in an elementary manner e.g.
                            shows little or no understanding in explaining
         LEVEL 1            the effects of Nyerere's policy of ujamaa             MARKS: 0–2
                          • Uses evidence partially to write a paragraph on
                            the topic or cannot write a paragraph on the topic
                          • Evidence is mostly relevant and relates to a great
                            extent to the topic e.g. shows an understanding
                            in explaining the effects of Nyerere's policy of
         LEVEL 2                                                                  MARKS: 3–5
                            ujamaa
                          • Uses evidence in a very basic manner to write a
                            paragraph
                          • Uses relevant evidence e.g. demonstrates a
                            thorough understanding in explaining the
                            effects of Nyerere's policy of ujamaa
         LEVEL 3                                                                  MARKS: 6–8
                          • Uses evidence very effectively in an organised
                            paragraph that shows an understanding of the
                            topic

                                                                                                     (8)

Copyright reserved                                                                Please turn over

### Page 17

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                   17                          DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                     NSC – Memorandum

2.6          EXTENDED WRITING

             2.6.1   [Plan and construct an argument based on evidence using
                     analytical and interpretative skills - L1 – LO1 (AS 3 and 4); LO2
                     (AS1, 2 and 3); LO3 (AS1, 2, 3 and 4)]

                     SYNOPSIS
                     Candidates need to discuss how Julius Nyerere's policy of ujamaa
                     transformed Tanzania the 1960s

                     MAIN ASPECTS
                     Candidates should include the following aspects in their response:

                     •   Introduction: Candidates should refer to how Nyerere's policy
                         of socialism transformed Tanzania's economy in the 1960s.

                     ELABORATION
                     • Arusha Declaration: Nyerere adopted and formalised the policy
                        of ujamaa to achieve economic progress and social justice in
                        Tanzania
                     • Enabled the country to share its wealth equally with the ideas
                        of socialism
                     • Nyerere was committed to the well-being of the poorest of the
                        poor
                     • Nyerere concerned with the welfare of people rather than an
                        economic growth model
                     • Nyerere insisted on pursuing socialism and self-reliance as the
                        only means to achieve development
                     • The programme of collectivisation was voluntary at first
                     • Built schools, hospitals, clinics, factories, roads and railways,
                        dams and bridges, hydro-electric power plants and other
                        infrastructure
                     • The quality and standard of life of Tanzanians improved.
                        (People had easier access to schools, clinics, clean water and
                        other services)
                     • Education was free from primary school to university level
                     • Tanzania attained the highest literacy levels in Africa
                     • Medical services was free in spite of Tanzania being one of the
                        poorest countries in Africa
                     • Any other relevant response

                     Conclusion: Candidates need to tie up their discussion with a
                     relevant conclusion.                                                        (30)

                     Use the matrix on page 6 in this document to assess this
                     extended writing

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 18

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                   18                          DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                     NSC – Memorandum

             2.6.2   Synthesise information to construct an original argument using
                     evidence from the sources and own knowledge to support the
                     argument -
                     L2 – LO1 (AS 3 and 4); LO2 (AS1, 2 and 3); LO3 (AS1, 2, 3 and 4)]

                     SYNOPSIS
                     Candidates need to indicate whether Nyerere's policy of ujamaa
                     was a great success or not. They need to support their argument
                     relevant evidence.

                     MAIN ASPECTS
                     Candidates should include the following aspects in their response:
                     •   Introduction: Candidates should indicate whether they agree or
                         disagree with the statement and indicate how they intend
                         supporting their argument.

