Skip to content

History Grade 12 Paper 2 NSC June 2014 Memo (English)

MemorandumHistoryGrade 12201423 pages

Grade 12 History Paper 2 memorandum from the NSC June 2014 (English), 23 pages. Read online or get the free PDF download, question paper linked when available.

Free to read online, no sign-up needed

Answer online

Loading document…

Loading document…

Questions in this paper

Document textSearch extracted text and jump to a page.
. ae a ides ww CW \\'s wii ielSicac uk ce alee Kr. Department: Basic Education SENIOR CERTIFICATE EXAMINATION “as basic education NZ REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA HISTORY P2 HIGHER GRADE 2014 MEMORANDUM van oparsed Copy Dee: ue th dev att Aig | 14 26.014 F Uwahucd > ck. Meds alte PRIVAT: This memorandum consists of 27 pages, 2054 -86- 15 OX 1410 PRETORIA 0004 MARKS: 200 PUBLIC EXAMINATIONS Copyright reserved Please turn over
History/HG/P2 Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE —- Memorandum DBE/2014 PRESENTATION CONTENT LEVEL 7 Has developed a relevant independent line of argument. Has employed analysis and historical explanation. Well planned and structured essay. Excellent technical skills and evidence. LEVEL 2 Has developed a relevant line of argument. Has employed analysis and historical explanation, Well planned and Structured essay. Minor flaws. LEVEL 3 Has developed a relevant line of argument. Has attempted analysis and historical explanation. Well planned and Structured essay. Structural flaws. Higher order skills absent. LEVEL 4 Attempts to Sustain a line of argument. Has attempted analysis and historical explanation. Essay planned and structured to a certain extent LEVEL § Attempts to sustain a Une of argument. Applied analysis and historical explanation to a certain extent. Attempt a structure. Technical flaws. LEVEL 6 Line of argument not sustained, Applied analysis and historical explanatio n occasional ly or not at all. No clear structure. LEVEL 7 LEVEL 8 No line of No attempt argument. to answer No analysis | the and question, historical explanation. No Structure. LEVEL 1 Question has been fully answered, Content selection fully relevant to line of argument. At 47-50 A 43 - 46 A- 40-42 LEVEL 2 Question has been answered. Content selection relevant to line of argument, 43-46 40-42 B+ 38 ~39 160 - 200 140-159 120 - 139 100-119 80-99 + 67-79 FF: 60-66 G: 50-59 GG: 40-49 H: 0-39 MYON LEVEL 3 Question answered to a great extent. Content adequately covered and relevant. B+ 38-39 36 ~ 37 35 C+ 33 - 34 LEVEL 4 Question posed is Tecognisable in answer. Content selection and contro! flawed, Omissions and irrelevant content selections. C+ 33 - 34 31-32 D+ 28 - 29 LEVEL § Content selection does relate to the question, but do not answer it. Omissions in coverage. Lacks control. om 30 26-27 E+ 23 - 24 LEVEL6 Question inadequately addressed. | Sparse content. 25 21-22 E- 20 LEVEL7 Question inadequately addressed or not at all, Inadequate content. Irrelevant to a great extent. 13-19 LEVEL 8 No relevant content selection. Totally flawed G 07-12 Ho-6 | Copyright reserved Pleasefurn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE - Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 QUESTION 1: AFRICA IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY QUESTION 1A Africa has nobody to blame for the continent's Challenges after independence other than African political leaders. Do you agree with this statement? Substantiate your answer by making reference to relevant post-independent countries in Africa. SYNOPSIS The answer must indicate whether the candidate agrees or disagrees with the statement. In agreeing with the statement the candidate must provide evidence regarding the inability of African political leaders to deal with the continent's problems after independence, If they disagree they must provide evidence that states that the continent's Problems after independence stemmed from the colonial rule and or other factors. Reference should be made to political, economic and social challenges as well as the Policies of some leaders that influenced post-independence development on the African continent. Candidates may also partially agree or partially disagree but still need to support the line of argument with adequate evidence. NB: The main aspects (bullets) must be used to address the requirements of the question and to develop a relevant line of argument. A mere Stating of facts is inadequate. MAIN ASPECTS ¢ Introduction - Candidates need to indicate their point of view in relation to the statement and develop a relevant line of argument by supporting it with evidence. ELABORATION * Political challenges: can refer to any aspects e.g. Administrative; Ethnic; Military; Type of government or any other relevant challenges. ¢ Economic challenges: can refer to any aspects