# History Grade 12 Paper 2 NSC November 2023 Memo (English)

> Grade 12 History Paper 2 memorandum from the NSC November Exam 2023 (English), 30 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.

- Page: https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-nov-2023-mg-eng/05436c91-0c26-41fb-8a45-7fa2f236b1cd
- Updated: 2026-10-29
- Subject: History
- Grade: Grade 12
- Document type: Memorandum
- Year: 2023
- Exam period: NSC November Exam
- Paper: 2
- Curriculum: CAPS
- Pages: 30

Breadcrumbs: [Home](https://www.hlayiso.com/) › [Library](https://www.hlayiso.com/library) › [Grade 12](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12) › [History](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12/history) › [History Grade 12 Paper 2 NSC November 2023 Memo (English)](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-nov-2023-mg-eng/05436c91-0c26-41fb-8a45-7fa2f236b1cd)

## About this document

History · Grade 12 · NSC November Exam · 2023. Memorandum. Read online or download the PDF.

Read it free online on the page above; download the PDF from there.

## Document text

Text extracted from the PDF. Layout, diagrams and tables may not survive extraction.

### Page 1

Downloaded from hlayiso.com

                                  NATIONAL
                             SENIOR CERTIFICATE

                                    EXEMPLAR

                                     GRADE 12

                                     HISTORY P2

                                  NOVEMBER 2023

                              MARKING GUIDELINES

MARKS: 150

                     These marking guidelines consist of 30 pages.

Copyright reserved                                                   Please turn over

### Page 2

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                     2                          DBE/November 2023
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

1.     SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS

1.1    The following cognitive levels were used to develop source-based questions:

 Cognitive                                                                  Weighting of
                                    Historical skills
  Levels                                                                     questions
                    Extract evidence from sources
                    Selection and organisation of relevant information         30%
 Level 1
                     from sources                                               (15)
                    Define historical concepts/terms in own words
                    Interpretation of evidence from sources
                    Explain information gathered from sources                  40%
 Level 2
                    Analyse evidence from sources                              (20)
                    Define of historical concepts in context
                    Interpret and evaluate evidence from sources
                    Engage with sources to determine its usefulness,
                     reliability, bias and limitations                          30%
 Level 3
                    Compare and contrast interpretations and                   (15)
                     perspectives presented in sources and draw
                     independent conclusions

1.2    The information below indicates how source-based questions are
       assessed:
         In the marking of source-based questions, credit needs to be given to any
          other valid and relevant viewpoints, arguments, evidence or examples.
         In the allocation of marks, emphasis should be placed on how the
          requirements of the question have been addressed.
         In the marking guideline, the requirements of the question (skills that need to
          be addressed) as well as the level of the question are indicated in italics.
         When assessing open-ended source-based questions, learners should be
          credited for any other relevant answers.
         Learners are expected to take a stance when answering 'to what extent'
          questions in order for any marks to be awarded.

1.3    Assessment procedures for source-based questions
        Use a tick () for each correct answer
        Pay attention to the mark scheme e.g. (2 x 2) which translates to two reasons
         and is given two marks each (); (1 x 2) which translates to one reason
         and is given two marks ()
        If a question carries 4 marks then indicate by placing 4 ticks ()

       Paragraph question
       Paragraphs are to be assessed globally (holistically). Both the content and
       structure of the paragraph must be taken into account when awarding a mark. The
       following steps must be used when assessing a response to a paragraph question:
        Read the paragraph and place a bullet (•) at each point within the text where
            the candidate has used relevant evidence to address the question.
        Re-read the paragraph to evaluate the extent to which the candidate has been
            able to use relevant evidence to write a paragraph.

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 3

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                       3                           DBE/November 2023
                                      NSC – Marking Guidelines

            At the end of the paragraph indicate the ticks (√) that the candidate has been
             awarded for the paragraph; as well as the level (1,2, or 3) as indicated in the
             holistic rubric and a brief comment e.g.
          ___________ •___________________________________________________
          _________________ • ____________________________ • _________________
                                                                               Level 2 √√√√
          COMMENT
          Used mostly relevant evidence to write a basic paragraph.

         Count all the ticks for the source-based question and then write the mark on the
          right hand bottom margin e.g. 32
                                            50
         Ensure that the total mark is transferred accurately to the front/back cover of the
          answer script.

2.        ESSAY QUESTIONS

2.1       The essay questions require candidates to:
         Be able to structure their argument in a logical and coherent manner. They need to
          select, organise and connect the relevant information so that they are able to
          present a reasonable sequence of facts or an effective argument to answer the
          question posed. It is essential that an essay has an introduction, a coherent and
          balanced body of evidence and a conclusion.
2.2       Marking of essay questions
         Candidates may have any other relevant introduction and/or conclusion than those
          included in a specific essay marking guideline for a specific essay.

