Downloaded from hlayiso.com
NATIONAL
SENIOR CERTIFICATE
GRADE 12
SEPTEMBER 2018
DESIGN P1 (THEORY)
MARKING GUIDELINE
MARKS: 100
This marking guideline consists of 23 pages.
Skip to contentAll 2018 papers 





View all





Design Grade 12 P1 Eastern Cape Mock 2018 Memo (English)
Grade 12 Design Paper 1 memorandum from the Eastern Cape Mock Exam 2018 (English), 23 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.
Design · Grade 12 · Eastern Cape Mock Exam · 2018 · English. Memorandum, 23 pages. Read online or download the PDF.
- Subject
- Design
- Grade
- Grade 12
- Language
- English
- Document type
- Memorandum
- Year
- 2018
- Exam period
- Eastern Cape Mock Exam
- Paper
- 1
- Curriculum
- CAPS
- Pages
- 23
- File size
- 388.6 KB
Free to read online, no sign-up needed
Loading document…
Loading document…
1 of 23
This exam
Eastern Cape Mock Exam 2018
Questions in this paper
Document textSearch extracted text and jump to a page.
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
2 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2018)
SECTION A: DESIGN LITERACY
QUESTION 1: ‘UNSEEN’ EXAMPLES
Answer EITHER QUESTION 1.1 or QUESTION 1.2
1.1 Allocate 10 marks in total
A maximum of 2 marks for each element/principle only
Only 1 mark per principle/element for identification without EFFECT
1.1.1 Allocate 8 marks
Choose ONLY 4 elements/principles
Line:
On the front of the dress are thick bold white lines and outlines of
geometric shapes (triangle, circles, rectangles) creating a strong focal
point. √ The stacking of shapes on the dress create an implied vertical
line which creates movement from top to bottom. √ The silhouette and
statuesque pose of the figure forms a tall implied vertical line. √ (2)
Unity:
Unity is achieved through continuation – the vertical stacking and
arrangement of one shape on top of the next. √ Unity is achieved by the
repetition of the geometric shapes as well as their uniform white colour.
The proximity in which the shapes are grouped on the front of the dress
create a sense of unity. √ (2)
Layout:
The lines and shapes are arranged in such a way that they follow the
vertical form of the figure. √ There are vertical lines on the side of the
figure echoing the curves of the body and acting as ‘dress straps’ above
her shoulders. √ There are triangles indicating the placement of her
breasts and a long horizontal rectangle dividing the upper and lower
body. √ The shapes are arranged in a totemic fashion and fit neatly into
each other elongating her form. √ (2)
Balance:
The dress is symmetrically balanced as there is an equal visual weight
on either side created by the mirror image of lines and shapes. √ This
gives the dress a sense of perfection and order. √ The perfect hairstyle
and ridged stance with her arms behind her back further enhance the
symmetry. √ (2)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2018) DESIGN P1 3
Contrast:
The white outlines of the shapes are emphasised as they contrast with
the stark black dress. √ There is a contrast in the sizes of the shapes
creating variety. The shapes appear to be rotated, pointing in many
different directions on the dress, creating visual movement. √ (2)
Credit any well-reasoned answer.
1.1.2 Allocate 2 marks
Bauhaus √– Simplicity with the use of pure geometric lines and shapes √
focusing on the basic and fundamental elements of design. √ (2)
Credit any well-reasoned answer. [10]
Q1.1 LEVEL COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
Remember, Recall,
1.1.1 1
Recognise, Name
Lower order 30%
Understand, Explain,
1.1.1; 1.1.2 1+1
Describe, Classify
Middle order Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 1.1.1; 1.1.2 3+1
