Skip to content

History Grade 12 Paper 2 NSC June 2013 Memo

MemorandumHistoryGrade 12201328 pages

Grade 12 History Paper 2 memorandum from the NSC June 2013, 28 pages. Read online or get the free PDF download, question paper linked when available.

Free to read online, no sign-up needed

Answer online

Loading document…

Loading document…

Questions in this paper

Document textSearch extracted text and jump to a page.
Downloaded from hlayiso.com basic education Department: Basic Education REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA SENIOR CERTIFICATE EXAMINATION HISTORY P2 HIGHER GRADE 2013 POSSIBLE ANSWERS MARKS: 200 28 pages. Please turn over Gopyrignt Teservea
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 2 DBE/2013 SCE - Global assessment of essays The essays will be assessed holistically (globally). This approach requires the educator to score the overall product as a whole, without scoring the component parts separately. This approach encourages the learner to offer an individual opinion through using selected factual evidence to support an argument .The learner will not be required to simply tegurgitate ‘facts’ in order to achieve a high mark. It will also discourage learners to prepare ‘model’ answers and reproduce them without taking into account the specific requirements of the question. Holistic essay marking credits learners’ opinions. Holistic assessment, unlike content based marking, does not penalise language inadequacies as the emphasis is on the following: ° the construction of an argument; « the appropriate selection of factual evidence to support such an argument; and e the learner's interpretation of the question. Assessment procedures of an essay 1. Keep the synopsis in mind when assessing the essay. 2. During the first reading of the essay ticks need to be awarded for a relevant introduction (indicated by a bullet in marking guideline/ memorandum) each of the main points/aspects that is properly contextualised (also indicated by bullets in marking guideline/ memorandum) a relevant conclusion (indicated by a bullet in marking guideline/ memorandum) e.g. in an answer where there are 5 main points there will be 7 ticks. 3. The following additional symbols can also be used: introduction, main aspects and conclusion not properly contextualised /\ . wrong statement ° irrelevant statement e¢ repetition R * analysis lav ° — interpretation “lV Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 2 DBE/2013 SCE - 4. The first reading of an essay will also be to determine to what extent the main aspects have been covered and to allocate the content level (on the matrix). c LEVEL 3 e The second reading of an essay will relate to the level (on the matrix) of presentation. Cc LEVEL 3 P LEVEL 1 e Allocate an overall symbol and mark with the use of the matrix. c LEVEL3 | Bt P hr The matrix The criteria according to which the essay will be assessed are organised within a matrix and the matrix will be used to allocate a symbol to an essay. Both the content and presentation axes are divided into eight competency levels. Each has criteria that will be used to assess an essay. Copyright reserved
History/HG/P2 Downloaded from hlayiso.com SCE - 4 DBE/2013 PRESENTATION CONTENT LEVEL 1 Has developed a relevant independent line of argument. Has employed analysis and historical explanation. Well planned and structured essay. Excellent technical skills and evidence. LEVEL 2 Has developed a relevant line of argument. Has employed analysis and historical explanation. Well planned and structured essay. Minor flaws. LEVEL 3 Has developed a relevant line of argument. Has attempted analysis and historical explanation. Well planned and structured essay. Structural flaws. Higher order skills absent. LEVEL 4 Attempts to sustain a line of argument. Has attempted analysis and historical explanation. Essay planned and structured to a certain extent LEVEL 5 Attempts to. sustain a fine of argument. Applied analysis and historicat explanation to acertain extent. Attempt a structure. Technical flaws. LEVEL 6 Line of argument not sustained. Applied analysis and historical explanatio n occasional ly or not at all. No clear structure. LEVEL7 No line of argument. No analysis and historical explanation. No structure. LEVEL 8 No attempt to answer the question. LEVEL 1 Question has been tully answered. Content selection fully relevant to line of argument. At 47-50 A 43-46 A- 40 - 42 LEVEL 2 Question has been answered. Content selection relevant to line of argument. 43-46 40-42 38 - 39 a" TOORAMIOGS 160 — 200 140 - 159 120 ~ 139 100-119 80-99 67-79 60 - 66 50-59 40-49 0-39 LEVEL 3 Question answered to a great extent. Content adequately covered and relevant. B+ 38-39 36 - 37 B- 35 C+ 33 - 34 LEVEL 4 Question posed is recognisable in answer. Content selection and control flawed. Omissions and wrelevant content selections. Cr 33 -— 34 31-32 D+ 28-29 LEVEL 5 Content selection does relate to the question, but do not answer it. Omissions in coverage. Lacks control. 30 26 ~ 27 E+ 23 — 24 LEVEL 6 Question inadequately addressed. Sparse content. D- 25 21-22 E- 20 LEVEL 7 Question inadequately addressed or not at all. Inadequate content. Irrelevant to a great extent. } | _! 