# History Grade 12 Paper 2 GP Prelim 2023 Memo (English)

> Grade 12 History Paper 2 memorandum from the GP Prelim 2023 (English), 26 pages. Read online or get the free PDF download, question paper linked when available.

- Page: https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-english-memo/d87dda00-dcbb-4e3c-80cf-43a430c6a495
- Updated: 2026-09-27
- Subject: History
- Grade: Grade 12
- Language: English
- Document type: Memorandum
- Year: 2023
- Exam period: GP Prelim
- Paper: 2
- Curriculum: CAPS
- Pages: 26

Breadcrumbs: [Home](https://www.hlayiso.com/) › [Library](https://www.hlayiso.com/library) › [Grade 12](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12) › [History](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12/history) › [History Grade 12 Paper 2 GP Prelim 2023 Memo (English)](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-english-memo/d87dda00-dcbb-4e3c-80cf-43a430c6a495)

## About this document

History · Grade 12 · GP Prelim · 2023 · English. Memorandum, 26 pages. Read online or download the PDF.

Read it free online on the page above; download the PDF from there.

## Document text

Text extracted from the PDF. Layout, diagrams and tables may not survive extraction.

### Page 1

Downloaded from hlayiso.com

       PREPARATORY EXAMINATION
                       2023
           MARKING GUIDELINES

              HISTORY (PAPER 2) (10792)

26 pages

### Page 2

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                          10792/23

1.   SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS

     1.1 The following cognitive levels were used to develop source-based
         questions.

     Cognitive                                                                Weighting of
                                       Historical skills
      levels                                                                   questions

                      •   Extract evidence from sources
                      •   Selection and organisation of relevant                  30%
     LEVEL 1
                          information from sources                             (15 marks)
                      •   Define historical concepts/terms
                      •   Interpretation of evidence from sources
                                                                                  40%
     LEVEL 2          •   Explain information gathered from sources
                                                                               (20 marks)
                      •   Analyse evidence from sources
                      •   Interpret and evaluate information and
                          evidence from sources
                      •   Engage with sources to determine the                    30%
     LEVEL 3              usefulness, reliability, bias, and limitations
                                                                               (15 marks)
                      •   Compare and contrast interpretations and
                          perspectives presented in sources and draw
                          independent conclusions

     1.2 The information below indicates how source-based questions are
         assessed:

          •      In the marking of all source-based questions credit needs to be given to
                 any other valid and relevant viewpoints, arguments, evidence or
                 examples.
          •      In the allocation of marks emphasis should be placed on addressing the
                 requirements of the question.
          •      In these marking guidelines the requirements of the question (skills that
                 need to be addressed) as well as the level of the question are indicated in
                 italics.

     1.3 Assessment procedures for source-based questions:

          •      Use a tick (✓) for each correct answer
          •      Pay attention to the mark scheme e.g. (2 x 2) which translates to two
                 reasons and is given two marks each (✓✓ ✓✓); (1 x 2) which translates
                 to one reason and is given two marks (✓✓)
          •      If a question carries 4 marks then indicate by placing 4 ticks (✓✓✓✓)

                                                  2

### Page 3

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                           10792/23

Paragraph question

Paragraphs are to be assessed globally (holistically). Both the content and structure of
the paragraph must be taken into account when awarding a mark. The following steps
must be used when assessing response to a paragraph question.

•   Read a paragraph and place a bullet () at each point within the text where the
    candidate has used evidence to address the question
•   Re-read the paragraph to evaluate the extent to which the candidate has been able
    to use relevant evidence to write a paragraph.
•   At the end of the paragraph indicate the ticks (✓) that the candidate has been
    awarded for the paragraph; as well as the level (1, 2 or 3) as indicated in the
    holistic rubric and a brief comment, e.g.

    ____________________ _______________________
    _________________________ _______________ ✓✓✓✓

    LEVEL 2 = 4

    Used mostly relevant evidence to write a basic paragraph

    •     Count all the ticks for the source-based question and then write the mark on the
                                            32
          right hand bottom margin, e.g..
                                            50
    •     Ensure that the total mark is transferred accurately to the front/back cover of the
          answer script next to the appropriate question number.

2. ESSAY QUESTIONS

    2.1     The essay questions require candidates to:
            • Structure the argument in a logical and coherent manner. They need to
               select, organise and connect the relevant information so that they are able
               to present a reasonable sequence of facts or an effective argument to
               answer the question posed. It is essential that an essay has an
               introduction, a coherent and balanced body of evidence and a conclusion.

    2.2     Marking of essay questions
            • Markers must be aware that the content of the answer will be guided by
               the marking guidelines provided.
            • Candidates may have any other relevant introduction and/ or conclusion
               than those included in a specific essay marking guideline for a specific
               essay.

                                                  3

### Page 4

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                    10792/23

2.3   Global assessment of the essay

      The essay will be assessed holistically (globally). This approach requires the
      teacher to assess the essay as a whole, without scoring the component parts
      separately. This approach encourages the learner to offer an individual
      opinion by using selected factual evidence to support an argument. The
      learner will not be required to simply regurgitate "facts" in order to achieve a
      high mark. This approach discourages learners from preparing "model"
      answers and reproducing them without taking into account the specific
      requirements of the question. Holistic marking of the essay credits learners’
      opinions which are supported by evidence. Holistic assessment, unlike
      content-based marking, does not penalise language inadequacies as the
      emphasis is on the following:

      •   The construction of the argument
      •   The appropriate selection of factual evidence to support such an
          argument
      •   The learner’s interpretation of the question

2.4   Assessment procedures of the essay

      2.4.1 Keep the synopsis in mind when assessing essay writing.

      2.4.2 During the first reading of the extended writing, ticks need to be
            awarded for a relevant introduction (indicated by a bullet in the marking
            guideline/memorandum), each of the main points/body that is properly
            contextualised (also indicated by bullets in the marking
            guideline/memorandum) and a relevant conclusion (also indicated by a
            bullet in the marking guideline/memorandum), e.g. in an answer where
            there are five (5) main points there can be seven (7) ticks.