Analyse, Compare, Interpret 1.1.1 1
Higher order Evaluate, Reflect, Judge 30% 1.1.1 1
Synthesise, Justify, Create 1.1.1 1
OR
1.2 Allocate 10 marks. A maximum of 2 marks per aspect.
Postmodern:
The use of a mixture of different materials, cheap coloured wire and expensive
gold-plated steel. √ It is also very colourful which gives it a whimsicality and
playfulness. √ The shape of the comb resembles a simplified female figure which
has an andromorphic quality. √ (2)
Negative space:
Most of the design occupies negative (background) space being formed by the
wire frame. The space enclosed by the wire creates more geometric shapes such
as circles and triangles and adds to the structured ridged shape of the comb. √
The amount of negative areas enclosed within the design gives the comb a
sense of lightness and delicacy, as it is not a solid metal mass. √ (2)
Use of materials:
The gold-plated metal frame gives off a sense of elegance and wealth. √ It is
reflective and contrasts against the matt quality of the coloured wire. √ The wire
twisting around the frame of metal frame has been hand-woven. √ The wirework
is reminiscent of Zulu wire basket weaving with the use of coloured plastic-coated
wire. The colourful wires reflect a diverse South African society. √ (2)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
4 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2018)
Structure:
The hair comb is made up of three main sections – a round (head), middle
chevron shaped (torso) and bottom ‘skirt’ of a female figure. √ The design
consists of simple lines and shapes (circles and triangles) giving it a sense of
simplicity. √ The shapes are symmetrically arranged, not unlike a human figure,
which shows perfection and order. √ (2)
Function:
The comb is gold-plated indicating that a stronger metal may be at the core for a
more practical use. √ The wire frame seems fragile because of the delicacy of the
construction which may cause it to bend. √ The top and middle section have
rough wire coils whereas the bottom is purely plated metal for easy placement
into a person’s hair. √ Because of the colourful wirework the comb may be used
purely for decorative purposes as it catches one’s eye. √ (2)
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. [10]
Q1.2 LEVEL COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
Remember, Recall,
1.2.1 1
Recognise, Name
Lower order 30%
Understand, Explain,
1.2.1 2
Describe, Classify
Middle order Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 1.2.1 4
Analyse, Compare, Interpret 1.2.1 1
Higher order Evaluate, Reflect, Judge 30% 1.2.1 1
Synthesise, Justify, Create 1.2.1 1
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2018) DESIGN P1 5
QUESTION 2: COMMUNICATION THROUGH DESIGN
2.1 Allocate 10 marks in total
2.1.1 Allocate 1 mark
People fear/dread things/people/situations that are unknown to them. But
instead of fear, people should be more curious/interested/inquisitive. (1)
2.1.2 Allocate 5 marks
The text (Arabic script) below the bust of the figure is an example of
Arabic calligraphy which is not understood by many western cultures. It is
unique to the Islamic or Muslim faith. √ Because you do not understand it
you may distance yourself from the culture. √ The fact the figure is fully
cloaked in Arabic attire (Hijab) shows that the person is lacking identity
and this links to fearing the unknown. √ It also suggests a sense of
mysterious. √ The dark black colour of the draped Hijab may be
associated with darkness and evil which reflects the message of fearing
the unknown. √ The pink background colour is stereotypically associated
with women and femininity as women are the ones who wear the
Hijab. √ The fact that the figure is split horizontally into two halves
indicates that there are two sides to the person and that they are not one-
dimensional. √ It may be that the bottom half reveals something about the
individual, beneath the ‘cloak’. √ The fact that the woman is viewed from
the back and her gaze is lowered to the right also indicates that she is
hiding or wants to be hidden displaying a sense of secrecy. √ (5)
2.1.3 Allocate 2 marks
Stereotypes are generalisations, or assumptions, that people make about
the characteristics of all members of a group. √ It is stereotypical to think
that Western cultures view the Arabic cultures as a culture that is feared
or not understood by other denominations/races/faiths. √
Associating the Arabic calligraphy with an Arabic woman is stereotypical
as there are people from different other denominations/races/faiths who
can read and write Arabic. √ Not all people that read/write Arabic,
especially woman, are fully cloaked to the point of non-recognition in their
attire. √ (2)
2.1.4 Allocate 2 marks
The Gestalt principle of Closure √ is evident as the Arabic calligraphy
creates the shape of a person’s torso. √
The gestalt principle of Uniform Connectedness √ applies as the text and
the attire are both black, unifying them. √ (2)
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. [10]
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
6 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2018)
Q2.1 LEVEL COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
Remember, Recall,
2.1.1 1
Recognise, Name
Lower order 30%
Understand, Explain,
2.1.2; 2.1.3 1+1
Describe, Classify
2.1.2; 2.1.3;
Middle order Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 2+1+1
2.1.4
Analyse, Compare, Interpret 2.1.2; 2.1.2 1+1
Higher order Evaluate, Reflect, Judge 30% 2.1.2 1
Synthesise, Justify, Create
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2018) DESIGN P1 7
QUESTION 3
Answer EITHER QUESTION 3.1 or QUESTION 3.2.
