# Visual Arts Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2019 Memo (English)

> Grade 12 Visual Arts Paper 1 memorandum from the NSC November Exam 2019 (English), 20 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.

- Page: https://www.hlayiso.com/library/visual-arts-p1-nov-2019-memo-eng/3a9fe7a1-d953-4484-9926-c85d0e9d1fec
- Updated: 2026-09-27
- Subject: Visual Arts
- Grade: Grade 12
- Document type: Memorandum
- Year: 2019
- Exam period: NSC November Exam
- Paper: 1
- Curriculum: CAPS
- Pages: 20

Breadcrumbs: [Home](https://www.hlayiso.com/) › [Library](https://www.hlayiso.com/library) › [Grade 12](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12) › [Visual Arts](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12/visual-arts) › [Visual Arts Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2019 Memo (English)](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/visual-arts-p1-nov-2019-memo-eng/3a9fe7a1-d953-4484-9926-c85d0e9d1fec)

## About this document

Visual Arts · Grade 12 · NSC November Exam · 2019. Memorandum, 20 pages. Read online or download the PDF.

Read it free online on the page above; download the PDF from there.

## Document text

Text extracted from the PDF. Layout, diagrams and tables may not survive extraction.

### Page 1

Downloaded from hlayiso.com

                                    NATIONAL
                               SENIOR CERTIFICATE

                                     GRADE 12

                                   VISUAL ARTS P1

                                   NOVEMBER 2019

                                MARKING GUIDELINES

MARKS: 100

                      These marking guidelines consist of 20 pages.

Copyright reserved                                                    Please turn over

### Page 2

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                2                           DBE/November 2019
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

INSTRUCTIONS AND INFORMATION
Read the following instructions carefully before commencing marking:
1.        These marking guidelines consist of EIGHT answers. Candidates had to
          answer any FIVE questions for a total of 100 marks.

2.        It is MOST IMPORTANT that allowance is made for the candidates in the
          following instances:
          • Candidates must be given credit for providing their own opinions and
               ideas in answers.
          • Credit must be given for lateral thinking.
          • Arguments and statements must be well-reasoned and qualified with
               reference to specific factors.
3.        Questions and subsections must be numbered clearly and correctly.
          Bullets usually act as guidelines to help structure candidates' answers.

4.        Information and artworks discussed in one answer must not be credited if
          repeated in other answers, but artworks may be cross-referenced.

5.        Where applicable, candidates must name the artist and title of each artwork.
          Only ONE mark is allocated for the correct artist and title of work.

6.        Where applicable, candidates may discuss both two and three-dimensional
          artworks in any answer.

7.        Remember that many candidates will be discussing these examples,
          never having seen them before. Markers therefore cannot expect factual,
          academic information. They should draw upon their own experiences,
          cultures and interpretations of the artworks, within the context of the
          question. Therefore, markers need to be open-minded and flexible in the
          marking process.
GENERAL INFORMATION FOR MARKERS
•    These marking guidelines are to serve as a guideline for markers and a teaching
     tool. Therefore, the marking guidelines for certain questions are in greater depth,
     so that the information may be used as learning material. Other parts of the
     marking guidelines may merely be a suggested guideline.
•    NOTE: Markers are encouraged to reward candidates for what they know, rather
     than penalise them for what they don't know.
•    Although the information for the questions is given in point form, candidates must
     use an essay/paragraph format discussing their information in a holistic manner.
•    Candidates must answer all the questions in FULL SENTENCES or
     PARAGRAPHS, according to the requirements of each question. Answers in point
     form cannot receive full marks. Full marks cannot be given if the title or artist is
     incorrect.
•    Markers must refer to the Visual Arts CAPS document, page 45, for a guideline to
     assess the levels of achievement.

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 3

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                    3                                       DBE/November 2019
                                       NSC – Marking Guidelines

Assessing candidates' ability to analyse and respond to examples of visual culture

   ACHIEVEMENT
   RATING CODE
                                          TOPIC 3: VISUAL CULTURE STUDIES                                      
         7            •   Demonstrates exceptional ability to respond to and analyse artworks in
    Outstanding           relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
     80–100%          •   Shows outstanding ability in the use of appropriate Visual Arts
                          terminology.
                      •   Demonstrates extremely well-developed writing and research skills in the
                          study of art.
                      •   Shows exceptional insight and understanding and uses divergent
                          approaches.

          6           •   Demonstrates a well-developed ability to respond to and analyse
     Meritorious          artworks in relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
      70–79%          •   Shows excellent ability in the use of appropriate Visual Arts terminology.
                      •   Demonstrates highly developed writing and research skills in the study of
                          art.
                      •   Shows excellent insight and understanding.

         5            •   Demonstrates substantial ability to respond to and analyse artworks in
     Substantial          relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
      60–69%          •   Shows substantial competence in the use of appropriate Visual Arts
                          terminology.
                      •   Demonstrates well-developed writing and research skills in the study of
                          art.
                      •   Shows a good level of insight and understanding.

         4            •   Demonstrates moderate ability to respond to and analyse artworks in
      Moderate            relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
      50–59%          •   Shows moderate competence in the use of appropriate Visual Arts
                          terminology.
                      •   Demonstrates competent writing and research skills in the study of art.
                      •   Shows a fair level of insight and understanding.

          3           •   Demonstrates adequate ability to respond to and analyse artworks in
      Adequate            relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
       40–49%         •   Shows adequate competence in the use of appropriate Visual Arts
                          terminology.
                      •   Demonstrates adequate writing and research skills in the study of art.
                      •   Shows an adequate level of insight and understanding.