e.g, Agriculture; Mining; Manufacturing; Transport; Communication or any other relevant challenges. Copyright reserved Pleaséturn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 . SCE - Memorandum DBE/2014 QUESTION 1B Explain the different points of view regarding the challenges and achievements of the Organisation of African Unity (OAU) since its formation in 1963. SYNOPSIS The answer must indicate that there are different points of view regarding the challenges and achievements of the Organisation of African Unity (OAU). Candidates need to support their line of argument by assessing both the challenges and achievements of the OAU. NB: The main aspects (bullets) must be used to address the requirements of the question and to develop a relevant line of argument. A mere stating of facts is inadequate. MAIN ASPECTS ¢ Introduction - Candidates need to take a line of argument and indicate how they intend to support it with relevant evidence. ELABORATION e Aims of the OAU Unity and solidarity; Better standards of living; Freedom and sovereign independence; Decolonisation: Meaningful international relations. e Achievements — may use any examples to illustrate the achievements United front; Support to liberation groups; Isolated apartheid South Africa; Settled border disputes; Problems with refugees; Increased economic cooperation; Any other relevant achievement e Shortcomings — (may use any examples to illustrate shortcomings Disunity; Rivalry between member states; Could seldom prevent clashes between states; Military coups; Any other relevant shortcoming e Any other relevant point. Conclusion ~ Candidates should tie up their argument, [50] Copyright reserved Please turn ovef
Downloaded from hlayiso.com . DBE/2014 SCE - Memorandum History/HG/P2 QUESTION 2: THE RISE OF SOVIET RUSSIA QUESTION 2A Discuss how the policies that Lenin implemented between 1917 and 1924 transformed the Soviet Union's economy. SYNOPSIS Candidates should indicate that Lenin implemented two economic policies between 1917 and 1924 namely War Communism and the New Economic Plan (NEP). The measures implemented under both policies in agriculture and industry should be highlighted and discussed. It needs to indicate how these policies transformed the Soviet Union. NB: The main aspects (bullets) must be used to address the requirements of the question and to develop a relevant line of argument. A mere stating of facts is inadequate. x MAIN ASPECTS * Introduction - Candidates should indicate that Lenin implemented two economic policies between 1917 and 1924 namely War Communism and the New Economic Plan (NEP) and must suggest how the policies transformed the Soviet Union. ELABORATION e War Communism and agriculture Aim: to feed Red Army and industrial workers; State ownership of land; Fixed food prices; Requisitioning of food; No hoarding allowed; Use of Cheka to enforce policy; Decrease in agricultural production e¢ War Communism and industry; Nationalisation of all industries and banks; Workers Committees managed the industries; Working day increased from 8-11 hours; Labour could be redeployed to where it was needed; Decrease in production due to untrained committees ° NEP and agriculture; Aim: to win back the support of peasants; Land could be rented and peasants employed; Tax paid to government; Surplus can be sold on the open market; Requisitioning of food abolished: A Kulak class emerged: Increased agricultural production noted Copyright reserved Please tufn over
HistoryGrP2 Downloaded from hlayiso.com neeioor4 SCE ~ Memorandum « NEP and industry; Industries with less than 20 workers privatised; Larger industries remained under state control; Emergence of NEPMEN (a business class); Increased industrial output e Financial Reforms Taxation more capitalistic; Banks created; Foreign trade increased 250% ¢ Any other relevant point. * Conclusion - Candidates should tie up their line of argument [50} Copyright reserved Please turn o}
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE — Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 QUESTION 2B Stalin was the greatest man on earth, the greatest statesman, the father of the nation and the genius of all time. Do you agree with this statement? Substantiate your answer by using relevant evidence from 1928 to 1941. SYNOPSIS Candidates should indicate whether they agree or disagree with the statement. In supporting the statement candidates must explain how Stalin was the greatest statesman, the father of the nation, the genius of all time. They should use evidence regarding the collectivisation and industrialisation of Soviet Russia under the Five Year Plans to substantiate their argument. Candidates should include the measures, resistance and successes of the Five Year Plans in both the agricultural and industrial spheres. if the candidate disagrees with the statement