      2.4.3 Keep the PEEL structure in mind when assessing an essay.

             P      Point: The candidate introduces the essay by taking a line of
                    argument/making a major point.
                    Each paragraph should include a point that sustains the major
                    point (line of argument) that was made in the introduction.
             E      Explanation: The candidate should explain in more detail what
                    the main point is about and how it relates to the question posed
                    (line of argument).
             E      Example: The candidates should answer the question by
                    selecting content that is relevant to the line of argument.
                    Relevant examples should be given to sustain the line of
                    argument.
             L      Link: Candidates should ensure that the line of argument is
                    sustained throughout the essay and is written coherently.

                                            4

### Page 5

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                    10792/23

      2.4.4 The following symbols MUST be used when assessing an essay:

             •     Introduction, main aspects and conclusion not properly
                   contextualised

             •     Wrong statement                                          ^
             •     Irrelevant statement                              |
                                                                     |
                                                                     |

             •     Repetition                                        R
             •     Analysis                                          A✓
             •     Interpretation                                    |✓
             •     Line of Argument                          LOA

2.5   The matrix

      2.5.1 Use of the analytical matrix in the marking of essays:

             In the marking of essays, the criteria provided in the matrix should be
             used. When assessing the essay note both the content and
             presentation. At the point of intersection of the content and presentation
             based on the seven competency levels, a mark should be awarded.

             (a) The first reading of essays will be to determine to what extent the
                 main aspects have been covered and to allocate the content level
                 (on the matrix).
                                                          I     LEVEL 4

             (b) The second reading of essays will relate to the level (on the
                 matrix) of presentation.
                                                        I      LEVEL 4
                                                        A      LEVEL 3

             (c)    Allocate an overall mark with the use of the matrix.
                                                           I      LEVEL 4
                                                                                26 – 27
                                                           A      LEVEL 3

             COMMENT
             Some omissions in content coverage
             Attempts to sustain a line of argument

                                            5

### Page 6

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                                                                         10792/23

GLOBAL ASSESSMENT OF ESSAYS: TOTAL MARKS: 50
                           LEVEL 7                 LEVEL 6            LEVEL 5          LEVEL 4        LEVEL 3          LEVEL 2           LEVEL 1
PRESENTATION               Very well planned       Very well          Well planned     Planned and    Shows some       Attempts to       Little or no
                           and structured essay.   planned and        and structured   constructed    evidence of a    structure an      attempt to
                           Good synthesis of       structured         essay.           an argument.   planned and      answer.           structure the
                           information.            essay.             Attempts to      Evidence is    constructed      Largely           essay.
                           Developed an            Developed a        develop a        used to some   argument.        descriptive, or
                           original, well          relevant line of   clear            extent to      Attempts to      some attempt
                           balanced and            argument.          argument.        support the    sustain a line   at developing
                           independent line of     Evidence used      Conclusion       line of        of argument.     a line of
CONTENT                    argument with the       to defend the      drawn from       argument       Conclusions      argument. No
                           use of evidence,        argument.          the evidence     Conclusions    not clearly      attempt to
                           sustained and           Attempts to draw   to support the   reached        supported by     draw a
                           defended the            an independent     line of          based on       evidence.        conclusion
                           argument throughout.    conclusion from    argument.        evidence.
                           Independent             the evidence to
                           conclusion is drawn     support the line
                           from evidence to        of argument.
                           support the line of
                           argument.
LEVEL 7
Question has been fully
answered. Content               47 – 50              43 – 46
selection fully relevant
to line of argument.
LEVEL 6
Question has been
answered.                       43 – 46              40 – 42           38 – 39
Content selection
relevant to the line of
argument.
LEVEL 5
Question answered to
a great extent. Content         36 – 39              36 – 37           34 – 35          30 – 33        28 – 29
adequately covered
and relevant.
LEVEL 4
Question is
recognisable in
answer.                                                                30 – 33          28 – 29        26 – 27
Some omissions or
irrelevant content
selection.
LEVEL 3
Content selection does
relate to the question,
but does not answer it,                                                                 26 – 27        24 – 25          20 – 23
or does not always
relate to the question.
Omissions in coverage.
LEVEL 2
Question inadequately
addressed.
                                                                                                       20 – 23          18 – 19           14 – 17
Sparse content.
LEVEL 1
Question inadequately
addressed or not at all.                                                                                                14 – 17            0 – 13
Inadequate or
irrelevant content.

Guidelines for allocating a mark for LEVEL 1:

•    Question not addressed at all/totally irrelevant content/no attempt to
     structure the essay                                                                                                            =0
•    Question includes basic and generally irrelevant information; no attempt to
     structure the essay                                                                                                            =1–6
•    Question inadequately addressed and vague; little attempt to structure the
     essay                                                                                                                          = 7 – 13

                                                                            6

### Page 7

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                        10792/23

QUESTION 1:       HOW DID THE TRADE UNIONS CHALLENGE APARTHEID LAWS
                  IN THE 1980s?