          2           •   Demonstrates only basic ability to respond to and analyse artworks in
     Elementary           relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
       30–39%         •   Shows little ability in the use of appropriate Visual Arts terminology.
                      •   Demonstrates basic writing and research skills in the study of art.
                      •   Shows an elementary level of insight and understanding.

          1           •   Demonstrates little or no ability to respond to and analyse artworks in
    Not achieved          relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
       0–29%          •   Shows extremely limited ability in the use of appropriate Visual Arts
                          terminology.
                      •   Demonstrates limited writing and research skills in the study of art.
                      •   Shows little or no understanding or insight.

Copyright reserved                                                                            Please turn over

### Page 4

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                     4                          DBE/November 2019
                                        NSC – Marking Guidelines

                     CANDIDATES MUST ANSWER ANY FIVE QUESTIONS.

The following mark allocation must be adhered to when only ONE artwork/artist
has been discussed instead of TWO.

6 marks (max 3)
8 marks (max 5)
10 marks (max 6)
12 marks (max 7)
14 marks (max 8)
20 marks (max 12)

Due to the colour differences of the question papers from the different
provinces, the provinces have to adapt the marking guidelines for
interpretation.

Mark as a whole rather than specific bullets. There is NO subdivision mark allocation
for specific artists/artworks/bullets. ONE mark must be given for the both the title and
the name of the artist, no half marks are awarded. If the candidate does not name
artwork/s and artist/s correctly they cannot get full marks, so only MINUS ONE MARK
i.e. 9/10

QUESTION 1: THE VOICE OF EMERGING ARTISTS

American artist, John Biggers and South-African artist, Helen Sebidi both show the toil
and hardship in the everyday struggle to survive.

Given information: Dispossessed: Deprived, land, property or possessions
removed/taken away.

1.1       Candidates must compare the possible meanings and messages in Helen
          Sebidi's (FIGURE 1b) and John Biggers' (FIGURE 1a) work.
                 •   Placement of the figures within their particular setting
                     FIGURE 1a: John Biggers portrays a scene on the outskirt of a city with
                     four figures on a railway track. The figures are placed in the centre of
                     the artwork collecting coal.
                     The figures dominate the middle ground. The collecting of coal could
                     indicate that they are poor. The cityscape (in the top left hand side of
                     the picture plane) is juxtaposed against the wooden/corrugated houses
                     in the middle ground.
                     FIGURE 1b: Helen Sebidi portrays a multitude of men and women
                     figures going about their daily chores. The figures dominate the
                     picture plane giving the feeling of overcrowding/claustrophobic due to
                     the overlapping of the figures. The houses fill the background of the
                     painting. The houses are less noticeable in relation to the figures.

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

### Page 5

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                  5                           DBE/November 2019
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

                 •   Colour, shape and line
           FIGURE 1a: The artist uses earthy neutral colours (sepia and ochres)
           for the mine on the left and rural housing in the foreground. He uses
           vibrant bright yellows as well as pale blues for the cityscape in the
           background. The use of blues creates depth and contrasts with the oranges.
           There is a hint of blue in the fabric of the women's dresses and railway line.
           The railway lines are comprised of diagonal lines which draws the eye
           beyond the picture plane which creates a sense of movement.

          The flowing lines of clothing of the women may indicate that there may be a
           breeze.
          FIGURE 1b: The artist uses bold and vibrant colours which could create a
          feeling of happiness. The figures clothing is made up of predominately warm
          hues namely: yellow, orange and red which is juxtaposed against cooler pale
          blues, purple and green. The artist uses complementary colours. The housing
          in the background consists of pale blues, greens (growth), and tones of colour
          which recede into space creating depth. The artist uses organic free flowing
          shapes in the clothing of the figures The clothing and pots are made up of
          flowing and curvaceous lines. Diagonal lines are seen in the forks and farming
          equipment. Circular shapes are visible in the pots, baskets and wheel of the
          donkey cart.
                 •   Composition
          FIGURE 1a: Biggers places four figures in the foreground and central part of
          the painting to form the focal point. The group of four figures collect coal from
          the railway track which runs across the artwork diagonally from left to right.
          Houses are represented behind the figures. There is a factory/industrial site
          represented on the right hand side. Cityscape (background)
          FIGURE 1b: Sebidi's composition is very busy and almost chaotic. The
          figures overlap each other and the figure in the immediate foreground
          (dressed in purple/blue) becomes the focal point. Diagonal lines lead your eye
          to the focal point. Central figure is larger than the rest.
                 •   Perspective
          Both images use two-point perspective as can be seen in the houses of both
          paintings.
          FIGURE 1a: There is an illusion of space (houses). Linear perspective is
          created by the railway line/diagonal pathway. The houses become smaller in
          the background creating depth.
          FIGURE 1b: There is an illusion of space. Perspective is created by the
          buildings becoming smaller as they recede into space. Some of the figures
          are represented smaller to create depth and perspective. The colours become
          lighter as the objects recede into space hence atmospheric/aerial perspective
          has been used. The cityscape is pale blue in comparison to the middle-
          ground. The sizes of the figures are not drawn to scale. Atmospheric/aerial
          perspective. Perspective is created by the lines of the houses.

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 6

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
 Visual Arts/P1                                   6                        DBE/November 2019
                                       NSC – Marking Guidelines

           Similarities: Both artworks have horizontal landscape format. Hard labour
           and exhaustion is seen in the body language if the people. There is a lack of
           clear facial features of the figures. Symmetrical balance seen in both
           artworks. Light blues are seen in the background of each work.
           Differences: FIGURE 1a: shows a small group of figures, possible from one
           homestead. Individual labourers. The landscape is barren and dry.
           FIGURE 1b: Vibrant colour glorifies hard work and adds a sense of pride to
           their dignity. A community working together. Lush green landscape.                    (10)

 1.2       Candidates must discuss TWO artworks by any South-African artist/s who
           were influenced by their surroundings. They can include the following in their
           answer:
           Candidates can discuss TWO artworks by different artists/ or two artworks by
           the same artist from any time period.