13-19 LEVEL 8 No relevant content selection. Totally flawed G 07-12 H 0-6 Copyright reserved Please 4 turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 5 DBE/2013 SCE-; SECTION A ESSAY QUESTIONS MARKERS MUST BE AWARE THAT THE CONTENT OF THE ANSWER WILL BE GUIDED BY THE TEXTBOOKS IN USE AT THE PARTICULAR CENTRE | CANDIDATES MAY HAVE ANY OTHER RELEVANT INTRODUCTION AND OR CONCLUSION THAN THOSE INCLUDED IN A SPECIFIC ESSAY MARKING GUIDELINES IN ASSESSING THE OPEN-ENDED SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS, CANDIDATES SHOULD BE GIVEN CREDIT FOR ANY OTHER RELEVANT RESPONSE | a en Seemann — Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 6 SCE- QUESTION 1: AFRICA IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY QUESTION 1A Explain how a combination of different factors contributed to the process of decolonisation of several African states in the 1960s. SYNOPSIS The answer must indicate to what extent a combination of different factors contributed to process of decolonisation of several African states in the 1960s. Candidates should refer to both external and internal factors. They need to develop the identified factors in order to support their answer. NB: The main aspects (bullets) must be used to address the requirements of the question and to develop a relevant line of argument. A mere stating of facts is inadequate. MAIN ASPECTS e Introduction - Candidates need to indicate how a combination of different factors contributed to the process of decolonisation of several Africa states. ELABORATION e Weakening of the Colonial Powers: can refer to any aspects e.g. Former colonial powers (esp. France and Britain) humiliated during WWII Loss of Asian colonies Cost of colonies — French and British - willing to invest large sums required to develop African colonies when faced with post-war reconstruction at home e New Balance of Power: can refer to any aspects e.g. Atlantic Charter, New superpowers — USA and USSR -— hostile to European colonialism e Creation of the United Nations Pressure universal suffrage (especially newly independent Asian countries International Declaration of Rights e Emergence of a more radical African nationalism: may refer to any aspects e.g. Pan-African movement gaining momentum during WWII years Manchester Conference 1945 Bandung Conference 1955 Emergence of mass parties in some African countries, etc. e Urbanisation/Growth of radical working class: may refer to any aspects e.g. Response to wartime experiences Urbanisation Industrialisation led to strikes in most African urban centres Youth in particular challenge the slow pace of change ‘Collaboration’ of middle class Africans with colonial powers etc. Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com a DBE/2013 SCE — History/HG/P2 Spread of Education: may refer to any aspects e.g. Combined with growing awareness of 'Western' concepts of freedom, democracy Middle class Africans eager to bring about change Conclusion — Candidates should tie up their line of argument. [50] Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 8 DBE/2013 SCE- QUESTION 1B The hopes and ambitions of the Organisation of Unity (OAU) have not been attained since its formation in 1963. Do you agree with this statement? Critically discuss. SYNOPSIS The answer must indicate whether the candidate agrees or disagrees with the statement. Candidates need to support their line of argument by assessing the achievements and shortcomings of the OAU. The candidate may choose to agree or disagree with the statement but both the achievements and shortcomings should be critically discussed. NB: The main aspects (bullets) must be used to address the requirements of the question and to develop a relevant line of argument. A mere stating of facts is inadequate. MAIN ASPECTS e Introduction - Candidates need to take a line of argument and indicate how they intend to develop that line of argument by supporting it with relevant evidence. ELABORATION e Aims of the OAU Unity and solidarity; Better standards of living; Freedom and sovereign independence; Decolonisation; Meaningful international relations. e Achievements — may use any examples to illustrate the achievements United front; African Bank Support to liberation groups; Isolated apartheid South Africa; Settled border disputes; Problems with refugees; Increased economic cooperation; Any other relevant achievement e Shortcomings — may use any examples to illustrate shortcomings Disunity; Rivalry between member states; Could seldom prevent clashes between states Lack of financial contribution Military coups; Any other relevant shortcoming e Conclusion — Candidates should tie up their argument. Copyright reserved [50]
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 9 DBE/2013 SCE - QUESTION 2: THE RISE OF SOVIET RUSSIA QUESTION 2A Explain to what extent Lenin's economic policies transformed Russia from 1917 te 1924. SYNOPSIS Candidates should indicate to what extent Lenin's economic policies namely the War Communism and the New Economic Plan (NEP) transformed Russia from 1917 to 1924. Both policies should be discussed. NB: The main aspects (bullets) must be used to address the requirements of the question and to develop a relevant line of argument. A mere stating of facts is inadequate. MAIN ASPECTS e* Introduction - Candidates should indicate to what extent Lenin's economic policies transformed Russia from 1917 to 1924 and must suggest how they intend to substantiate their chosen line of argument. ELABORATION e: War Communism and agriculture Aim: to feed Red Army and industrial workers State ownership of land Fixed food prices Requisitioning of food No hoarding allowed Use of Cheka to enforce policy Decrease in agricultural production, etc. e War Communism and industry Nationalisation of all industries and banks Workers Committees managed the industries Working day increased from 8-11 hours Labour could be redeployed to where it was needed Decrease in production due to untrained committees, etc. e NEP and agriculture Aim: to win back the support of peasants Land could be rented and peasants employed Tax paid to government Surplus can be sold on the open market Requisitioning of food abolished A Kulak class emerged Increased agricultural production, etc. Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 10 SCE - NEP and industry Industries with less than 20 workers privatised Larger industries remained under state ‘control Emergence of NEPMEN (a business class) Increased industrial output, etc. Financial Reforms Taxation more capitalistic Banks created Foreign trade increased 250%, etc. Conclusion — Candidates should tie up their line of argument. Copyright reserved DBE/2013 {50}
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 11 DBE/2013 SCE — QUESTION 2B It was Stalin's statesmanship that paved the way for economic reforms in Russia between 1928 and 1938. Do you agree with this statement? Substantiate your answer. SYNOPSIS Candidates should indicate whether they agree or disagree with the statement. In supporting the statement candidates must explain how Stalin's statesmanship paved the way for economic reforms in Russia. They should use evidence regarding the collectivisation and industrialisation of Soviet Russia under the Five Year Plans to substantiate their argument. Candidates should include the measures, resistance and successes of the Five Year Plans in both the agricultural and industrial spheres. If the candidate disagrees with the statement they need to support their answer with relevant evidence. NB: The main aspects (bullets) must be used to address the requirements of the question and to develop a relevant line of argument. A mere stating of facts is inadequate. MAIN ASPECTS e Introduction - Candidates should indicate whether they agree or disagree with the statement and indicate their line of argument. Any other relevant introduction. ELABORATION e State control of the economy (Gosplan) and Five Year Plans Quotas Targets Planning, etc. e Agricultural transformation as a result of the Five Year Plans Collectivisation Farms Resistance of Kulaks and use of Cheka (state police) to destroy them Successes and failures e {(ndustrial transformation as a result of the Five Year Plans New industries Infrastructure Propaganda/Stakhanovs Use of slave/forced labour Successes and failures e Conclusion - Candidates should tie up their line of argument. Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 12 DBE/2013 SCE - QUESTION 3: THE RISE OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA QUESTION 3A Discuss to what extent the Seven Fat Years led the 1929 Great Depression. SYNOPSIS Candidates should discuss the various causes of the 1929 Great Depression. Focus on the Seven Years and show how this led to the crash of the Stock Market in 1929. NB: The main aspects (bullets) must be used fo address the requirements of the question and to develop a relevant line of argument. A mere stating of ‘facts’ is inadequate. MAIN ASPECTS e Introduction - Candidate should indicate to what extent The Seven Fat Years led to the great Depression of 1929. ELABORATION e Seven Fat Years — a brief description can be given of the rise of the American economy (e.g. motor industry, consumer goods, communication, theatre and film industry or any other relevant factors) Only a discussion of Seven Fat Year without reference to weaknesses would be inadequate. e Over-speculation: Share prices had risen dramatically during 1920s Millions of people wanting to own shares had increased ‘Buying on the margin’ allowed those with very little money to buy shares Value of shares pushed to an artificial high, etc. e Overproduction Due to mass production techniques Ceiling reached on domestic consumption but production remained high Led to false impression of productivity and economic confidence , etc. e Uneven distribution of weaith Not everyone benefited during the 1920s (especially agriculture, old industries, Afro Americans) There was a limit to the consumer driven boom (i.e. not everyone could afford a new car, radio, fridge etc). The domestic market could not keep pace with production, etc. e Republican policies All of the above problems were made worse by the Republican's Laissez faire economic policies e.g. Tariff Policy - Europe applied their own tariffs in response to USA's protective tariffs. Business could not export surplus goods when domestic market became saturated. Business and banks were not regulated allowing for unsound (and corrupt) business practices, etc. ¢ Conclusion - Candidates should tie up their tine of argument. 