Skip to content

History Grade 12 P2 NSC November 2023 Addendum (English)

AddendumHistoryGrade 12202314 pages

Grade 12 History Paper 2 addendum from the NSC November Exam 2023 (English), 14 pages. Read online or get the free PDF download.

Free to read online, no sign-up needed

Answer online

Loading document…

Loading document…

Questions in this paper

Document textSearch extracted text and jump to a page.
Downloaded from hlayiso.com NATIONAL SENIOR CERTIFICATE GRADE 12 HISTORY P2 NOVEMBER 2023 ADDENDUM This addendum consists of 14 pages. Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 2 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum QUESTION 1: HOW DID THE CONGRESS OF SOUTH AFRICAN TRADE UNIONS (COSATU) RESPOND TO THE APARTHEID GOVERNMENT'S LABOUR REFORMS IN THE 1980s? SOURCE 1A The article below was published in The Namibian newspaper on 6 December 1985. It explains events unfolding during the conference launch of the Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU) and also describes COSATU's role as a labour movement. The Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU), launched at a rally attended by more than 10 000 workers in Durban last weekend, promises to present the toughest challenge to government and industry yet seen in the history of the South African labour movement. Leaders of the new super federation have already threatened to call a national strike if the government carries out its threat to repatriate (send back) migrant workers, and have pledged to organise workers in the homelands in defiance of any restrictions on unions in these regions. In policy guidelines adopted at the launching conference, the Congress also came out in support of disinvestment (withdrawal of investment), as well as the eventual nationalisation of South Africa's mines and other major industries. Emphasising the political role the new federation intends to play, COSATU President Elijah Barayi said the Congress hoped to fill the vacuum (space) created by the banning of the African National Congress (ANC), and that it was committed to one-person one-vote in a unitary South Africa. The Congress also called for a national minimum wage, a 40-hour week at full pay, a ban on overtime and the establishment of a national unemployed workers' union as an affiliate of the federation. With a membership of half a million, including the 150 000-strong National Union of Mineworkers (NUM) and the 100 000-strong Federation of South African Trade Unions (FOSATU), the formation of COSATU has been described as a triumph (victory) for trade unionism. [From The Namibian, 6 December 1985] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 3 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum SOURCE 1B The poster below, designed by COSATU's media worker Patrick Cockayne, demonstrates COSATU's protest against the apartheid government's Labour Relations Amendment Act that was introduced in 1987. [From Red on Black: The Story of the South African Poster Movement by J Seidman] AN INJURY TO ONE IS AN INJURY TO ALL Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 4 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum SOURCE 1C The extract below, taken from The Washington Post, was published on 25 February 1988. It explains the apartheid government's crackdown on COSATU and other anti-apartheid organisations. The decree (law) announced by the Minister of Law and Order, Adriaan Vlok, says that the United Democratic Front (UDF) and other restricted anti-apartheid groups (including COSATU) may continue to exist and will not be prohibited from keeping financial records, performing administrative functions or complying with an obligation imposed by or under any law or court of law. But they will have to obtain the Law and Order Minister's permission to conduct any other activities. Vlok said that despite emergency regulations already in effect, some opposition groups had persisted in establishing, maintaining and promoting a revolutionary climate. In November, Security Police Chief, Johan Van der Merwe, signalled the possibility of such a crackdown when he told reporters that legal radical organisations such as the UDF and COSATU are of more concern to the police than illegal groups such as the African National Congress (ANC). COSATU, which had begun to fill the organisational vacuum (empty space) created by the detention of most of the UDF's national and regional leaders, is now prohibited (banned) from campaigning for the legalisation of outlawed organisations like the ANC, from urging for the release of detainees, from boycotts of local black elections and from calling for disinvestments or sanctions against South Africa (SA). [From The Washington Post, 25 February 1988] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 5 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum SOURCE 1D The source below highlights measures adopted by COSATU during its special congress on 14 May 1988. It was in response to the threat posed by the apartheid government's restrictions and the Labour Relations Amendment Act. The special congress was called in response to two specific challenges to COSATU: The government's February 24 restrictions which legally limited COSATU to a narrow range of factory-floor trade unionism and effectively banned 17 other organisations, among them the United Democratic Front (UDF), a close and formal COSATU ally; and the Labour Relations Amendment Act, a bill intended, according to Manpower Minister, Pietie du Plessis, to 'restore the balance in industrial relations in favour of the employer'. Even after it had been slightly softened in the final draft presented to the Tricameral Parliament 24 hours after the special congress. The bill will substantially (largely) limit workers' right to strike, open trade unions to civil action for losses incurred (experienced) by their members' actions and outlaw (ban) solidarity action in industrial disputes. Combined, the restrictions and the bill attempted to deny COSATU a right woven (merged) into the fabric of its existence: the right to operate on the national political terrain, both to achieve its members' factory-floor demands, and in their broader, political interests. 