Downloaded from hlayiso.com
NATIONAL
SENIOR CERTIFICATE
GRADE 12
VISUAL ARTS P1
NOVEMBER 2021
MARKING GUIDELINES
MARKS: 100
TIME: 3 hours
These marking guidelines consist of 20 pages.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Skip to contentAll 2021 papers 





View all





Visual Arts Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2021 Memo (English)
Grade 12 Visual Arts Paper 1 memorandum from the NSC November Exam 2021 (English), 20 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.
Visual Arts · Grade 12 · NSC November Exam · 2021. Memorandum. Read online or download the PDF.
- Subject
- Visual Arts
- Grade
- Grade 12
- Document type
- Memorandum
- Year
- 2021
- Exam period
- NSC November Exam
- Paper
- 1
- Curriculum
- CAPS
- Pages
- 20
- File size
- 471.5 KB
Free to read online, no sign-up needed
Loading document…
Loading document…
1 of 20
This exam
NSC November Exam 2021
Questions in this paper
- Question 1Visual Literacy and Art Analysis40 marks
- Question 2Visual Literacy and Art Analysis20 marks
- Question 3Visual Literacy and Art Analysis20 marks
- Question 4Visual Literacy and Art Analysis20 marks
- Question 5Visual Literacy and Art Analysis20 marks
- Question 6Post-1994 Democratic Identity in South African Art30 marks
Document textSearch extracted text and jump to a page.
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 2 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
INSTRUCTIONS AND INFORMATION
Read the following instructions carefully before commencing marking:
1. These marking guidelines consist of EIGHT answers. Candidates had to
answer any FIVE questions for a total of 100 marks.
2. It is MOST IMPORTANT that allowance is made for the candidates in many
instances:
● Candidates must be given credit for providing their own opinions and
ideas in their answers.
● Credit must also be given for lateral thinking.
● It is also important that arguments and statements are reasoned and
qualified by reference to specific factors.
3. Questions and subsections must be numbered clearly and correctly. Bullets
usually act as guidelines to help structure candidates' answers.
4. Information and artworks discussed in one answer must not be credited if
repeated in other answers but artworks may be cross-referenced.
5. Where applicable, candidates must name the artist and title of each artwork
mentioned. Only ONE mark is allocated for the correct artist and title of work.
ONE mark must be deducted if no comparison is made.
6. Where appropriate candidates may discuss both two-dimensional and three
dimensional artworks in any question.
7. Remember that many candidates will be discussing these examples,
never having seen them before. Markers therefore cannot expect factual,
academic information. They should draw upon their own experiences,
cultures and interpretations of the artworks, within the context of the
question. Therefore markers need to be open-minded and flexible in the
marking process.
GENERAL INFORMATION FOR MARKERS
These marking guidelines serve as a guideline for markers as well as a teaching
tool. Therefore, the guidelines for certain questions are in greater depth, so that
the information may be used as learning material. Other parts of the marking
guideline may merely be a suggested guideline.
● NOTE: Markers are encouraged to reward candidates for what they know, rather
than penalise them for what they don't know.
● Although the information for the questions is given in point form, candidates must
use an essay/paragraph format discussing their information in a holistic manner.
● Candidates must answer all the questions in FULL SENTENCES or
PARAGRAPHS, according to the requirements of each question. Answers in point
form cannot receive full marks. Full marks cannot be given if the title or artist is
incorrect.
● Markers must refer to the Visual Arts CAPS document page 45 for a guideline to
assess the levels of achievement.
Copyright reserved
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 3 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
Assessing candidates' ability to analyse and respond to examples of visual culture
ACHIEVEMENT TOPIC 3 VISUAL CULTURE STUDIES
RATING CODE
● Demonstrates exceptional ability to respond to and analyse artworks in
Outstanding relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
80–100% ● Shows outstanding ability in the use of appropriate visual arts
terminology.
● Demonstrates extremely well-developed writing and research skills in
the study of art.
● Shows exceptional insight and understanding and uses divergent
approaches.
● Demonstrates a well-developed ability to respond to and analyse
Meritorious artworks in relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
70–79% ● Shows excellent ability in the use of appropriate visual arts
terminology.
● Demonstrates highly developed writing and research skills in the study of
art.
● Shows excellent insight and understanding.
● Demonstrates substantial ability to respond to and analyse artworks in
Substantial relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
60–69% ● Shows substantial competence in the use of appropriate visual arts
terminology.
● Demonstrates well-developed writing and research skills in the study of
art.
● Shows a good level of insight and understanding.
● Demonstrates moderate ability to respond to and analyse artworks in
Moderate relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
50–59% ● Shows moderate competence in the use of appropriate visual arts
terminology.
● Demonstrates competent writing and research skills in the study of art
● Shows a fair level of insight and understanding.
● Demonstrates adequate ability to respond to and analyse artworks in
Adequate relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
40–49% ● Shows adequate competence in the use of appropriate visual arts
terminology.
● Demonstrates adequate writing and research skills in the study of
art.
● Shows an adequate level of insight and understanding.
● Demonstrates only basic ability to respond to and analyse artworks in
Elementary relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
30–39% ● Shows little ability in the use of appropriate visual arts terminology.
● Demonstrates basic writing and research skills in the study of art.
● Shows an elementary level of insight and understanding.
● Demonstrates little or no ability to respond to and analyse artworks in
Not achieved relation to their cultural, social, political and historical contexts.
0–29% ● Shows extremely limited ability in the use of appropriate visual arts
terminology.
● Demonstrates limited writing and research skills in the study of art.