2.3       Global assessment of the essay
          The essay will be assessed holistically (globally). This approach requires the
          teacher to assess the essay as a whole, rather than assessing the main points of
          the essay separately. This approach encourages the learner to write an original
          argument by using relevant evidence to support the line of argument. The learner
          will not be required to simply regurgitate content (facts) in order to achieve a level
          7 (high mark). This approach discourages learners from preparing essays and
          reproducing them without taking the specific requirements of the question into
          account. Holistic marking of the essay credits learners' opinions that are supported
          by evidence. Holistic assessment, unlike content-based marking, does not penalise
          language inadequacies as the emphasis is on the following:

         The learner's interpretation of the question
         The appropriate selection of factual evidence (relevant content selection)
         The construction of an argument (planned, structured and has an independent line
          of argument)

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 4

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                     4                         DBE/November 2023
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

2.4    Assessment procedures of the essay

       2.4.1 Keep the synopsis in mind when assessing the essay.

       2.4.2 During the reading of the essay, ticks need to be awarded for a relevant
             introduction (which is indicated by a bullet in the marking guideline), the
             main aspects/body of the essay that sustains/defends the line of argument
             (which is indicated by bullets in the marking guideline) and a relevant
             conclusion (which is indicated by a bullet in the marking guideline).
             For example in an essay where there are five (5) main points there could be
             about seven (7) ticks.

       2.4.3 Keep the PEEL structure in mind when assessing an essay.

                P    Point: The candidate introduces the essay by taking a line of
                     argument/making a major point.
                     Each paragraph should include a point that sustains the major point
                     (line of argument) that was made in the introduction.
                E    Explanation: The candidate should explain in more detail what the
                     main point is about and how it relates to the question posed (line of
                     argument).
                E    Example: The candidates should answer the question by selecting
                     content that is relevant to the line of argument. Relevant examples
                     should be given to sustain the line of argument.
                L    Link: Candidates should ensure that the line of argument is sustained
                     throughout the essay and is written coherently.

       2.4.4 The following symbols MUST be used when assessing an essay:

               • Introduction, main aspects and conclusion not properly contextualised

                                                  ^
               • Wrong statement                  _________________
               • Irrelevant statement             |
                                                  |
                                                  |
               • Repetition                       R
               • Analysis                         A√
               • Interpretation                   I√
               • Line of Argument                 LOA

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 5

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                     5                         DBE/November 2023
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

2.5    The matrix

       2.5.1 Use of the matrix in the marking of essays

       In the marking of essays, the criteria as provided in the matrix should be used.
       When assessing the essay note both the content and presentation. At the point of
       intersection of the content and presentation based on the seven competency
       levels, a mark should be awarded.

        (a)      The first reading of essays will be to determine to what extent the main
                 aspects have been covered and to allocate the content level (on the
                 matrix).
                                                          C        LEVEL 4

        (b)      The second reading of essays will relate to the level (on the matrix) of
                 presentation.

                                                           C       LEVEL 4
                                                           P       LEVEL 3

        (c)      Allocate an overall mark with the use of the matrix.

                                                           C      LEVEL 4
                                                           P      LEVEL 3
                                                                               }26–27
                 COMMENT
                 Some omissions in content coverage.
                 Attempts to sustain a line of argument.

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 6

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                                            6                                                DBE/November 2023
                                                           NSC – Marking Guidelines

MARKING MATRIX FOR ESSAY: TOTAL: 50
                           LEVEL 7             LEVEL 6             LEVEL 5             LEVEL 4            LEVEL 3             LEVEL 2             LEVEL 1*
PRESENTATION             Very well           Very well           Well planned and    Planned and        Shows some          Attempts to         Little or no
                         planned and         planned and         structured essay.   constructed an     evidence of a       structure an        attempt to
                         structured essay.   structured essay.   Attempts to         argument.          planned and         answer.             structure the
                         Good synthesis      Developed a         develop a clear     Evidence used to   constructed         Largely             essay.
                         of information.     relevant line of    argument.           some extent to     argument.           descriptive or
                         Developed an        argument.           Conclusion          support the line   Attempts to         some attempt at
                         original, well      Evidence used to    drawn from the      of argument.       sustain a line of   developing a line
                         balanced and        defend the          evidence to         Conclusions        argument.           of argument. No
CONTENT                  independent line    argument.           support the line    reached based      Conclusions not     attempt to draw a
                         of argument with    Attempts to draw    of argument.        on evidence.       clearly supported   conclusion.
                         the use of          an independent                                             by evidence.
                         evidence and        conclusion from
                         sustained and       the evidence to
                         defended the        support the line
                         argument            of argument.
                         throughout.
                         Independent
                         conclusion is
                         drawn from
                         evidence to
                         support the line
                         of argument.

LEVEL 7
Question has been
fully answered.
Content selection
                            47–50               43–46
fully relevant to line
of argument.
LEVEL 6
Question has been
answered.
Content selection           43–46               40–42               38–39
relevant to a line of
argument.
LEVEL 5
Question answered
to a great extent.
Content adequately          38–39               36–37               34–35               30–33              28–29
covered and
relevant.
LEVEL 4
Question
recognisable in
answer.                                                             30–33               28–29              26–27
Some omissions or
irrelevant content
selection.
LEVEL 3
Content selection
does relate to the
question, but does
not answer it, or
does not always                                                                         26–27              24–25               20–23
relate to the
question.
Omissions in
coverage.
LEVEL 2
Question
inadequately                                                                                               20–23               18–19               14–17
addressed. Sparse
content.

