NATIONAL SENIOR
CERTIFICATE
GRADE 12
SEPTEMBER 2023
RELIGION STUDIES P2
MARKING GUIDELINE
MARKS: 150
This marking guideline consists of 17 pages.
Skip to contentAll 2023 papers 





View all





Religion Studies Grade 12 P2 Eastern Cape Mock 2023 Memo
Grade 12 Religion Studies Paper 2 memorandum from the Eastern Cape Mock Exam 2023 (English), 17 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.
Religion Studies · Grade 12 · Eastern Cape Mock Exam · 2023 · English. Memorandum, 17 pages. Read online or download the PDF.
- Subject
- Religion Studies
- Grade
- Grade 12
- Language
- English
- Document type
- Memorandum
- Year
- 2023
- Exam period
- Eastern Cape Mock Exam
- Paper
- 2
- Curriculum
- CAPS
- Pages
- 17
- File size
- 309.4 KB
Free to read online, no sign-up needed
Loading document…
Loading document…
1 of 17
This exam
Eastern Cape Mock Exam 2023
Questions in this paper
- Question 1.1Topical Issues in Society20 marks
- Question 1.2Common Features of Religion30 marks
- Question 2.1The Variety of Religions30 marks
- Question 2.2Common Features of Religion14 marks
- Question 2.3Common Features of Religion6 marks
- Question 3.1The Variety of Religions26 marks
Show all 14 questions
- Question 3.2The Variety of Religions12 marks
- Question 3.3The Variety of Religions12 marks
- Question 4.1Research Into and Across Religions20 marks
- Question 4.2Research Into and Across Religions16 marks
- Question 4.3Research Into and Across Religions14 marks
- Question 5.1Common Features of Religion18 marks
- Question 5.2Topical Issues in Society12 marks
- Question 5.3Common Features of Religion20 marks
Document textSearch extracted text and jump to a page.
2 RELIGION STUDIES P2 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2023)
QUESTION 1
1.1 1.1.1 Impact of crime and violence
• It affects economic productivity when the victim miss work.
• Effects from exposure to violence and crime include hypertension,
stroke and mental disorder.
• Children can be exposed to bullying, abuse, or witnessing violence
in variety of settings
• Older adults can also experience violence, including abuse of the
elderly or from an intimate partner.
• May increase depression and stress and develop fear and anxiety.
(NOTE: Any other relevant response must be credited.) (6)
1.1.2 Measures that can be done to prevent crime and violence in
schools.
• Universal school-based programmes that focus on skill-building
related to emotional self-control and social problems.
• Teamwork to reduce or prevent violent behaviour among school-
aged children.
• Violence intervention programmes that involve screening and
intensive case management.
• Additional research and interventions are needed to address crime
and violence throughout our lifespan.
(NOTE: Any other relevant response must be credited.) (6)
1.1.3 Religious teachings: Christianity as an example
• God desires peace; He also desires that humans should live in
justice and freedom.
• Christianity teaches non-violence.
• Jesus in Mathew 5 said, ‘Blessed are the peacemakers’, and told
others to turn the other cheek in the face of violence.
• Christians are told to love their enemies.
• The Ten Commandments states, ‘you shall not kill’.
• All violence is considered as an offence against God.
• Psalm 11, says, ‘The lord examines both the righteous and the
wicked. He hates those who loves violence.’
• Proverbs 3 and 10 condemns violence, especially to women.
(NOTE: Any relevant answer fact must be credited.) (8)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2023) RELIGION STUDIES P2 3
1.2 1.2.1 Role of Divinity
Example 1: Christianity
• God is one, but is made up of three personalities/persons.
• They are God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit.
• He created the universe/earth to be used by man.
• He created everything visible and invisible.
• Man relates to God through Jesus Christ.
• He is continuously involved in the world; His creative energy is
constantly at work in the world.
Example 2: Hinduism
• Contrary to the popular misconception that Hindus have many
gods, the belief in one God is the central teaching of the Hindu
worldview.
• The highest concept of God in Hinduism is Brahman the Supreme
Being, who is everywhere and is the source of our existence.
• God can also be experienced in graded stages according to the
spiritual development of the devotee.
• The first level or experience of God under Brahman is Ishwara, the
formless God who is everywhere and has qualities like love, peace
and compassion. He is formless.
• God is also presented as the Eternal Feminine, the Mother
Goddess who fulfils all the prayers of her devotees.