● Shows little or no understanding or insight.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 4 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
CANDIDATES MUST ANSWER ANY FIVE QUESTIONS.
The following mark allocation must be adhered to when only ONE artwork/artist
has been discussed instead of TWO.
6 marks (max 3)
8 marks (max 5)
10 marks (max 6)
12 marks (max 7)
14 marks (max 8)
20 marks (max 12)
CODES TO BE USED BY MARKERS:
R-Repetition
G-Given
IRR-Irrelevant
I/C- incomplete
QNA- question not answered
NF- or V- not focused/vague
1 mark will be deducted if the candidate doesn’t include the correct name/title of
artwork/artist
Due to the colour differences of the question papers in the different provinces,
the provinces have to adapt the marking guidelines for interpretation.
QUESTION 1: THE VOICE OF EMERGING ARTISTS
1.1 Candidates must compare FIGURE 1a and FIGURE 1b by referring to the
following: No comparison -1 mark
Narrative/Stories
FIGURE 1a: The story is an intimate consult between a mother with a child
and the iSangoma (Xhosa Culture). The composition is set in the interior of a
room/traditional home that appears to be private and confidential. A
traditional home like feel. (Animal skins on walls, floor looks like mud floor,
sitting on the
floor). Sibisi focused on abundance.
FIGURE 1b: The story is about a group of Sangomas (Zulu) enjoying a feast
of a variety of food (chicken, pap and beers). The composition reflects the
interaction/conversation between five seated Sangomas on the floor of a
modern house and a figure standing in the doorway. doorway. In both
paintings the sangoma is present as well as sitting on the floor in the
presence of the main figure. The feast for initiation/welcoming of new
iSangoma to group (young man bringing traditional ceremonial bear in bear
vessel in door opening). The feast consists of whole chicken cooked with just
salt and ‘pap’. The green enamel bowl is used to wash hands for a cleaning
ceremony. Both works are created in a simple illustrative narrative style with
underlying moral stories.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 5 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
Visual clues indicating the 25-year time difference
The complimentary colours of purple and yellow in FIGURE 1a differs to
the bright colours of red and green in Figure 1b. The portrayal of the
figures in FIGURE 1a is formal as the woman is consulting the
iSangoma. In FIGURE 1b is an informal feast held by a group of
iSangomas, with an array of food and modern beer (could be muti or
liquor) in a crate, labeled with the SAB logo. Their clothing is more
modern but still traditional whereas in FIGURE 1a the iSangoma wears
clothing made entirely of natural organic material. The modern items
are the pallet/table on the floor, curtain and shelves with bottles on in
the background, and the opened door. In a. people sit on the ground in
a traditional hut from the past. The Sangoma in Pemba’s work is male
where as more women are taking up this profession in recent years.
Formal art elements. Candidates can discuss any art elements like colour,
line, shape etc.
Colour: FIGURE 1a: There is a variety of earthy colours used such as
browns, ochres and yellows which dominate the artwork. Complementary
colours such as purples and yellows are in the foreground and background.
The orange blanket that covers the baby contrasts and complements the
blues hues of the mother's head wrap/scarf. The cooler colours in the
background create perspective. The use of white in the garments and the
beadwork of the iSangoma/Healer's attire draws the viewer's attention to the
figures. The women and child are a little larger than the iSangoma on the
right. The vertical line of the wall behind the iSangoma and the curtain behind
the mother and child create depth and separate the background from the
foreground. The background is painted in softer and lighter tones to create
depth.
The diagonal lines of the iSangoma's legs draws the eye into the picture
plane creating depth. Sangomas extended hand towards the mother and child
indicating his acknowledgment of her. She is looking down and he is facing
the viewer. Repetition of circular shapes in the composition. Heads of the
mother, child, sangoma and headdress, as well as circular shapes in
background. Same repetition of circular shapes in 1b. The heads of the men,
the bowls on table and floor and the drums. 1a and 1b has a horizontal effect
with the people almost sitting in a line while 1.b also has vertical lines from the
curtains, door
and drummer on the right. Figures in 1.b almost stylised while 1. a is a more
informal respectful depiction.
FIGURE 1b: The warm reds dominate in the composition which is contrasted
by the black and white traditional attire of the Sangomas. The brown animal
printed on the head wrap and the drum represents the African tradition. The
green bowl/dish of water complement the red surrounding. The green is also
echoed on the door creating a sense of balance in the painting. Depth is
created by the arrangement of the green bowl, table and beer crate in the
foreground and the five figures in middle ground against the red wall in
background. Which is further enhanced by the figure at the open doorway
including the landscape behind him. Depth/perspective is created by the
diagonal at the door as well as the line that separates the floor and the red
wall. The bright colours and the busy interaction of the Sangomas against the
plain darker red wall also creates depth.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 6 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
Focal point
FIGURE 1a:
The iSangoma's traditional/ decorative attire and hand gestures make him the
focal point. Candidates can discuss any other art elements as long as they
substantiate their answers. Focus is placed on the lady with the baby (white
shirt and circular movement of red swaddle around the baby and lady’s arm)
which leads our eye to the iSangoma. The Sangoma is flanked by animal skin
and skull placing emphasis on him. Fig.1a the mother is also wearing.
FIGURE 1b:
The seated, front-facing figure (lady) in the middle is the focal point. She is
the only figure wearing a plain white top. Candidates can discuss any other
art elements as long as they substantiate their answers. The focus is on the
food (white ‘pap’ balls). The light source shines on it with hands reaching out.