2 [50] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 13 SCb QUESTION 3B The New Deal had far reaching consequences for the United States of America. Evaluate the accuracy of this statement in the context of Roosevelt's New Deal policy. SYNOPSIS Candidates should indicate their line of argument after evaluating the statement. Candidates should refer to the impact of Roosevelt's New Deal. Candidates should refer to the impact of the New deal on the USA. An evaluation of Roosevelt's measures of relief, recovery and reform should be highlighted. NB: The main aspects (bullets) must be used to address the requirements of the question and to develop a relevant line of argument. A mere stating of ‘facts’ is inadequate. MAIN ASPECTS Introduction - Candidates should indicate their line of argument and state the reasons for Roosevelt's New Deal policy. ELABORATION The consequences of the New Deal policy should be given. Relief measures and its positive and negative impact e.g. Civilian Conservation Corps - mass job creation, e.g. reforestation Public Works Administration -public works construction Civil Works Administration -created jobs at minimum pay Works Progress Administration -mass job creation Home Owners' Loan Corporation - loans granted to home owners Tennessee Valley Authority -mass employment, etc. Recovery and its positive and negative impact e.g. Agricultural Adjustment Act - plan food production and guaranteed reasonable food prices Farm Credit Act - repay mortgages National Recovery Administration and Act - codes for owners, producers and workers, etc. Reform measures and its positive and negative impact e.g. Bank holiday - Reconstruction Finance Corporation Security Exchanges Act - rules for shares market National Labour Relations Act - labour legislation Social Security Act - welfare system Wagner Act - trade unions, etc. Conclusion - Candidates should tie up their line of the argument. Copyright reserved DBE/2013 [50] Please turn over
History/HG/P2 Downloaded from hlayiso.com 14 DBE/2013 SCE- SECTION B: SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS MARKING SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS * In marking all source-based questions credit needs to be given to any other valid and relevant viewpoints, arguments, evidence or examples. e Inthe allocation of marks emphasis should be placed on addressing the requirements of the question. e Inthese marking guidelines the requirements of the question (skills that need to be addressed) as well as the level of the question are indicated in italics. LEVELS OF SOURCE-BASED QUESTIONS LEVEL 1 (L. 1) Extract evidence from sources LEVEL 2 (L 2) Straightforward interpretations by using evidence from one source and broader knowledge to show an understanding of the period/event/issue. LEVEL 3 (L 3) Straightforward interpretations by using evidence from more than one source and broader knowledge to show an understanding of the period/event/issue. LEVEL 4 (L 4) Complex interpretations often involving more than one source.. These questions look at aspects such as bias, reliability, usefulness, the use of organising concepts (similarity and difference; cause and consequence; chronology; change and continuity) to explain contrasts, comparisons, differing points of view and as a last step using these insights to write a paragraph or in other words, to write a piece of history based on the evidence in the sources. Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 15 DBE/2013 SCE ~ QUESTION 4: AFRICA IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY 41 4.1.1 4.1.2 WHAT COMMON CHALLENGES DID THE AFRICAN STATES FACE AFTER THEY GAINED INDEPENDENCE IN THE 1960S? ‘a) [Extract evidence from Source 4A — L7] Values of participation Accommodation of political opponents The spirit of tolerance It did not give them as much power as it gave to their predecessors Not easy to make the transition from authoritarian system to parliamentary democracy (3 x 1) (3) (b) [Interpretation and explanation of evidence of Source 4A — L2] (i) Ethnicity The ruling party did not cater for the interests of all different ethnic groups Leaders could not cope with nationalistic demands of different ethnic groups Any other relevant response . (ii) Economic challenges Leaders found it difficult to get investors The government is blamed for the failure of one-product economies Mismanagement/greed/corruption/ ineffective financial policies Colonial rulers reluctant to invest in newly independent African states Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) (c) [Interpretation of evidence in Source 4A — L3] e The army in a country that is not neutral towards political parties e The army was used as an instrument to maintain or gain political power e Any other relevant response (1 x 2)(2) (a) [interpretation of evidence from Source 4B - L2] e Only that one product provides an income to be used to buy imported goods e If the price of the product falls on the international market there is no income to pay for imported goods e Lack of diversification led to under-development e Any other relevant response ( (b) [Use of background knowledge to explain evidence from Source 4B — Lo e Inthe 1970s the prices of raw minerals on the international market began to fall e This meant that the exports from African countries e.g. typical crops like cocoa, coffee and cotton as well as minerals like copper brought the African countries less money as compared to previous years e Poor exchange rate meant more money was paid for goods Led to increase in production costs e Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) Copyright reserved Please once