LEVEL 1    *
Question
inadequately                                                                                                                   14–17                0–13
addressed or not at
all. Inadequate or
irrelevant content.

* Guidelines for allocating a mark for Level 1:
            Question not addressed at all/totally irrelevant content; no attempt to structure the essay              =0
            Content selection includes basic and generally irrelevant information; no attempt to structure the essay = 1–6
            Question inadequately addressed and vague; little attempt to structure the essay                         = 7–13

Copyright reserved                                                                                                           Please turn over

### Page 7

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                      7                           DBE/November 2023
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

SECTION A: SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS
QUESTION 1:          HOW DID THE CONGRESS OF SOUTH AFRICAN TRADE UNIONS
                     (COSATU) RESPOND TO THE APARTHEID GOVERNMENT'S
                     LABOUR REFORMS IN THE 1980s?
1.1          1.1.1    [Extraction of evidence from Source 1A - L1]
                       '… if the government carries out its threat to repatriate migrant
                           workers'
                       'and have pledged to organise workers in the homelands in
                           defiance of any restrictions on unions in these regions'
                                                                                 (any 1 x 1)       (1)

             1.1.2    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1A – L2]
                       To put pressure on the South African government to
                           change/dismantle its apartheid policy
                       To isolate South Africa from the rest of the world/cutting it off
                           from foreign economic support by imposing sanctions -
                           forcing it to capitulate
                       COSATU was aligned to the ANC which used the
                           disinvestment tactic to intensify the fight against apartheid
                       To force the apartheid government to change its policy which
                           in turn would lead to better working conditions for workers
                       Any other relevant response                              (any 1 x 2)       (2)
             1.1.3    [Definition of term from Source 1A – L1]
                       Economic policy placing means of production under state
                          control
                       Economic policy limiting private ownership and promoting
                          ownership by the state in all means of production
                       Any other relevant response                         (any 1 x 2)            (2)

             1.1.4    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1A – L2]
                       COSATU was not only involved with labour issues but also
                           with political matters
                       COSATU supported the objectives of the liberation struggle -
                           fighting for the right to vote for all South Africans/democratic
                           rights
                       All South Africans should exercise their right to vote within a
                           united South Africa
                       Any other relevant response                              (any 2 x 2)       (4)

Copyright reserved                                                              Please turn over

### Page 8

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                     8                        DBE/November 2023
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

1.2          1.2.1    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1B - L2]
                       To mobilise workers to support the struggle against the Labour
                           Relations Amendment Bill/Act
                       To galvanise/show support and solidarity from broader sectors
                           of society against the Labour Relations Amendment Bill/Act
                       To highlight the struggle against the restrictions that the
                           Labour Relations Amendment Bill/Act will impose on workers
                           and their unions
                       To notify its (COSATU) members of the planned special
                           congress to be held in Johannesburg on 14 – 15 May 1988
                       Any other relevant response                         (any 2 x 2)        (4)
             1.2.2    [Extraction of evidence from Source 1B – L1]
                       The COSATU logo/name appears on the poster
                       ‘FORWARD WITH COSATU’
                       ‘AN INJURY TO ONE IS AN INJURY TO ALL’
                       ‘Special Congress JOHANNESBURG MAY 14 -15 1988’
                       ‘workers’
                       ‘NO! to the Labour Bill’
                       ‘NO! to restrictions’
                       ‘ORGANISE!’
                       ‘RESIST!’
                       ‘factories’                                (any 1 x 2)                 (2)

             1.2.3    [Determining limitations of Source 1B – L3]
                      The source is LIMITED because:
                       It was designed by a COSATU media worker (Patrick
                          Cockayne) who was fiercely opposed to the government and
                          its legislations
                       It caters only for the perspective of COSATU/one-sided
                          perspective
                       It against the government's introduction of the Labour
                          Relations Amendment Act (LRA) to restrict trade unions
                       It used emotive language, NO! NO! to influence mobilisation
                          against the legislation of the LRA
                       Any other relevant response                         (any 2 x 2)        (4)

1.3          1.3.1    [Extraction of evidence from Source 1C – L1]
                       '… they will have to obtain the Law and Order Minister's
                           permission to conduct any other activities'  (1 x 2)                (2)

             1.3.2    [Extraction of evidence from Source 1C –L1]
                        'UDF'
                        'COSATU’                                               (2 x 1)        (2)

Copyright reserved                                                          Please turn over

### Page 9

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                      9                            DBE/November 2023
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

             1.3.3    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1C – L2]
                       The apartheid government feared that ANC and COSATU
                           leaders would mobilise people and form a strong opposition
                           against the government
                       They saw both the ANC and COSATU as puppets of the
                           Soviet Union
                       The ANC and other political prisoners were regarded as a
                           threat to the apartheid government
                       The struggle for liberation would be expedited if the ANC was
                           unbanned
                       Any other relevant response                          (any 1 x 2)             (2)
             1.3.4    [Explanation of concept from Source 1C – L2]
                       Campaigns organised by COSATU and aligned organisations
                          for economic punitive measures (trade boycotts) to be
                          implemented to isolate South Africa from the world, forcing it
                          to change its apartheid policy
                       Formal/official blocking of economic, cultural, political relations
                          between foreign countries and the apartheid government of
                          SA to force it to end apartheid
                       Any other relevant response                            (any 1 x 2)           (2)