3.1 Allocate 10 marks. A maximum of 2 marks per aspect
3 marks maximum for writing 2 separate paragraphs
Maximum of 30% for pure identification without effect
The colours used in the Koons handbag are true to the painting of Vincent van
Gogh. The colours are analogous green, blue and yellow that create a
harmonious effect √ while the Mali handbag makes use of a limited colour palette
of solid striking colours of black and white with accents of red and blue. √ The
light blue handle and bunny motif of the Koons handbag have been perfectly
matched to the blue sky to unify these fittings to the bag √ while the striking red
handle of the Mali handbag creates a bold focal point against the white framed
lining of the handbag. √ (2)
The Koons handbag was influenced/inspired by the landscapes captured by
Vincent van Gogh images of rolling hills and wheat fields, √ while the Mali
handbag takes its inspiration from the geometric diamond patterns found in
Xhosa beadwork and Zulu basket weaving of indigenous South African tribes. √ (2)
In the Koons handbag a swirling contour pattern √ can be found in the
characteristic brushwork and subject matter of a Van Gogh painting while the
Mali handbag exhibits three finely woven geometric diamond shapes on the front
of the bag. √ The Koons handbag has a gold monogram pattern placed sparsely
over the entire bag which gives it a touch of glamour √ while the Mali handbag
has a detailed black and white geometric diamond pattern adorning the front,
contained within solid sections of white, blue and red as a border pattern. √ (2)
It can be assumed that the target market for both handbags are for women
because of their fine detailing which includes such details as the gold lettering
and trim on the Koons handbag and the decorative gold-plated buckle on the Mali
handbag. √The Koons handbag is for someone who has an appreciation for
visual art or a knowledge of Post-Impressionist art, √ while the Mali handbag is
for someone who values a South African identity because it reflects patterns
reminiscent of indigenous Xhosa and Zulu cultures. √ (2)
The production techniques for both handbags may incorporate a combination
of handwork and mechanised production techniques – the Koons handbag uses
a digital print of an artwork while the main body of the Mali handbag appears to
be handwoven with leather strips. √ Both handbags appear to have sturdy leather
handles that makes them practical for everyday use as they will not break or
wear easily. √ Both handbags appear to have only one opening at the top for
ease of access - the Koons handbag has a zip running the length of the top of the
of the bag while the Mali handbag incorporates the use of a buckle and strap. √ (2)
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. [10]
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
8 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2018)
Q3.1 LEVEL COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
Remember, Recall,
3.1 1
Recognise, Name
Lower order 30%
Understand, Explain,
3.1 2
Describe, Classify
Middle order Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 3.1 4
Analyse, Compare, Interpret 3.1 1
Higher order Evaluate, Reflect, Judge 30% 3.1 1
Synthesise, Justify, Create 3.1 1
OR
3.2 Allocate 10 marks. A maximum of 2 marks per aspect
3 marks maximum for writing 2 separate essays/paragraphs
Maximum of 30% for pure identification without effect
This comparative essay compares the (Classical) Parthenon in FIGURE F
with the (Contemporary) Buddha Worship Site in FIGURE G. The candidate
may choose ANY OTHER suitable examples for the comparison.
Purpose and function:
The original purpose of the Parthenon was to serve as a pagan temple that was
dedicated to the goddess Athena. √ It was not designed to house a congregation
but the Athenian treasures. The Parthenon was designed to be experienced only
from the outside. √ The aim of the Buddha Worship Site was to build a prayer hall
that would enhance the attractiveness of a stone Buddha sculpted 15 years ago.