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 16 DBE/2013 SCE - (c) [Analysis of evidence to come up with a solution — L2] They needed to look at building secondary economies/ industrialise to ensure a lower demand for imported manufactured goods Develop skills of population and try to provide a demand for goods that could then be manufactured locally Any other relevant response (1 x 2) (2) 4.1.3 (a) [Extraction of evidence from Source 4C — L1] Indigenous systems Islamic types Christian types European religious models European secular models (any 3 x 1) (3) (b) [Provide solutions to problems identified in Source 4C - L2] eoeeeve Select problem e.g. (No marks given for selection) Millions of young people and adults received no education at all Education was not equally assessable to all segments of society Females were under-represented at all levels Rural areas were far worse than urban areas For a variety of reasons some ethnic or linguistic groups were inadequately served. Too often the curricula and methods of instruction remain bookish and lacked relevance to local realities and problems confronting Africa. Qualified teachers were in short supply. Adequately furnished school facilities, libraries and equipment were either non-existent or inadequate Solutions: Implemented compulsory education up to grade 9 Built more schools less prestige projects Abolished discrimination along gender lines Extended infrastructure to isolated rural areas Acknowledge equality of linguistic and ethnic groups Implemented outcomes-based education/ determined skills required in the country Built more pre-vocational schools Built teacher training colleges Got privately owned economies involved in sponsoring the future industry etc. Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 17 DBE/2013 SCE-. (c) [Determine reliability of Source 4C — L3] Candidates can state either reliable and/ or not reliable. In answering this question candidates need to interrogate the origin of the source and state the extent to which the source is biased. They need to support their answer with relevant evidence. RELIABLE e Evidence provided is typical/ supported by evidence in other sources ¢ The authors are Africans with experience of the African challenges e Any other relevant response OR NOT RELIABLE e Itis a biased/one-sided point of view « Itcan be seen as generalisations e Any other relevant response (2 x 2)(4) (a) [Interpretation of mood in a poetic Source 4D — L2] e Any word that indicates a mostly negative/dark/pessimistic/downbeat/ depressing mood (any 1 x 2) (2) (b) [Determine usefulness of evidence from Source 4D — L3] Candidates can state either useful and/ or not useful. In answering the question candidates need to interrogate the relevance and reliability of the source as well as to state to what extent the source is biased. They need to support their answers with relevant evidence. USEFUL e Itis a primary source written by a person who experienced these conditions It provides insight into how people felt about what happened It gives an idea of the grave perils people had to face Any other relevant response OR NOT USEFUL « tis biased/one-sided/a single point of view e It an overly emotional and an unbalanced point of view e Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) Copynght reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 18 DBE/2013 SCE — Memorandum (c) Analysis of evidence to explain agreement or disagreement — L2] Candidates can state either agree or disagree. They need to support their answers with relevant evidence. AGREE ° Lawlessness is spreading ° Selfishness is the rule . And women and jewellery e Education suffers ° Wealth abounds/ amass wealth . Any other relevant answer OR DISAGREE ° Many of the aspects referred to were legacies of the colonial period ° Prestige projects was an indication of independence and development ° Backwardness and underdevelopment was mainly caused by colonial powers ° Any other relevant answer (any 4 x 2) (2) 4.1.5 [Compare sources to determine similarities — L3] e Source 4A implies leaders wanted more power as they were used to authoritarian political culture while Source 4D highlights a grim view of Africa ¢ Difficulty according to Source 4A with values of participations while Source 4D shows a lack of consultations and participation e Source 4A outlines a spirit of tolerance while Source 4D talks about a sense of abandonment e According to Source 4A there was civilian intervention in military matters while Source 4D shows lawlessness e Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) DEPARTRENT OF BASIC EDUCATION 2013 -06- 06 PRIVATE BAG X 110 PRETORIA 0004 PUBLIC EXAMINA Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 19 DBE/2013 SCE — 4.1.6 [Extract evidence from all sources and use own knowledge fo organise information in a structured paragraph — L4] Use the holistic rubric below and the following to allocate a mark. The paragraph must be based on the evidence from relevant sources and own knowledge. Candidates can refer to the following: Transition to parliamentary democracy Military coups/One-party states Africanisation/localisation Arbitrary drawing up of borders of African states Ethnicity Many African countries depended on one or two exports to earn money to buy imports When the price of these exports fell, these economies faced huge problems Millions of young people and adults received no education Education was not equally assessable to all segments of society Females were under-represented at all levels Rural areas were far worse than urban areas For a variety of reasons some ethnic or linguistic groups were inadequately served. ¢ Too often the curricula and methods of instruction remain bookish and lacked relevance to local realities and problems confronting Africa. Qualified teachers were in short supply Adequately furnished school facilities, libraries and equipment were either non- existent or inadequate eoeoeeee @eeseees e Poverty/AlDS/few hospitals, doctors nurses e Urbanisation ¢ Poor infrastructure e Any other relevant response no es ¢ Cannot extract (relevant) evidence from sources bs Py LEVEL1 |° Extracts