1.1   1.1.1   [Extraction of evidence from Source 1A – L1]

              •   To seek agreement on the alignment of the labour movement with
                  the political struggles of the majority.                   (1 x 2)        (2)

      1.1.2   [Extraction of evidence from Source 1A – L1]

              •   The death in detention of Neil Aggett                           (1 x 1)   (1)

      1.1.3   [Extraction of evidence from Source 1A – L1]

              •   Food and Canning Workers Union / FCWU
              •   Federation of South African Trade Unions /FOSATU                (2 x 1)   (2)

      1.1.4   [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1A – L2]

              •  FOSATU, GAWU and the UDF worked together in order to highlight
                 students’ grievances
              (Any other relevant response.)                             (1 x 2)            (2)

      1.1.5   [Definition of a historical concept in Source 1A – L1]

              •  A method of protesting by not supporting/buying at certain shops /
                 Refusal to buy from certain shops
              • Communities not supporting/buying from identified white owned
                 businesses.
              (Any other relevant response.)                                (any 1 x 2)     (2)

1.2   1.2.1   [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1B – L2]

              •  It means the union is prepared to fight against the injustices and ills
                 of the society created by apartheid.
              • The union is prepared to fight for liberation/equality/freedom of South
                 Africa.
              • The union is prepared to fight for better living and working conditions.
              (Any other relevant response.)                                  (any 1 x 2)   (2)

                                                7

### Page 8

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                 10792/23

1.2.2 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1B – L2]

       •  It refers to the Tricameral Parliament/ constitution
       •  Koornhoff bills/New Deal
       •  Reforms /changes introduced by Botha as a way of giving Coloureds
          and Indians representation in parliament
       • Constitution of 1983 that excluded blacks from the 3 Chamber
          Parliament
       • Black people were not satisfied with the Black Local Authorities Act –
          gave black people the impression that they were in control of their
          own affairs.
       (Any other relevant response.)                                (any 1 x 2)     (2)

1.2.3 [Extraction of evidence from Source 1B – L1]

       •   Shooting
       •   Banning
       •   Imprisonment                                                    (3 x 1)   (3)

1.2.4 [Extraction of evidence from Source 1B – L1]

       •   Pay high rents
       •   Pay unrealistic electricity bills
       •   Pay expensive transport.
       •   Live in overcrowded houses
       •   Not enough houses                                           (any 2 x 1)   (2)

1.2.5 [Evaluation of the reliability of information from Source 1B – L3]

       THE SOURCE IS RELIABLE BECAUSE:

       •  It is a direct speech(primary source) by Samson Ndou, the Unionist
          representative/ mediator who knows the plight of workers
       • It is a speech of a worker who has first-hand experience of the
          working conditions in the factories.
       • The speaker in the source is a black community member who
          experienced first-hand the social injustices of low wages, and lack of
          housing in townships.
       • The source gives the date, 20 August 1983, which is the date on
          which the speech was delivered which makes it a primary source
       • The source is corroborated by Source 1C which mentions the
          grievances of workers in the 1980s.
       (Any other relevant response.)                                 (any 2 x 2)    (4)

                                               8

### Page 9

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                      10792/23

1.3 1.3.1 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1D – L2]

            •  To inform members about their campaign to fight for workers’ rights.
            •  To make the public aware about the campaigns they led in the 1980s.
            •  To list their concerns so that members and the public should know
               what they stood for.
            • To show the public their demands, therefore trying to encourage
               them to join the campaign / garner their support
            • To show that workers/ different unions stand united under COSATU/
               solidary/ strength in the fight for workers’ right
            (Any other relevant response.)                                (any 2 x 2)     (4)

     1.3.2 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1D – L2]

            •  That as the union they have power/amandla to bring change to labour
               and South African politics.
            • To encourage unity among different political and labour
               organisations.
            • To show the strength of unions to fight for better living and working
               conditions.
            •   Clenched fists was used as a symbol against the injustices of
               apartheid in the labour force
            (Any other relevant response.)                                  (any 2 x 2)   (4)

1.4 [Comparison of information from Sources 1B and 1C – L3]

     •  Source 1B states that workers were unhappy with overcrowded houses and
        in Source 1C demands are made for decent houses/ Both sources show
        workers faced overcrowding or housing challenges
     • The speaker in source 1B says that wages are low and the placard in 1C
        makes a demand for a living wage/ Both sources show workers received
        poor or low wages
     • Source 1B refers to workers experiencing problems in the factories and
        Source 1C lists a variety of problems faced by workers in the factories./Both
        sources show that workers experienced a variety of problems in the factories
     (Any other relevant response.)                                        (any 2 x 2)    (4)

1.5 1.5.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 1D – L1]

            •   United Workers’ Union of South Africa/UWUSA                     (1 x 1)   (1)

     1.5.2 [Definition of a historical concept from Source 1D – L2]

            •   When the apartheid government had the power to make policies that
                were not permitted for the protection of the government and
                repressing black South Africans.
            •   Laws to suspend any protests/gathering/rights of workers.
            •   These laws were meant to supress black workers.