they need to support their answer with relevant evidence. NB: The main aspects (bullets) must be used to address the requirements of the question and to develop a relevant line of argument. A mere stating of facts is inadequate. MAIN ASPECTS * Introduction - Candidates should indicate whether they agree or disagree with the statement and indicate their line of argument. ELABORATION e State control of the economy (Gosplan) and Five Year Plans Quotas Targets Planning * Agricultural transformation as a result of the Five Year Plans Collectivisation Farms . Resistance of Kulaks and use of Cheka (state police) to destroy them Successes and failures e Industrial transformation as a result of the Five Year Plans New industries Infrastructure Propaganda/ Stakhanovs Use of slave/forced labour Successes and failures ¢ Any other relevant point. * Conclusion - Candidates should tie up their line of argument. [50] Copyright reserved Please turn over
History/HG/P2 Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE - Memorandum DBE/2014 QUESTION 3: THE RISE OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA QUESTION 3A The Wall Street Crash of 1929 was expected. Critically assess the validity of this statement. SYNOPSIS Candidates in answering the question should determine whether the Wall Street Crash was expected because of the underlying weaknesses of the American economy, or whether it could have been prevented. They should discuss the various causes of the 1929 Great Depression and show how this led or did not inevitably lead to the crash of the Wall Street Stock Market in 1929. NB: The main aspects (bullets) must be used to address the requirements of the question and to develop a relevant line of argument. A mere stating of ‘facts’ is inadequate. MAIN ASPECTS Introduction - Candidates should indicate whether the statement is valid or not and then develop an appropriate line of argument. ELABORATION Over-speculation Share prices had risen dramatically during 1920s; Millions of people wanted to own shares; ‘Buying on the margin’ allowed those with very little money to buy shares: Value of shares pushed to an artificial high Overproduction Due to mass production techniques; Ceiling reached on domestic consumption but production remained high; Led to false impression of productivity and economic confidence Uneven distribution of wealth; Not everyone benefited during the 1920s (especially agriculture, old industries, Afro Americans): There was a limit to the consumer driven boom (i.e. not everyone could afford a new car, radio, fridge etc) The domestic market could not keep pace with production Copyright reserved Please turn ovs
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE - Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 ¢ Republican policies All of the above problems were made worse by the Republican's laissez faire economic policies e.g. Tariff Policy - Europe applied their own tariffs in response to USA's protective tariffs: Business could not export surplus goods when domestic markets were saturated; Business and banks were not regulated allowing for unsound (and corrupt) business practices e.g. buying on the margin, panic selling of stock, etc. ¢ The Wall Street Crash e Any other relevant point. * Conclusion - Candidates should tie up their line of argument. (50) Copyright reserved Please turn over Ss
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE ~ Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 QUESTION 3B Explain to what extent Roosevelt's New Deal policy was successful in building @ prosperous America after the destruction and despair that was caused by the Great Depression of 1929, SYNOPSIS Candidates should explain to what extent Roosevelt's New Deal policy has Succeeded in waging a war against the destruction and despair caused by the Great Depression in America. Candidates should refer to the impact of Roosevelt's New Deal on the USA. An evaluation of Roosevelt's measures of relief, recovery and reform should also be highlighted. NB: The main aspects (bullets) must be used to address the requirements of the question and to develop a relevant line of argument. A mere stating of ‘facts’ is inadequate. MAIN ASPECTS ¢ Introduction - Candidates should indicate their line of argument and indicate how it will be substantiated. ELABORATION ¢ Relief measures and its Positive and negative impact e.g. Civilian Conservation Corps - mass job creation, e.g. Reforestation; Public Works Administration -public works construction; Civil Works Administration -created jobs at minimum pay; Works Progress Administration -Mass job creation; Home Owners' Loan Corporation - loans granted to home owners; Tennessee Valley Authority -mass employment, etc. ¢ Recovery and its positive and negative impact e.g. Agricultural Adjustment Act - plan food production and guaranteed reasonable food prices: Farm Credit Act - repay mortgages; National Recovery Administration and Act - codes for owners, producers and workers, etc. * Reform measures and its positive and negative impact e.g. Bank holiday - Reconstruction Finance Corporation; Security Exchanges Act - rules for shares market; National Labour Relations Act - labour legislation; Social Security Act - welfare system; Wagner Act - trade unions, etc. e Any other relevant point. * Conclusion - Candidates should tie up their line of the argument. [50] Copyright reserved Please turn over p