1.4          1.4.1    [Extraction of evidence in Source 1D – L1]
                       'The government's February 24 restrictions (which legally
                           limited COSATU to a narrow range of factory floor trade
                           unionism …’/‘… effectively banned 17 other organisations …'
                       'the Labour Relations Amendment Act' (‘limit workers' right
                          to strike’/‘open trade unions to civil action for losses incurred
                          (experienced)/by their members' actions’/‘outlaw (ban)
                          solidarity action in industrial disputes’                (any 2 x 1)       (2)

             1.4.2    [Extraction of evidence from Source 1D - L1]
                        '… limit workers' right to strike …'
                        '… open trade unions to civil action for losses incurred by their
                           members' actions …'
                        '… outlaw solidarity action in industrial disputes'
                        'restore the balance in industrial relations in favour of the
                           employer'                                           (any 1 x 3)           (3)

             1.4.3    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1D – L2]
                        To curb COSATU from challenging the state politically at a
                            national level
                        COSATU could not mobilise its workers at national level
                            (politically) because it focussed on workers rights at factory
                            floor level
                        The rights of the employers were protected
                        Any other relevant response                              (any 1 x 2)        (2)

Copyright reserved                                                                Please turn over

### Page 10

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                      10                          DBE/November 2023
                                      NSC – Marking Guidelines

             1.4.4     [Interpretation of evidence from Source 1D – L2]
                         COSATU would not accept government restrictions and the
                            LRA
                         COSATU ban it/prepared to suffer/fight for workers rights
                         COSATU would mobilise workers for mass would stand up and
                            challenge attempts by the government to
                         demonstrations against their employers and government
                         Any other relevant response                         (any 2 x 2)          (4)

1.5          [Comparison of evidence in Sources 1B and 1D – L3]
              Source 1B is a poster depicting COSATU's call to reject the LRA and
                restrictions and Source 1D highlights COSATU's formal reaction against
                the LRA and restrictions - adopted at its special congress on 14 May
                1988
              Source 1B makes a notification of the special congress that was to be
                held from 14 – 15 May 1988 and Source 1D highlights the resolutions
                that were taken against the dual threat of the bill and restrictions during
                the special congress
              Both sources highlight that the protest actions against the Bill and
                restrictions were adopted during COSATU’s special congress on 14 May
                1988
              Both sources highlight the fact that workers should resist the Bill and
                restrictions/Both sources indicate that COSATU was forceful in their
                resistance
              Both sources highlight the democratic rights of workers
              Both sources indicate COSATU’s commitment to resist the LRA
              Any other relevant response                                       (any 2 x 2)       (4)

Copyright reserved                                                              Please turn over

### Page 11

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                      11                          DBE/November 2023
                                      NSC – Marking Guidelines

1.6          [Interpretation, evaluation and synthesis from relevant sources – L3]

             Candidates could include the following aspects in their response:

                COSATU launched on 5 December 1985 as a labour movement to
                 challenge apartheid labour reforms (Source 1A)
                COSATU President Elijah Barayi committed it to fill the political gap
                 created by the banning of the ANC and other political organisations
                 (Source 1A)
                COSATU would use its huge membership from NUM and FOSATU to
                 build a formidable force of trade unionism against the apartheid
                 government (Source 1A)
                COSATU called for a national minimum wage and other advantages for
                 workers (Source 1A)
                COSATU as a trade union federation posed a threat to the apartheid
                 government and foreign investors (own knowledge)
                COSATU used posters to communicate and conscientise its members,
                 workers and the general public (Source 1B and own knowledge)
                COSATU called on workers to organise and resist the Bill and restrictions
                 (Source 1B)
                COSATU began to fill the organisational vacuum created by the
                 detention of most of the UDF's national and regional leaders (Source 1C)
                Called on the international community to impose sanctions and
                 disinvestment (Source 1C and own knowledge)
                COSATU organised a Special Congress to react to the threat posed by
                 the government's restrictions (Source 1D)
                COSATU committed itself to never give in to restrictions by the employer
                 or government (Source 1D)
                COSATU successfully organised various campaigns and strikes to
                 pressurise the apartheid government (own knowledge)
                Any other relevant response

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 12

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                  12                      DBE/November 2023
                                  NSC – Marking Guidelines

       Use the following rubric to allocate marks:

                 Uses evidence in an elementary manner e.g. shows no
                  or little understanding of how COSATU responded to
                  the apartheid government's labour reforms in the
                                                                           MARKS 0 – 2
LEVEL 1           1980s.
                 Uses evidence partially or cannot write a paragraph.
                 Evidence is mostly relevant and relates largely on the
                  topic e.g. shows some understanding of how
                  COSATU responded to the apartheid government's
                  labour reforms in the 1980s.                             MARKS 3 - 5
LEVEL 2
                 Uses evidence in a very basic manner to write a
                  paragraph.
                 Uses relevant evidence e.g. demonstrates a thorough
                  understanding of how COSATU responded to the
                  apartheid government's labour reforms in the 1980s.
LEVEL 3                                                                    MARKS 6 - 8
                 Uses evidence very effectively in an organised paragraph
                  that shows an understanding of the topic.