                                              9

### Page 10

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                      10792/23

            • Union activity was made illegal.
            (Any other relevant response.)                                  (any 1 x 2)     (2)

     1.5.3 [Extraction of evidence from Source 1D – L1]

            •   Jay Naidoo                                                        (1 x 1)   (1)

     1.5.4 [Interpretation of information from Source 1D – L2]

            •  They wanted to monitor all the activities of COSATU/ keeping records of
               people going in and out of COSATU offices
            • So that security forces must supress their activities.
            • Dampen the efforts of the Unions/ threaten the union/ instil fear in the
               unions
            •   To enforce the state of emergency
            (Any other relevant response.)                                   (any 1 x 2)    (2)

     1.5.5 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1D – L2]

            •  Business preferred to negotiate with organised labour union
               representatives.
            • Business was against the arrest of union leaders.
            • Business was uncomfortable negotiating with ordinary people/members.
            (Any other relevant response.)                                 (any 1 x 2)      (2)

1.6 [Interpretation, evaluation and synthesis from relevant sources – L3]

     Candidates could include the following aspects in their response:

     •   Unions came together to unite against unfair apartheid laws (Source 1A)
     •   Unions got involved in political struggles (Source 1A, Source 1C)
     •   Some unions like FOSATU concentrated only on labour issues (Source 1A)
     •   Union movements organized stayaways, and work stoppages as a way to
         show the government their grievances (Source 1A, Source 1D)
     •   Unions supported student grievances (Source 1A)
     •   They worked with the UDF to defy apartheid laws (Source 1A)
     •   They organised strikes and stayaways (Source 1A)
     •   Union movement fought for May day to be recognised as a Worker’s day
         (Source 1A, Source 1D)
     •   Unions faced state repression like detention, murder, shooting and banning
         and many restrictions (Sources 1A, 1B, 1D)
     •   Individual unions supported each other’s causes like FOSATU supporting
         FCWU
     •   Unions also fought for job security and better working conditions (Sources 1B
         and 1C)
     •   Workers faced the problem of poor wages which affected their financial status
         and campaigns were launched to demand living wage (Sources 1B and 1C)

                                             10

### Page 11

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                         10792/23

    •  Sometimes unions were at loggerheads because of different principles
       (Source 1D)
    • Members retaliated/protested when their leaders were arrested (Source 1D)
    (Any other relevant response.)

Use the following rubric to allocate marks:

                    •   Uses evidence in an elementary manner, e.g. shows
                        no or little understanding in explaining how the
                        trade unions challenged apartheid laws in the            MARKS
        LEVEL 1
                        1980s.                                                    0–2
                    •   Uses evidence partially or cannot write a paragraph
                        on the topic.
                    •   Evidence is mostly relevant and relates to a great
                        extent to the topic, e.g. shows some understanding
                        in explaining how the trade unions challenged            MARKS
        LEVEL 2
                        apartheid laws in the 1980s                               3–5
                    •   Uses evidence in a very basic manner to write a
                        paragraph.
                    •   Uses relevant evidence, e.g. demonstrates a
                        thorough understanding in explaining how the trade
                        unions challenged apartheid laws in the 1980s            MARKS
        LEVEL 3
                    •   Uses evidence very effectively in an organised            6–8
                        paragraph that shows an understanding of the topic.

                                                                                              (8)
                                                                                             [50]

QUESTION 2:        HOW DID THE TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION
                   (TRC) DEAL WITH THE MURDER OF POLITICAL ACTIVISTS
                   SUCH AS THE COSAS 4?

2.1 2.1.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 2A – L1]

            •     “the country’s transition from repressive rule to democracy in 1994.”
                                                                                   (1 x 2)    (2)

     2.1.2 [Extraction of evidence from Source 2A – L1]

            •     To combat impunity (exemption from punishment)
            •     Recreate a culture of accountability
            •     To uncover truth about gross human rights violations
            •     Assist families of the victims in getting closure
                                                                              (any 3 x 1)     (3)

     2.1.3 [Definition of a historical concept from Source 2A – L2]

                                                11

### Page 12

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                      10792/23

           •  An official pardon/forgiveness for people who had committed political
              offences / atrocities during apartheid/1960 – 1994
           • An exclusion from prosecution for perpetrators of political crimes(on
              condition that they disclose the whole truth and prove political motive)
           (Any other relevant response.)                                   (any 1 x 2)   (2)

     2.1.4 [Extraction of evidence from Source 2A – L1]

           •   Apartheid state
           •   Liberation movements
           •   Members and leaders of groups such as ANC, IFP and PAC
                                                                    (any 2 x 1)           (2)

     2.1.5 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2A – L2]

           •   An important feature of the TRC was its openness and transparency.
           •   The TRC ensured that South Africans became aware of the atrocities
               that had been committed during the apartheid years on both sides of
               the political spectrum.

           .
           •  TRC leaders persuaded them to participate in the amnesty process.
           •  Because the ANC, IFP and PAC had also lost members while they
              were in exile
           • They wanted to prove that their actions were politically motivated
           (Any other relevant response.)                                 (any 1 x 2)     (2)

2.2 2.2.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 2B – L1]

           •   Finally, those responsible for the death of three of the COSAS 4 who
               were murdered by the Security Branch in February 1982, more than
               40 years ago would be prosecuted.                               (1 x 1)    (1)

     2.2.2 [Extraction of evidence from Source 2B – L1]

           •   Joe Mamasela / Mamasela
           •   Thlomedi Ephraim Mfalapitsa/ Mfalapitsa                          (2 x 1)   (2)

     2.2.3 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2B – L2]

           •  They did not want to implicate themselves.
           •  They did not think that the bodies would be found.
           •  To prevent post-mortem examination of bodies that might present a
              different conclusion/transparency/truthful cause of death.
           • The cause of death would then be used for further investigation into
              the prosecution of those responsible for the murders of the deceased.
           (Any other relevant response.)                                 (any 1 x 2)     (2)

                                             12

### Page 13

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                       10792/23

     2.2.4 [Explanation of a historical concept in own words from Source 2B – L1]

           • The restoration of friendly relations
           • An act of making peace between former enemies
           • Pursuit of unity between black and white/ perpetrator and victim
           (Any other relevant response.)                                (any 1 x 2)       (2)

     2.2.5 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2B – L2]

           •   Did not tell the whole truth/Lied about how the three members of
               COSAS 4 died
           •   Had covered up the murder
           •   Failed to prove political motive                           (any 1 x 2)      (2)