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE ~ Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 SECTION B: SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS MARKING SOURCE-BASED QU ESTIONS ¢ In marking all source-based questions credit needs to be given to any other valid and relevant viewpoints, arguments, evidence or examples. e In the allocation of marks emphasis should be placed on addressing the requirements of the question. e In these marking guidelines the requirements of the question (skills that need to be addressed) as well as the level of the question are indicated in italics. LEVELS OF SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS LEVEL 1 (L 1) Extract evidence from sources Straightforward interpretations by using evidence from LEVEL 2 (L 2) one source and broader knowledge to show an understanding of the period/event/issue. Straightforward interpretations by using evidence from LEVEL 3 (L 3) more than one source and broader knowledge to show an understanding of the period/event/issue. Complex interpretations often involving more than one source. These questions look at aspects such as bias, reliability, usefulness, the use of organising concepts (similarity and difference; cause and consequence; LEVEL 4 (L 4) chronology; change and continuity) to explain contrasts, comparisons, differing points of view and as a last step using these insights to write a Paragraph or in other words, to write a piece of history based on the evidence in the sources. Copyright reserved Please over
History/HG/P2 Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE —- Memorandum DBE/2014 QUESTION 4: AFRICA IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY 41 4.44 WHAT PROMPTED THE PROCESS OF DECOLONISATION AMONG VARIOUS AFRICAN STATES IN THE 1960s? (a) (Extract evidence from Source 4A ~ LT] ¢ To strip Africans of their responsibility in conducting their own affairs e To convince Africans that their civilisation is nothing less than savagery (2 x 1) (2) (b) [Explain the messages in the cartoon — L3] e Africans were not free to rule themselves as they were kept in chains e African were prevented from taking action against colonialism ¢ Adult Africans were treated like or seen as a foetus in the womb of mother Africa ° Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) (c) [Compare the sources in Source 4A to show supporting idea — L3] ° Both sources show Africans were unable to take responsibility/ rule themselves ¢ Both sources show Africans in a negative light ¢ Africans are shown as infantile (childish) in both sources/ undermines Africans e Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2)(4) (d) [Explanation of a concept in Source 44 — La] e Decolonisation refers to the Process where Africans desired to rule themselves ¢ To shed the yoke of colonisation and govern themselves e Any other relevant answer (1 x 2) (2) 4.1.2 (a) [interpretation of evidence in Source 4B — L2] ¢ He believed that Africans had the ability to develop their own countries e He believed it should be done in partnership with their former colonial powers Any other relevant response {any 1 x 2) (2) Copyright reserved Pleasé turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE — Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 (b) [Interpretation of evidence from Source 4B —L2] Candidates can state either yes and or no. They need to support their answer with relevant evidence. YES e He says Africans will be able to achieve equality in the long run/ in hundred to two hundred years ® He stated they had the capacity to be equal to their colonial masters OR NO e Even though he says Africans can achieve equality in the long run he implies that they will not really be equals « Welensky implies that Africans will not be able to dominate in a partnership with Britain/ Europeans * Any other relevant response (2 x 2) (4) (c) [Interpretation of evidence in Source 4B — L2] e Outrage e Anger; Disgust e Any other negative reaction (any 1 x 2) (2) 4.1.3 (a) [Interpretation of evidence in Source 4C— L2] e Africans will free themselves from colonial powers ¢ African countries will have to concentrate on developing their economies ¢ Basic human rights should be given attention especially regarding