                                                                                           (8)
                                                                                           [50]

Copyright reserved                                                      Please turn over

### Page 13

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                     13                            DBE/November 2023
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 2:          HOW DID THE TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION
                     (TRC) EXPOSE LEADERS OF THE APARTHEID GOVERNMENT
                     FOR GROSS VIOLATIONS OF HUMAN RIGHTS COMMITTED
                     BETWEEN 1960 AND 1994?

2.1          2.1.1    [Extraction of evidence from Source 2A – L1]
                       '… in order to avoid responsibility'                          (1 x 2)       (2)

             2.1.2    [Definition of term from Source 2A – L1]
                       Process of exempting someone who committed a politically
                          motivated crime from prosecution
                       Granting of official pardon or forgiveness to a perpetrator that
                          would give full disclosure to political atrocities committed in the
                          past
                       Any other relevant response                              (any 1 x 2)        (2)

             2.1.3    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2A – L2]
                       Most injustices committed in the past by the apartheid
                           government were against blacks who demanded explanations
                           to find closure
                       The amnesty process led to those who tortured and killed
                           black activists to be scot free
                       The high command of the security forces who issued
                           instructions to kill activists was not held accountable
                       Families of victims did not always get the whole truth of what
                           happened to their loved ones
                       They wanted to hear from perpetrators themselves
                       Any other relevant response                                (any 1 x 2)      (2)

             2.1.4    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2A – L2]
                        That the TRC had to reveal the truth about atrocities
                           committed in the past to forge reconciliation amongst South
                           Africans
                        The TRC should create a platform where victims and
                           perpetrators could tell their stories to help those affected get
                           closure and be willing to reconcile
                        All South Africans should face the past to achieve healing and
                           reconciliation
                        Any other relevant response                            (any 2 x 2)         (4)

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 14

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                     14                            DBE/November 2023
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

             2.1.5    [Extraction of evidence from Source 2A – L1]

                      (a)
                       ‘… he was of the opinion that a process was required in order
                            to enable South Africans to come to terms with the conflict
                            of the past in a spirit of reconciliation and to get on with the
                            future without recriminations (accusations)’
                         '… favoured a general amnesty for perpetrators of politically
                            inspired violence'                                    (any 1 x 1)       (1)

                      (b)
                       'A general amnesty went very much against ANC thinking'
                                                                             (1 x 1)                (1)

2            2.2.1    [Extraction of evidence from Source 2B – L1]
                       '… Botha's government had adopted a policy of killing its
                           opponents'
                       ‘torture’
                       ‘abduction’
                       ‘arson’
                       ‘sabotage'
                       '… used terminology like eliminate, take out and wipe out …’
                                                                          (any 3 x 1)               (3)

             2.2.2    [Explanation of a term from Source 2B – L2]
                       Network of underground state sponsored security force
                          members, right wing groups and those opposed to the ANC
                          that were used to block or derail the ANC take over
                       Any other relevant response                           (1 x 2)               (2)

             2.2.3    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2B - L2]
                       De Klerk wanted to hide the truth about how the NP supported
                           violence
                       The report was an indictment/accusation on the NP
                           government and its security agents
                       De Klerk as head of state was not willing to investigate
                           atrocities committed by the third force because they were
                           neutralising the ANC
                       De Klerk allowed third force activities to be carried out under
                           his watch because they supported the National Party (NP)
                           government
                       De Klerk did not want to risk further dissension within his party
                       Any other relevant response                           (any 2 x 2)           (4)

             2.2.4    [Extraction of evidence from Source 2B – L1]
                        Commissioner of Police/Van der Merwe                         (1 x 1)       (1)

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 15

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                     15                          DBE/November 2023
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

2.3          2.3.1     [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2C - L2]
                        Only member of the Apartheid government that would be held
                            accountable for atrocities committed applied for amnesty
                        Adriaan Vlok was the Minister of Police in the apartheid
                            government who was held responsible for human rights
                            violations
                        Only Adriaan Vlok appeared before the Amnesty Committee
                        Any other relevant response                            (any 1 x 2)       (2)

             2.3.2     [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2C - L2]
                        Tutu implied that there were many other NP leaders who
                            evaded/escaped the Amnesty process
                        Tutu implied that many leaders got away because of their
                            unwillingness to cooperate with the TRC process
                        Many leaders were guilty of political crimes committed but
                            were not brought to book
                        Tutu as the chairperson of the TRC did not have the power to
                            force them to appear before the Amnesty Committee
                        Some political leaders refused to appear before the TRC
                        Any other relevant response                         (any 2 x 2)          (4)