√ Unlike the Parthenon viewers are encouraged to enter the structure in order to
view the Buddha Statue within. √ (2)
Target market:
The pagan worshippers of Athena never entered the Parthenon but were only
afforded occasional glimpses of the statue of Athena, designed by Pheidias, in
the inside chamber through the open doors. The worshippers followed a ritualistic
path that guided them around the outside of the temple to view the lavish friezes
and relief sculptures that celebrated the myth and history of Athens. √ People
coming to view the Buddha Statue enter through a long approach tunnel in order
to heighten the anticipation of viewing the statue, which is invisible from the
outside. √ When the hall is reached, visitors look up at the Buddha, whose head
is encircled by a halo of sky at the end of the tunnel. √ (2)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2018) DESIGN P1 9
Layout/Plan:
The simple, rectangular layout/plan of the Parthenon is almost 70 meters long
and 30 meters wide, and the façade is constructed according to the golden ratio
of 5 : 8, which is considered to be the most proportionally appealing rectangle. √
The triangular pediment and frieze are supported by 46 Doric columns encircling
the building. The building consisted of two simple chambers. √ Slight
adjustments were made to the dimensions that make the building appear
perfectly regular to the naked eye through optical illusion – the stylobate is a
slight convex shape; the columns all lean inwards; and the main body of the
columns have an outward bulge. √ The Buddha statue is covered from below
the head with a hill of lavender plants. At first, one only sees the head of the
statue surrounded by the landscape of the hill. √ The whole body of the Buddha
cannot be seen from outside which gives visitors a more serene appreciation
of the Buddha. The project might be considered on the scale of landscape
design rather than architecture. One of the site’s charms is how well it
achieves harmony with the natural landscape. √ (2)
Materials and building techniques:
The materials used for the ancient 'cult statue' of the goddess Athena were ivory
and gold. The temple was constructed of marble. √ The blocks were held in
place by bronze or iron pins set into molten lead, a flexible system that could
withstand earthquakes and the ceiling was constructed of wood. √ The Buddha
statue is 13,5 metres tall and weighs 1 500 tons. It is made of fine, highly
selected solid stone. √ Made up of arches of folded concrete, the approach
tunnel is dimly lit to create a “womb-like” atmosphere, while the opening at the
centre is naturally lit and surrounded by concertinaed concrete walls that narrow
towards the sky. √ A water garden at the base of the mound is surrounded by
tall cast-concrete walls and a small border of grey gravel. √ (2)
Relation to the site:
Situated high up on a hill (the Acropolis), the Parthenon is clearly visible from
the city below. The Parthenon should be viewed as a magnificent work of
sculpture inspired by the proportions of the human figure. √ The Buddha Statue
worship site sits on a gently sloping hill on 180 hectares of lush land
belonging to a cemetery. √ The vegetation which includes 150,000 lavender
plants provides a seasonally appropriate backdrop for the statue, changing from
green in spring to purple in summer and finally white in winter, when the mound
is heaped in snow. √ (2)
Credit any other well-reasoned information. [10]
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
10 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2018)
Q3.2 LEVEL COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
Remember, Recall, Recognise,
3.2 1
Name
Lower order 30%
Understand, Explain, Describe,
3.2 2
Classify
Middle order Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 3.2 4
Analyse, Compare, Interpret 3.2 2
Higher order Evaluate, Reflect, Judge 30%
Synthesise, Justify, Create 3.2 1
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2018) DESIGN P1 11
SECTION B: DESIGN HISTORY
QUESTION 4: INTERNATIONAL DESIGN HISTORY
4.1 Allocate 20 marks in total
Allocate 10 marks for each movement
Candidates must be penalised for LIMITED or NO REFERENCE to the
statement
Allocate one combined mark for the name of a designer and a work
If TWO designers’ works are discussed only allocate marks for ‘new’
information that support the aims/influences/characteristics of the
movement
This marking guideline supplies an answer for the following two possible
movements:
THE ARTS AND CRAFTS MOVEMENT:
4.1.1 Because of rapid industrialisation, multi-storey buildings, factories, bridges
and railway lines started to appear towards the end of the 19 th century and
rapid urbanisation often resulted in slums in Britain and Europe. Factories
proved to be a serious health risk to people so the period was the beginning
of socialism and protection of the rights of craftsmen. √ As a rebellion to
industrialisation in Europe and the fussy mass-produced designs of the
Victorian Age the aim to develop great design was to eliminate unnecessary
ornament and make designs simpler. √
Designers were influenced by the natural environment – plants, birds and
animal forms √ and in this way put an emphasis on natural materials such as
stone leather, wood and natural fibres √ and moved towards re-establishing
‘pure-craftsmanship’ and a closer working relationship between worker and
designer. √ Handicrafts such as embroidery, carving, block printing and
stained-glass windows were revived. √ People looked towards Medieval Art
especially Gothic architecture of a purer, higher, Godly society √ and the
English Cottage style in homes displayed local stone, bare floorboards and
interior roof beams characteristic of the peasant style. √
The Arts and Crafts style was characterised by hand-hammered finishes as
proof of honest construction methods which were applied to silver and
copper. √ Some artisans added hammered finishes to machine made items
for aesthetic purposes. Metal workshops made hinges, handles, metal studs
for upholstery and wooden cabinetry were forms of handcrafted hardware. √
In 1935 Frank Lloyd Wright designed ‘Fallingwater’ √ for the Edgar J.