evidence from ‘sources in a very elementary manner Marks: 0-3 bed S] * Orcannot report on topic “o7 Fil e Uses evidence/or own knowledge partially to report on topic me TT} of i ¢ Extracts evidence from sources that is mostly relevant i LEVEL 2 : Evidence relates to a large extent to the topic. Marks: +6 _ Uses evidence from sources and own knowledge in a very basic manner. « £xtracts relevant evidence from sources Evidence relates very well to the topic. LEVEL 3 | + Uses evidence from sources and own knowledge very effectively | Marks: 7-10 in an organised paragraph « That shows an understanding of the topic. (10) [50) / Copynght reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 20 DBE/2013 SCE - QUESTION 5: CIRCUMSTANCES THAT LED TO THE SECOND WORLD WAR 5.1. HOW DID HITLER USE PROPAGANDA TO GAIN SUPPORT FOR THE NAZI PARTY IN THE 1930s? 5.1.1 (a) [Extract evidence from the source — L1] e The SS (Schutz Staffel) e The SA troops e Gestapo (any 2 x 1) (2) (b) [Use of background knowledge — L2] e Hitler ordered the SS to purge the Nazi Party and army e Anyone seemingly ambitious or in opposition to Hitler were killed e Leaders like Ernst Rohm (SA) and Von Schleicher were killed e Any other relevant response (any 1 x 2) (2) (c) [Interpretation of evidence in the Source — L2] « These Germans are spies and informants of the Nazi Party against ordinary German folk e Any other relevant answer (1 x 2) (2) (d) [Interpretation of evidence in the Source - L2] e There was no freedom of choice e« Germany was not a democratic state e Any other relevant answer (any 1 x 2) (2) (e){Interpretation of evidence from the source — L2] They instilled fear into those thinking of resistance They helped to enforce the ban on criticism of Hitler It would lessen the existence of enemies of the Nazi state Germans spied on their fellow citizen who they thought was critical of Hitler or the Nazi state (any 2 x 2) (4) 5.1.2 (a) [Interpretation of evidence of the Source 5B — L2] e Unemployment shows a steady decrease (1 x 2) (2) (b) [interpretation of evidence in the Source — L2] e When unemployment dropped more people supported the Nazi Party e {t showed people that the Nazi Party was delivering on their promises to provide work e Any other relevant answer (any 1 x 2) (2) / Copyright reserved Please turn ove,
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 21 DBE/2013 SCE - (c) [Determine similarities between factors in the source — L3] e Government had to spend increasingly more money to create employment opportunities e A decrease in unemployment necessitated increased government spending e Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) (d) [Determine usefulness of the source — L3] Candidates can state either useful and/ or not useful. In answering the question candidates need to interrogate the relevance and reliability of the source as well as to state to what extent the source is biased. They need to support their answers with relevant evidence. USEFUL e The source provides useful insights into the link between government spending and unemployment e It provides valuable insights into how unemployment decreased in Germany between 1932 to 1938 It shows an increased government spending from 1932 to 1938 e Any other relevant response OR NOT USEFUL « tis a not known how these figures were arrived at e The figures are not exact and could have been manipulated e Any other relevant response (2 x 2) (4) 5.1.3 (a) [Interpretation of evidence from a visual source — L2] e The neat blocks in the photograph shows Hitler emphasized discipline and obedience The photograph shows Hitler as leader of the Germans The Nazi flags and military presence show the power of the State It creates an image of solidarity and a sense of belonging It would fill young men with the desire to be one of the marchers It reinforces Hitler ability to deliver on his promises regarding the development of Germany e It shows the importance of national solidarity e It shows the success of building a new Nazi society e Any other valid response (any 2 x 2) (4) b) [Explanation of a concept — L2] e Showed Germans that the Nazi Party was well organised e Attempted to influence people to think that the Nazi Party was working in the interest of Germany ¢ Any other relevant answer AZX2) (4) Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com Mistory/HG/P2 22 DBE/2013 SCE - (c) [Determine reliability of Source 5C — L3] Candidates can state either reliable and/ or not reliable. In answering this question candidates need to interrogate the origin of the source and state to what extent the source is biased. They need to support their answers with relevant evidence. RELIABLE e Evidence provided is typical/supported by evidence in other sources e Its primary evidence that dates back to the actual event e Any other relevant response OR NOT RELIABLE « The photographer is unknown © Itis a biased/ one-sided point of view/ it could have been pure propaganda e The photos could have been posed e Any other relevant response (2 x 2)(4) 5.1.4 [Comparison of sources to illustrate similarities — L4] e Source 5A shows unemployment decreasing whilst Source 5C indicate one way of decreasing unemployment by taking young men into the army/organised labour Both sources indicate the importance of strict discipline e Both sources indicate the necessity of absolute obedience to Hitler Any other relevant answer (any 2 x 2) (4) Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 23 DBE/2013 SCE - 5.1.5 [Using information from all the