2.3 2.3.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 2B – L1]

           •   Eustice “Bimbo” Madikela/ Madikela
           •   Ntshingo Mataboge/ Mataboge
           •   Fanyana Nhlapo/ Nhlapo
           •   Zandisile Musi/ Musi                                         (any 2 x 1)    (2)

     2.3.2 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2C – L2]

           •   To shift the blame away from himself.
           •   He did not order their killing therefore he could not be held
               responsible.
            (Any other relevant response.)                                   (any 1 x 2)   (2)

     2.3.3 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2C – L2]

           •  To allow for forensic tests which would lead to the prosecution of the
              killers.
           • To get post-mortem results so that families can get closure
           • Because the bodies were buried quickly to make sure nobody
              tampered with them in a way which could implicate the askaris.
           (Any other relevant response.)                                 (any 1 x 2)      (2)

     2.3.4 [Determining the usefulness of evidence from Source 2C – L3]

           The source is USEFUL because:

           •   It contains evidence from a TRC hearing held in May 1999 into the
               murders of the COSAS 4.
           •   It is a testimony of Coetzee during the Amnesty hearings where he
               admitted to not giving a legal order to have the members of COSAS 4
               killed.
           •   The hearing took place in May 1999, the exact date when the
               amnesty hearings were held.

                                              13

### Page 14

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                          10792/23

            •  The source gives insight as to who was implicated in the murder of
               the COSAS 4, namely Coetzee and Mfalapitsa.
            • The source gives the names of the 3 killed members, namely Eustice
               “Bimbo” Madikela, Ntshingo Mataboge and Fanyana Nhlapo.
            (Any other relevant response.)                               (any 2 x 2)          (4)

2.4 2.4.1 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2D – L2]

            • To indicate that the case of the COSAS 4 finally went to court.
            • The family and friends of the COSAS 4 can finally seek justice.
            • To show the public who the perpetrators were.
            • To show that the NPA is acting on outstanding TRC cases.
            • To show that after 40 years family can still find closure.
            (Any other relevant response.)                               (any 2 x 2)          (4)

     2.4.2 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2D – L2]

            •  40 years later some family members have passed on.
            •  The person in the picture (Mfalapitsa) is one of two surviving
               perpetrators.
            • Some family members might have made peace with what happened.
            • Not such a high-profile case anymore
            (Any other relevant response.)                                  (any 2 x 2)       (4)

2.5 [Comparison of evidence in Sources 2C and 2D – L3]

     •  Source 2C states that families knew who the cops/killers were and Source
        2D shows the picture of the former askari/cop, Thlomedi Ephraim Mfalapitsa
        appearing in court for the murder of three of the COSAS 4 members.
     • Source 2C states families filed an application with the Krugersdorp
        Magistrate’s Court to have the bodies of their loved ones exhumed to
        facilitate possible prosecution of the killers later and Source 2D shows family
        members attending a hearing into the murder of the members of COSAS 4
        in the Krugersdorp Magistrate’s Court.
     • Source 2C states that Mfalapitsa applied to the TRC for amnesty and that it
        was denied and Source 2D shows Mfalapitsa who appeared before the
        Krugersdorp Magistrate’s Court in relation to the murder of the COSAS 4.
     (Any other relevant response.)                                          (any 2 x 2)      (4)

2.6 [Interpretation, evaluation and synthesis from relevant sources – L3]

     Candidates could include the following aspects in their response:

     •   The TRC was established to investigate human rights abuses that were
         committed during the period between 1 March 1960 and 10 May 1994
         (Source 2A)
     •   The TRC held public hearings where both victims and perpetrators of
         politically motivated crimes had a chance to tell their stories, to facilitate
         reconciliation (Source 2A)

                                                14

### Page 15

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                    10792/23

•  The TRC identified torture, killings, disappearances and abductions, and
   severe ill treatment as some of the human rights abuses (Source 2A)
• The TRC also identified liberation movements to give evidence regarding
   their involvement in human rights abuses (Source 2A)
• Carel Coetzee, Willem Frederick Schoon, Abraham Grobbelaar, Christiaan
   Siebert Rorich and Mfalapitsa all applied for amnesty for their involvement in
   the killing of the COSAS 4 (Source 2B)
• The TRC did not grant them amnesty for the murder of the COSAS 4
   (Source 2B)
• Brigadier Cliffy Marion was instrumental in the TRC not granting amnesty on
   the premise that they were not telling the truth (Source 2B)
• Family members were happy that amnesty was refused and the case was
   referred to the NPA for further investigation and prosecution (Source 2B)
• Senior government officials leaned on the NPA and forcibly suppressed the
   prosecution of all 300 TRC cases (Source 2C)
• Families of the COSAS 4 are still not happy with the process as Coetzee
   was still not telling the truth about what happened to the COSAS 4
   (Source 2C)
• The police lied to the TRC that the COSAS 4 had “blown themselves up”
   (Source 2C)
• Families wanted the bodies exhumed for further investigation to get to the
   truth to find closure (Source 2C)
• Families wanted retributive justice as they felt the police were heartless
   towards them with continuous lies (Own knowledge)
• The TRC forwarded the case to the NPA to further investigate after
   uncovering more human rights abuses (Source 2C)
• The NPA is in the process of prosecuting perpetrators for the killing of the
   COSAS 4 (Source 2D)
• Other perpetrators have since died (Own knowledge)
• Only Mfalapitsa and Rorich are alive. Mfalapitsa is still appearing before the
   NPA in relation to the murders (Sources 2C and 2D)
• Due to the case taking long, the full truth may never be established in the
   case (Own knowledge)
(Any other relevant response.)