Mood/atmosphere
FIGURE 1a:
The mood is gloomy, spiritual, intimate, and cultural within a traditional
setting. The woman's posture and facial expressions convey a concerned,
caring, protective, submissive, respectful, accepting, withdrawn, and quiet
mood. The iSangoma is represented as powerful, energetic, confident, and
lively. The mother and the iSangoma have contrasting emotions/expressions.
The atmosphere of the painting shows an expressive, intimate, private, warm,
cozy setting due to the colours and style used as well as the arrangement of
figures in the painting. The woman creates a calm, apprehensive and
protective atmosphere with her hand on the baby’s head. atmosphere
whereas the iSangoma is livelier due to his expressive gestures and facial
expression.
FIGURE 1b:
The painting has a celebratory and festive atmosphere. The mood is serious
and the Sangomas are busy eating and enjoying the feast. The atmosphere is
one of unity and connectivity with each other. (10)
1.2 Candidates must write an essay in which they discuss the artwork of any
TWO artists (ONE artwork per artist) that have captured interesting themes.
Provide the name of the artists and the title of the artworks. Candidates must
discuss ONE artwork per artist.
They must consider the following in their essay:
Subject matter
Influences
Formal art elements
Media and technique
The message /meaning of the artwork (10)
[20]
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 7 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
QUESTION 2: SOUTH AFRICAN ARTISTS INFLUENCED BY AFRICAN AND/OR
INDIGENOUS ART FORMS
2.1 Candidates must discuss the interpretation of the theme of soccer by
considering the following:
FIGURE 2a: Zamani Romeo Makhanya, Soccer's Rhythm, ink print on
cotton paper, 2010.
FIGURE 2b: Jackson Hlungwane, Christ Playing Soccer, carved wood,
date unknown.
FIGURE 2c: Umberto Boccioni, Dynamism of a Soccer Player, oil on
canvas, 1913.
How the two dimensional and three dimensional use of media
affects the portrayal of the theme.
FIGURE 2a: Vibrant colours are printed on cotton paper which is visually
pleasing and creates an exciting atmosphere present at a soccer game. To
the viewer, it seems as if the spectators, as well as the players, are portrayed
simultaneously on one level and almost appear to overlap each other.
Fragmenting the faces, bodies and clothing by using sharp vertical lines
create a busy mood and contributes to the energetic playing of the game.
The figures are painted in a stylised, figurative and distorted manner and are
almost cubistic which is evident in the fragmented, simplified faces and
figures. Is divided in half by a very strong vertical line and uses two
contrasting colours red and green. Indicating day and night - soccer is a big
part of African lifestyle as well as two competing teams. Footprints are visible.
2D work caught the ‘spirit and energy of soccer’
FIGURE 2b: A three dimensional sculpture made from indigenous wood
portrays Christ playing soccer. The arms are folded around the body to create
movement. The feet are clad in soccer shoes and the ball is perfectly
balanced between them. Incised into the wood are carvings depicting a badge
on the jersey/shirt. The artist has used a subtractive method when carving the
wooden sculpture. Wood is a long-lasting, hardy, sturdy medium. The wood
changes colour with age. The natural grain of the wood is visible creating
texture. The surface has been polished as the wood is shiny. Curved lines are
used. Capture a moment in soccer-playing, using the flow of the grain of the
wood to suggest the position of the arms legs, feet and ball, and focusing on
the ball.
FIGURE 2c: If one looks closer the image of a calf muscle can be seen in the
centre of the painting. Feet are the most important factor in the playing of
soccer and through the dynamic diagonal lines and shape the artist managed
to portray animated movement. Fragmentation, light beams, repetition of
shapes, and stippled brush marks suggest movement.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 8 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
Energy/rhythm/movement portrayed in the style and technique of
the work:
FIGURE 2a: The mask-like faces are typically African. In the centre of the
composition as well as on the right side of the print, hands are seen playing
on a drum. It may symbolise merriment, happiness, excitement and
movement. The repetition of the patterns on the clothing depicts traditional
African motifs. The repetition of the feet symbolises the physical energetic
kicking actions of a soccer player. A soccer ball as the sun becomes a
metaphor for soccer being the light of their lives in Africa. Three other round
shapes are visible representing the movement of a bouncing ball. Rhythm is
created by the imagery used which can be seen in the repetition of the feet,
the playing of the drums and the sounds made by the vuvuzelas. The portraits
are portrayed with open mouths either singing or playing actively. Rhythm is
also created by the repetition of the colours, the bouncing balls and the many
feet.
FIGURE 2b: In the sculpture, a figurative, distorted, simplified figure is carved
from wood. An expressionistic naïve approach is evident in the hard facial
features, large head and shortened legs. Potential movement is seen in the
kinetic energy of the arms and legs. Line is created by the arms that are
wrapped around the body of the soccer player. The legs of the figure are
static and the soccer ball is held between his feet. The figure is preparing to
move or dribble the ball.
FIGURE 2c: In this Futuristic work, Boccioni wanted to capture movement
and energy. The artist used fragmented shapes painted in vibrant contrasting
blues and oranges. This adds to the energy and movement in the painting.
Diagonal lines seem to radiate from the centre giving it an explosive image.
African and/or Western influences
FIGURE 2a: In the centre of the print is a large egg that may symbolise
fragility, new life, and hope created by a game that brings people together.
The image of the two vuvuzelas, usually used at a soccer match, is teams
that play against one another. Bright colours, African textile pattern on
clothing/black skin colour/Modern African hairstyles/masklike faces
FIGURE 2b: The sculptor used indigenous wood of South Africa to create a
modern soccer player dressed in soccer gear. The method is typical African
carving, depicting naive distortion of the body. Typical African woodcarving
techniques/Western-style soccer clothing
FIGURE 2c: The influence of Cubism and Pointillism on Futurism can be seen
The fragmentation of the shapes creates movement and vibrancy. It depicts
the energy of a soccer game. Western Futurism movement techniques.