equality between men and woman African countries will have to work hard to establish acceptance of democracy ° Any other relevant response (any 1 x 2) (2) (b) [Extract evidence from Source 4C -L1 7} « Freedom from foreign domination e Freedom for all men and women from oppression, indignity, intimidation and exploitation * Right to the individual citizen to re-elect or replace government of his/ her country e Any other relevant response (any 2 x 1) (2) (c) [Analysis of evidence in Source 4C — L2] ¢ Democracy to Nyerere meant that the interests of individuals were taken care of The election of government should be a free and fair process Any other relevant response (2 x 2)(4) Copyright reserved Please tyrfi over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE —- Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 4.1.4 [Comparison of Sources 4B and 4C to show differences— L3] * Source 4B does not see Africans being able to gain self-rule or an equal footing with Europeans in less than a hundred years whereas Source 4C believes it is attainable within ten years ¢ Source 4B believed that Africans will never dominate in a partnership with Europeans countries/ Britain whereas Source 4C indicates that freedom should include every aspect of government ¢ The tone in Source 4B is condescending/ patronising/ disdainful/ arrogant/ negative whilst the tone in Source 4C is challenging/ demanding/ tough ° Any other relevant answer (any 2 x 2) (4) 4.1.5 (a) [Explanation of a concept in Source 4D — L2] ¢ To know and fight for your basic human rights e The awareness of people that they have the right to self-determination ¢ Any other relevant answer (1 x 2) (2) (b) [interpretation of evidence in Source 4D- L2] ¢ Africans across the whole continent are filled with feelings of national awareness which cannot be ignored The end of colonial rule/ foreign domination is in sight ¢ Political and other changes in Africa are inevitable ¢ Any other relevant answer (any 1 x 2) (2) (c) [Determine usefuiness of evidence from Source 4D — L3) Candidates can state either useful or not useful. In answering the question candidates need to interrogate the relevance and reliability of the source as well as to state to what extent the source is biased. They need to support their answer with relevant evidence, USEFUL e Itis a primary source written by a person who has first-hand experience of the development of African nationalism ¢ It provides insights into how people felt about what happened 2 It gives an idea of the changes that colonial governments had faced * Any other relevant response OR NOT USEFUL ° = Itis biased/ one-sided It is only Macmillan’s point of view e Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) Copyright reserved Pleasettirn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE — Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 4.1.6 [Extract evidence from the relevant sources and use own knowledge to organize information in a structured Paragraph — L4] Use the holistic rubric below and the following to allocate a mark. The paragraph must be based on the evidence from relevant sources and own knowledge. Candidates can refer to the following: ° Africans were determined to free themselves as soon as possible from the chains of foreign domination e Africans after the Second World War were no longer treated as inferior African nationalists like Sekou Touré, Nyerere, Nkrumah and others fought against oppression Africans wanted to have a Say in the running of their countries The fight against foreign domination was supported by Asian countries Colonies fike Britain realised they could no longer ignore the demand for self- determination: ‘The winds of change are blowing through the continent’ International organisations such as the United Nations supported decolonisation The super powers supported African states in their fight against colonialism Qualified Africans were returning to Africa to support the fight for independence Conferences such as the Bandung Conference advanced the fight for independence Effect of the defeat of colonial powers in the Second World War such as France e Any other relevant response ° Cannot extract (relevant) evidence from sources ¢ Extracts evidence from sources in a very elementary manner “0. LEVEL 1 |» Orcannot report on topic Marks: 0-3 e Uses evidence/or own knowledge partially to report on topic ° Extracts evidence from sources that is mostly relevant LEVEL2 7; Evidence relates to a large extent to the topic. Marks: 4-6 * Uses evidence from sources and own knowledge in a very basic manner. ¢ Extracts relevant evidence from sources Evidence relates very well to the topic. LEVEL3 |e Uses evidence from sources and own knowledge Marks: 7-10 very effectively in an organised paragraph ¢ That shows an understanding of the topic. (10) [50] Copyright reserved Please turndver