2.4          2.4.1    [Extraction of evidence from Source 2D – L1]
                       '… turning its back on the foot soldiers …'                 (1 x 2)       (2)

             2.4.2    [Extraction of evidence from Source 2D – L1]
                        '… had already met on three occasions …'
                        '… were planning the fourth meeting to prepare themselves for
                           what must felt like the coming onslaught of the Truth and
                           Reconciliation Commission (TRC) …'
                        ‘… each individual goes before the commission and tells their
                           story alone’                                    (any 1 x 2)            (2)

             2.4.3    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 2D - L2]
                        The foot soldiers were to appear before the TRC process on
                           their own/not included in the meeting of ex- ministers, generals
                           and the State Security Council
                        The government misled the foot soldiers who were employed
                           by them to commit political crimes
                        The foot soldiers were not protected/defended and felt
                           betrayed by the government they served when they appeared
                           before the TRC
                        Any other relevant response                            (any 1 x 2)       (2)

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 16

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                       16                          DBE/November 2023
                                       NSC – Marking Guidelines

             2.4.4      [Ascertain the reliability of Source 2D – L3]
                        The source is RELIABLE because:
                         The author, Paul Erasmus was an eyewitness who served in
                            the Security Branch of the South African Police
                         It is taken from Paul Erasmus's confessions as contained in his
                            biography
                         Paul Erasmus had inside information of the activities of the
                            National Party (NP)
                         He gave an account of how foot soldiers felt about being left
                            on their own by the National Party leadership
                         The source can be corroborated by Source 2B and Source 2C
                         Any other relevant response                        (any 2 x 2)             (4)

2.5          [Comparison of evidence from Sources 2C and 2D – L3]
              In Source 2C Tutu refers to the apartheid leaders who got away from
                (evaded) the TRC and in Source 2D the state security council met to plan
                their response against the coming onslaught of the TRC
              In Source 2C the apartheid leaders seemed defiant to appear as
                individuals to the Amnesty process and in Source 2D they were making
                arrangements for a blanket amnesty
              Both sources allude to the fact that the National Party leaders evaded the
                TRC process
              Source 2C shows small fish (foot soldiers) who appeared before the TRC's
                Amnesty process and Source 2D refers to the National Party having turned
                its back on its foot soldiers as if they acted on their own accord
              Any other relevant response                                         (any 2 x 2)       (4)

Copyright reserved                                                                Please turn over

### Page 17

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                     17                        DBE/November 2023
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

2.6          Interpretation, evaluation and synthesis of evidence from relevant sources -
             L3]

             Candidates could include the following aspects in their response:
              The Promotion of National Unity and Reconciliation Act of 1995 laid the
                basis for the formation of the TRC encouraging perpetrators to disclose
                the truth about human rights violations (Source 2A)
              The TRC provided the NP an opportunity to disclose human rights
                violations committed during the apartheid era (Source 2A)
              The TRC provided a platform for victims and perpetrators to tell their
                stories (own knowledge)
              TRC verdict declared that Botha's government adopted a policy of killing
                opponents (realm of criminal misconduct) and was responsible for torture,
                abduction, arson and sabotage in the 1970s (Source 2B)
              FW de Klerk was held accountable for criminal misconduct/ third force by
                the TRC (Source 2B)
              Van der Merwe, Commissioner of Police, was held accountable for the
                bombing of anti-apartheid organisations offices - Khotso House
                (Source 2B)
              Adriaan Vlok, Minister of Police was the only big fish caught by the TRC
                because he was a minister in the apartheid government (Source 2C)
              The apartheid government foot soldiers admitted their role in the
                atrocities and applied for amnesty (Source 2D)
              The apartheid leaders met to corroborate their story and refused to
                appear before the TRC (Source 2D)
              The foot soldiers felt betrayed by the apartheid leaders as they had to
                take accountability for the violations of human rights (Source 2D)
              Any other relevant response

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 18

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                  18                        DBE/November 2023
                                  NSC – Marking Guidelines

Use the following rubric to allocate marks:

                 Uses evidence in an elementary manner e.g. shows no
                  or little understanding of how the Truth and
                  Reconciliation Commission (TRC) exposed leaders of
   LEVEL 1                                                                    MARKS 0 – 2
                  the apartheid government for gross violations of
                  human rights committed between 1960 and 1994.
                 Uses evidence partially or cannot write a paragraph.
                 Evidence is mostly relevant and relates to a great extent
                  on the topic e.g. shows some understanding of how
                  the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC)
                  exposed leaders of the apartheid government for
   LEVEL 2                                                                    MARKS 3 – 5
                  gross violations of human rights committed between
                  1960 and 1994.
                 Uses evidence in a very basic manner to write a
                  paragraph.
                 Uses relevant evidence e.g. demonstrates a thorough
                  understanding of how the Truth and Reconciliation
                  Commission (TRC) exposed leaders of the apartheid
   LEVEL 3        government for gross violations of human rights             MARKS 6 – 8
                  committed between 1960 and 1994.
                 Uses evidence very effectively in an organised paragraph
                  that shows an understanding of the topic.