Expressionism (10)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 9 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
2.2 Candidates must describe the work of any TWO South African artists whose
work reflects indigenous and/or African symbols and art forms. Candidates
must name the artists and titles of the artworks.
They may use some of the following in their essay:
Subject matter
Influences
Formal art elements
Style
Message and/or meaning (10)
[20]
QUESTION 3: SOCIO-POLITICAL ART, INCLUDING RESISTANCE ART OF THE
1970s AND 1980s
3.1 Candidates must compare any TWO artworks from FIGURES 3a, 3b and 3c by
referring to the following guidelines: no comparison -1 mark
FIGURE 3a: Willie Bester, Speelman (Play man), mixed media sculpture, 1995.
FIGURE 3b: Ayanda Mabulu, Infant Democracy, oil paint and gold leafing on
canvas, 2017.
FIGURE 3c: Khaya Witbooi, Gun Shake, mixed media, 2017.
Line, colour, form and pattern
FIGURE 3a: The figure holds a gun in a diagonal line while pointing it to the
ground. The vertical line of the stand holding the drip bottle form a contrast to
the solid form of the figure. Colour can be seen in the turquoise, orange and
green spray paint on the metal sculpture imitating camouflaged clothing soldiers
normally wear. The three-dimensionality of the sculpture has a lifelike form.
Pattern and texture are created by the small individual parts of metal objects
used to create the sculpture. No feelings/oppressor ready to push back any
upheaval. Metal cold and unapproachable.
FIGURE 3b: The alternating red and gold rays create a pattern. It creates a
vortex of rays, forms a pattern and contrasts with the curvilinear lines of the
drapery of the mother figure. The strong vertical line of the gun symbolises the
power and strength of the mother figure. The red shapes/ribbons are outlined by
a thin black line.
The striking red colour could symbolise blood, violence, love, anger, passion or
danger. Vertical line in the composition is created by a mother figure holding a
machine gun in her right hand while breastfeeding the baby. The soft, silky
clothing and accessories worn by the mother could depict the wealth or royalty
of her cultural/traditional/indigenous roots.
The mother figure and baby are painted in a range of browns. The colour
red/magenta is visible in the headdress and the clothing of the mother
figure.The turquoise and orange in the clothing is repeated in the necklace. Dark
green is used in the gun and repeated in the folds of the fabric/clothing.
Medieval icon art Pieta with gold leaf / Madonna-like African woman figure in
Chinese propaganda poster style.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 10 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
FIGURE 3c: There are a variety of curvilinear lines seen in the hands, the
explosion and faces. There are diagonal lines that imitate an explosion. The
continuous horisontal line divides the picture plane. Contour lines define and
outline the hands, gun, explosion and portraits. There is a dominant use of warm
red, yellow and orange colour throughout the artwork except for the contrasting
ultramarine blue gun/hand. The colours used are arbitrary and non-
representational. The bright yellow used in the background emphasises the
handshake being the focal point.
Style and media:
FIGURE 3a: The use of mixed media like the metal objects combined with real
objects like the bottles and army hat, give the sculpture a mechanical and
almost robotic appearance. The media creates tactile texture and the sculpture
invites the viewer to engage with it.
FIGURE 3b: The style is naturalistic. The flat application of colour in the
background flattens the composition. The use of gold is symbolic of divinity
reminiscent of Early Renaissance artworks.
FIGURE 3c: It is similar to the 60s style of Pop art and typical Post-Modern in
the combination of images. During the 1960's posters, flyers, pamphlets, comic
strips included Memphis designs, Ben Day dots, patterns and cartoon
caricatures. This mixed media artwork is illustrative. Bright, flat colour is applied
in a smooth and mechanical manner.
The focal point consists of a red-coloured hand shaking a blue-coloured hand
that has a pistol emerging as one of the fingers/hand.
The portrayal of the gun in each artwork and its role in relation to the
other images in the artwork:
FIGURE 3a: The gun held by the soldier points toward the ground. This makes
it less violent as it is not directed at anyone. The mask on the face indicates that
there could be chemical substances in the air. The gun becomes a symbol of
defense and not attack. The soldier is being fed or held alive by the bottles
attached to his back. The gun signifies his position as someone fighting in a war
or part of a defense force.
FIGURE 3b: The mother holding a gun is symbolic of protection, security,
power, strength and confidence. The baby represents innocence, vulnerability,
helplessness, love, hope and the future generation.
FIGURE 3c: The image of the gun combined with the hand in a handshake
could mean dishonesty, deceit, deception, cheating, treachery and betrayal.
The handshake placed in the centre of the square format becomes the focal
point. Bullet-like sharks are placed on the bottom right corner. The portraits in
the artwork might be the people in conflict.
How these works address socio-political issues in South Africa?
FIGURE 3a: 'Speelman' may refer to armed men playing a game in a troubled
society. The artist portrays a figure that is armed, masked and carries
substances on his back as life support which may indicate that this is how one
survives in a violent country.
FIGURE 3b: The title Infant Democracy- The term infant refers to a small
child/baby and a democracy refers to a fair/equal country. This could mean that
a parent in a young new democracy must fight for the rights of a child. It could
also refer to our democracy being young and new and needing to be nurtured
and protected like a young child. This image is also paving the way for future
generations in terms of freedom and liberation.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 11 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
FIGURE 3c: There are images of shark-like bullets at the bottom of the
composition symbolic of trickery and deceit. The background has watermarks of
faces ranging from people in history to comical characters. There is a stylised
image of an explosion or gunshot symbolic of tension, hatred, deceit and war.