• God descends to the earthly plane to correct human affairs
(avatara) which become chaotic because of humanity's lack of
morality and love.
• Divine incarnations come to fulfil a divine mission through their
great spiritual influence, teachings and personal conduct, reversing
vice and promoting virtue, love, compassion and, importantly,
devotion to God.
• In Hinduism, Rama and Krishna are popular divine incarnations.
(NOTE: Any relevant factor must be credited.) (10)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
4 RELIGION STUDIES P2 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2023)
1.2.2 Discuss the concept of life after death as part of human
existence.
Example 1: Christianity
• According to Christianity, life does not cease with death, but
continues beyond the grave.
• Those who die enter a new phase, called paradise/heaven, which
lasts from the moment they die to the day of Resurrection.
• Sinners go to Hades/hell, where they are punished.
• It is believed that on the Last Day, the ordinary world will no longer
exist, and everything will come under the control of God
• On this day, there will be a final judgement, and everyone will either
be punished or rewarded.
• Only those who have lived a life according to the will of God will be
allowed into an eternal life.
• Death, therefore, is not the end of life, but a phase in the journey of
humankind.
• The resurrection implies that life has a purpose, that good and evil
must have reward and that there is a higher life beyond this world.
(NOTE: Any relevant factor must be credited.)
Example 2: Hinduism
• According to the Vedas, everyone has a soul or ‘self’ that lives in the
body.
• There is a cycle of birth and rebirth.
• This is referred to as reincarnation, whereby a soul evolves.
• The aim of every Hindu is to free the 'self' from this cycle, so that it
can become one with Brahma.
• This stage is called moksha.
(NOTE: Any relevant factor must be credited.) (10)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2023) RELIGION STUDIES P2 5
1.2.3 Discuss the nature of evil
EXAMPLE 1: CHRISTIANITY
• According to Christianity God did not create evil.
• God created a perfect world and perfect human beings.
• Evil was introduced later when Adam and Eve disobeyed God's
commands.
• Christianity calls this kind of disobedience sin.
• Christians believe that evil is often used by Satan to influence
human beings to rebel against God and then disappear.
(NOTE: Other relevant facts should be credited.)
EXAMPLE 2: HINDUISM
• Hindus do not deny the reality of pain, misery and evil in the world.
• They believe that evil is not inherent in the human being.
• Evil is like a cloud throwing its shadow over the passing sun.
• The cloud passes but the sun does not change.
• In Brahman there is no evil.
• According to Hinduism, suffering and evil are caused by a
perception of duality between man and the universe, between us
and God.
• If we become one with Brahman, there will be no evil.
(NOTE: Other relevant facts should be credited.) (10)
[50]
Copyright reserved Please turn over
6 RELIGION STUDIES P2 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2023)
QUESTION 2
2.1 Difference in governance
2.1.1 EXAMPLE 1: Christianity
Catholic Church
• The head of the Catholic Church is the Pope.
• The centre of power of this branch is in Rome.
• The Catholic branch has many orders, namely, monks, nuns,
priests, and friars.
• The Catholic Church is governed at parish level by priests,
deaneries by deans, dioceses by bishops and arch dioceses by
archbishops.
• A cardinal can govern an entire country or a geographical region.
Eastern Orthodox Church
• This branch is controlled by priests and bishops.
• Authority within the church is in die hands of a group of bishops.
• A diocese is a group of parishes under the leadership of a bishop.
Protestantism
• This movement was started in 1517 by a German monk, Martin
Luther.
• The churches are ruled by ordained ministers and bishops or
elected elders.
• Overall rule is by higher authority such as a synod or general
assembly chaired by the presiding bishop
• Some Protestant churches are independent and not responsible to
any higher authority than the congregation.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2023) RELIGION STUDIES P2 7
EXAMPLE 2: Islam: Governance
Sunni
• There is no clergy in Sunni Islam.
• Any Muslim can serve on the community boards.
• Governance is community based.
• Scholars of Islam and community members serve on the governing
boards of mosques, madrassas and schools.
Shi’a Islam
• Shi’a Muslims revere the descendants of the Prophet Muhammed