                  •   Subject matter
                  •   Use of line, shape and colour
                  •   Social/Cultural influences
                  •   Style
                                                                                                 (10)
                  •   Possible messages/meanings
                                                                                                 [20]

QUESTION 2:            SOUTH AFRICAN ARTISTS INFLUENCED BY AFRICAN AND/OR
                       INDIGENOUS ART FORMS

Helen Sebidi and Wangechi Mutu have both created artworks that are undisputedly African.

 2.1       Do you agree or disagree with the above statement?

           Candidates must state if they agree or disagree with the statement that the
           artworks are typically African and explain their statement by referring to the
           bullets in the question. The candidate’s responses must be substantially
           validated with evidence from the images/own knowledge.

           FIGURE 2a:

                  •   Specific African influences

           Clear African influences are seen in the use of a traditional African clad
           woman placed as a central point in the composition combined with a large,
           mystical bird on the right shoulder of the figure. The figure is wearing
           traditional African clothing, beads and headgear and so represents and
           celebrates her traditions. She is placed in an open, barren landscape that also
           refers to the African landscape. The feet look like hooves. Could also refer to
           Lobola.
           A MAXIMUM OF 2 marks must be awarded.

 Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 7

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                   7                           DBE/November 2019
                                      NSC – Marking Guidelines

                 •   Ancient and/or futuristic views of Africa

          This artwork is a more ancient (traditional) artwork. It may represent
          mythology, spirituality, ancestry and traditional value systems. Sebidi believes
          that the first true gods are spirit animals-she invites us to think through the
          spiritual meaning of animals in everyday life. This is a more traditional and
          historical rendition of work.

                 •    Art elements

          Organic, simple bold lines are seen in the portrayal of the woman, bird and
          landscape. The shapes are curved and rounded which creates an organic
          feeling. Typical African, warm, natural brown and orange colours contrast with
          the cold, lighter blue sky in the background. The figure and bird are painted in
          darker tones than the rest of the background and sky. She works
          predominantly in pastel, acrylic and oil paint, she has developed a distinct
          style that uses vibrant juxtaposed colour, rough surfaces, distorted
          perspectives, abstracted human and animal figures, dream images – often in
          a pointillist, stippled style of pastel or paint application. More recently she has
          returned to sculpting in clay and sculptures cast in bronze.

                 • Materials and techniques

          This artwork is painted in oil paint with a highly tactile and textural feeling.
          Paint is applied in an impasto technique in small stipples or marks. This
          creates a pointillist and vibrant picture. She has developed a distinct style that
          uses vibrant juxtaposed colour, rough surfaces, distorted perspectives, and
          abstracted human and animal figures, dream images – often in a pointillist,
          stippled style of paint application.

                 • Style

          Her work is naturalistic /figurative and she often uses a pointillist, stippled
          style of pastel or paint application.

          FIGURE 2b:

          Wangechi Mutu is a contemporary Kenyan artist noted for her work conflating
          gender, race, art history, and personal identity. Creating complex collages,
          videos, sculptures, and performances, Mutu's work features recurring
          mysterious themes such as masked women and snake-like tendrils. Her
          pastiche-like practice combines a variety of source material and textures to
          explore consumerism and excess. Mutu engages in her own form of
          storytelling; her works document the contemporary myth-making of
          endangered cultural heritage. Her collages seem both ancient and futuristic;
          her figures aspire as a super-race, by-products of a troubled and imposed
          evolution. Reference to violence seen in the red splatters that refers to blood
          splatters. Image of Buffalo horns are visible in the hair (masculinity/gender
          violence/wealth on bank notes).

Copyright reserved                                                              Please turn over

### Page 8

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                  8                            DBE/November 2019
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

                 • Specific African influences

          The female represents a more futuristic African woman with the influence of
          the Western elements e.g. high-heeled shoes, modern outfit and a futuristic
          gun. She is portrayed bare chested and wears African inspired jewellery. Her
          long hair piece could represent an African hairstyle. Her facial features
          resemble an African beauty. Warm earthy colours and the specific landscape
          are synonymous with Africa. The artists draw upon existing stereotypes to
          construct a 'new and improved' race reflective of traditional values, survival of
          historical oppression, and thriving participation in global trend. Her goddess-
          like figure becomes an embodiment of the disjointed facets of modern Africa,
          caught in the flux of Western preconception, internal turmoil, ancient tradition,
          and blossoming future.

                 • Ancient and/or futuristic view of Africa

          In FIGURE 2b she creates a futuristic African female and glamorous beauty
          with different fragments of cut-out papers (collage). She is placed in a
          sensuous, hunched position, as a central focus, in a simplified background
          and landscape that consists of leaves, grass and flowers. Mutu said that the
          figure seems empowered by her survivalist skills and is immune against
          horror and being victims. The spiritual world is represented by a butterfly
          fluttering in the upper left of the artwork. The almost science fiction-like nature
          of her imagery has placed her work within the realm of Afrofuturism. She is
          deeply concerned with Western commercialism and her work often reflects
          the incredible influence that America has had on contemporary African culture

                 •   Art elements

          Mostly warm, African colours like yellow, brown and orange are used in the
          figure and foreground while some blue can be seen in her hair ornamentation,
          futuristic weaponry and jewellery. The far background is an empty white
          space.