The cartoon imagery of faces, Ben Day dots and the Memphis design could
show mass production. The black, white and grey image of an explosion is
illustrated in the top left-hand corner. The title 'Gun shake' means that while
they are shaking hands in good faith, the gun is symbolic of deceit/ betrayal. The
gun has malicious intent. Bright Pop-art-like hands-on typical supermarket
advertisement indicates trade and money / as well as shadows of Jan van
Riebeeck, which was on South African money notes in the past. The blue and
pink hands can be a reference to gender roles being either male or female. The
bright colours could indicate that there is no remorse for the traitors, they do not
feel guilty/responsible.
All the artworks ‘deal’ with socio-political issues by means of violence. The
comic’ face in 3c can refer to death as its eye’s are crossed. (10)
3.2 Candidates must write a critical analysis of TWO artworks from TWO different
artists (ONE artwork per artist) whose themes reflect socio-political issues. They
must name the artist and the title of the artwork.
They must consider the following:
Subject matter
Formal elements of art
Message/meaning (10)
[20]
QUESTION 4: ART, CRAFT AND SPIRITUAL WORKS MAINLY FROM RURAL
SOUTH AFRICA
4.1 Candidates must discuss the stories told in FIGURES 4a and 4b by comparing
the following:
FIGURE 4a: Lucky Sibiya, Warrior, woodcut, 1977.
FIGURE 4b: Judus Mahlangu, Baptism, etching, 1975.
Format
FIGURE 4a: Sibiya makes use of a vertical /portrait format that suits the
imagery used. The large figure in the front dominates the vertical format due to
his large elongated body with outstretched hands. Behind him we have a sense
of recession/depth showing the large crowd getting prospectively smaller as
they recede towards the natural landscape format of cattle and rounded huts.
FIGURE 4b: The long horizontal format has been used successfully to show a
close-up view of the gathered group of people witnessing the baptism. The cut-
off view of the figures in this format makes the viewer feel part of the activity,
giving us an understanding of the religious fervor felt by the people standing in
the water.
Focal point
FIGURE 4a: The focal point is the large figure in the foreground with
outstretched arms as it is much larger than the other figures behind it and it fills
up a large part of the composition.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 12 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
FIGURE 4b: The focal point is the preacher in the foreground who is baptising
the person at the bottom of the scene. He is placed in the centre of the
composition, his head is lifted and his gaze is upwards and he is wearing a
contrasting black and white patterned shirt.
Line and texture
FIGURE 4a: Curvilinear lines create the huts in the background and the lines
of the landscape. Vertical lines can be seen in the shapes of the figures. Short,
vertical and horizontal incisions create texture in the background. The diagonal
lines of the outstretched arms create movement and tension in the negative
space. Vertical lines in the middle ground indicate the grass in the field. The
use of lines is stylised and simple. White lines are used to outline the shapes
and figures whereas 4b used dark outlines. The smooth texture of the figures
contrasts with the rough markings of the field.
FIGURE 4b: Horizontal and vertical lines on the clothing create texture and
pattern. Organic lines form the shapes of the figures. The lines help to direct
the viewer's eye in a rhythmic motion creating movement in the figures echoed
in the ripples of the water. The black-etched outlines around all shapes. Lines
also suggests different texture textiles (Checkered / lined / Dotted / flowery) of
people’s clothing.
Depth and perspective
FIGURE 4a: Depth and perspective are created by the figures receding into
the distance towards a vanishing point. Overlapping / Big figure in front with
smaller figures in the back
FIGURE 4b: Similar portrayal is visible in FIGURE 4b. The overlapping figures
create a sense of depth and perspective.
Style
FIGURE 4a: Sibiya uses deliberate distortion and exaggeration in his stylised
version of the figures and cattle. There is a big figure in front and there is less
detail in the back. Small pinhead figures
FIGURE 4b: The expressive style of Mahlangu's work is used to portray the
emotional body language/gestures of the community. (10)
4.2 Candidates must discuss the work of any TWO artists (ONE work per artist)
who create art, craft, and/or spiritual works from rural South Africa.
They may refer to the following guidelines:
Influences
Media and technique
Possible meaning/purpose/function
How do these artworks/crafts/spiritual works contribute to society?
Elaborate. (10)
[20]
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 13 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
QUESTION 5: MULTIMEDIA AND NEW MEDIA – ALTERNATIVE
CONTEMPORARY AND POPULAR ART FORMS IN SOUTH
AFRICA
FIGURE 5a: Fiona Kirkwood, Spirit Coat, stones, paper cut-outs, 1000
cooldrink can tabs, plastic, cotton thread, steel, wire and other recyclable
materials, installation, 2001.
FIGURE 5b: Fiona Kirkwood, Spirit Coat, (detail) stones, paper cutouts, 1000
cooldrink can tabs, plastic, cotton thread, steel, wire and other recyclable
materials, installation, 2001.
5.1 Candidates must discuss the Spirit Coat (FIGURE 5a-c) by referring to the
following:
Teaching tool: Kirkwood's works reflect her awareness of the spirit of South
Africa and the energy, vibrancy of post-apartheid democracy, HIV/AIDS and
environmental issues. The underlying message is a desire to protect all forms of
life
The possible significance of the cut-out figures placed in a circle of
stones on the floor:
The paper body cut-outs could represent corpses as well as different race
groups. The cut-outs are placed on the floor in a circular pattern. This could
represent the coming together of different race groups in a spiritual environment.