Kaufmann family of Pittsburgh. The design of the house promoted harmony
between man and nature. It hovers right over the rushing mountain stream in
perfect harmony. √ It extends 30 feet in height above the ledges, although
strong horizontal lines and low ceilings help maintain an overall sheltering
feeling that strengthens the connection between the building and the natural
surrounds. √ The bedrooms are small, some with low ceilings to encourage
people outward toward the open social areas, decks, and outdoors. √ The
design incorporates broad expanses of windows and balconies that reach
out into their surroundings and blur the connection between the interior and
exterior environment. √ (10)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
12 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2018)
ART DECO:
The main aim of Art Deco was to construct a better world out of the
depression and environment of WW1 with a futuristic outlook on life. √
War had a devastating impact affecting the relationship between its
people and the economies in Europe and America. √ Art Deco aimed to
create a sense of escapism through the unreal environments they
created √ and embraced sensational, carefree modern living and daring
great new designs. √ The movement responded to the demands of the
machine age and of new materials as well as the requirements of mass
production. √ Women appeared more animated, fashionable and more
independent after WW1 contributing to male dominated fields such as
sports and cinema. √
During the 1920’s there was a fascination with Ancient Egypt because of
the discovery of Tutankhamen’s grave in 1922. √ Designs were therefore
influenced by Egyptian motifs such as the lotus bud and papyrus,
scarabs and the sphinx. √ Another influence was Ancient Greek and
Roman art for their elegant poses, muscular proportions of ‘perfect’
classical figures and imagery from classical mythology. √ Travel to Exotic
countries such as some in Africa also had an influence on designs
brought on by the trade of ivory and animal hides. √
The Chrysler Building by architect William van Allen √ in New York
was the tallest building in the world at the time of its completion in 1928.
The building showcased typical Art Deco characteristics such as
stepped forms and zigzags derived from Aztec and Inca temples and
Egyptian Pyramids √ as well as the sunburst motif symbolising radiating
energy and expressing excitement and optimism for the future. √ Various
architectural details and especially the gothic inspired gargoyles were the
inspiration for Chrysler automobile products like the hood ornaments of
the Chrysler Plymouth. √
Walter Chrysler was the chairman of the Chrysler Corporation and his
intention was to construct the building as Chrysler’s headquarters,
meeting the high demand for motor vehicles. √ The machine age had
changed people’s lives making travel faster than before. Streamlined
forms of cars and ocean liners, emphasised speed, technology,
aerodynamics. √ (10)
Credit any other valid aims, influences, characteristics as well as
designers and examples. [20]
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2018) DESIGN P1 13
Q4.1 LEVEL COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
Remember, Recall, Recognise,
4.1 4
Name
Lower order 30%
Understand, Explain, Describe,
4.1 2
Classify
Middle order Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 4.1 8
Analyse, Compare, Interpret 4.1 3
Higher order Evaluate, Reflect, Judge 30% 4.1 3
Synthesise, Justify, Create
4.2 4.2.1 Allocate 2 marks
FIGURE H – Deconstructivism √
FIGURE I – Scandinavian √ (2)
4.2.2 Allocate 8 marks. A maximum of 2 marks per aspect
3 marks maximum for writing 2 separate paragraphs
Subject matter:
FIGURE H consists of fragmented geometric shapes (cubes) in distorted
perspectives with intersecting diagonal lines which create a sense of
dynamic movement. √ The images inspired by nature in FIGURE I,
consists of plant and animal motifs which is a typical characteristic of
Scandinavian textile design, incorporating stylised biomorphic themes. √ (2)
Aims:
In Deconstructivism space seems to be ‘cut’ with a diagonal focus,
creating a sense of fragmentation, dynamism, and visual chaos which is
evident in the subject matter in FIGURE H. √ In FIGURE I designs were
based on nature with simple, minimal forms and shapes, and designers
focused on creating functional and beautiful designs with clean lines. √ (2)
Perspective:
There are multiple perspectives in FIGURE H creating instability and
tension. √ The objects have been rendered using two-point perspective
with various vanishing points creating a sense of imbalance and dynamic
energy. √ There is a lack of perspective in FIGURE I which makes the
textile appear flat. √ Unlike the objects in FIGURE H the objects do not
overlap or touch allowing each object its own personal space. √ (2)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
14 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2018)
Colour:
The colour used in FIGURE H is a cool analogous colour palette with
tints and shades of blue and maroon/pink shapes against a pure white
background which creates a sense of unity within the chaos. √ FIGURE I
consists of bright and cheerful colours which create a sense of
playfulness and whimsy. √ Plant and animal forms in light colours
(orange, white, pale yellow) create a lively contrast to the cool blue tone
of the background. √ (2)
Consider any other well-reasoned and supported facts. [10]
Q4.2 LEVEL COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
Remember, Recall,
4.2.1 1
Recognise, Name
Lower order 30%
Understand, Explain,
4.2.2 2
Describe, Classify
Middle order Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 4.2.1; 4.2.2 1+3
Analyse, Compare, Interpret 4.2.2 2
Higher order Evaluate, Reflect, Judge 30% 4.2.2 1
Synthesise, Justify, Create
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2018) DESIGN P1 15
SECTION C: DESIGN IN A SOCIO-CULTURAL/ENVIRONMENTAL AND
SUSTAINABLE CONTEXT
QUESTION 5 (20 marks)
Answer EITHER QUESTION 5.1 or QUESTION 5.2.