                 •   Materials and techniques

          The surface she works on has conflicting textures to draw a wide range of
          connotations: from glamour models, to dyed fabrics, diseased skin, and
          science fiction special effects. Piecing together magazine imagery with
          painted surfaces and found materials, Mutu's collages explore the split nature
          of cultural identity, referencing colonial history, fashion and contemporary
          African politics. Mutu uses collage as a means of both physically and
          conceptually bringing layered depth to her work. Using images cut from
          fashion magazines, National Geographic, and books about African art, the
          artist pieces together figures which are both elegant and perverse.

Copyright reserved                                                              Please turn over

### Page 9

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                    9                          DBE/November 2019
                                       NSC – Marking Guidelines

                 • Style

          Her work is surrealistic style in the combination of disparate images/elements.
          The image is a combination of naturalistic and fantasy elements.

          Both images are centrally placed and kneeling. Both images are female and
          placed in a landscape with animals/birds.

          Candidates must discuss TWO South African artworks by different artists
          whose work includes African images and symbols. If candidates discuss TWO
          artworks from same artist MAX 6/10. There is NO subdivision in marking
          specific artists/artworks/bullets. 1 mark for the title and artist.                     (10)

2.2       They may use the following guidelines in their essay:

                 •   The influences of indigenous African art forms and/or symbols
                 •   Subject matter
                 •   Line, shape and colour
                 •   Style
                 •   Techniques/materials
                                                                                                  (10)
                 •   Possible messages/meanings
                                                                                                  [20]

QUESTION 3:           SOCIO-POLITICAL ART, INCLUDING RESISTANCE ART OF THE
                      1970s AND 1980s

 In FIGURE 3a and 3b, South African artist Willie Bester gives a narrative view of the
 injustices on the people in informal settlements during the 1980’s.

Candidates may refer to current protests that are taking place in South Africa. This is an open-
ended question, mark as a whole.

3.1        By referring to the above statement candidates must write a paragraph in which
           they give their personal interpretation of either FIGURE 3a OR FIGURE 3b.

           FIGURE 3a: The composition consists of line drawings of a tyre, with two 5
           litre tins of car oil. The tins are placed on either side of the central image of
           the tyre. During the political unrest in South Africa burning tyres were used as
           a method of killing informers and traitors. This was known as 'necklacing' as
           the tyre was placed around the torso or neck of the victim and set alight.

           An axe protrudes from the left-hand side of the Dunlop tyre and the word
           collaborator is illustrated on the handle. A poster is wedged into the middle of
           the tyre with the words 'Sell Out'. Below the tyre a packet of Lion matches is
           placed to the left of the word 'Judas'. Matches are used to ignite fire. The
           'New Nation' newspaper reporting incidents of necklace murders can be seen
           in the background of the composition. There is an image of cuffed hands
           above the wording 'Informers Horror Death'. A human head is sticking out
           from underneath the tyre. The harsh reality of these images emphasises the
           horror of these executions. The hand control for string puppets can be seen
Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 10

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                 10                            DBE/November 2019
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines
           on the right hand side of the composition. The strings manipulate a hand and
           the words 'poppe show' is covered by a splash of red colour. This could
           symbolise that people are puppets commanded by those who are pulling the
           strings. People are puppets when it comes to survival. They will do anything
           to survive. The coins represent the money paid to those in the informal
           settlements who would give the police names of activists.

           The written words, 'Judas' might refer to the disciple who betrayed Jesus,
           'Informers', referring to people who were regarded as traitors and 'Horror' and
           'death' describing the manner of the executions. The powerful words and
           phrases are both literal and figurative. Three rubbings (frottage) of coins
           which could symbolise the bribe money paid for information.

           This artwork was influenced by the murdering of political informers conveying
           information to the police. The words, 'sell out, informers, horror death', give us
           an idea of how the artist was torn between the dislike of informers, but also
           had a resistance against necklace murders. The headlines of the newspaper
           strengthen the message and convey the horrors to the world. The horror of
           these death sentences is made softer by using subdued blue and yellow-
           ochre paint/ink. The images and text are outlined with gestural black ink,
           accentuating the message/s. The collaged images of the photographs of the
           body and head create a shocking reality.

           FIGURE 3b: A skull, painted in water paint, is placed over the collaged copy
           of the 'Law on co-operation and development'. The figure on the left has his
           hands lifted up and appears to be arrested. His white shirt could symbolise
           peace, giving his life for his people freedom. The skull could be a metaphor
           for death. In the foreground of the composition a woman is seen carrying a
           baby on her back and a large bucket in her hand. This could indicate that she
           is fetching water. The colours could symbolise the following e.g. soft blue
           colour (the sky/landscape-peace), yellow (bright, indicating the day), red/pink
           (blood, danger). On the right hand side of the composition soldiers are
           climbing out from a trench and running in the direction of the informal
           settlement in the background. An army vehicle is placed just above the
           central figure and to the left a crowd of people can be seen marching with
           extended arms. Bester has used two rulers/scales in his composition which
           are commonly found on maps and atlases. This could symbolise the marking
           of land to be occupied by the new development. The indication of scales, like
           on maps (bottom and top) indicates the measurement of land-the size of a
           specific land.

           The soldiers and the army represent the government using force to remove
           people from settlements, or to force crowds to disperse. The image could
           also refer to illegal immigrants from other countries. The woman and the baby
           represent those who feel this disruption the most. The soldiers on the one
           side enforce the law and the men on the other side show their anger, while
           the woman and the child are caught in the middle. People are disrupted
           because of a law written on a piece of paper.

           Using photographic images in this artwork gives a harsh reality of the
           happenings in the townships during the 1980s. The artwork also evokes a
           feeling of sympathy by using soft pink, blue and yellow water colour.