sources and own knowledge to construct an argument — L4] Use the holistic rubric below and the following to allocate a mark. e Propaganda was used to reshape peoples beliefs, values and ideas along Nazi lines e Needed to create national solidarity and trusting Hitler was important aspect of propaganda: Source 5C photograph 1 used rallies as shown in the photograph e The Nuremburg rallies, marches and meetings took place to give German's a sense of belonging: Source 5C photograph 1 e It attempted convinced people that every German supported Hitler: Source 5C photograph 1 e {t showed that the Nazi's created order out of chaos: Source 5C photos 1 and 2 e Hitler focused on the youth especially regarding the war effort e Youth felt they were in safe hands, could get jobs and were helping to build a strong Germany: Source 5C photo 2 e Hitler also used the strong tradition of German militarism to attract the youth to join the army e Atrallies uniforms, flags, torches, spades, song, salutes and speeches were used to get support from the Germans e Both coercion and propaganda required tremendous government expense and were linked to ending unemployment: Source 5B e Any other relevant response Cannot extract (relevant) evidence from sources. Extracts evidence from sources in a very elementary manner Or cannot report on topic Uses evidence and or own knowledge partially to report on topic LEVEL 1 Marks: 0-3 « Extracts evidence from sources that is mostly relevant LEVEL2 |° Evidence relates to a large extent to the topic. Marks:4-6 e Uses evidence from sources and own knowledge in a very basic : manner. ¢ Extracts relevant evidence from sources Evidence relates very well to the topic. LEVEL3 |« Uses evidence from sources and own knowledge very effectively | Marks: 7-10 in an organised paragraph that shows an understanding of the topic. (10) [50] Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 24 DBE/2013 SCE - QUESTION 6: INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS AND EVENTS 1945 TO 1970: 6.1 6.1.1 THE COLD WAR HOW DID THE SOVIET UNION REACT TO THE CREATION OF THE NORTH ATLANTIC TREATY ORGANISATION (NATO)? (a) [Extract evidence from a source — L1] To settle any international dispute by peaceful means/ refrain from the threat or use of force. The parties, separately and jointly will maintain and develop their individual and collective capacity to resist an armed attack. The parties will consult whenever their territorial integrity, political independence or security of any of the parties was threatened. The parties agreed that an armed attack against one or more of them in Europe or North America shall be considered an attack against all of them (any 2 x 1) (2) (b) [Interpretation of evidence from Source 6A — L2] ( . their desire to live in peace with all peoples and all governments’ They are resolved to unite their efforts for collective defence... ... Settle any dispute ... by peaceful means’ '_.. to refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force' ‘_... will maintain and develop their capacity to resist armed attack’ ‘... if an armed attack occurs ... will .. take ... such action as deemed necessary’ Any other relevant response (any 1 x 2) (2) c) [Interpretation from Source 6A — L2] Members of NATO wanted to stand together Support each other in case of an armed attack on any one or more members The western powers wanted to prevent communism from spreading to Germany and Western Europe The Cold War created two power blocks namely Western powers and Soviet Union and its supporters “., safeguard freedom of peoples...” “...promote stability and well being....” Any other relevant response (2 x 2) (4) Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 25 DBE/2013 6.4.2 SCE - (d) [Explain the usefulness of Source 6A — L3] Candidates can state either useful and/ or not useful. In answering the question candidates need to interrogate the relevance and reliability of the source as well as to state to what extent the source is biased. They need to support their answers with relevant evidence. USEFUL e It is an extract from the official treaty text e [It provides information on the aims and purposes of NATO e It provides insights into how the western powers reacted in the Cold War e Any other relevant response OR NOT USEFUL e The source is biased/ does not provide a Russian point of view ¢ The information is limited does not give the background to the Cold War e Any other relevant answer (any 2 x 2) (4) (a) [Quote evidence from Source 6B — L1] e The Treaty has a aggressive character and its directed against the USSR e NATO was directed against the USSR (any 1 x 2) (2) (b) [Interpretation of evidence from Source 6B ~ L2] In contradiction with the principles and aims of the United Nations Organisation In contradiction with the Treaty between Great Britain and the Soviet Union In contradiction with the Treaty between France and the Soviet Union In contradiction with the Treaty between the Soviet Union, the United States and Great Britain / the Yalta and Potsdam agreements Any other relevant answer (any 1 x 2) (2) (c) [Determine the value of Source 6B — L3] Candidates can state either valuable and/ or not valuable. In answering the question candidates need to interrogate the relevance and reliability of the source as well as to state to what extent the source is biased. They need to support their answers with relevant evidence. VALUABLE e It provides insights into how the Soviet Union viewed NATO e It provides insights into the reasons for the