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE - Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 QUESTION 5: CIRCUMSTANCES THAT LED TO THE SECOND WORLD WAR 5.1 HOW DID ADOLF HITLER IMPLEMENT HIS FOREIGN POLICY IN THE 1930s? 5.1.1 (a) [Extract evidence from Source 5A -L1] e Saar e The Rhineland (2x 1) (2) (b) [Interpretation of map in Source 5A and use of own knowledge — 1.2] France Poland Czechoslovakia Belgium Netherlands Austria (any 2 x 1) (2) (c) [interpretation of evidence in Source 5A — La] * The Saar: Inhabitants of Saar voted in a plebiscite to rejoin Germany * The Rhineland: Hitler decided to remilitarise the Rhineland knowing Chamberlain followed an appeasement policy and France would not risk retaliation ° Austria: Hitler gave an ultimatum to Von Schussnigg * Sudetenland: Hitler promised Britain and France that it was his last territorial conquest ¢ Czechoslovakia: Hitler gambled that Britain and France would not come to Czechoslovakia's rescue (any 2 x 2) (4) 5.1.2 (a) [Extract evidence from Source 5B- 11] e Army e Fighter Aircraft * Bombers (any 2 x 1) (2) (b) [Interpretation of evidence in Source 5B and own knowledge — L2] * Hitler acknowledged Britain's supremacy in naval forces e The table shows that Germany had less battleships and destroyers than Britain (2 x 2) (4) Copyright reserved Please turf over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE — Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 (c) [Determine usefulness of Source 5B — L3] Candidates can state either useful or not useful. In answering the question Candidates need to interrogate the relevance and reliability of the source as well as to state to what extent the source is biased. They need to support their answer with relevant evidence. USEFUL e The source provides useful insights into the link between Germany's expansion versus the inaction of Britain and France * It provides valuable insights into the extent of militarisation by the big powers in Europe in the period up to 1938 ® Any other relevant response OR NOT USEFUL ¢ itis a not known how these figures were arrived at The figures could have been manipulated e It does not provide a broader view on events that led to Hitler's easy success in foreign policy * Any other relevant response (2 x 2) (4) 5.1.3. (a) [Explanation of a concept in Source 5C- 12] e An attempt by Chamberlain to Prevent war by trying to pacify Hitler by giving in to some of his demands in foreign policy e Any other valid response (1 x 2) (2) (b) [interpretation of evidence from Source 5C — L2] e Some historians viewed the policy of appeasement as a shameful policy in which Britain surrendered to Hitler's demands/ epitome of failure cowardice e Some historians believed the policy of appeasement was a logical and realistic policy based on a clear assessment of Britain's military and economic weaknesses at the tine e Any other relevant answer (2 x 2) (4) (c) [interpretation of evidence in Source 5C — L2] Candidates can state either yes or no, They need to support their answer with relevant evidence. YES/AGREE ¢ Chamberlain felt it was important to do everything in his power to prevent a Second World War * Chamberlain as Prime Minister had the responsibility to protect Britain and her people at a time when he felt their military power was not strong enough Chamberlain did not realise that Hitler could not be trusted Logical and realistic poticy e Any other relevant answer OR Copyright reserved Please turp’over HS
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE - Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 NO/DISAGREE ° Hitler knew his enemies weaknesses and played on it which allowed Hitler to take over the Rhineland; Sudetenland, Austria and the Polish Corridor without firing one shot * Hitler's previous actions meant that he could not be trusted. ¢ Chamberlain inadvertently gave Hitler time to build up Germany's military strength e Any other relevant answer (any 2 x 2) (4) 5.1.4 (a) [Interpretation of evidence in Source 5D — 1.2] e As events that were running splendidly e Regarded Hitler's actions with admiration and pride — liberated Austria e As acleansing of the human race * As diplomatic superiority over Britain and France who ‘sold out’ Czechoslovakia e Any other relevant answers (any 1 x 2) (2) (b) [Interpretation of evidence in Source 5D-— 12] ¢ Both viewpoints show the Strength of Hitler's propaganda machine regarding foreign policy ¢ Both points of view show the strength of Hitler's ability as orator to Sway people to accept his policies ¢ Any other relevant answer (1x 2) (2) (c) [Determine reliability of Source 5D ~ L3] Candidates can state either reliable or not reliable. In answering this question candidates need to interrogate the origin of the source and state to what extent the source is