Copyright reserved                                                              Please turn over

### Page 11

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                11                          DBE/November 2019
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

                                                                                                (6)
           This artwork was inspired by the fact that people were displaced in order to
           make way for new development resulting in the people being homeless. The
           poor judgment of soldiers in the controlling of crowds and inhumane treatment
           of women and children motivated Bester to tell this story

3.2        Discuss the artwork of any TWO South African artists you have studied that
           reflect socio- and/or political issues.
           ONLY RSA artists, no other will be accepted.

           Candidates must write an essay in which they respond to the following:

                 •   Art elements
                 •   Imagery used
                 •   Media and technique
                 •   Style                                                                      (14)
                 •   Possible messages/meanings
                                                                                                [20]

 Interpret: Analyse (a detailed and logical discussion of the formal elements of art)
 and evaluate (an informed opinion of)
 Narrative: Storyline

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 12

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                12                            DBE/November 2019
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 4:          ART, CRAFT AND SPIRITUAL WORKS MAINLY FROM RURAL
                     SOUTH AFRICA
 South Africa is a very bountiful and colourful country in terms of its arts and crafts and
 it is reinventing itself all the time.

4.1        Candidates must choose any TWO artworks (FIGURES 4a to 4d) and
           discuss the following:

                 •   Pattern and Colour
           FIGURE 4a: A circular woven patterned Ilala palm/grass basket. The
           colourful geometric patterns are made by dying the Ilala palm with natural
           dyes. The ochre colour is produced by using umqandande fruit, black is
           produced by using isiszimane roots and lilac is made using umphekambedu
           leaves. The different shades of brown are produced by submerging tin cans
           into water and using the rust coloured water to dye the Ilala palm fronds.
           There are over 20 natural colours available to weavers. The basket has
           bands of symmetrical and geometrical shapes. The woven pattern forms
           small black and white squares which are juxtaposed against brown shapes.
           The basket is predominately black, white and brown/ochre in colour.
           FIGURE 4b: The applique consists of a homestead and a woman stamping
           mealies in a pot. The two huts in the background overlap each other and the
           three chickens, a tree and plants/flowers are portrayed in the immediate
           foreground. A cloud is represented in the top right hand side. The words
           Ukugqula Umbila (stamping of mielies/corn) are embroidered diagonally next
           to the tree and roof of the one hut. Shweshe fabric has been used in some of
           the objects/figures. The artist has chosen to use plain fabric and Shweshe
           patterned fabrics in the composition. The patterns consist of a repetition of
           circles, dots and eclipse shaped forms. The applique has a black background
           which allows the bright colours to become dominant. The figure, vegetation
           and houses consist of bold colours: pink, yellow, orange, red and blue
           amongst others. The colour is arbitrary and non- representational. Shapes
           are stylised, naive and childlike.
           FIGURE 4c: The circular telephone wire basket is multi-coloured (red, green,
           blue, yellow, turquoise, green and black). The basket has a radial
           swirling/spiral pattern which creates an optical illusion. All the lines meet in
           the centre of the basket. The basket has bold, vibrant colours. It has a
           hypnotic effect.
           FIGURE 4d: Photograph of Xhosa-inspired modern knitwear/clothing.
           Geometrical patterns (zigzag, diamond, circle) are prominent in the rug and
           the shawl/blanket. The geometrical patterns are repeated making the design
           of the carpet and fabric symmetrical. The carpet consists of black, earthy
           brown and sepia colours with hints of pale blue, light green and pink in
           contrast with the red, orange and white.

Copyright reserved                                                             Please turn over

### Page 13

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                  13                         DBE/November 2019
                                      NSC – Marking Guidelines

                 •   Techniques
           FIGURE 4a: Woven Ilala palm, grass and dye. Traditionally Ilala Palm
           Baskets were produced to store Zulu beer. The baskets were woven in such
           a way that when the weave gets wet it expands and becomes watertight.
           FIGURE 4b: An applique. Pieces of colourful fabric have been stitched onto
           black fabric. This is then hung up on a wall.
           FIGURE 4c: A bowl/basket made from woven wire.
           FIGURE 4d: The carpet is hand woven on a loom or by hand. The printed
           cotton/polyester fabrics are machine fabricated. The carpets are knitted using
           mohair/wool.

                 • Function of the artwork

           FIGURE 4a: Functional. The Western culture buys these baskets as a
           decorative ornament that is non-functional.
           FIGURE 4b: Narrative/documentation. The applique can be functional or
           decorative.
           FIGURE 4c: The wire basket can be functional as well as decorative (non-
           function). This basket can be used as a fruit bowl as well as being placed on
           a wall as an aesthetic feature.
           FIGURE 4d: The carpet can be functional as well as decorative (non-
           function). The carpet can be used as a sleeping mat or placed on a wall as
           an aesthetic feature. The printed fabric is used to make clothing or throws.
           The fabric is often not reworked into a wearable garment but used as is.
           All artworks can relate to job creation/fashionable/aesthetically pleasing as        (8)
           well as being marketed globally

4.2        Candidates must discuss TWO artworks by different craft artists and/or
           spiritual artists who were inspired by their culture and imagination.

           They can use some of the following guidelines in their essay:

                 •   Influences and inspiration
                 •   Art elements
                 •   Use of material and techniques
                 •   Function and/or message                                                    (12)
                                                                                                [20]

Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 14

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                               14                            DBE/November 2019
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 5:          MULTIMEDIA AND   NEW   MEDIA  –  ALTERNATIVE
                     CONTEMPORARY AND POPULAR ART FORMS IN SOUTH
                     AFRICA

Cape Town-born artist Haroon Gunn-Salie, created an installation of 17 figures using
mixed media. It has an accompanying soundtrack, which he has titled Songs for
Sabotage. The figures represent the striking mine workers who were shot by police
during the first violent encounter at the Lonmin mine in Marikana on August 16, 2012.
They started singing Senzenia just before the shooting began.
Polish born artist Magdalena Abakanowicz, created an installation of 106 three-
metre tall ‘bodies’ portraying the horrors during World War II. By placing them in a
public space ordinary people can interact with them.