                                                                                             (8)
                                                                                             [50]

Copyright reserved                                                        Please turn over

### Page 19

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                    19                          DBE/November 2023
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 3:          HOW     DID   POWERFUL     INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL
                     INSTITUTIONS, NAMELY THE INTERNATIONAL MONETARY
                     FUND (IMF) AND WORLD BANK, SHAPE THE GLOBALISED
                     ECONOMIES SINCE THE 1980s?

3.1          3.1.1    [Definition of a term from Source 3A - L1]
                       Economies that have access to resources from all countries
                          across the world
                       Economies that reap benefits from political and economic
                          resources that are accessible across the world
                       Increasing inter-dependence as a result of cross border trade
                       Economies influenced globally where resources of developing
                          countries are exploited
                       Any other relevant response                         (any 1 x 2)          (2)

             3.1.2    [Extraction of evidence from Source 3A – L1]
                       ‘presents Africa and black people as marginal’ (globalising
                          economies seek resources from every corner of the world, and
                          globalised economies reap considerable benefits from their
                          economics and political dominance)
                       'the devastation of the environment'
                       'climate change'
                       'depletion of natural and mineral resources'
                       'labour exploitation'                                 (any 4 x 1)        (4)

             3.1.3    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3A – L2]
                      Powerful nations and financial institutions:
                       designed Structural Adjustment Programmes that favoured
                           themselves
                       designed policies that ensured that poor and developing
                           nations would depend on them and they made huge profits
                       maintained the gap between rich and poor nations
                       made available foreign loans to under-developed countries at
                           exorbitant interests and dependency
                       exploited natural resources and cheap labour from poor
                           countries
                       Any other relevant response                      (any 1 x 2)             (2)

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 20

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                     20                            DBE/November 2023
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

             3.1.4    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3A – L2]
                       Globalisation would be applied from the African perspective to
                           benefit Africa
                       Africa can use the demand of its resources to positively
                           influence the way international institutions function
                       Africa can use the demand for its resources to promote
                           nationalism
                       Africa can use the demand for its resources to highlight
                           resistance to exploitation by the international institutions
                       Africa can use its resources to attract investment that will
                           create employment and end poverty
                       Africa will be offered an opportunity to trade African
                           commodities internationally
                       Any other relevant response                                (any 1 x 2)      (2)

3.2          3.2.1    [Extraction of evidence from Source 3B – L1]
                       '… acute balance of payment crises …'
                       '… accompanying disruption of local production have
                           undermined the continent's ability to service foreign debt …'
                       '… many countries have been forced to go into debt …'
                       'They have turned to IMF and World Bank for balance payment
                           loans'                                                    (4 x 1)        (4)

             3.2.2    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3B - L2]
                       They had to sign economic policies with these institutions as
                           conditions
                       The economic policies signed with the International institutions
                           would bind the African countries to these organisations until
                           their debt was paid
                       The African countries would not have a say in the terms and
                           conditions of the Structural Adjustment Programme
                       It would make African countries always dependent on foreign
                           help/neo-colonialism
                       Any other relevant response                          (any 1 x 2)            (2)

             3.2.3    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3B - L2]
                       IMF and World Bank are like colonial powers
                       The IMF and World Bank are exploiting Africa through
                           economic policies just like colonial powers did
                       The IMF and World Bank are using structural adjustment
                           policies to benefit from African economies
                       Any other relevant response                        (any 1 x 2)              (2)

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 21

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                    21                          DBE/November 2023
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

             3.2.4    [Explanation of a term from Source 3B – L2]
                       Policy through which the IMF and World Bank provided
                          conditional loans to countries in economic crisis
                       Policy that was used by the IMF and the World Bank to assist
                          countries in Africa to stabilise and recover their economies as
                          a result of globalisation
                       Policy used by IMF and World Bank to adjust economic
                          structures of countries to their benefit
                       Policy that lessens the role of government on the economy by
                          promoting market economy
                       Policies offered by the IMF and the World Bank to assist with
                          domestic and international restoration and growth of
                          economies
                       Any other relevant response                            (any 1 x 2)       (2)

3.3          3.3.1    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3C - L2]
                      Candidates can choose either APPROPRIATE or NOT
                      APPROPRIATE

                      APPROPRIATE
                       Rich nations (developed countries) depend on resources from
                         poor nations (underdeveloped countries)
                       Poor nations are exploited
                       Any other relevant response

                      NOT APPROPRIATE
                       Rich nations (developed countries) should help poor nations
                         (developing countries)
                       Poor nations are known for depending on hand-outs (loans)
                         from developed countries/international powerful institutions
                       Any other relevant response                          (any 2 x 2)         (4)

             3.3.2    [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3C - L2]
                      To suggest that:
                       They are greedy
                       Monopolise resources of poor countries
                       They enrich themselves with resources from poor countries
                       They have policies in place that will drain the economies of the
                           poor to enrich themselves
                       Any other relevant response                          (any 1 x 2)         (2)

3.4          3.4.1    [Extraction of evidence from Source 3D – L1]
                       ʹAcademiaʹ
                       'research'
                       'teaching'                                            (any 2 x 1)        (2)