and believe that they have divine right to lead Muslims.
• Such a leader is referred to as an ‘imam’.
• The final word in any uncertainty about any religious or political
issues lies with the representative of the Imam.
• The governance is in the hands of mullahs (priests) who rule by
religious decree.
(NOTE: Any relevant fact should be credited.) (10)
2.1.2 Difference in teachings
EXAMPLE 1: Christianity
Catholicism
• The Catholic Church considers itself the original Christian Church.
• They believe that everyone is born in sin because of Adam and
Eve’s disobedience to God.
• God is made up of three persons: Father, Son and the Holy Spirit.
• The Holy Spirit comes from God the Father and the Son.
Eastern Orthodox Church
• The Holy Spirit comes only from God the Father.
• They believe that they are the rightly guided church.
Protestantism
• The Bible has more authority than the Pope.
• They teach the faith is the way to salvation.
• They teach that salvation is a gift given freely through the work of
Jesus Christ.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
8 RELIGION STUDIES P2 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2023)
EXAMPLE 2: Islam teachings
Islam is divided into two major branches, namely the Sunni and the
Shi’a.
Sunni Islam
• Sunni refers to following the Sunnah (example) of Prophet Muhammed.
• The hadith narrated by the companions of the Prophet have equal status to
those narrated by his family members.
• The Sunni believes that all the teachings contained in the Books of Hadith
are equally important.
• The Sunnis do not accept that a caliph must come exclusively from the
Prophet's family
Shi’a Islam
• The Hadith narrated by the companions of the Prophet, have less
significance than that narrated by his family members.
• The Shi’a follow the teaching and opinions only of a living scholar.
• They believe that the last caliph from the Prophet’s family was hidden in a
cave and will one day reappear as leader. He is referred to as Imaam.
(NOTE: Any relevant fact should be credited.) (10)
2.1.3 Difference in practice
EXAMPLE 1: Christianity
Catholicism
• There is regular attendance of the Holy Mass.
• Confirmation is a sacrament, and all members must undergo the
training before they are confirmed.
• There is a veneration of the cross.
• The followers are expected to confess their sins to a priest.
Eastern Orthodox Church
• There is the lighting of candles.
• There is the kissing of the saints called icons.
• They use incense during the Holy Mass.
Protestantism
• They regularly attend church services on Sunday.
• There is a performance of healing services.
• There are revival crusades.
(NOTE: Any relevant fact should be credited).
Copyright reserved Please turn over
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2023) RELIGION STUDIES P2 9
EXAMPLE 2: ISLAM – Practices
Practice: Sunni
• Religious practices are strictly in accordance with the Sunnah of the
Prophet as laid down in the Hadith.
• In Sunni Islam, an ‘Imam’ is simple a leader of a congregational
prayer.
• Mutah (temporary marriage) is forbidden.
• Imam does not denote formal training in Sunni Islam.
Practice: Shi’a
• They believe that the Caliphate (the Prophet Muhammed’s
successor) will come from his descendants.
• Imams are only descendants of the Prophet Muhammed who they
believe to be divinely appointed.
• The shrine of Hussein in Karbala is an important pilgrimage for the
Shia’s.
• Mutah (temporary marriage) is allowed.
• They practice self-mutilation, for example at the commemoration of
tragedy of Karbala.
• There are two schools of legal opinion – Akbar and usuli.
(NOTE: Any relevant fact should be credited) (10)
2.2 Hermeneutical principles
• Grammar and historical context and historical facts to interpret sacred
texts. One must use the rules of grammar
• Clearest meaning – one should take the literal meaning of the text.
• Plan, purpose and context. A piece of writing should be viewed as a whole.
What is the writing plan or structure? What was the author's purpose in
writing the text? What is the context of the passage being looked at?
• Meaning of words/Etymology: The meaning of words changes over time
and in different places. Find out the original meaning as they were used in
the normative source.
• Figurative meaning: Figurative and non-literal meaning must be taken into
account.
• Other sacred texts: Sacred texts themselves may be used to interpret
other sacred texts.
(NOTE: Any relevant fact should be credited.) (14)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
10 RELIGION STUDIES P2 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2023)