                                        15

### Page 16

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                           10792/23

Use the following rubric to allocate marks:

                •     Uses evidence in an elementary manner e.g. shows no
                      or little understanding of how the TRC dealt with the        MARKS
  LEVEL 1
                      murder of political activists such as the COSAS 4.            0–2
                •     Uses evidence partially or cannot write a paragraph.
                •     Evidence is mostly relevant and relates to a great extent
                      on the topic e.g., shows an understanding of how the
                      TRC dealt with the murder of political activists such        MARKS
  LEVEL 2
                      as the COSAS 4.                                               3–5
                •     Uses evidence in a very basic manner to write a
                      paragraph.
                •     Uses relevant evidence e.g., demonstrates a thorough
                      understanding of how the TRC dealt with the murder
                                                                                   MARKS
  LEVEL 3             of political activists such as the COSAS 4.
                                                                                    6–8
                •     Uses evidence very effectively in an organised
                      paragraph that shows an understanding of the topic.
                                                                                                 (8)
                                                                                                [50]

QUESTION 3:          HOW HAS SOUTH AFRICA’S MEMBERSHIP OF BRICS
                     AFFECTED THE SOUTH AFRICAN ECONOMY?

3.1 3.1.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 3A – L1]

            •       Brazil
            •       Russia
            •       India
            •       China
            •       South Africa                                                  (any 3 x 1)    (3)

     3.1.2 [Extraction of evidence from Source 3A – L1]

            •       Jim O’Neill                                                       (1 x 2)    (2)

     3.1.3 [Definition of a historical concept in Source 3A – L1]

            •  A disease prevalent over a whole country or the world.
            •  Outbreak of a disease all over the world/over a wide geographical
               area.
            • A highly contagious disease spread by a virus, that affects people all
               over the world such as COVID-19.
            (Any other relevant response.)                                 (any 1 x 2)           (2)

     3.1.4 [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3A – L2]

            •       The Ukraine crisis has led to an increase in food prices.
            •       Increase in fuel/petrol prices.

                                                  16

### Page 17

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                       10792/23

           •  Extreme price shocks and disruption of the supply chain for wheat and
              sunflower oil.
           • Cooking oil prices went up.
           • Eskom finds it difficult to secure diesel to burn turbines because of the
              crisis.
           • Led to unemployment and lowered GDP.
           • Increase in inflation.
           (Any other relevant response.)                                   (any 1 x 2)    (2)

     3.1.5 [Interpretation of information from Source 3A – L2)]

           •  It will provide a platform for developing countries to voice their
              concerns.
           • It will provide a voice in world transformation concerning the global
              economic system/to stop Western powers from monopolising the
              global economy.
           • Enable developing countries to have a greater say in decisions
              concerning their destinies (e.g. decisions on energy sources).
           • So that BRICS can be seen to be a competitive player (taken
              seriously) in the global economy.
           (Any other relevant response.)                                    (any 1 x 2)   (2)

3.2 3.2.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 3B – L1]

            •   South Africa                                                    ( 1 x 1)   (1)

     3.2.2 [Explaination of concept from Source 3B – L2]

            •  A meeting between heads of states of countries belonging to
               BRICS/Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa
            (Any other relevant response.)                                       (1 x 2)   (2)

     3.2.3 [Interpretation of information from Source 3B – L2]

            •  Increased access to each other’s markets allows members to trade
               with each other easily
            • Members can invest in each other’s economies
            • Partnership creates a business friendly environment for investors in
               BRICS countries
            • The New Development Bank can make funds/loans for member
               countries
            (Any other relevant response.)                               (any 1 x 2)       (2)

     3.2.4 [Interpretation of information from Source 3B – L2]

            •   membership improves competitiveness with other countries
            •   Improves SA’s trade with other countries
            •   Leads to economic growth
            •   Boosts investment in infrastructure
                                              17

### Page 18

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                         10792/23

            (Any other relevant response.)                                    (any 1 x 2)    (2)

     3.2.5 [Extraction of evidence from Source 3B – L1]

            •   New Development Bank                                               (1 x 2)   (2)

3.3 3.3.1 [Interpretation of information from Source 3C – L2]

            •  The BRICS Development Bank opens doors to emerging economies
               to access funds (money inside the walls) for infrastructural
               development.
            • The Development Bank will help developing countries to overcome
               infrastructure problems (building walls with brick and mortar) to
               enable sustainable development.
            • The New Development bank will focus on infrastructure construction
               which has been hampering economic and social development in
               emerging economies.
            • The infrastructure projects that the bank funded would then create
               jobs in the construction sector (building industry).
            • The Development Bank would also provide funds to educate the
               population (trolley full of books) to prepare them for jobs in the
               manufacturing sector.
            (Any other relevant response.)                                     (any 2 x 2)   (4)

     3.3.2 [Interpretation of information from Source 3C – L2]

            •  Provides loans/funding for emerging economies.
            •  Provides capital for investment in poor countries.
            •  Funds infrastructure development in emerging economies.
            •  Aims to improve the lives of people in poorer countries.
            •  Would create jobs in the construction sector for the unemployed in
               these countries.
            • Would create jobs in the manufacturing sector.
            (Any other relevant response.)                                (any 1 x 2)        (2)

     3.3.3 [Explanation of limitations from Source 3C – L3]

            •   The source is one-sided – from a Chinese newspaper and China is a
                partner in BRICS
            •   It is one-sided in support of the goals of the bank for its members
            •   The source does not highlight other infrastructure projects such as
                the Medupi Thermal Power Plant and South Africa’s Lesotho
                Highlands Water Project to improve the standard of living.
            •   Repayment plans of loans provided for infrastructure and
                development is not mentioned in the source.
            •   The source does not specify for which other projects (other than
                infrastructure and education) the money is intended.
                                                18