'Taken together, the entire bill and the restrictions effectively ban COSATU,' said General Secretary Jay Naidoo on 25 February. The dual threat of the restrictions and the bill demanded several things of COSATU: An immediate and decisive response, both as a warning to employers and the government that COSATU would not knuckle under (give in) without a struggle, and to generate support for further resistance; on-going agitation and action to demonstrate to employers specifically that support of the bill might cost them more than it was worth. [From Work in Progress, Issue No. 54, June–July 1988] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 6 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum QUESTION 2: HOW DID THE TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION (TRC) EXPOSE LEADERS OF THE APARTHEID GOVERNMENT FOR GROSS VIOLATIONS OF HUMAN RIGHTS COMMITTED BETWEEN 1960 AND 1994? SOURCE 2A The source below has been taken from a biography of FW de Klerk, the leader of the National Party, titled A Question of Balance: A Biography of FW de Klerk written by John Cameron-Dow. … The National Party supported the idea of a Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) in order to avoid responsibility. Their approach was built around the concept of amnesty. In their view, a disclosure of past misdeeds should be rewarded with exemption (exclusion) from prosecution. It wasn't that simple; black South Africans were entirely justified in their demand for explanations. Furthermore, the vehicle of their liberation, the African National Congress (ANC), was now in power. The scope and nature of the commission would be determined by Mandela and his government. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) followed the passing of the Promotion of National Unity and Reconciliation Act in 1995. Three committees were set up to carry the commission's mandate, described by the Minister of Justice, Dullah Omar, as 'a necessary exercise to enable South Africans to come to terms with their past on a morally accepted basis and to advance the cause of reconciliation'. FW de Klerk maintains that he was of the opinion that a process was required in order to enable South Africans to come to terms with the conflict of the past in a spirit of reconciliation and to get on with the future without recriminations (accusations). He is known to have favoured a general amnesty for perpetrators of politically inspired violence. A general amnesty went very much against ANC thinking. It is now common knowledge that appalling (terrible) atrocities (crimes) were committed in the name of state security, particularly in the closing years of PW Botha's presidency. But how could FW de Klerk, a senior member of cabinet, not have been aware of the atrocities that were being committed; there was surely a collective complicity (involvement) at cabinet level. [From A Question of Balance: A Biography of FW de Klerk by J Cameron-Dow] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 7 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum SOURCE 2B The source below is an extract from a book written by M Meredith, who worked as a correspondent for The London Observer and the Sunday Times newspapers in the 1990s. It focuses on how the findings of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) exposed the atrocities committed by the National Party government from the late 1970s. Having laid down its criteria on accountability, the TRC delivered its verdict on the principal protagonists (characters). It was Botha's government in the late 1970s, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) declared, that had entered the 'realm of criminal misconduct'. Previous governments had ruled by repression but Botha's government had adopted a policy of killing its opponents. It was also responsible for the widespread use of torture, abduction, arson and sabotage. At meetings of the State Security Council, leading members, including Botha, Malan, Vlok and the heads of the security forces, had used terminology like 'eliminate, take out and wipe out', knowing full well this would result in the killing of political opponents. The 'realm (scope) of criminal misconduct' extended into FW de Klerk's period in office. The TRC was highly critical of FW de Klerk's failure to tackle the problem of the 'third force' – a network of security force members and right-wing groups seeking to wreck (ruin) any transition that would lead to an African National Congress (ANC) government. Though it acknowledged that FW de Klerk had taken steps to dismantle the national security management system he had inherited from Botha, the TRC said he had made 'little obvious attempts to curb (control) third force activitiesʹ, and had ignored pleas from senior officers like General Steyn, the Defence Force Chief of Staff, to institute a thorough investigation. He had failed to take action, concluded the TRC 'either deliberately or by omission'. The TRC cited (mentioned) testimony it had heard that FW de Klerk