2.3 Reward and punishment
EXAMPLE 1: Christianity
• Reward and punishment are fair.
• Rewards motivate believers to sacrifice their life because of the greater
rewards
• Rewards have influenced people to die for their beliefs.
• Punishment helps believers to live according to their religious teachings.
• Punishment is one of the motivation factors to adhere to religious
teachings.
• We are all rewarded in this world by doing good.
• There is no need for extra reward.
(NOTE: Any relevant fact should be credited.) (6)
[50]
Copyright reserved Please turn over
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2023) RELIGION STUDIES P2 11
QUESTION 3
3.1 3.1.1 The Interfaith Action in Africa (IFAPA)
• Committed to working together for peace, democracy, unity on the
continent.
• To ensure a decent life for all.
• Establish and registering national chapters.
• It also includes the commissioning of meetings of religious leaders,
who take the IFAPA decisions.
• To send interfaith delegations to conflict areas.
• To participate in the World Forum.
(NOTE: Other relevant fact should be credited.) (8)
3.1.2 National Religious Leader’s Forum (NRLF)
• It is made up of the leaders of various religions in South Africa.
• It serves as a consultative and advisory body to the president and
deals with religious matters.
• It is involved with the major issues facing South African society today.
• Some examples are:
o To stop the abuse of women and children (GBV)
o To spread awareness of HIV/Aids and help those infected and
affected
• To promote ethical and moral values, and assisting with the moral
regeneration to our country.
• The work of this body ranges over a number of issues, in short, to
address the needs that arise in our country.
(NOTE: Other relevant fact should be credited.) (10)
3.1.3 The African Council of Religious Leaders – Religious for Peace
(ACRL-RfP)
• It was founded in 2002 and it is the largest and most representative
multi-religious platform in Africa.
• Respecting religious differences, acting on deeply held and widely
shared moral concerns and values.
• Preserving identity of each religious community.
• Honouring the different ways religious communities are recognised in
Africa.
• Supporting locally led multi religious structures within RFP networks
in the continent.
• Upholding the principles of representatively, subsidy and solidarity
(NOTE: Other relevant fact should be credited.) (8)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
12 RELIGION STUDIES P2 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2023)
3.2 3.2.1 Relationship between religions since democracy in South Africa.
• The country changed from being a Christian state to secular state.
• There is peace, harmony and co-operation among religions in South
Africa since democracy (ecumenism)
• The Bill of Rights in the Constitution of the RSA, 1996 (Act 108)
guarantees the freedom of religion.
• The World Conference of Religions for Peace in South Africa is
included in the constitution.
• The World Parliament of Religions conference was held in Cape
Town in 1999.
• Religious Leaders for Electoral Justice structure and the National
Forum for Religious Leaders were formed from this conference.
• Religious Leaders for Electoral Justice monitor and observe South
Africa’s democratic elections.
(NOTE: Any relevant fact should be credited.) (12)
3.3 How African Initiated churches developed in South Africa.
• Africa Initiated started their own form of Christianity as African Initiated
Churches (AIC) in the late 1800’s
• As first they were members of the European-controlled churches.
• They were not happy with the treatment they received
• They felt that their culture was regarded as unchristian by the European
leaders of the Christian religion.
• They were tired of racial discrimination in their churches
• They left European-led churches like Methodist Church, Anglican Church,
Presbyterian Church etc.
• And formed Ethiopian type churches, Zion Christian churches (ZCC),
ibandla Lamanazarete, apostolic churches and other Zionist churches.
• Christian churches started by Africans, who broke away from whites-
initiated churches.
• Further encouraged by Black American missionaries
(NOTE: Any relevant fact must be credited.) (12)
[50]
Copyright reserved Please turn over
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2023) RELIGION STUDIES P2 13
QUESTION 4
4.1 4.1.1 Briefly explain Darwin’s theory of evolution.
• The theory proposes that all life evolved from primitive forms and
continues to adapt and evolve.
• Species contain a great variety of minor differences.