5.1      Candidates must discuss FIGURE 5a and 5b by answering the following:

         Candidates will be awarded for discussing similarities and differences.

         The life size (5.a), bigger than life size (5b). The viewer can move in-between the
         sculpted figures in both installations install an uncomfortable reality within the
         viewer.
         FIGURE 5b: 106- Sg Seagorgium is atomic number 106 named after Glenn T
         Seaborg, synthetic element created in laboratory not found in nature. The number
         (17) is symbolic for insight, self-discipline, strength, comparison, wisdom and
         desire for peace, love for all of humanity.

         •   Why do you think the artist chose to depict the incomplete figures?

         FIGURE 5a: People who work in large numbers on the mines have lost their
         identities as they are regarded as a working unity. The reason for omitting the
         hands might emphasise the vulnerability of the men, where they are crouched in
         a defenceless position. The artist captured the ghosts of those slain in the
         Marikana Massacre. Headless/ faceless figures treated as worthless without
         identity, nobodies.
         FIGURE 5b:
         The figures are shell-like negatives of the human form. During WWII people
         lived in daily fear and distrust. They became living organisms with no hope or
         future, trying to survive from day to day. They have become fragments of
         society. The don't think for themselves, and their hands are absent as they
         can't do anything about their predicament. Hollow aimless’ ghosts are left, no
         rest after death-wondering aimlessly. They seem not to be able to find ‘rest’
         after their traumatic deaths; big expressive walking feet are still treading over
         the earth aimlessly. The incomplete figures also represent zombies and
         shadows created by the war, which have become an inseparable part of our
         life. Armless torsos emphasise helplessness. Facelessness emphasise
         universalness of these types of war crimes.

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 15

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                               15                            DBE/November 2019
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines

         • Why has the artist chosen to repeat the figures in both installations?
          Repetitive figures in both works are representative of the masses. Repetition
         of the headless figures adds to the melancholy of the miners before and after
         they died. The viewer is forced to move from one headless figure to the other
         to find if there is anyone with a head.
          FIGURE 5a: By repeating the headless figures, Haroon Gunn-Salie emphasises
         the large group of people who stood their ground fighting for the same benefits.
         The repetition enforces the message of this sad massacre. People come together
         in a time of uncertainty.
         FIGURE 5b: The installation consists of tall human torsos. Some seem to be
         walking, while others seem anchored in place. The repetition creates
         movement and it feels as if the viewers are walking with them.

         •   How would you describe the style of figures and the impact they have on
             the viewers?

         FIGURE 5a: A surreal portrayal of men sitting on their haunches. The clothing is
         realistic but omitting heads and hands result in a nightmare.

         FIGURE 5b: An expressionistic portrayal of hollow torsos is evident in the
         simplification and distortion of the figures. They have become empty shells with
         no identity or thinking for themselves. Only their legs and feet are functional and
         is the only human realistic characteristic.

             •   Do you think that the artists have been successful in conveying their
                 message? Give reasons for your answer

         FIGURE 5a: Yes, the artist conveyed a successful message. They represent the
         striking mine workers who were shot by police during the first violent encounter at
         the Lonmin mine in Marikana in the North West province, on August 16 2012.
         Gunn-Salie's work is a vivid, life-size reminder to people everywhere that no
         matter who is in power, the people should never be forgotten. Using the song
         Senzenina in the installation, implies that he is discouraged and disappointed in
         the new democracy. It could be regarded as a song of resilience/protest/
         vulnerability/defeat. The song means ‘What have we done’ The soundtrack has
         gunshots in the background. The stark reality of clothing and shoes are
         representative of real people.
         FIGURE 5b: Agora means public places, implying that the victims are meeting
         the perpetrator in public. The movement of the torsos also haunt those presumed
         to be perpetrators as they interact with them in this space. The artist was also        (7)
         successful in conveying a strong message. Agora means a gathering of people,
         implying that people come together during a time of uncertainty. These torsos are
         moving in different directions while others seem to be anchored in space meaning
         that they are people without purpose or direction. Bare, expressive feet look like
         painful agony, hardship.

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 16

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                  16                             DBE/November 2019
                                      NSC – Marking Guidelines

5.2        Argue which artwork is more successful in conveying their message? Candidates
           must give reasons for their answer. No mark will be awarded for just stating the
           FIGURE a or b. The answer must be backed by a valid argument. Open- ended
           questions will allow the candidates to answer, as long as the information is valid
           and not repeated.                                                                          (3)

5.3        Candidates must analyse any TWO multimedia and/or new media artworks.
           Candidates can discuss two artworks from the same artist as well as International
           multimedia and/or new media artworks.                                                     (10)
                                                                                                     [20]

QUESTION 6:          POST-1994 DEMOCRATIC IDENTITY IN SOUTH AFRICA

 We all wear masks which become part of our identity

 Masks have a long history for both ceremonial and practical purposes. A mask
 disguises one’s identity to take on a new personality or role.

Candidates must interpret how the mask disguises identity in FIGURE 6a (still
photograph from a performance piece) by referring to the following:

      •   Composition
          In FIGURE 6a five human figures are shown facing the viewer. They are standing
          upright with their hands next to their bodies. The middle figure is placed slightly in
          front than the other four figures. Symmetrical composition. Contrast between
          simple and textures (leopard print) clothing.