was aware that his commissioner of police, Van der Merwe, had been involved in illegal activity regarding the bombing of Khotso House and yet continued to retain his position as the most senior policeman in the country. [From Coming to Terms – South Africa's Search for Truth by M Meredith] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 8 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum SOURCE 2C The cartoon below was drawn by Zapiro and was first published in the Sun. Times on 2 August 1998. It depicts the apartheid government's cabinet ministers who evaded accountability for the violations of human rights committed between 1960 and 1994. [From Truth and Reconciliation in South Africa: 10 Years on by C Villa-Vicencio and F du Toit] FW de Klerk PW Botha Adriaan Vlok Pik Botha Magnus Malan Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 9 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum SOURCE 2D The extract below has been taken from the confessions made by P Erasmus, a member of the security branch of the South African Police. He exposes the dark secrets of the apartheid-era policing system ordered by the National Party cabinet and the State Security Council in the early 1980s. The leader of the Democratic Party, Tony Leon, summed it up when he said that it seemed as though the National Party was turning its back on the foot soldiers who, encouraged by their political leaders, had committed acts of terror against the South African people. Johan van der Merwe later turned on his former masters and admitted that FW de Klerk had, indeed, been briefed on all secret projects during the last four years of his government. Van der Merwe had, however, set himself up against former members of the South African Police (SAP) too, by putting his name on the indemnity (protection) list of 3 500 police officers whom FW de Klerk had approved just before being replaced by Mandela in the April 1994 election. As an expression of solidarity (unity) with the SAP of his era, FW de Klerk had placed his own name on that list too. When it was reported that FW de Klerk, some ex-ministers and generals involved with the State Security Council had already met on three occasions and were planning the fourth meeting to prepare themselves for what must have felt like the coming onslaught of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), I felt that old fury (anger) burning bright as ever inside me. Surely the concept of a truth commission was that each individual goes before the commission and tells their story alone, because that is what they chose to do – for whatever reason. We, the foot soldiers, were embattled (affected), not so much by our consciences, but by the fact that we had been disregarded and discarded (rejected), thrown away by those who represented a government that had employed us to kill, maim (cut into pieces) and torture. This is the truth. We simply could not get over it. [From Confessions of a Stratcom Hitman by P Erasmus] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 10 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum QUESTION 3: HOW DID POWERFUL INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS, NAMELY THE INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND (IMF) AND THE WORLD BANK, SHAPE THE GLOBALISED ECONOMIES SINCE THE 1980s? SOURCE 3A The extract below has been taken from a book by T Falola and B House-Soremekun. It explains how globalisation negatively affects the continent of Africa. Globalisation presents Africa and black people as marginal (unimportant): globalising economies seek resources from every corner of the world, and globalised economies reap considerable benefits from their economics and political dominance. The Wealth of Nations, to borrow from Adam Smith's famous book, is used not only to develop the resources within the boundaries of nation-states, but also to tap into the resources of other countries. Africa has given to the outside world more than it received in return, creating the basis to talk about the poverty of nations, the ultimate peak of human progress. Globalisation's critics point to the devastation of the environment, climate change, depletion (reduction) of natural and mineral resources, labour exploitation … Africa is the case study of both positions, providing examples of the benefits and problems of globalisation. Africa experiences globalisation 'from above', that is, a situation where powerful nations and companies with more resources are able to control the major actions and policies that determine the characteristics of global encounters. If Africa is part of the equation of globalisation 'from below', any discussion of its place in the global system will draw us into issues of nationalism and resistance – how Africans can mobilise themselves to win power and privileges, and how international institutions must be reformed. The actors who control globalisation from above call on African countries to practise democracy, but the same democratic principles do not apply to the United Nations Security Council, where a handful of countries have veto (to reject) power. [From Globalisation and Sustainable Development in Africa by T Falola and B House-Soremekun] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 11 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum SOURCE 3B The source below is an extract from a book by BK Campbell and J Loxley. It highlights the impact of globalisation through international financial institutions, namely the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank, on African countries in the 1980s. The conditions with