### Page 19

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                       10792/23

            (Any other relevant response.)                                  (any 2 x 2)    (4)

3.4 [Comparison of evidence from Source 3B and 3C to ascertain how sources
    support each other – L3]

    •  Source 3B states that BRICS member countries e.g South Africa, has
       received 5,4 billion dollars from the New Development Bank and Source 3C
       shows how BRICS Development Bank provides funds aimed at alleviating
       poverty in emerging economies.
    • Source 3B states that BRICS Development Bank provides funds aimed to
       improve infrastructure and Source 3C depicts how the bank makes funds
       available for infrastructure development.
    (Any other relevant response.)                                         (2 x 2)         (4)

3.5 3.5.1 [Extraction of evidence from Source 3D – L1]

            •   BRICS may erode South Africa’s domestic economy.
            •   Products from BRICS countries compete directly with those of South
                Africa.
            •   BRICS and industrialised countries are targeting Africa’s resources
                which poses a direct threat to SA’s economy.                (any 1 x 1)    (1)

     3.5.2 [Extraction of evidence from Source 3D – L1]

            •   Stoves
            •   Fridges
            •   Trains                                                      (any 1 x 1)    (1)

     3.5.3 [Extraction of evidence from Source 3D – L1]

            •   Structural obstacles
            •   Poor economic and political policies
            •   Lack of imagination in leadership                           (any 2 x 1)    (2)

     3.5.4 [Interpretasie van inligting uit Source 3D – L2]

            •   BRICS countries are already exporting their manufactured goods to
                Africa, thereby taking SA’s ideal market.
            •   The manufacturing industry in South Africa is on a decline,
                consequently certain manufacturing areas such as the East Rand has
                become deserted.

            •  Unemployment increased as manufacturing plants closed down.
            •  Job creation has declined.
            •  High tariffs make it difficult for South African manufactured goods to
               enter BRICS markets.
            (Any other relevant response.)                                   (any 2 x 2)   (4)

                                              19

### Page 20

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                        10792/23

3.6 [Interpretation, evaluation, and synthesis from relevant sources – L3]

     Candidates could include the following aspects in their response:

     •   BRICS provided socio economic recovery from the pandemic. (Source 3A)
     •   BRICS built resilient and self-sufficient supply chains for South African
         products. (Source 3A)
     •   The Ukraine crisis has led to high food and fuel prices and a sharp increase
         in inflation. (Source 3A)
     •   The South African economy benefits from increased trade with other BRICS
         countries which has impacted positively on the poor. (Source 3B)
     •   BRICS boosts investment for infrastructure development. (Source 3B)
     •   Imports and exports between member countries improves economic growth.
         (Source 3B)
     •   BRICS provides opportunities in terms of food security, sustainable
         development and technological co-operation. (Own knowledge)
     •   Creates a business-friendly environment for investment in South Africa.
         (Source 3B)
     •   The New Development Bank opens doors to access funds for sustainable
         infrastructural development. (Source 3C)

     •  The Development Bank provides funds/loans to alleviate poverty
        (Source 3C and own knowledge)
     • BRICS may erode South Africa’s domestic economy (Source 3D)
     • BRICS countries target Africa’s resources thereby threatening SA’s
        economy
     • BRICS are exporting manufactured goods to Africa which is SA’s ideal
        market (Source 3D)
     • Interest rates that SA must pay for loans from the bank are high (Own
        knowledge)
     • High tariffs make it difficult for South African goods to enter BRICS markets
        (Own knowledge)
     (Any other relevant response.)

                                             20

### Page 21

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                10792/23

Use the following rubric to allocate marks:

                •   Uses evidence in an elementary manner, e.g. shows
                    little understanding of how South Africa’s
                    membership of BRICS affected the South African          MARKS
    LEVEL 1
                    economy.                                                 0–2
                •   Uses evidence partially or cannot write a paragraph
                    on the topic.
                •   Evidence is mostly relevant and relates to a great
                    extent to the topic, e.g. shows some understanding on
                    how South Africa’s membership of BRICS affected         MARKS
    LEVEL 2
                    the South African economy.                               3–4
                •   Uses evidence in a very basic manner to write a
                    paragraph.
                •   Uses relevant evidence, e.g. demonstrates a thorough
                    understanding on how South Africa’s membership
                                                                            MARKS
    LEVEL 3         of BRICS affected the South African economy.
                                                                             5–8
                •   Uses evidence very effectively in an organised
                    paragraph that shows an understanding of the topic.
                                                                                     (8)
                                                                                    [50]

                                              21

### Page 22

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                          10792/23

SECTION B: ESSAY QUESTIONS

QUESTION 4:      CIVIL RESISTANCE, 1970s TO 1980s: SOUTH AFRICA: THE
                 CRISIS OF APARTHEID IN THE 1980s

[Plan and construct an original argument based on relevant evidence using analytical
and interpretative skills.]

SYNOPSIS

Candidates need to critically discuss how Steve Biko and the philosophy of Black
Consciousness empowered black people in South Africa to stand up against
apartheid in the 1970s.

MAIN ASPECTS

Candidates should include the following aspects in their essays:

Introduction: Candidates need to critically discuss how Steve Biko and the
philosophy of Black Consciousness empowered black people in South Africa to stand
up against apartheid in the 1970s. They should also indicate how they will support
their line of argument.