biased. They need to support their answer with relevant evidence. RELIABLE e Evidence provided is typical/ supported by evidence in other sources * Its primary evidence that dates back to the actual event ¢ Any other relevant response OR NOT RELIABLE * Itis a biased/ one-sided pro-Hitler point of view e It could have been propaganda ¢ Any other relevant response (2 x 2)(4) 5.1.5 [Comparison of Sources 5A to 5D to illustrate differences— L4] e Source 5A, 5B and 5C deals with responses outside Germany with regards to Hitler's foreign policy whereas Source 5D deals with some German responses * Sources 5A, 5B and 5C indicate the influence of the appeasement policy whereas Source 5D shows the impact of propaganda * Sources 5A, 5B and 5C are secondary sources, created after the event whilst Source 5D is a primary source it focuses on the People’s perceptions at the time of Hitler's foreign policy ¢ Any other relevant answer (2 x 2) (4) Copyright reserved Please turn o
History/ HG/P2 Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE — Memorandum DBE/2014 5.1.6 [Using information from the relevant sources and own knowledge to construct an "argument — L4] Use the holistic rubric below and the following to allocate a mark. Hitler used the following to implement his foreign policy in the 1930s: Propaganda to reshape Peoples’ beliefs, values and ideas along Nazi lines Britain's policy of appeasement The Naval Agreement with Britain The Neutrality Pact with Soviet Russia to prevent aggression on both fronts The introduction of military conscription The strong tradition of German militarism to attract the youth to join the army Chamberlain's trust at Munich to advance his policy Britain and France’s unwillingness to act with regards to territories that were far removed from them ee Both Britain and France's Playing for time to try and build up their armed forces The fact that Chamberlain felt some of his aims were reasonable * Chamberlain view that are no winners in war and desire to prevent a repeat of the First World War e Any other relevant response LEVEL 1 Cannot extract (relevant) evidence from sources Extracts evidence from sources in a very elementary manner Or cannot report on topic Uses evidence and or own knowledge partially to report on topic Marks: 0-3 LEVEL 2 Extracts evidence from sources that is mostly relevant Evidence relates toa large extent to the topic. Marks:4-6 Uses evidence from sources and own knowledge in a very basic manner. LEVEL 3 Extracts relevant evidence from sources Evidence relates very well to the topic. Uses evidence from sources and own knowledge Marks: 7-10 very effectively in an organised paragraph that shows an understanding of the topic. Copyright reserved (10) [50] Please turp-6ver
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE - Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 QUESTION 6: INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS AND EVENTS 1945 TO 1970: THE COLD WAR 6.1 HOW DID THE WEST REACT TO THE BERLIN BLOCKADE OF 1948? 6.1.1 (a) (Extract evidence from Source 6A— 1] ¢ Stalin feared a strong new German Currency. e Stalin feared that old money would be flooded into the Soviet zone (any 1 x 2) (2) (b) [Determine the messages of Source 6A — L3] e The Blockade is Stalin’s strategy to conquer West Berlin and to move on to take over the other Western countries e West Berlin is only the first country (mouse) that Stalin (the cat) is going to devour the western and the other countries (mice) will be next e Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) (c) [Compare the written and visual source in Source 6A and explain the differences — L2] 2 The message from a history textbook is written from a Soviet point of view and shows the West as the aggressor e The visual source is drawn by a British cartoonist and is from a Western point of view and shows Stalin as the aggressor e Any other relevant response (2 x 2) (4) 6.1.2 (a) [Interpretation of evidence from Source 6B — L.2] e [West] Berlin is located in the Soviet zone of Eastern Germany with no corridor for the West to enter or leave it e Any other relevant answer (1 x 2) (2) (b) [Interpretation of evidence from Source 6B — L2] ° The West opened three air corridors to West Berlin/ West used aeroplanes e Any other relevant answer (1 x 2) (2) (c) [interpretation of Source 6B and use of own knowledge — L3] * Stalin could lift the Berlin Blockade Stalin could shoot down the aeroplanes of the Western powers Stalin could declare war against the Western powers Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) eee 6.1.3 (a) [Extract evidence from Source 6C ~ Li It would have a disastrous effect on their plans for Western Europe {t would slow down European recovery Avoided confrontation Any other relevant response (any 1 x 2) (2) Copyright reserved Please turnaver h '