5.1 5.1.1 Allocate 2 marks
Social design is defined as a design process that contributes to improving
human well-being and livelihood and links to designing for people's needs
rather than their wants. √The design in FIGURE J is considered a
necessity for survival as air pollution poses a real threat to the health of
young children. √ (2)
Credit any other well-reasoned answer.
5.1.2 Allocate 2 marks
It’s intended to be both playful and featuring simple shapes. √ It has
bright colours that draw attention. √It is educational – the mask is made
of many interchangeable parts so children and parents can assemble it
themselves. √By colouring the different parts of the mask, it is intended
to teach children about how the mask works. √The interchangeable
pieces also allow kids to customise it introducing a greater sense of
ownership. √ (2)
5.1.3 Allocate 2 marks
No. The device may be considered socially unacceptable from an
aesthetic viewpoint. Society expects individuals to conform and in most
parts of the world wearing a face mask in public is not common
practice. √ As a practical device it does not apply to places where air
quality is not a threat to people. √
Yes. Air quality is deteriorating in major cities because of air pollution
(smog). √Flu epidemics and airborne transmissible viruses such as
Ebola are becoming more prevalent in the world. √ (2)
Credit any other well-reasoned responses.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
16 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2018)
5.1.4 Allocate a total of 14 marks
Allocate 7 marks per essay for each designer
Allocate 1 combined mark for the name of the designer/design
agency/studio and the title of a product
SOUTH AFRICAN DESIGNER/DESIGN AGENCY/STUDIO
YTSAI Design Studios, ‘Vissershok Primary School’. √ (1)
YTSAI has been involved in various community projects in association
with Safmarine – including the creative conversion of a decommissioned
Safmarine shipping container into a much-needed classroom for a rural
South African school. √The classroom is constructed to address green
principles as well as supporting social functions including a projecting roof
to shelter bleacher seating (raised strands consisting of tiered rows of
bleaches) that wraps into a vertical surface for movie screenings. √ At just
12m2, the colourful classroom provides a learning space for 25 learners in
Grade R. √ The structure serves as a classroom in the morning and a
school library in the afternoon for learners and community. √The
building is sustainable in that the airflow is natural and implemented by
means of a gap between the roof and container, saving on electricity for
cooling. √ The large roof keeps out direct sunlight and reduces heat while
the colourful windows staggered along the sides of the container ensures
cross ventilation. √ Steel frames extend outward from the container to a
cute play area with swings, climbing ropes and a slide amongst other fun
filled items for the children to run, jump and play. √ The arena-style
stepped seating provides a space for children to mingle and socialise
while having lunch and also offers a good place for school assemblies. √
Adjacent to the container is a fairly large area that has been set aside as
a vegetable garden. √Here children can learn to grow their own food
also providing the school with fresh produce to further supplement their
feeding program. √ (6)
Other South African examples may include: Monkeybiz; Mapula;
Miele; Garth Walker; Streetwires. Credit any other relevant
examples and information
INTERNATIONAL DESIGNER/DESIGN AGENCY/STUDIO
Diébédo Francis Kéré, ‘Gando Primary School and Library’. (1)
Diébédo Francis Kéré is a German-trained architect from the small West
African village of Gando in Burkina Faso. In 1998, while still a student, he
founded ‘Bricks for Gando’, a charitable foundation focusing on
sustainable architecture for the growth of his community, √ and he began
to raise funds to build a primary school and library in his home village. √
The village of Gando has 3 000 inhabitants that live in small mud huts
with tin or straw roofs and there is no access to running water or
electricity.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2018) DESIGN P1 17
The community was originally sceptical about the use of clay in the
school’s construction, as clay is perceived as a poor material, unlikely to
survive the rainy season; sturdier concrete is preferred. However, as
concrete would have been both expensive and highly unsuitable, becoming
extremely hot in the high temperatures of Burkina Faso, Kéré utilised clay
which is both cheap and locally available. √The clay was protected with
a wide tin roof raised up over the building to protect it from the rain and
permit air to circulate beneath, keeping temperatures low and providing an