creation of the Warsaw Pact a mumeempmey e {t assists in the understanding of the Cold War e Any other relevant response OR NOT VALUABLE e tis a biased/ one-sided point of view/ not balanced point of view e It was written for propaganda purposes e ACommunist/ Soviet point of view tes al e Any other relevant response (any bod a) (4) Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 26 DBE/2013 SCE- 6.1.3 (a) [Determine the messages of a cartoon — L3] e NATO is an aggressive and not a defensive alliance e NATO is powered by American dollars and on its way to the Soviet Union/ USA is financing NATO to attack the USSR e NATO is pretending to be a peaceful alliance e Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) (b) [Determine interpretation of event in a cartoon — L3] Candidates can state either biased and/ or not biased. In answering the question candidates need to interrogate the origin and reliability of the source and explain to what extent the source is biased. They need to support their answers with relevant evidence. BIASED e The USA was providing European countries and NATO with financial aid (dollars) to extend its own influence and isolate the Soviet Union e NATO was an alliance of pro-democratic countries trying to use capital to buy friendship e — Any other relevant response NOT BIASED e The USA was providing European countries with financial aid (dollars) to help them recover after the Second World War but not to attack the Soviet Union e The NATO Treaty clearly states that it will not attack any country or use force or armed attack unless one or more of its members is attacked e There was no need for NATO to pretend being aggressive Even though America had a nuclear bomb NATO's ability to defend themselves — much less take offensive action against any country was severely limited e Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) 6.1.4 (a) [Extract evidence from a source — L1] The desire for a system of collective security NATO provided a threat of another war NATO created a menace to the national security of peace loving states NATO necessitated the need to safeguard the security and peace of Europe e To promote friendship, co-operation and mutual assistance (any 2 x 1) (2) (b) [Extract evidence from a source — L1] People's Republic of Albania People's Republic of Bulgaria Hungarian People’s Republic The German Democratic Republic The Polish People’s Republic The Rumanian People's Republic The USSR The Czechoslovak Republic any Dep Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 97 DBE/2013 SCE- (c) [Interpretation of evidence — L2] e Negatively e Concerned e Communist threat looming e Any other relevant answer (any 1 x 2) (2) ow) [Interpretation and analysis of evidence from Source 6D — L3] The countries who were members of both military blocs were also members of the UNO The UNO Charter aims to promote peace/ prevent war The UNO Charter aims to create friendly relations amongst world states Any other relevant response (any 1 x 2) (2) (b) [Compare source to provide similarities — L3] SIMILARITIES e Both Treaties profess to secure peace and peaceful relations among European states e Both profess to be guided by the purposes and principles of the Charter of the UNO « Both claim to be defensive and not offensive Both profess to refrain from using force or armed attack unless one or more of its members are being attacked e Both consider an attack on one or more an attack on all e Any other relevant response (any 2 x 2) (4) Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com History/HG/P2 28 DBE/2013 SCE - 6.1.6 [Extract selected evidence and use own knowledge to organise the information in a structured paragraph - L4] Use the holistic rubric below and the following to allocate a mark. The paragraph must be based on the evidence from relevant sources and own knowledge. It can focus on some of the following aspects: e« The Cold War implies action and reaction from both sides as it was a psychological war Events in Europe especially Germany required protective measures The Soviet Union responded negatively towards the founding of NATO It viewed the Treaty's claim to being defenceless as useless/ not justified as no-one threatened or intended to attack its members It states that the Treaty has a clearly aggressive character The establishment of NATO was seen as a military alliance that would have grave international consequences e It says it was in contradiction with the Treaty between Great Britain and the Soviet Union e It says it was in contradiction with the Treaty between France and the Soviet Union e — It says it was in contradiction with the Treaty between the Soviet Union, the United States and Great Britain/the Yalta and Potsdam agreements e Any other relevant response « Cannot extract (relevant) evidence from sources e Extracts evidence from sources in a very elementary manner Marks: 0-3 LEVEL1 |e Orcannot report on topic ° e Uses evidence and or own knowledge partially to report on topic « Extracts evidence from sources that is mostly relevant LEVEL2 |° Evidence relates to a large extent to the topic. Marks: 4-6 Uses evidence from sources and own knowledge in a very basic manner. « Extracts relevant evidence from sources « — Evidence relates very well to the topic. LEVEL3 |e Uses evidence from sources and own knowledge very effectively | Marks: 7-10 in an organised paragraph that shows an understanding of the topic. (10) [50] TOTAL: 200 Copyright reserved

Study this subject

More from Grade 12 History

View all