Skip to content

Religion Studies Grade 12 P2 November 2024 NSC Memo (Eng)

MemorandumReligion StudiesGrade 12202415 pages

Grade 12 Religion Studies Paper 2 memorandum from the November 2024 NSC (English), 15 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.

Free to read online, no sign-up needed

Answer online

Loading document…

Loading document…

Questions in this paper

Document textSearch extracted text and jump to a page.
NATIONAL SENIOR CERTIFICATE GRADE 12 RELIGION STUDIES P2 NOVEMBER 2024 MARKING GUIDELINES MARKS: 150 These marking guidelines consist of 15 pages. Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 2 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines QUESTION 1 1.1 • Xenophobia is the fear, hatred and distrust of strangers or foreign groups. • Racism is discrimination and prejudice against people based on their race or ethnicity. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (4) 1.2 • The xenophobic or racist person may fear or feel uncomfortable to mingle with strangers or other nationalities/races. • Avoid certain geographic areas. • Hate people from certain countries. • People tend to think their group/race is superior compared to others. • Hostility toward people from other cultures/races. (8) NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. 1.3 • Rapid globalisation: • Globalisation led to national boundaries becoming transparent. This has led to increased migration to certain countries. • Cultural factors: • Culture includes identifying people through dress code, language and nationalism. • Material or economic factors: • People become afraid that foreigners will take their job opportunities and steal their resources. • Interactive factors: • Inhabitants do not feel safe when they interact with people of different cultures. • Media stereotyping: • Media has a major impact on people's attitudes. When foreigners are shown in a negative light, xenophobic attacks increase. • Lack of education and diversity: • People need to be educated about foreign cultures. • Racism • This is a broader form of discrimination which can lead to xenophobia. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (Only 4) (4 x 4) (16) 1.4 • Religious communities must organise counselling sessions within their communities. • Sermons must address racism and xenophobia. • Sunday school classes can be used to address racism and xenophobia. • Religious communities must create awareness of how marginalisation, discrimination and oppression can affect an individual's thoughts. • They must broaden people's experiences by promoting cultural tourism. • Exposure to the wider world may reduce the symptoms of xenophobia. • Encourage people to read books that can improve knowledge of different cultures. This will reduce fear of the unknown. • Organise a 'Cultural Day' where people from different cultures can teach one another about their cultures. (10) NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 3 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines 1.5 EXAMPLE 1: CHRISTIANITY • The Bible teaches that God created all humanity in His image. • The Bible does not indicate anywhere that one nationality or ethnic group is superior to another. • According to Christian teachings, there is no difference between Jew and gentile. • Heaven will include people from 'every nation, from all tribes and peoples and languages.' Rev 7:9-12 • The Old Testament has instructions to care for the foreigner and aliens among the people. Lev 19:34 • The Old Testament teaches that God is not partial and His plan of salvation is for all people. Ps146:8/Acts10:34-35 • The New Testament makes God's saving of the gentiles patently obvious. Jesus came because 'God so loved the world.' John3:16/Gal 3:28 • The Bible also teaches that no wrong or violence should be done to the foreigner, the fatherless or the widow. Deut. 10:19; 23:7 • Jesus Christ spoke to a Samaritan woman, which was taboo. He showed the gospel transcends human boundaries. EXAMPLE 2: HINDUISM • The teachings of Hinduism lay emphasis on the practice of Dharma, the essence of which is, 'do not do unto others that which you would not wish for yourself.' • Hinduism promotes love and mutual respect for all people. • It teaches that the Divine is equally present in all. • All beings are connected through this shared divine presence. • Hinduism forbids prejudice and discrimination against anyone, even people of a different race or culture. • Hindus think of all living creatures as equal, so they show them respect. This will include people of various races, religions and culture. • 'Dana' and 'seva' are actions which many Hindus follow. 'Dana' is helping others through charity irrespective of race or culture, and 'seva' is serving others without wanting back. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (12) [50] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 4 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines QUESTION 2 2.1 DIVINE INSPIRATION • It refers to the breath (power and knowledge) of an extra-ordinary being that has been breathed into a person. • The extra-ordinary being or power comes into an ordinary person, taking over that person and inspiring him/her with divine knowledge. • Divine inspiration is a very significant normative source in various religions. • People who stood face to face with God or a divine power are believed to have had divine inspiration. • The founders of various religions were inspired to establish the different religions.Examples are Abraham, Moses, the Prophet Muhammed and the Apostles. CONTEMPORARY INSPIRATION • Contemporary inspiration means current inspiration (taking place in this era). • Religious leaders and other ordinary members of religions who are being inspired during this era experience contemporary inspiration. • Contemporary inspiration is used as a guidance to the followers of a particular religion. • Today we still find people who get inspired to write books and hymns. These individuals usually commit themselves to a religious life and experience inspiration from time to time. (2 x 6) (12) NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. A maximum of EIGHT marks may be awarded for either divine or contemporary inspiration. 2.2 EXAMPLE 1: JUDAISM • Like in many religions, the original inspiration was largely spread first by oral traditions. • Such oral traditions were transmitted faithfully for hundreds and even thousands of years. • The primary scripture in Judaism is collectively known as the Tanach. • The Tanach is made up of the Torah, Nevi'im and Ketuvim. • The first group of the primary scriptures began to enjoy canonical status by the 5th century BCE. • The second group of primary scriptures gained canonical status by the 3rd century BCE. • The third group of primary scriptures was finally accepted into the canon in the last decade of the 1st century CE. • The corpus of these scriptures was decided by the scholars after careful deliberation of the revealed word of God. • The Apocryphal were not included as divinely revealed books. • The canon was thereafter supported by the Talmud. • The Talmud was completed by the end of the 5 th century CE. • On the third tier, were further detailed rabbinical explanations of the Torah. • The most important of these rabbinical explanations were written down (Midrash). Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 5 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines EXAMPLE 2: HINDUISM • In Hinduism the original sound of the spoken word is awarded absolute priority. • The oral teachings and written texts originated from inspiration that can be traced back 4 000 years ago. • The original inspiration was transmitted orally for centuries and even millennia before the advent of heard writings. • The 'heard' writings are distinguished from secondary, derived and humanly composed writings, such as philosophical interpretations. • This distinction, however, is not absolute. • The composition, commentaries and interpretations were later included in the sacred tradition of the Vedas. • The Brahmanas and Upanishads later became compositions, commentaries and interpretations of the earlier collections. • As time went by, there was development from the original to the derived, to the different classical philosophical schools. • Examples of the classical philosophical schools that have developed are Nyaya, Vaishesika, Sankhya, Purva-Mimamsa, Yoga and Vedanta. • Over the years there have been more innovative and authoritative commentators and re-interpreters. • Examples of the innovative and authoritative commentators are Shankara and Vivekananda. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (12) 2.3 • Grammar and historical context • This means that the writings must be understood within the context of the time and circumstances in which the text was written. • Clearest meaning • The meaning that is clearest to the reader should be considered. • Plan, purpose and context • The writing plan or structure of the whole document must be considered. • An extract must be seen as part of the whole. • E.g. Is the writing in the form of poetry or prose? • Meaning of words • The meaning of words often changes over time and context. • For the correct interpretation, the original meaning must be considered. • Figurative language • Figurative language is used widely in sacred texts. • This must be identified as such, so that it is not interpreted literally. • Figurative language requires the application of all the other hermeneutical principles for correct interpretation. • Other sacred texts • One sacred text may be used to interpret other sacred texts from the same religion. • This is because there is consistency between the teachings of the religion and its sacred text. NOTE: Marks must be awarded for any THREE of the above. (3 x 4) (12) Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 6 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines 2.4 • The establishment of the Parliament of the World's Religions took place in Chicago in 1893. • Its aim was to create a global dialogue of faiths. • In 1993 the Parliament was again held in Chicago to work together on world issues, as well as creating a declaration titled 'Towards a Global Ethic.' • In 1999 the Parliament in Cape Town highlighted the issue of HIV and Aids. • In 2004 the Parliament met in Barcelona, Spain, and focused on religious violence, safe water, refugees and eliminating external debt in developing countries. • In 2007 the focus was on the Millennium Development Goals for eradicating poverty. • In 2009 the Parliament met in Melbourne, Australia and dealt with aboriginal reconciliation, sustainability and global climate change. • The Parliament has always selected common social challenges, which has encouraged religions to work together. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (14) [50] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 7 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines QUESTION 3 3.1 3.1.1 EXAMPLE 1: ISLAM • Sunni Muslims • Shi'a Muslims EXAMPLE 2: CHRISTIANITY • Roman Catholic Church • Eastern Orthodox Church • Protestantism (4) 3.1.2(a) EXAMPLE 1: ISLAM SUNNI MUSLIMS • Sunni refers to following the 'Sunnah' (example) of the Prophet Muhammad. • The Hadith narrated by the companions of the Prophet have equal status to those narrated by his family members. • The Sunni sect believes that all the teachings contained in the Books of Hadith are equally important. • Sunnis follow the teachings of scholars from the 7th and 8th centuries. SHI'A MUSLIMS • Shi'a means 'partisan' or separate party. • The Hadith narrated by the companions of the Prophet have less significance than those narrated by his family members. • The Shi'a follow the teachings and opinions only of living scholars. • They believe that the last caliph from the Prophet's family was hidden in a cave and will one day reappear as leader. He is referred to as 'Imam'. EXAMPLE 2: CHRISTIANITY ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH • This branch sees itself as the original church of Christ. • The Holy Spirit comes from God the Father and the Son. • They believe that the Pope is the supreme earthly authority of the Roman Catholic Church. • They believe that the Pope is infallible. Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 8 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines EASTERN ORTHODOX CHURCH • According to the Eastern Orthodox Church, the Holy Spirit comes from God the Father only, and not the Son. • They believe that they are the rightly guided church. • They teach that no one has the power to change Christian teachings and traditions. • They see the Bible as canonical. PROTESTANTISM • In Protestantism, the Bible has more authority than the Pope. • Protestants teach that rituals are less important than belief. • They believe that faith is the key to salvation. • Salvation is a gift given freely through the work of Jesus Christ, who died for sinners. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. A maximum of SIX marks may be awarded for each branch. (12) 3.1.2(b) EXAMPLE 1: ISLAM SUNNI MUSLIMS • Religious practices are strictly in accordance with the Sunnah of the Prophet, as laid down in the Hadith. • In Sunni Islam, an 'Imam' is simply a leader of a congregational prayer. • Imam does not denote formal training in Sunni Islam. • Muttah (temporary marriage) is forbidden. SHI'A MUSLIMS • Imams are only descendants of the Prophet Muhammad, whom they believe to be divinely appointed. • The shrine of Husein in Karbala is an important pilgrimage for the Shi'a. • Muttah (temporary marriage) is allowed. • They practise self-mutilation, e.g., at the commemoration of the tragedy of Karbala. • They are allowed to combine the five daily prayers to three. EXAMPLE 2: CHRISTIANITY ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH • There is regular attendance of the Holy Mass. • Confirmation is a sacrament and all members must undergo the training before they are confirmed. • There is veneration of the cross. • The followers are expected to confess their sins to a priest. • They ordain their priests. • Nuns and monks do not marry. • There is no dissolution of marriage. • They practise last rites before the death of a person. Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 9 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines EASTERN ORTHODOX CHURCH • They express piety by kissing images of saints, called icons. • They see the entire Bible as canonical. • Ordained priests can get married. • They use incense during the Holy Mass. PROTESTANTISM • Attendance of Sunday services is very important in Protestantism. • Holy Communion services are also practised in many forms of Protestantism. • Speaking in tongues is a characteristic of the Pentecostal/Charismatic churches. • They have revival tent crusades with the gospel to reach the lost. • Healing services are also common. • Charity is seen as an outward sign of inner grace, and not as 'buying one's way to heaven'. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (12) A maximum of SIX marks may be awarded for each branch. 3.1.3 EXAMPLE 1: ISLAM • The Sunni-Shi'a split started after the death of the Prophet Muhammad in 632CE. • A debate ensued as to who the Prophet's successor would be. • The Sunni group believed that Abu Bakr, the prophet's father-in- law, should be the successor or caliph. • The Shi'a believed that the Prophet's son-in-law, Ali ibn Talib, should be the first caliph. • While this was a political difference, the disagreement escalated over the interpretation of certain Hadith (teachings of the Prophet) and laws. • Most Sunnis accept the Hadith collections of Imam Bukhari. • The Shi'a gives more importance to the Hadith narrated by the family of Prophet Muhammad (Ahl al Bayt). Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 10 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines EXAMPLE 2: CHRISTIANITY • After the crucifixion of Christ, the church was unified but had two main subgroups in the early years. • These were the Eastern (Constantinople) and Western (Rome) traditions. • In about 1054, the two subgroups officially separated. • The supreme authority of the Pope in Rome was challenged by Constantinople. • The other difference was the status of the Holy Spirit in the Trinity. • The Rome-based church was called the Roman Catholic Church. • The eastern branch was referred to as Eastern Orthodox Church, or Greek/Russian Orthodox Church. • In the 15th century, the Roman Catholic Church was challenged by reformers, or Protestants. • The major disagreement was over the supreme authority of the Pope and the corruption by Catholic office bearers. • Another major issue was the Catholic practice of penance, whereby a person's sins were pardoned by making a donation to the church. • Each of the three major branches has further subdivisions. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (12) 3.2 EXAMPLE 1: TAOISM NO • According to Taoism, humans are responsible for all suffering. • In order to avoid suffering, they must align themselves with the Tao. • People are good and perfect to be in harmony with Tao, other people and within themselves. • Human beings must also be flexible to the way of the Tao. • Human beings are expected to modify their desires and plans to be in line with the TAO. EXAMPLE 2: CHRISTIANITY YES • In the Book of Job, we find a story where a righteous man endures great sufferings because of Satan. • Jesus healed the sick people who were suffering because of evil spirits. • Some Christian churches exorcise evil spirits from possessed individuals. • Due to an apparent increase in the influence of evil, pastors are currently invited to schools to render spiritual support. • According to Christian teachings, evil and suffering are caused by the devil. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (10) [50] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 11 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines QUESTION 4 4.1 • Secularism means a separation of power between state and religion. • In the 16th century, Martin Luther set in motion certain changes that led to the splintering of Christianity into Catholic and Protestant groups. • This led to decades of religious wars in Europe. • At the time, the Church was very influential, both politically and socially. • Kings, emperors and nobility used the church to establish their power. • In return, religious leaders also influenced rulers to promote their interpretation of beliefs. • Religion and politics were intertwined, and wars continued. • People started to seek for a state where there would be religious tolerance. • Intellectuals of the time came to a conclusion that religion was divisive rather than uniting. • A government which was based purely on reasoning and on an understanding of human nature was then the solution. • The Prince of Orange was one of the first persons to advocate a split between church and state. • Thus government was divorced from religion and secularism came into being. • NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (12) 4.2 • It creates a collective sense of fairness and people will choose this over religion. • There is less judgement of people in society.Morality is not dependent on religious values. • In affluent Western societies, there is a little need for prayer. • People lead comfortable lives and do not need a god. • Religion has been blamed for numerous wars, particularly in Europe, e.g. the Spanish Inquisition and the Crusades. This caused people to lose faith in religion. • The Protestant movement set in motion numerous religious wars in Europe, with each church and king trying to impose a particular brand of Christianity on others. • Unacceptable conduct by religious leaders causes disillusionment among their followers, e.g. child abuse by Catholic priests, exploitation of the poor by Hindu priests. • The growing influence of science also diminished the power of religion. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (12) 4.3 • In a secular state there is peace because all religions are recognised as being equal. • There is no religion that is officially favoured by the state. • It promotes religious freedom. • Secularism embraces various value systems and, as a result, it promotes religious tolerance. • In a secular constitution, all religions may practise and worship in their own ways but must not infringe on the rights of others. • In state functions, such as the inauguration of the president, all religions participate. This shows religious tolerance. • Religion cannot dictate terms regarding the laws of the state. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (14) Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 12 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines 4.4 EXAMPLE 1: • AGNOSTICISM • This term was first used by the philosopher, TH Huxley, in 1869. • The word 'agnosticism' comes from Greek: 'a' meaning 'without' and 'gnosis' meaning 'knowledge'. • This refers to uncertainty about God-knowledge. • Agnostics believe that it is not possible to either prove or disprove the existence of a God/supernatural being. • Agnostics are sceptical of religious teachings. • They also argue that humans cannot comprehend such a thing as a divine power. • They reject religious doctrine, especially religions that claim to have intricate knowledge of the divine. EXAMPLE 2: • MATERIALISM • As a secular worldview, materialism believes that matter is the only reality. • Materialism teaches its followers that there is no supernatural realm. • This worldview is opposed