ideal learning environment for Gando’s children. √
The men and women from the village helped crush stones to prepare the
flooring, collected stones for the foundations and pressed earth for the
school walls bringing the community together. √ This also radically reduced
the potentially huge costs of European engineers and builders. √ Through
helping out with the project, villagers were also receiving training across a
range of construction techniques, developing their own skills √and
opening a window of opportunity for them to secure other building jobs. √
In a region with a literacy rate well below the national average of 25%,
most pupils’ parents are illiterate and they have no books at home. The
library enables pupils to broaden their knowledge and to gain a deeper
understanding of their school subjects and the world around them. √It is
also open to non-students, and is therefore a valuable resource for the
entire community. √The eucalyptus facade around the library creates a
calm and open space in which pupils can both study and relax. √This is
the first time in Gando that eucalyptus wood has been used for
construction. The roof’s design also represents a technical innovation as
traditional clay pots have been cut in half and inserted in the ceiling, letting
in light and allowing fresh air to circulate. √ (6)
Other international examples include: B.J. Krivaneck; Adriana Bertini.
Credit any other relevant examples and information [20]
Q5.1 LEVEL COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
Remember, Recall, 5.1.1; 5.1.4 1+2
Recognise, Name
Lower order 30%
Understand, Explain, 5.1.1; 5.1.4 1+2
Describe, Classify
Apply, Implement, 5.1.2; 5.1.4 2+6
Middle order 40%
Organise
Analyse, Compare, 5.1.4 2
Interpret
Evaluate, Reflect, 5.1.4 2
Higher order 30%
Judge
Synthesise, Justify, 5.1.3 2
Create
OR
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
18 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2018)
5.2 5.2.1 Allocate 2 marks
Yes. The woven structure of the basket makes it strong and suited to its
purpose as a shopping bag and for the transporting of large loads. √
The materials do not wear easily making them durable and long lasting.
√ They are made from natural materials therefore they do not pose a
threat to the environment. √The basket form allows for a wide opening
to stuff full of groceries. √The handles are strong and thick making it
comfortable for the handler to hold and carry over long distances. √
Decorative patterns and dye coloured strands can be incorporated into
the woven basket to reflect contemporary trends. √ (2)
Credit any other well-reasoned response.
5.2.2 Allocate 8 marks in total
Candidates to choose to discuss only ONE of these traditional
crafts: isiZulu basketry, isiZulu pottery, isiZulu beadwork,
isiXhosa beadwork or Ndebele wall painting
Marks can ONLY be awarded for the relevant aspect
EXAMPLE: isiZulu Beadwork
Allocate 3 marks
Materials, methods and processes in making the craft product:
The materials, methods and processes used by Zulu beaders show the
use of different kinds of materials to take beadwork to new levels by
combining traditional beadwork skill with contemporary designs √ to
create jewellery and objects that delights the senses with their richness
and colour. √ Seeds, stones, bits of bone, colourful glass beads and
precious gemstones are used. √ The brightly coloured beads are
creatively strung on cotton thread in specific rows using colour as
meaning and message. √ (3)
Allocate 3 marks
A description and analysis of ONE example:
The beaded love letter is used by Zulu women to communicate with their
men. √ This communication is coded in colours and geometric triangular
shapes and usually contain a maximum of seven colours. √ The three
corners represent the father, mother and child. √ White usually represents
spiritual love, purity and virginity. √ Colour Coding refers to the use of
various colours to convey meaning in a code. Colour coding assumes
that in a given context various basic colours have a static meaning, literal
or figurative. √ (3)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2018) DESIGN P1 19
Allocate 2 marks
The possible functions of the craft product:
Traditional beadwork was used as a method of colonial trade. √ It was
also a means of expression, communication and storytelling. √ In the
past, patterns and colours were woven into beadwork, symbolising
feelings and ideas to lovers and friends. √ The function of most of the
beadwork is created by women living in the rural areas of South Africa. √
They have always expressed themselves through personal decoration
and that came as an expression to enhance physical appearance. √ Apart
from that, beadwork could express superior status √ or magical properties
to protect human from illness or hurtful forces. √ (2)
Credit any other well-reasoned response.