• In the fight for survival, better adapted variations will be favoured
while those that are not ‘fit’ will struggle to survive.
• In this way a species may gradually change its form and become
more complex by developing along a path of successful variations.
• The theory of evolution asserts that humans evolved from a
common primate ancestor with apes.
• Darwin’s theory consists of four ideas:
o Species contain a great variety of differences.
o Both the world and species change over time.
o In the fight for survival, better adapted variation will be
favoured while those that are not fit will struggle to survive.
o A species may gradually change its form and become more
complex by developing along a path of successful variation.
• According to Charles Darwin humans evolved from apes.
(NOTE: Any relevant fact should be credited.) (12)
4.1.2 Religious response to the theory of evolution.
Example: Christianity
• Christianity has no doubt that God created the universe as part of
His divine plan for humanity.
• The book of Genesis describes how God created the world in six
days (and on the seventh day He rested).
• God created Adam and Eve, thus there is no place for the theory
of evolution in creation.
• Darwin’s work was regarded as controversial by the church.
• The theory was criticised as follows:
o There is no evidence in human history for the development of
new species
o There is no evidence of one species having developed from
another
o The attempts to create new species by cross-breeding tend to
be unsuccessful because the hybrids cannot breed
o Christians argue that certain aspects of creation are too
complex to have happened by natural selection
• Many Christians resolve the conflict by suggesting that the Bible
should be interpreted symbolically and not literally.
(NOTE: Any relevant fact must be credited.) (8)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
14 RELIGION STUDIES P2 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2023)
4.2 4.2.1 Religious teachings about how universe came into being.
Example 1: Christianity
• According to Christianity in the beginning there was nothing but
chaos.
• The book of Genesis says God created the world and the universe in
six days and rested on the seventh day.
• The world was perfect after the Holy Trinity had finished with
creation.
• Human, marine, animal and plant life all belong to God.
• God created human beings in His own image.
Example 2: Buddhism
• This world is just one of millions of worlds.
• In Each of these worlds a Buddha will rediscover the true nature of
beings.
• Buddhism flourishes for thousands of years and then it slowly dies
out.
• Another man will try to understand why people suffer and he
becomes the next Buddha.
• Each cycle has a Buddha.
(NOTE: Other relevant answers should be credited.) (8)
4.2.2 Briefly explain the difference between Christianity and modern
astronomers.
• Western astronomers challenged the belief that the earth is the
centre of the universe, which was fitting perfectly with the Christian
view of creation.
• The Orthodox Church could not believe that God would put man on
the planet that was not perfect.
• Astronomers, such as Copernicus produced the heliocentric theory,
which states that the earth is revolving around the sun.
• In the Bible it was the sun that moved not the earth.
• The astronomers appeared to be contradicting the literal word of the
Bible.
(NOTE: Any relevant fact must be credited.) (8)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2023) RELIGION STUDIES P2 15
4.3 Big Bang Theory
• The scientific theory of the creation of the universe is called the 'Big
Bang' theory.
• It explains how the universe came into existence.
• The theory of evolution explains the development of life from a simple form
to its most complete form today.
• This development includes the evolution of humans through primitive
stages to modern humans.
• It is believed that evolution still continues today.
• The study of evolution of the universe is called 'cosmology.'
• What existed before the Big Bang is not known.
• There was a big explosion in space and within seconds the universe had
appeared and expanded to an enormous size.
• It happened about fifteen billion years ago.
• Small temperature differences in the initial explosion led to varying
densities throughout the universe.
• These eventually formed into clusters of matter and energy.
• Huge spaces separated these clusters.
• They formed vast collections of stars that we call galaxies.
• Some galaxies condensed into a combination of stars and planets called
solar systems.
• Our earth is in one of the solar systems.