                     ELABORATION

                     DISAGREE
                     • Resistance by most farmers to move into ujamaa villages
                     • People unwilling to leave their ancestral land for new areas
                     • Communal ownership was a threat to private ownership
                     • Peasants were 'forced' into collectivised/ villages
                     • People refused to work on the collective farms
                     • The expected production from the collectivised farms was not
                        realised
                     • Collective farms became unproductive
                     • Opposition to capitalist financial institutions was a mistake by
                        Nyerere
                     • Tanzania continued to be poor because of decreased
                        production
                     • Nyerere admitted that ujamaa was a failure
                     • Ujamaa led to decreased agricultural production resulting in
                        increased unemployment and poverty
                     • By the 1980s Tanzania relied heavily on imports
                     • Any other relevant response

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 19

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                   19                           DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                     NSC – Memorandum

                     AGREE
                     • Ujamaa was committed to the well-being of the poorest of the
                       poor
                     • Concerned with the welfare of people rather than economic
                       growth principles
                     • Collectivisation was a voluntary process
                     • Built schools, hospitals, clinics, factories, roads and railways,
                       dams and bridges, hydro-electric power plants and other
                       infrastructure
                     • Education was a priority (Millions of adults were now literate;
                       Education was free from primary school to university level;
                       Tanzania attained the highest literacy rate in Africa)
                     • People had easier access to clinics, clean water and other
                       services
                     • Medical services were free in spite of Tanzania being one of
                       the poorest countries in Africa
                     • Nyerere was against capitalist financial institutions like the IMF
                       and the World Bank
                     • Any other relevant response

                     •   Conclusion: Candidates should tie up their argument with a
                         relevant conclusion                                                     (30)
                                                                                                 [75]

                     Use the matrix on page 7 in this document to assess this
                     extended writing

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 20

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                   20                             DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                     NSC – Memorandum

QUESTION 3:          HOW DID THE CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT CHALLENGE THE
                     UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT IN THE 1960s?

3.1          3.1.1   Extraction of information from Source 3A – L1– LO1 (AS3)]

                     •   To dismantle institutionalised racial segregation, discrimination
                         and inequality                                             (1 x 1)        (1)

             3.1.2   [Definition of concept from Source 3A – L2 – LO2 (AS1)]

                     •   A practice of separating people along racial lines and
                         subjecting them to different treatment
                     •   A racial policy of treating black and white American differently
                     •   Any other relevant response                         (any 1 x 2)           (2)

             3.1.3   [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3A – L2 – LO1 (AS3); LO3
                     (AS2)]

                     •   African Americans were treated inhumanely in the South
                     •   African Americans remained subordinate citizens and were
                         treated badly
                     •   Any other relevant response                           (2 x 2)             (4)

             3.1.4   [Interpretation and evaluation of information from Source 3A – L3–
                     LO1 (AS3); LO2 (AS3); LO3 (AS2)]

                     •   Tried to prevent the spread of information regarding the
                         atrocities committed against the Civil rights activists
                     • People outside the South did not know of the violence that was
                         committed against African Americans
                     Any other relevant response                                 (2 x 2)           (4)

3.2          3.2.1   [Extraction of evidence from Source 3B – L1 – LO1 (AS3)]

                     •   Students did not use violence
                     •   Students were respectful
                     •   Students followed the 'do's' and 'don'ts' that guided their non-
                         violent behaviour                                        (1 x 1)          (1)

             3.2.2   Interpretation of information from Source 3B – L2– LO1 (AS3 and
                     4); LO2 (AS2 and 3)]

                     CORE was responsible for organising sit-ins – Gordon Carey, its
                     representative went to new York to organise sit-ins
                     • The SCLC spread the information about sit-ins to other
                         students – Ella Baker of the SCLC contacted students on
                         many college campuses.
                     Any other relevant response                                    (2 x 2)        (4)

Copyright reserved                                                              Please turn over

### Page 21

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P1                                   21                          DBE/Feb-Mar. 2014
                                     NSC – Memorandum

             3.2.3   [Extraction of evidence from Source 3B – L1 – LO1 (AS3)]

                     •   They put signs on store windows such as: 'No trespassing',
                         'We Reserve the Right to Service the Public As We See Fit'
                         and 'CLOSED – on the interest of Public Safety'    (1 x 2)              (2)

3.3          3.3.1   [Extraction of evidence from Source 3C – L1 – LO1 (AS3)]

                     •   He announced that a new, and more militant phase of his civil
                         rights campaign would be initiated in Selma in Alabama
                     •   He said 'we are not asking, we are demanding the ballot.'
                                                                                (1 x 1)          (1)