Symbols in the work, e.g. crosses, etc. and their meaning:
The coat is a symbol of spiritual protection. There is an embroidered linear
outline of the map of Africa which represents all the people from the African
continent. The artist uses beadwork as well as plastic cross-like object to
reinforce the spiritual theme. The beadwork on the back of the garment forms a
large cross.
Stones creating a circular shape is symbolic of a traditional/ritual ceremony.
The use of a variety of unconventional and recycled materials and the
role they play in creating texture, colour and mood:
A life-size wearable coat is made by using traditional beadwork techniques and
recycled materials. The metal cold drink tops are shiny, representing a knight in
shining armour. The artist uses various recycled and throw-away objects in her
artwork which gives them a new purpose that results in a beautiful new artwork.
The various waste material makes up a spirit coat as opposed to a heap of
waste products. The unconventional materials are weaved together very much
like traditional craft weaving techniques. This could link the ancestral spirit to the
modern-day coat. The various materials add to the tactile quality of the coat.
The placement of the stones on the circumference creates a barrier around the
coat. It could represent an enclosure of safety for those being in the
circumference.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 14 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
Significance of the title: do you think the work is a successful
expression of a 'Spirit coat', and why. In our modern world, why
would the artist want to create a spirit coat?
'Spirit Coat': implies that the coat could be worn to a spiritual gathering/could
also be more personal. It symbolises that all Africans from the African continent
can be draped and protected by this coat. This could represent the coming
together of different race groups in a spiritual environment. In our modern world
with all the different religions, differences and tension experienced in cultures
and societies the artist wanted to create one specific spirit coat implying that one
spirit will guide all people under one garment of spirituality. The learner’s own
response to whether the artwork is a successful expression will vary.
The Circle indicates and alludes to the ‘circle of life’ including everybody. People
(figures) who die will take on a spiritual form. Spiritual armour (tabs look like
medieval chain-mail) as described in the bible/cotton wool symbolic of the
Bible’s innocent lamb – protection and honour. Address the need for Spiritualism
and move away from consumerism and ‘throw-away’ culture (also seen in using
found objects to make the artwork). The light emanating from the coat in figure
5a supports the idea of ‘spirituality/holiness’. The
circle on the floor could symbolise a ‘prayer circle’.The black and white paper
body cutouts figures from different race groups are holding hands. The vertical
placing of the coat can be compared to a Christ-like figure/Holy figure. Stone
circles are typical of African culture. A circle is a symbol of eternity or a complete
cycle – a life cycle. The colour white represents spirituality as well and looks like
a cloud. Recycled materials can be symbolic of the rebirth of the old.
(10)
5.2 Candidates must discuss any TWO contemporary artworks that use
new/alternative media to create a powerful message. They must name the
artists and the titles of the artwork. (10)
[20]
QUESTION 6: POST-1994 DEMOCRATIC IDENTITY IN SOUTH AFRICA
6.1 Candidates must justify their arguments by referring to the statement and any
THREE of the FIGURES 6a-6e.
The candidate must be credited when speaking specifically about identity
by referring to the three artworks given. The candidate doesn’t need to
discuss the artworks in length. Any debate can be accepted and this
question is more about the debating the issues rather than anlysisng each
artwork.
FIGURE 6a: Maluka creates a contemporary and decorative artwork that
reminds us of graffiti art, cartoons, Pop Art, and contemporary graphic design.
The portrait of a young woman is portrayed with eerily penetrating eyes that
create a hypnotic effect as if she can't stop her gaze. She is placed in the centre
on a boldly patterned background with bright colours and patterns. She
represents the street culture of South Africa as she has bright pink hair and
wears modern patterned clothing. This could be a trans person, not necessarily
a woman if you look at the title that refers to the ‘prodigal son’. Relates to the
selfie culture in social media in the facial expression, represents a ‘posed look’.
The figure has pink hair, ladylike ‘prodigal son (title) suggest gay/ transgender /
transvestite man which is not accepted or welcome in his family/community.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 15 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
FIGURE 6b: The portrait is of a young person smiling shyly at the audience.
The use of thread woven on the face creates texture and represents pixels of a
photograph. It seems as if the picture is out of focus and conceals the identity of
the person. The face could be a male. The use of the thread implies femininity
fragility due to its delicacy which is not usually associated with men and creates
lacy drapes and patterns in the background. Identity is often portrayed by how
we look and what we dress and how other people approve of us. The current
problems experienced by youngsters are the unconditional acceptance by others
on social media and they will do anything to hide their real appearance or soften
the reality. Feminine lace portrait, A-typical to be used to portray a man. Live
reflection of society right now where all borders get blurred.
FIGURE 6c: Flynn creates a portrait of a contemporary male portrayed against a
colourful graffiti-like background. Flat, bright colours are used in the figure and
background which creates a contemporary/graffiti effect. The male person is
wearing a mask decorated with colourful rows of patterns which could now refer
to the masks worn during the Covid-19 pandemic even though it was made in
2017. The figure is also crowned which could mean that he might be an
important person or the kingpin of a street gang. The decorative shapes and
forms on his body could refer to tattoos or coding and the influence of
technology on contemporary people. Popular culture iconography e.g. graffiti-like
/ superheroes (crown) 1011011 – Binary code / tattoos / religious symbols /
mask symbolic of protection – sometimes from ourselves.
FIGURE 6d: Claudette Shreuder uses family photographs and her memories to
create miniature sculptures of them. Some people identify or don't identify with
their families and feel that they don't fit in. The figures look serious and stern
staring blankly lacking expression. The sculptures appear similar to play things
or dolls to play with. The artwork is influenced by African Art sculptures e.g.
Benin. Three women with man/man-child / baby-boy – suggest women’s role as
nurturers of men forever (sometimes not willingly so).