ELABORATION

     •   Background on the political vacuum created by ANC and PAC leadership
         being banned and being in exile
     •   Empowerment of blacks for self-realisation
     •   To accept themselves/have self-confidence/self-reliance/sense of identity
     •   Empowered blacks to reject the spirit of self-pity; inferiority complex; self-
         alienation and domination by external forces.

Political empowerment

     •   Black students started to organise themselves to resist white domination by
         breaking away from NUSAS and forming SASO (1968).
     •   Black students adopted the philosophy of Black Consciousness (Role of
         Biko/SASO).
     •   SASO was for university students and SASM for schools.
     •   BC led to the formation of the Black Peoples Convention (BPC) in 1972
         which involved students, churches, communities and trade unions.
     •   Unions aligned to the BC philosophy included the Black Parents’
         Association and the Black Allied Workers Union (BAWU).
     •   The South African Students Movement formed in 1972 which exposed
         Blacks to the ideals of BC.
     •   BCM and SASO organised FRELIMO Rallies (1974).
     •   The arrests of BC leaders heightened political activism.

                                               22

### Page 23

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
                                                                                   10792/23

Student empowerment

    •   The Bantu Education Department introduced Afrikaans as a medium of
        instruction in schools (1975).
    •   SASO and SASM influenced the formation of the Soweto Students
        Representative Council (SSRC).
    •   Both black teachers and students rejected Afrikaans – as the language of the
        oppressor.
    •   Some teachers and learners were already exposed to the ideas of Biko and
        the BC philosophy through SASO student teachers from universities.
    •   The departmental circular on Afrikaans (50/50) was the trigger for the Soweto
        uprising.
    •   On 16 June 1976 students protested peacefully against the implementation of
        the circular.
    •   Police responded to the student protests (Hector Petersen, a 13-year-old boy
        was one of the first casualties of this uprising).

Empowerment through community programmes

    •   Biko’s banishment (government response) to King Williams Town led to a
        diverted focus on community programmes. Dr Mamphela Ramphele’s
        banishment
    •   The BC promoted independence from whites by promoting Black Community
        Programmes to support blacks without white assistance. (Zanempilo Health
        Clinic/Ginsburg Educational Trust/Zimele Trust Fund/Solempilo Community
        Health Centre /Njwaqa Leatherworks, Mhloti Black Theatre /Ithuseng
        Community Health Programme and Winter School Projects)

Empowerment through labour

    •   Mobilised workers to form trade unions.
    •   BC led to the formation of the Black Allied Workers Union (BAWU) – worker’s
        strikes in Durban in 1973).

Empowerment through media

    •  Role of media that was sympathetic to the BC philosophy, e.g. The World
       newspaper
    • Government banned all media that promoted/aligned with BCM
    (Any other relevant response.)

Government response •       All 17 BC aligned organisations were banned
                    •       Biko killed in 1977 while in police custody
                    •       Government introduced more repressive laws

Conclusion: Candidates should sum up their argument with a relevant conclusion.         [50]

                                            23

Text truncated here. Open the document page to read the rest.

## Related documents

- [HISTORY P2 GR12 QP JUNE 2023 English](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-gr12-qp-june-2023-english/8444f2f9-4c71-46a1-972c-8b0f923e9927) — History · QP · 2023 · Eng
- [HISTORY P2 GR12 ADDENDUM SEPT 2023 English](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-gr12-addendum-sept-2023-english/7ebc175c-3acc-4751-b898-2a770db59777) — History · Addendum · 2023 · Eng
- [History P2 (SG) (English) June 2014 Possible Answer](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-sg-english-june-2014-possible-answer/b6322558-818f-4c67-b34d-309f2eecce06) — History · Memo · 2014 · Eng
- [HISTORY P2 GR12 ADDENDUM SEPT 2022 English](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-gr12-addendum-sept-2022-english/e5d10556-c154-433f-8fd2-98646e28994c) — History · Addendum · 2022 · Eng
- [Gr12 History P2 (English) SEP 2022 Question Paper](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/gr12-history-p2-english-sep-2022-question-paper/4ecf07fc-c5be-4181-868c-5e74b2676b7a) — History · QP · 2022 · Eng
- [History P2 Add June 2021 English](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-add-june-2021-english/4b70309f-2760-4254-8778-f8fe061ab26d) — History · QP · 2021 · Eng

## More from Grade 12 History

- [Workguide - Case Study Strategies](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/workguide-case-study-strategies/0b4c8d70-c563-4cfe-93e0-dad57e8fbeb3) — Guide
- [Gr 12 History P1 (English) 2024 Question Paper X05](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/gr-12-history-p1-english-2024-question-paper-x05/7b41ec15-3856-4a67-a9db-cedd424e51c5) — QP · 2024 · Eng
- [History P1 Nov 2024 Addendum Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p1-nov-2024-addendum-eng/df93fb24-73e0-435a-8d91-bce9f456ba2c) — Addendum · 2024 · Eng
- [History P2 Nov 2023 Addendum Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-nov-2023-addendum-eng/115e775e-ffa7-4295-a812-c3f541a7b7bb) — Addendum · 2023 · Eng
- [History P2 Nov 2023 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-nov-2023-afr/1406231f-0475-4c85-8862-7a120bee5f2e) — QP · 2023 · Afr
- [HISTORY P1 GR12 ADDEN SEPT 2022 English](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p1-gr12-adden-sept-2022-english/f45ccdc0-4084-4c3d-b1b8-1a30ab014473) — Addendum · 2022 · Eng

## Collection

- [Grade 12 past papers](https://www.hlayiso.com/grade-12/past-papers)

---

Hlayiso: free CAPS and IEB past papers, memos, notes and study guides for South African learners. When citing, link the page URL above, not a PDF or /api/ URL.