             3.3.2   [Interpretation of information from Source 3C – L2– LO1 (AS3 and
                     4); LO2 (AS2 and 3)]

                     •   He reacted strongly by deciding to arrest Martin Luther Junior
                         and many other demonstrators
                     •   He arrested 770 demonstrators on 1 February and 500 more
                         by 3 February 1965
                     •    Any other relevant response                          (2 x 2)           (4)

3.4          3.4.1   Interpretation of information from Sources 3D L2 – LO1 (AS4)]
                     •   Voting rights – only 2,4% of Selma's African Americans were
                         registered to vote                                   (1 x 2)            (2)

             3.4.2   [Evaluate information from Source 3D - L2 – LO2 (AS3)]

                     Candidates should indicate whether the march was
                     SUCCESFUL or NOT SUCCESFUL and support their answer
                     with relevant evidence.

                     SUCCESFUL
                     • President Johnson pushed through a Voting Rights Bill – which
                        was passed by Congress to become law in 1968

                     NOT SUCCESFUL
                     • It was a token march
                     • Marchers turned back after a short distance
                     • Any other relevant answer                                 (1 x 2)         (2)

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

Text truncated here. Open the document page to read the rest.

## Related documents

- [History P1 Feb-March 2014 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p1-feb-march-2014-eng/496bdf16-b408-425c-be6e-3a997a135e8d) — History · QP · 2014 · Eng
- [HISTORY P1 JUNE 2014 GRADE 12 MEMO](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p1-june-2014-grade-12-memo/f43de79f-37ce-47dc-bc4b-f253bac84b10) — History · Memo · 2014
- [History P1 (HG) (English) June 2014 Memo](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p1-hg-english-june-2014-memo/af99a7de-7cff-42ba-8fe1-10db347d9bd2) — History · Memo · 2014 · Eng
- [HIST P1 GR12 QP AFR SEP 2014](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/hist-p1-gr12-qp-afr-sep-2014/3296a2b9-b5f3-4845-9366-f96f2839b363) — History · QP · 2014 · Afr
- [History P1 (SG) (English) June 2014 Addendum](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p1-sg-english-june-2014-addendum/4aa7434a-8815-410f-a2dd-92249bec2c0a) — History · Addendum · 2014 · Eng
- [History P1 (SG) (English) June 2014 QP](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p1-sg-english-june-2014-qp/4cee2274-271e-4435-91c3-0840a3727422) — History · QP · 2014 · Eng

## More from Grade 12 History

- [Workguide - Case Study Strategies](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/workguide-case-study-strategies/0b4c8d70-c563-4cfe-93e0-dad57e8fbeb3) — Guide
- [HISTORY P1 ADDEN GR12 SEP 2024 Afrikaans](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p1-adden-gr12-sep-2024-afrikaans/4faf89db-d19f-40cf-891f-e87e004b0bc5) — Addendum · 2024 · Afr
- [HISTORY P2 GR12 ADDENDUM SEPT 2024 Afrikaans](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-gr12-addendum-sept-2024-afrikaans/b61f3bc2-3524-48c9-af60-f3348133d582) — Addendum · 2024 · Afr
- [HISTORY P2 GR12 QP SEPT 2024 Afrikaans](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-gr12-qp-sept-2024-afrikaans/8367f672-7028-4e67-a52a-705b946b5122) — QP · 2024 · Afr
- [Gr 12 History P1 (English) 2024 Question Paper X05](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/gr-12-history-p1-english-2024-question-paper-x05/7b41ec15-3856-4a67-a9db-cedd424e51c5) — QP · 2024 · Eng
- [HISTORY P2 GR12 ADDENDUM JUNE 2024 Afrikaans](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-gr12-addendum-june-2024-afrikaans/e7a9d6cf-de1b-4007-b7b2-b4d762b2fa10) — Addendum · 2024 · Afr

## Collection

- [Grade 12 past papers](https://www.hlayiso.com/grade-12/past-papers)

---

Hlayiso: free CAPS and IEB past papers, memos, notes and study guides for South African learners. When citing, link the page URL above, not a PDF or /api/ URL.