FIGURE 6e: The Essop brothers portray themselves throughout the composition
in both traditional and modern clothing. They depict themselves breaking their
fast with Fast food (MacDonald's and Coke) which is unusual in their culture. It
shows the amalgamation of their tradition with western culture by breaking their
fast at the beach and not at their home with their families. This photomontage
also has an unusual representation of a prayer mat at the beach which is not
conforming to traditional customs. The brothers are questioning their identity as
Muslim individuals in today's world. (10)
6.2 Candidates must discuss any TWO artworks which address identity in a
democratic South African society. They must name the artist/s and the title of
the artworks.
They may refer to the following guidelines:
Imagery
Identity politics
Style and techniques
Meaning/messages (10)
[20]
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 16 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
QUESTION 7: GENDER ISSUES: MASCULINITY AND FEMININITY
7.1 Candidates must discuss the above statement by referring to FIGURES 7a-
7d. They may consider the following:
FIGURE 7a:
The significance of:
The hands on the face
The artist chooses to confront and shock the viewer by using the red
handprints over the mouths of the victims which reinforces them being
silenced. The red handprints can represent or symbolise blood or violence.
The red handprints over the mouth are symbolic of the physical abuse women
experience on a daily basis or a command to be silent and not talk about rape
and abuse.
The photographs are monumental in scale. They are reminiscent of the Super
Realist portraits of Chuck Close. The red hands are as big as the face. This
forces the viewer to sit up and take notice. The scale of abuse is much bigger
than we realise or care to acknowledge.
Underwear on the pavement
Lingerie, also known as underwear is universally associated with women's
undergarments worn by all women from different walks of life. The lingerie is
arranged in two lines below the photographs on the walkway/pavement. It
almost forms a pattern alluding to household violence and abuse which
becomes a behavioural pattern. It could reflect how women are
discarded/thrown away by scattering the underwear on the pavement. It
restricts the movement of the public and forces pedestrians to navigate their
way around the work. This forces the viewer to confront the issue of abuse.
Colour
The protestors displayed large-scale colour photographs of sad/fearful faces
of women. Each image is representative of a real person. By having these in
colour it also indicates the different nationalities and race groups of people
that are victims of Gender-based Violence. All types of people that will be
viewing these images can relate to the image/message. Red handprints cover
their mouths which refers directly to the women who are victimised and
silenced. The colour red may refer to blood and pain/suffering of the women.
The artist has placed red and white lingerie on the sidewalk below the larger-
than-life-size photographs, which sends a direct and clear message to
society. The colour red contrasts with the light colours of the portraits. The
addition of the white lingerie could allude to purity and innocence while the
red could allude to violence, abuse and death.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 17 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
FIGURE 7b:
The significance of:
The hands on the face
The hands are shielding the face. The figure is in a defensive and
submissive pose. The abuser is trying to silence his victim.
Colour
The blood-red face and hands symbolises fear, pain and anger. The bright
turquoise blue marble eyes stand out against the red. The turquoise blue
eyes could represent the innocence of a child. The gold writing 'BE MINE' are
words spoken/ scream out by the child are clearly visible against the fairly
plain white background. The (blood platter) is primarily situated in the
foreground and becomes the focal point. It suggests that the incident of
abuse has recently happened.
FIGURE 7c:
Colour
The artist uses limited colours such as a variation of red on the figures and a
horisontal band of writing against the white background/ wall. The lighter red
of the baby stands out against the larger blood red/ maroon figure. The green
scared eyes of the child provoke or engage with the viewer. The red writing in
the background could relate to calligraphy writing with blood/ a cut finger. The
different shades of red separate the images creating depth. Ironically the
Happy Father's day stamp relates to a dearly loved parent who in this case
might well be the abuser.
FIGURE 7d:
The significance of:
Shoes
The protestors in Brussels marched to show their disapproval of abuse
against women. They chose various pairs of red shoes (different shades of
red) that indicate the various status, ages and occupations held by women,
reinforcing that all women are affected. A single red boot is seen to be
symbolic of the struggle and violence leading to the loss of life. The name of
the person and the date of her death has been inscribed on the boot as a
remembrance of her life. This shoe almost represents a tombstone. These
worn-out shoes show the struggle and suffering of these women that possibly
worked hard to care for their families. The Red shoes are the female victim's
personal items representing all types of women across the world
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 18 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
Colour
The red shoes symbolise death, blood and violence. Usually, the colour red is
connected with love and passion which is contradicted here.
Mood/emotion, atmosphere e.g. communication through eyes, material,
media and technique
FIGURE 7a
The mood is sad, disturbing, upsetting it evokes deep emotions from the
viewer. The eyes are tearing which shows the pain and suffering of these
women. The eyes on the far right stare out intensely indicating anger. The
first image portrays hurt. The high-definition images show real people with
real emotions. The use of real underwear makes the message clear and
unavoidable, which would shock the viewer.
FIGURE 7b
The little girl appears to be vulnerable, scared, defeated this is indicated by
the hand gestures and the eyes. The hands are raised up with palms facing
outwards similar to someone that has given up, surrendered or is submissive.
The eyes look downwards to the left, afraid to make eye contact to turn
inward emotionally. The splashes of blood indicate the violent act of abuse.
The blood around her mouth may indicate the attack or abuse she has /is
experiences/experienced. The pale skin shows the loss of blood lifelessness
and death-like pallor. The use of ink, wood glue on paper adds to the realistic
effect of the blood on the artwork.