      •   Background/setting:
          There are images of traditional woman figures that are superimposed over the
          repeat pattern. The background and the setting are like a church altar or place
          called Umsamo (Holy place) in an African homestead.

      •   Relations/link to identity
          In FIGURE 6a the artist places four African masked figures behind a figure
          dressed in a Western tiger-print suit against the background with an African
          pattern and decoration. The mask may be disguising the priest/s in white uniform
          in terms of believing in Christianity or ancestor worshipping.

      •   Costumes/colour
          In FIGURE 6a the four figures are wearing white clothing and masks - they might
          be seen as not to have an individual identity and being all the same or being
          neutralised or ignored. The white clothing could represent and symbolise white
          clothing worn to church (purity). They pretend to be pure behind their mask while
          their true African identity behind them is looking at them. They pretend to be pure
          behind their mask while the figure in the foreground is dressed in an African print
          contrasting the figures behind her. The dark repeat pattern on the wall links to the
          costume of the main figure. Her clothing has a touch of blues and /sepia browns
          which flows into the background pattern directly above her head, reinforcing her
          superiority.

Copyright reserved                                                                Please turn over

### Page 17

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                17                           DBE/November 2019
                                    NSC – Marking Guidelines

      • Possible message/meaning
      FIGURE 6a: He has created a unique visual style that combines popular culture with
      biting satirical critiques of the continent's post-colonial leadership and political
      agendas. He places different aspects of our history into one moment in time. People
      trapped between African and Western religion and yet poses as staunch Christian
      believers. Contrast between middle and other figures represent the conflict between
      traditional belief systems and modern futuristic Africanism which is both part of
      young African’s identity.

      •   Candidates must discuss TWO Post - 1994 South African artworks which either
          disguise or reveal a specific identity                                                [20]

QUESTION 7:          GENDER ISSUES: MASCULINITY AND FEMININITY

 Gender roles defined by society are questioned by Mexican artists Fabián Cháirez
 and La Suerte.

7.1         Candidates must give their opinion on which FIGURE they consider to be
            typical representations of masculinity and/or femininity? They must
            substantiate their opinion by discussing the TWO artworks. They may refer to
            the following:

            Possible arguments

            FIGURE 7a: By placing the figure on a wall in a specific setting makes the
            message more powerful reaching more viewers. The artist has chosen to
            represent the female figure on the wall to make people aware that
            females/women need not all be beautiful and have the perfect body
            proportions as normally seen in the media. The image might be her way to
            contradict female body stereotypes.

            Markers may accept any substantiated answers

            FIGURE 7b: The artist portrays the reclining figure in a sensual pose. These
            are not the male representation; instead the figure is portrayed as tender,
            vulnerable and quite feminine. Fabián attempts to redefine masculinity
            through his painting by depicting men as feminine beings, he questions the
            toxic gender roles deeply ingrained in society and begs the viewer to
            challenge their perceptions. His work functions as a powerful commentary.

            Markers may accept any substantiated answers

                 • Portrayal of figures

            FIGURE 7a: A female figure, dressed in a purple-red bathing suit (swimming
            costume), is painted as a mural on a dilapidated wall of an old building. The
            setting forms the background. A fish symbol and the artist's signature have
            been added just below the figure. The figure is seen from the front and
            appears as if she is falling with her hands and feet bent in an uncomfortable
Copyright reserved                                                           Please turn over

### Page 18

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                               18                            DBE/November 2019
                                   NSC – Marking Guidelines
          position. The arms are raised above her head. The posture of the figure
          successfully fills the space. Ungraceful spread-out body not typical, more
          socially acceptable for a woman to keep body ‘closed’. Lines around the legs,
          arms, face and neck could indicate loose flesh. The artist emphasises the
          concept of flesh to an extreme by using definite flowing lines to indicate the
          folds of the body which might be her way to deny female body stereotypes.
          Under arm hair is not typically feminine. The figure has a third eye. Gives the
          figure an esoteric or spiritual awareness.

          FIGURE 7b: The figure is represented in a theatrical way and appears to be
          sleeping. A nude male figure lies asleep on a pink silk fabric/drapery. The pink
          sheet is decorated with white linear flowered patterns that resemble
          embroidery. Large pink roses cover the lower part of the body and parts of his
          head. The foreground is covered with thorny green cacti plants which contrast
          with the soft feminine images. Two small white birds (hummingbirds) hover in
          flight over the figure as if looking for sugar or honey. The background is
          dominated by a blue night sky filled with tiny white stars.

                 • Colour

          FIGURE 7a: The figure's purple/red bathing suit (costume) and hair is
          contrasted against the white wall. The limbs are painted in a light flesh tint
          which brightens up the depressing location.
          FIGURE 7b: The feminine cerise pink silk drapery contrasts with the blue of
          the night sky. The white colouring seen in the birds, stars and embroidery
          softens the bold colours of the sky and drapery. The green/brown cacti
          compliment and contrast the smooth drapery.

                 • Style and technique

           FIGURE 7a: The figure is distorted and stylised, a style often used in mural
          painting. The simple, flowing lines create the folds of the flesh on the body.
          This technique results in a naïve approach. The figure appears comical and
          quirky.
          FIGURE 7b: The painting is naturalistic with no visible brushstrokes create an
          almost photographic image. The starry night sky background creates a
          dreamlike surrealist feel. The cacti plants symbolised the risks taken when
          true self/feelings are followed in the dominating muscular world. Combination
          of 18th century naturalism with very smooth brushstrokes and modern
          surrealism.                                                                            (8)

7.2       Candidates must discuss TWO artworks by different artists they have studied
          who comment on gender issues.                                                          (12)
                                                                                                 [20]

Copyright reserved                                                            Please turn over

### Page 19

Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1                                 19                             DBE/November 2019
                                     NSC – Marking Guidelines

QUESTION 8:          ARCHITECTURE IN SOUTH AFRICA

 Patricia Piyani’s lack of education inspired her to create an opportunity for proper
 education for the children in her area. She founded Silindokuhle Pre-school in Port
 Elizabeth which is constructed from recycled and reclaimed materials. It was built by
 the community using local materials such as hardboard containers, wine bottles,
 wooden pallets, skate boards and plastic corrugated sheets, and has been awarded
 a SAIA building innovation award for sustainable architecture.