History/HG/P2 Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE - Memorandum DBE/2014 (b) [interpretation of evidence in Source 6C — L2] ° President Truman decided to embark on an airlift of supplies to West Berlin * The airlift meant the West provided food, fuel and medical supplies to West Berlin ° Truman decided not to abandon the West Berliners e — Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) (c) [Determine reliability of Source 6C — L3] Candidates can state either reliable or not reliable. In answering this question Candidates need to interrogate the origin of the Source and state to what extent the source is biased. They need to support their answer with relevant evidence. RELIABLE ¢ Evidence provided is typical/ supported by evidence in other sources * Its primary evidence that dates back to the actual event/ Truman's memoirs «Any other relevant response OR NOT RELIABLE ° Itis a biased/ one-sided point of view e Any other relevant response (2 x 2) (4) [Compare Sources 6A and 6C to show support — L 3] e Both the visual source in Sources 6A and 6C believed that Stalin wanted to use the Berlin Blockade not only to take over Berlin but also the western countries ¢ Both the visual source in Source 6A and Source 6C is from a Western point of view Both Sources 6A and 6C show that the West responded with an airlift e Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) (a) [Analysis of evidence from Source 6D- L2] ¢ Johnston believed Truman should have established a corridor to West Berlin at the Potsdam Conference * Johnston feared that if the USA became involved in a war with Soviet Russia, American soldiers will be butchered ¢ Johnston believed Truman trusted Stalin/ believed Joe Stalin to be a ‘good old chap’ ¢ Johnston feared greater demands on the pockets of American taxpayers * Any other relevant answer (any 1 x 2) (2) (b) [Interpretation of evidence in Source 6D — L2] e Bynot taking any aggressive steps/ take peaceful action ° The West remained in Berlin e Any other relevant answer (1 x 2) (2) Copyright reserved Please turn oye
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE - Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 (c) [Explain the usefulness of Source 6A ~L3] Candidates can state either useful or not useful. In answering the question candidates need to interrogate the relevance and reliability of the source as well as to state to what extent the source is biased. They need to support their answer with relevant evidence. USEFUL ¢ Itis a primary source/ letter written at the time of the event ¢ It provides insight into how some American people regarded Truman's actions/ not all American were happy with Truman's actions e Any other relevant response OR NOT USEFUL e The source is biased/ one-sided ° Any other relevant answer (any 2 x 2) (4) Copyright reserved Please tupaover
Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE — Memorandum History/HG/P2 DBE/2014 6.1.6 [Extract selected evidence and use own knowledge to organise the information in a structured paragraph - L4] Use the holistic rubric below and the following to allocate a mark. The paragraph must be based on the evidence from relevant sources and own knowledge. It can focus on some of the following aspects: The West reacted in the following ways: Decided to come up with a solution to help West Berlin Not allowing Stalin to squeeze them out of Berlin Introduced an airlift Western powers provided West Berlin with food, fuel and medical supplies Everyday 380 American planes flew into Berlin Nearly 300 000 flights delivered close to 2.5 million tons of cargo The airlift was kept going for 10 months Kept on with the airlift even though it was dangerous especially in winter months The West saw it as an attempt by Stalin to force them out of Berlin The West believed Stalin wanted to take over Berlin and then move on to taking over the western countries * Truman was initially willing to go to war against Soviet Russia grave international consequences e Not allowing the blockade to slow down European recovery Any other relevant response e Cannot extract (relevant) evidence from sources Extracts evidence from sources ina very elementary manner . LeveL © Or cannot report on topic Marks: 0-3 Uses evidence and or own knowledge partially to Teport on topic e xtracts evidence from sources that is Mostly LEVEL relevant 2 e Evidence relates to a large extent to the topic. Marks: 4—6 Uses evidence from sources and own knowledge in a very basic manner. ¢ Extracts relevant evidence from sources LEVEL |° Evidence relates very well to the topic. 3 * Uses evidence from sources and own knowledge Marks: 7~10 very effectively in an organised paragraph that shows an understanding of the topic. (10) [50] TOTAL: 200 Copyright reserved

Study this subject

More from Grade 12 History

View all