• This is where the evolution of life takes place.
• Again, the theory does not dispel the existence of a divine being.
• It only provides a scientific explanation of the structure and composition of
the universe
(NOTE: Any relevant fact must be credited.) (14)
[50]
Copyright reserved Please turn over
16 RELIGION STUDIES P2 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2023)
QUESTION 5
5.1 5.1.1 Inspiration
• It refers originally to the breath (power, knowledge) of an extra
ordinary power.
• An example of the breath of an extra ordinary power is a deity,
coming into a person and taking that person’s own breath.
• Inspiration refers to a state of being inspired to write, do something
or commit yourself to a particular life or experience.
• Inspiration is a very significant normative source in various
religions.
• Various religions have figures who received inspiration from a
higher power or wisdom.
• Inspiration may be referred to as true origin of all religions.
• There are many religious figures that have inspired many
generations of followers, RG, Abraham, Moses and Judges, Jesus
Christ, the Buddha, Prophet Mohammed and Baha’u’llah.
(NOTE: Any relevant answers must be credited.) (8)
5.1.2 Importance of sacred texts in religion
• Written sacred texts is more rigid than oral texts.
• Sacred books are fixed yardsticks of measuring right and wrong.
• Sacred books contain the history of different eras of the past.
• They also reflect the languages and cultures of the past eras.
• Sacred books serve as reliable references of the teachings and
beliefs of a religion.
• Sacred books serve as a unifying source of religion.
(NOTE: Other relevant fact must be credited.) (10)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2023) RELIGION STUDIES P2 17
5.2 5.2.1 Concept of secular humanism
• ‘Secular’ refers to ‘non-religious’.
• Humanism is a group of philosophies that believe human beings
can develop ethics and morality independently of a supernatural
being.
• Secular humanism is a branch of humanism that rejects religious
doctrine
• It also rejects the existence of a supernatural being.
• It is often associated with scientists and academics.
• Secular humanism generally leads to atheism.
• Secular humanism originated as a liberal view of human rights.
• It was not anti-religion, but emphasised that people’s emotional and
spiritual needs can be fulfilled without religion.
• Examples of secular humanism are atheism, communism,
agnosticism and materialism.
(NOTE: Other relevant answers should be credited.) (12)
5.3 5.3.1 AGNOSTICISM
• This term was first used by the philosopher T.H. Huxley in 1869.
• Darwin’s theory of human evolution challenged the idea of a
supreme creator.
• Agnostics believe that it is not possible to either prove or disprove
the existence of a God/supernatural being.
• Agnosticism comes from Greek – ‘a’ meaning without and ‘gnosis’
meaning ‘knowledge’.
• This refers to uncertainty about God-knowledge.
• Agnostics are sceptical of religious teachings.
• They reject religious doctrine – especially religions that claim they
have spiritual knowledge.
(NOTE: Other relevant fact must be credited.) (10)
5.3.2 ATHEISM
• Atheism, on the other hand, is a denial of the existence of a god or
a Supreme Being.
• There are different degrees of atheism.
• Some atheists simply doubt the existence of a god but are not
concerned with proving this.
• This is referred to as ‘soft atheism’.
• It is very similar to agnosticism.
• They turn to the sciences to explain the nature of the world and the
universe.
• Some atheists reject religion because they blame religion for wars
and other acts of violence.
(NOTE: Other relevant answers should be credited.) (10)
[50]
TOTAL: 150
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Study this subject
Recommended for this subject

Question paper
Religion Studies Grade 12 P2 Eastern Cape Mock 2020 QP (Eng)

Question paper
Religion Studies Grade 12 P2 Eastern Cape Mock 2018 QP (Eng)

Memorandum
Religion Studies Grade 12 P1 Eastern Cape Mock 2017 Memo

Memorandum
Religion Studies Grade 12 P2 Eastern Cape Mock 2016 Memo

Memorandum
Religion Studies Grade 12 P2 Eastern Cape Mock 2013 Memo

Memorandum
Religion Studies Grade 12 P2 Eastern Cape Mock 2013 Memo
More from Grade 12 Religion Studies

Annual teaching plan
Gr 12 Rel Stu ATP 2023 24

Question paper
Religion Studies Grade 12 P1 November 2024 NSC QP (Eng)

Question paper
Religion Studies Grade 12 P1 November 2024 NSC QP (Afr)

Question paper
Religion Studies Grade 12 P2 November 2024 NSC QP (Afr)

Question paper
Religion Studies Grade 12 P1 NSC June 2023 QP (Eng)

Question paper