to the religious worldviews that are based on the beliefs that affirms the existence of any form of spiritual reality. • Materialism teaches that nothing exists but nature. • According to materialism, any being that is viewed as beyond nature is a creature of imagination. • Materialism forbids its followers to subject themselves to any spiritual dependency. • New terms were developed from materialism, namely, dialectical materialism and historical materialism. • In dialectical materialism matter is regarded as the fundamental cause of everything. • Historical materialism: economics and the relationships between workers and owners as the basic structure in the community are referred to as historical materialism. • However, contemporary physicists and neuroscientists are challenging the materialist explanation of reality. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (12) [50] Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 13 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines QUESTION 5 5.1 • It is not known what existed before the Big Bang. • The Big Bang Theory is the scientific account of how the universe came into being. • It teaches that there was an enormous explosion from which the different planets were formed. • These eventually formed into clusters of matter and energy. • The clusters continued to condense in a lumpy way and formed the vast collection of stars called galaxy. • This happened about 13,7 billion years ago. • According to the scientific theory the earth was formed about 4,5 billion years ago. • No god or supreme being is mentioned. EXAMPLE 1: CHRISTIANITY • In the beginning only God existed. • The Creator then makes the universe from nothing. • God created the universe in six days and He rested on the seventh day. • God created the perfect world through the power of His Word. • He created the sun and the moon as the regulators of time. • Christianity mentions a Supreme Being called God as a creator. EXAMPLE 2: HINDUISM • In Hinduism, the Creator exists in either active or passive state. • The passive state is a state of rest, when nothing happens. • After a very long time the Creator becomes active again. • This is when part of the universe becomes different from other parts, and creation begins. • To Hindus, the universe itself is the Creator. • In Hinduism the Creator is neither male nor female. • Hindus believe that the Big Bang theory is an alternative way of explaining how the universe came about. • Hinduism has no problem with the Big Bang Theory. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. A maximum of SIX marks may be allocated for either the Big Bang theory OR the religious account. (12) Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 14 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines 5.2 • The scientific explanation is called Darwin's theory of evolution. • The theory proposes that all life evolved from primitive forms and continues to adapt and evolve. • It asserts that humans have evolved from an ancestor shared with apes. The theory consists of the following ideas: • Species contain a great variety of minor differences. • In the fight for survival, the adapted variations will be favoured while those that are not fit will struggle to survive. • This applies to change in humans as well. • In the fight for survival, humans adapted and gradually changed from apes to human beings. • The process of change and adaptation happened over a very long period of time. • Science offers no explanation of creation as part of a divine plan. (14) NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. 5.3 5.3.1 HINDUISM • Hindus have no problem with the theory of evolution. • They believe that the universe is based on evolution. • They believe that they have a more advanced theory of evolution than the scientific one. • The scientific theory is limited. • It focuses only on the physical perspective of creation. • Hindus believe that if one lives a good life one will evolve through many rebirths until one is physically and spiritually advanced. • Ultimately, one will achieve liberation from physical death and be one with God. • Hindus believe that there is an intelligent designer behind everything, like evolution of humanity and of the universe. (12) Copyright reserved Please turn over
Religion Studies/P2 15 DBE/November 2024 NSC – Marking Guidelines 5.3.2 CHRISTIANITY • In contrast, there is no connection between the traditional Christians and the theory of evolution. • Traditional Christians only accept that God created Adam and Eve, as it is narrated in the Book of Genesis. • They argue that there is no evidence that human beings evolved from apes. • God created perfect human beings and gave them authority to rule and manage the world. • However, there is a connection between the theory of evolution and liberal/progressive Christians. • They argue that everything in the universe was created by God. • The process of evolution is also part of the Divine Plan. (It is referred to as 'theistic evolution.') • Progressive Christians accept the idea of guided/theistic evolution, and add that the creation myth must be seen as symbolic. • They admit that there were some stages of creation which involved evolution, as explained by scientists. NOTE: Other relevant answers must be credited. (12) [50] TOTAL: 150 Copyright reserved

Study this subject

More from Grade 12 Religion Studies

View all