which African governments have had to respond to the global crisis of the early 1980s have had the effect of locking them into new forms of dependent relationships with Western governments and international financial organisations. In particular, the acute (severe) balance of payments crises suffered by most African states in recent years, and the accompanying disruption of local production, have undermined the continent's ability to service foreign debt incurred in better times. Indeed, many countries have been forced to go into debt in an effort to stave (repair) off economic collapse and/or in an attempt to stimulate economic recovery. In particular, they have turned to the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank for balance of payments loans. Usually they have done so reluctantly (unwillingly), and because they have exhausted other possibilities of obtaining finance. Sometimes banks' bilateral donors and other sources of funding insist that African governments borrow from international institutions as a condition for maintaining their own contribution to balance of payment assistance. Never before have the international financial institutions wielded (used) such pervasive (extensive) influence on policy formulation in Africa; not since the days of colonialism have external forces been so powerfully focused to shape Africa's economic structure and the nature of its participation in the world system. Structural adjustments, as advocated by the international institutions, seek to restore growth and stability by recasting (changing) relative prices, domestic expenditures and the type and degree of state intervention in the economy. [From Structural Adjustment in Africa by BK Campbell and J Loxley] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 12 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum SOURCE 3C This cartoon titled 'Dependence Theory' was taken from the book The Development of Underdevelopment by AG Frank. It sheds light on a view regarding the dependency theory. [From The Development of Underdevelopment by AG Frank] POOR NATIONS RICH NATIONS Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 13 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum SOURCE 3D The source below is an extract from a book titled Globalisation and Its Discontents by J Stiglitz. It shares his personal experiences working in powerful international financial institutions. In 1993 I left Academia (university) to serve on the Council of Economic Advisers under President Bill Clinton. After years of research and teaching, this was my first major foray (attempt) into policy making, and more to the point, politics. From there I moved to the World Bank in 1997, where I served as chief economist and senior vice-president for almost three years, leaving in January 2000. I couldn't have chosen a more fascinating time to go into policy making. I was in the White House as Russia began its transition from communism and I worked at the World Bank during the financial crisis that began in East Asia in 1997 and eventually enveloped the world. I had always been interested in economic development and what I saw radically changed my views of both globalisation and development. Foreign aid, another aspect of the globalised world, for all its faults still has brought benefits to millions, often in ways that have almost gone unnoticed: guerrillas in the Philippines were provided jobs by a World Bank-financed project as they laid down all their arms, irrigation projects have more than doubled the incomes of farmers lucky enough to get water, education projects have brought literacy to the rural areas, in a few countries Aids projects have helped contain the spread of this deadly disease. Those who vilify (criticise) globalisation too often overlook the benefits. But the proponents (supporters) of globalisation have been, if anything, even more unbalanced. To them, globalisation (which typically is associated with accepting triumphant capitalism, American style) is progress; developing countries must accept it, if they are to grow and to fight poverty effectively. But to many in the developing world, globalisation has not brought the promised economic benefits. [From Globalisation and Its Discontents by J Stiglitz] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/P2 14 DBE/November 2023 NSC – Addendum ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Visual sources and other historical evidence were taken from the following: Cameron-Dow, J. 2016. A Question of Balance: A Biography of FW de Klerk, JCD Publishers, USA. Campbell, B and Loxley J. 1989. Structural Adjustment in Africa, St Martin's Press Inc., USA. Erasmus, P. 2021. Confessions of a Stratcom Hitman, Jacana Media, South Africa. Falola, T and House-Soremekun, B. 2011. Globalisation and Sustainable Development in Africa, University of Rochester Press, United Kingdom. Frank, AG. 2005. The Development of Underdevelopment, New England Free Press, USA. Meredith, M. 1999. Coming to Terms – South Africa's Search for Truth, Public Affairs, USA. Seidman, J. 2008. Red on Black: The Story of the South African Poster Movement, STE Publishers, South Africa. Stiglitz, J. 2002. Globalisation and Its Discontents, WW Norton & Company, USA. The Namibian, 6 December 1985 The Washington Post, 25 February 1988 Villa-Vicencio, C and Du Toit, F. 2006. Truth and Reconciliation in South Africa: 10 Years on, David Phillip, South Africa. Work in Progress, Issue No. 54, June–July 1988, Publication of the Southern African Research Service. Copyright reserved

Study this subject

More from Grade 12 History

View all