FIGURE 7c
The little girl appears emotionless and lifeless. This is indicated by the twisted
neck the limp hands as well as the flat line (heart line that usually indicates
death) in the background horizontally. The eyes that are rolled upward
appear dead. The blood spills and smears of it in the background indicate the
serious act of violence that she has endured. The atmosphere shows her
surrounding as being abusive as the writing on the wall indicates this by the
following word: Happy Father's day. The image contradicts the message
indicated. She is alone, isolated fragile, weak and has a sense of emptiness.
FIGURE 7d
The mood is depressing and sad due to the number of shoes that are
included in the display. The various red shoes also add to the mood and the
atmosphere as they represent women, children and older people that are
affected which has a direct impact on all types of people that can easily relate
to this.
Candidates must justify by referring to the images in figures 7a-7d
Candidates must indicate which of these examples they feel has the
greatest impact on drawing the public's attention to this social issue.
They must give reasons for their answers
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 19 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
Example: They highlight the importance of gender-based violence creating
public awareness even if people are not used to following the news on social
media platforms. These are unavoidable displays where the spectator is
challenged to debate and discuss these unspoken difficult issues. The
underwear is intimate symbolising the invasion of the most private space of a
woman. These are not items and photographs that are usually displayed in
public, however, the artist aims to create shock and awareness to the
passing pedestrians/viewers. The objects emphasise the vulnerability of
women in society. The hands seem to be defensive trying to protect herself. (10)
7.2 Candidates must write an essay on TWO artworks (one artwork per artist)
that they have studied that addresses gender issues. They must name the
artist and the title of the artwork. (10)
[20]
QUESTION 8: ARCHITECTURE IN SOUTH AFRICA
8.1 Candidates must write a paragraph discussing FIGURES 8a and 8b by referring
to some of the following:
How does the statement by Frank Lloyd Wright apply to each
example?
In FIGURE 8a the mirrored building/house is placed in a mountainous
landscape in Gstaad, Switzerland, where the surrounding landscape is reflected
on the mirrors and becomes part of the house. In FIGURE 8b the house is
placed in the barren Franschhoek landscape and almost disappears into the
landscape. The indigenous wood used for the cladding of the exterior of the
house contributes to the merging with nature. The glass would create warmth in
the interior of the building (like a hothouse).
By referring to FIGURE 8a discuss how time and light will have an
effect on the exterior of the building. Elaborate
Time and light will have a definite effect on the exterior of the building.
Depending on the time of day or season different images will be reflected on the
mirrors, changing as time goes by and light changes during the different
seasons. During daytime when it is light, the colours will be bright and the
landscape, sky, clouds and sun will be seen in the reflections. During night time
when there is no light the darker sky, moon and stars will be reflected in the
mirrored panels.
How has Aitken in FIGURE 8a used his materials/media in an
innovative manner? Elaborate.
In FIGURE 8a large mirrors cover the exterior of the structure. These mirrors
reflect different parts of the landscape at the same time. The viewer can walk
around the structure to view all the angles and enter the building where mirrors
are placed at different angles to create a kaleidoscope effect.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Visual Arts/P1 20 DBE/November 2021
NSC – Marking Guidelines
By referring to FIGURE 8b discuss the advantages of building the
structure off-site.
These homes have been designed on sustainable design principles,
incorporating low-maintenance materials. Workers can assemble the structure
in their workshop and they would not have to travel to the site with their
equipment and materials making it cost-effective. Different weather conditions
can affect the construction of buildings if done on-site therefore it is better to
work indoors where circumstances can be regulated/manipulated. They are
built off-site in a factory in South Africa to minimise constructions waste and
then installed on-site to assemble a unique structure.
Each house has a different roof structure. Discuss the advantages
and disadvantages of each.
In FIGURE 8a the house has a pitched roof and is constructed by using angled
trusses. This creates slanted roof surfaces so that rainwater and snow could
flow down easily because of gravity. The advantage of a pitched roof is that it
can provide more space/volume in the interior of the building to enlarge room
space, build higher walls, and have more ceiling space to utilise. The
disadvantages of a slanted roof are that it is costlier to build and it could be
aesthetically visually intrusive when placed in natural surroundings. FIGURE 8b
has a flat roof which enhances the box-like shape of the modular eco-home.
The advantages of a flat roof are that constructing the roof will be cheaper and
the structure can be erected in a shorter space of time. The disadvantages of a
flat roof are that it usually leaks when not sealed effectively and should be
cleaned regularly to take away any debris that can cause blockages. (8)
8.2 Candidates must discuss any TWO South African buildings that fit into their
environment in an interesting manner. Name the architect and title of the
building/structure.
They must consider some of the following in their answer
Location/Site
Function/Purpose
Influences
Materials used
Design and style
An architectural structure can also be accepted.Hector Peterson Memorial or
Nelson Mandela Bridge with any date accepted. (12)
[20]
TOTAL: 100
Copyright reserved
Study this subject
Recommended for this subject

Question paper
Visual Arts Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2021 QP (Eng)

Question paper
Visual Arts Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2021 QP (Afr)

Memorandum
Visual Arts Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2020 Memo (Afrikaans)

Memorandum
Visual Arts Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2019 Memo (Afrikaans)

Memorandum
Visual Arts Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2019 Memo (English)

Memorandum
Visual Arts Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2018 Memo (English)
More from Grade 12 Visual Arts

Annual teaching plan
Gr 12 Vis Arts ATP 2023 24

Question paper
Visual Arts Grade 12 P1 NSC June 2025 Question Paper (Eng)

Question paper
Visual Arts Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2025 QP (Afr)

Question paper
Visual Arts Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2025 QP (Eng)

Question paper
Visual Arts Grade 12 P2 NSC November 2025 QP (Afr)

Question paper