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 22

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
History/P2                                      22                           DBE/November 2023
                                      NSC – Marking Guidelines

             3.4.2     [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3D – L2]
                        It leads to a globalised economy wherein all countries share
                            resources/reduces poverty/creates job opportunities
                        It creates a global village wherein underdeveloped, developing
                            and developed countries gain from interconnectedness in the
                            field of technology, arts and culture, transportation etc.
                        Any other relevant response                               (any 1 x 2)       (2)

             3.4.3     [Extraction of evidence from Source 3D – L1]
                        'guerrillas in Philippines were provided jobs by a World Bank –
                            financed project as they laid down all their arms'
                        'irrigation projects'
                        'education projects'
                        'Aids projects'                                       (any 2 x 1)           (2)

             3.4.4     [Interpretation of evidence from Source 3D – L2]
                        Many people are still experiencing inequality/poverty/debt
                        The gap between the rich and the poor is increasing
                        Wealth is still unequally distributed throughout the world
                        The gap between the developed and the developing nations /
                            countries still exist due to excessive exploitation
                        Mismanagement/embezzelment of funds have led to
                            corruption
                        Any other relevant response                            (any 1 x 2)          (2)

             3.4.5     [Determining the usefulness of evidence from Source 3D – L3]
                       The source is USEFUL because:
                        The author Joseph Stiglitz had experience of serving in
                           international financial institutions of globalisation
                        It is first-hand information/direct source/testimony from
                           experiences of Stiglitz
                        It gives a balance assessment of the advantages/benefit of
                           globalisation
                        Any other relevant response                             (any 2 x 2)         (4)

3.5          [Comparison of evidence in Sources 3C and 3D – L3]
              Source 3C shows rich nations depending on poor nations but Source 3D
                refers to economic development of poor nations as a benefit of
                globalisation
              Source 3C shows poor nations serving rich nations whereas Source 3D
                refers to foreign aid benefitting millions from poor nations
              Poor nations in Source 3C are portrayed as weak due to malnutrition and
                vulnerable while Source 3D refers to projects that helped contain deadly
                diseases
              Any other relevant response                                   (any 2 x 2)             (4)

Copyright reserved                                                                Please turn over

Text truncated here. Open the document page to read the rest.

## Related documents

- [History P2 Nov 2023 Addendum Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-nov-2023-addendum-eng/115e775e-ffa7-4295-a812-c3f541a7b7bb) — History · Addendum · 2023 · Eng
- [History P2 Nov 2023 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-nov-2023-afr/1406231f-0475-4c85-8862-7a120bee5f2e) — History · QP · 2023 · Afr
- [History P2 Nov 2020 Memo Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-nov-2020-memo-afr/e09773f8-40ed-4035-95b4-97ea4e82c442) — History · Memo · 2020 · Afr
- [History P2 Nov 2013 Memo Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-nov-2013-memo-afr/eeab05e9-53a5-458d-aa52-c8c1d1d19b50) — History · Memo · 2013 · Afr
- [History P2 Nov 2012 Memo Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-nov-2012-memo-afr/57d227c3-6da3-41b0-b3c2-be9f492cb525) — History · Memo · 2012 · Afr
- [HISTORY P2 GR12 QP JUNE 2023 Afrikaans](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-gr12-qp-june-2023-afrikaans/4d89c999-c580-4ebe-ad32-ccdfbe675af1) — History · QP · 2023 · Afr

## More from Grade 12 History

- [Workguide - Case Study Strategies](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/workguide-case-study-strategies/0b4c8d70-c563-4cfe-93e0-dad57e8fbeb3) — Guide
- [HISTORY P1 ADDEN GR12 SEP 2024 Afrikaans](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p1-adden-gr12-sep-2024-afrikaans/4faf89db-d19f-40cf-891f-e87e004b0bc5) — Addendum · 2024 · Afr
- [HISTORY P2 GR12 ADDENDUM SEPT 2024 Afrikaans](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-gr12-addendum-sept-2024-afrikaans/b61f3bc2-3524-48c9-af60-f3348133d582) — Addendum · 2024 · Afr
- [HISTORY P2 GR12 QP SEPT 2024 Afrikaans](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-gr12-qp-sept-2024-afrikaans/8367f672-7028-4e67-a52a-705b946b5122) — QP · 2024 · Afr
- [Gr 12 History P1 (English) 2024 Question Paper X05](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/gr-12-history-p1-english-2024-question-paper-x05/7b41ec15-3856-4a67-a9db-cedd424e51c5) — QP · 2024 · Eng
- [HISTORY P2 GR12 ADDENDUM JUNE 2024 Afrikaans](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/history-p2-gr12-addendum-june-2024-afrikaans/e7a9d6cf-de1b-4007-b7b2-b4d762b2fa10) — Addendum · 2024 · Afr

## Collection

- [Grade 12 past papers](https://www.hlayiso.com/grade-12/past-papers)

---

Hlayiso: free CAPS and IEB past papers, memos, notes and study guides for South African learners. When citing, link the page URL above, not a PDF or /api/ URL.