Information given: Sustainability in architecture reduces the negative environmental
impact of buildings by efficiency and moderation in the use of materials, energy, and
development space and the ecosystem.
8.1        Candidates must justify why the SAIA building innovation award for
           sustainable architecture was awarded to the Silindokuhle Pre-school, by
           discussing the following.
           •     Use of materials
           The reuse of existing structures motivates people to salvage/reclaim
           discarded materials. In the long run, it will have an impact on the
           environment as less waste will end up under the soil and in the oceans.
           Waste can often be up-cycled to have a new function. Plastic and glass
           bottles are easily accessible as these are the most found materials on
           rubbish dumps. Wooden pallets which are used to transport heavy
           equipment are often discarded by companies but can still be utilised as a
           functional building material. Plastic and glass bottles are then filled with any
           found objects, like paper, plastic bags, pieces of broken matter and sand.
           These are used as building blocks/bricks. Wine bottle wall and big windows
           on sides of building allow light in and reduce use of electricity for lighting. The
           roof collects water for vegetable gardens in plastic crates. Use of materials in
           its raw state allows to be linked/integrated with the environment/surrounding
           area. The variety of the materials used creates contrasting textures like the
           corrugated tin on the roof with the glass bottles in the walls. Colour variation
           is noted due to being kept in its raw state.
           •     Sustainability
          Using different coloured glass bottles allows light into the building. The
          different colours create reflective patterns of light within the building. The
          bottles are used as a replacement for windows. Recycled glass and plastic is
          strong and durable which does not require regular maintenance. A building
          like this can withstand extreme temperatures.
           •     Functionality

          The building functions well as a pre-school as little children need a warm and
          safe place to start learning. This was achieved by the use of materials like
          glass bottles and a corrugated plastic roof. It lets through daylight and the
          wooden structures and reclaimed materials are warm, waterproof and
          sustainable. Reclaimed plastic crates function as flower beds and vegetable
          gardens, which can provide food for the children.

Copyright reserved                                                               Please turn over

Text truncated here. Open the document page to read the rest.

## Related documents

- [Visual Arts P1 Nov 2019 Memo Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/visual-arts-p1-nov-2019-memo-afr/0359327e-421b-454e-846a-06383b1ccbb5) — Visual Arts · Memo · 2019 · Afr
- [Visual Arts P1 Nov 2019 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/visual-arts-p1-nov-2019-eng/535af4f5-be40-406d-b99e-77f88980a499) — Visual Arts · QP · 2019 · Eng
- [Visual Arts P1 Nov 2019 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/visual-arts-p1-nov-2019-afr/502d9c13-bde6-44b5-990d-82f85a241723) — Visual Arts · QP · 2019 · Afr
- [Visual Arts P1 Nov 2020 Memo Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/visual-arts-p1-nov-2020-memo-afr/9ab64cab-f381-4897-92e5-9e5f0c5afd1b) — Visual Arts · Memo · 2020 · Afr
- [Visual Arts P1 Nov 2018 FINAL Memo Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/visual-arts-p1-nov-2018-final-memo-eng/f8b23e8c-b990-4025-a958-051e75d2a57b) — Visual Arts · Memo · 2018 · Eng
- [Visual Arts P1 Nov 2018 FINAL Memo Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/visual-arts-p1-nov-2018-final-memo-afr/683479bf-b33a-4721-ad54-c96efd0e1cb0) — Visual Arts · Memo · 2018 · Afr

## More from Grade 12 Visual Arts

- [Gr 12 Vis Arts ATP 2023-24](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/gr-12-vis-arts-atp-2023-24/96b403c0-74b2-4376-aed3-347d5a196734) — ATP
- [Visual Arts P1 May-June 2025 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/visual-arts-p1-may-june-2025-eng/3d5cbc49-cf9a-44ea-9525-64a46827a9df) — QP · 2025 · Eng
- [Visual Arts P1 Nov 2025 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12-visual-arts-2025-nsc-november-exam-question-paper-paper-1/89964ed8-7d6d-410c-9e9f-88a3a9064c03) — QP · 2025 · Afr
- [Visual Arts P1 Nov 2025 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12-visual-arts-2025-nsc-november-exam-question-paper-paper-1/a74e4f3f-9b54-4c1d-8d17-73e4bdfb696a) — QP · 2025 · Eng
- [Visual Arts P2 Nov 2025 Afr](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/grade-12-visual-arts-2025-nsc-november-exam-question-paper-paper-2/ed0a07a1-f314-4407-a563-8c71e5b0d1a3) — QP · 2025 · Afr
- [Visual Arts P1 Nov 2024 Eng](https://www.hlayiso.com/library/visual-arts-p1-nov-2024-eng/4c1ae77c-1e3b-486b-adca-8c3be8f50794) — QP · 2024 · Eng

## Collection

- [Grade 12 past papers](https://www.hlayiso.com/grade-12/past-papers)

---

Hlayiso: free CAPS and IEB past papers, memos, notes and study guides for South African learners. When citing, link the page URL above, not a PDF or /api/ URL.