5.2.3 Allocate 10 marks in total
Marks can ONLY be awarded for the relevant aspect
The name of the designer/design group and the name of the
product:
Monkeybiz, ‘Beaded dolls, bags, animals, cushion covers and
sculptures’. √ (1)
A brief description and analysis of at least ONE work, explaining
how it reflects the influence of the traditional craft:
Monkeybiz purchases richly coloured glass seed beads in bulk and
supplies it to women in the townships of Cape Town. √High quality
beads are used for maximum luster. √The structure of each beaded
doll is constructed of wire and Monkeybiz recycles discarded cotton
clothing off-cuts from clothing manufacturers as the stuffing material for
beaded dolls and animals. √Monkeybiz brings the beads and cotton to
the bead artists and once the artwork is completed the bead art pieces
are collected from them. √The main artworks crafted by the beaders
are inspired by African wildlife such as giraffes, lions and elephants. √
The beaded patterns are influenced by their cultural background
incorporating geometric patterns such as chevrons, stripes and
crosses. √The colours used are predominantly brightly coloured
contrasting colours such as black and white orange and blue etc. √ Every
piece is a unique once-off artwork and is signed by the artist. √ (5)
The ethical concerns that are addressed by the work of the
designer/design group:
As a non-profit company, Monkeybiz operates in a donated office space
and the artists beading to do at home which allows them to look after
their families and avoid transport costs. √It is a sustainable income –
generating organisation that provides self-employment opportunities to
bead artists and provides them with skills training and support. √ They
live in Cape Town’s informal settlements like Khayelitsha, Philippi,
Mandela Park and other areas and many of them are HIV positive. The
beadwork project provides self-employment opportunities to 450 women
who were previously unemployed, with 200 women on the waiting list. √ (4)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
20 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2018)
Other examples include: Haldane Martin, Monkeybiz, Laduma
Ngxokolo. Credit any other relevant designers. [20]
Q5.2 LEVEL COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
Remember, Recall, 5.2.2; 5.2.3 1+3
Recognise, Name
Lower order 30%
Understand, Explain 5.2.2 2
Describe, Classify
Apply, Implement, 5.2.1; 5.2.2; 1+3+4
Middle order 40%
Organise 5.2.3
Analyse, Compare, 5.2.2; 5.2.3 1+1
Interpret
Higher order
Evaluate, Reflect, 5.2.2; 5.2.3 1+2
30%
Judge
Synthesise, Justify, 5.2.1 1
Create
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2018) DESIGN P1 21
QUESTION 6 (20 marks)
6.1 Allocate 6 marks in total
- As the structure was built by hand no machinery was used, conserving
electricity and limiting carbon emissions from fuel burning machines. √
- The building materials were locally available on site limiting the carbon
footprint of vehicles transporting material over distances to and from the
construction site. √
- The structure was erected in 60 days. Therefore no long-term building and
construction processes impacted negatively on the environment. √
- The light wooden structure lifts the roof up, allows light into the building, and
generates natural ventilation; so there is no need for air-conditioners and the
use of electric fans etc. √
- By using natural building materials, there is no need to produce new man-
made materials for the site. √
- There will always be a natural supply of building materials (earth, wood,
vegetation) thereby promoting the principle of sustainability. √
- If the building needs to be torn apart the materials would not pose a threat to
the environment. They would disintegrate naturally. √
- By employing locals to build the structure strong community bonds are formed
and social interaction encouraged. √
- The porch extends into the garden increasing the shaded spaces allowing
people to study outdoors. √ (6)
Credit any other well-reasoned answer.
6.2 Allocate a total of 14 marks
Allocate 7 marks per essay for each designer
Allocate 1 combined mark for the name of the designer/design
agency/studio and the title of a product
Marks can ONLY be awarded for the relevant aspect of the question
INTERNATIONAL DESIGNER/DESIGN AGENCY/STUDIO
The name of the designer/design agency/studio AND the title of a product:
Julie Bargmann, ‘Testing the Waters’/’Vintondale Reclamation Park’. √ (1)
How the designer/design agency or studio addresses environmental and/or
sustainable concerns in his/her/their design process:
Julie Bargmann is internationally recognised as a designer who reclaims polluted
and industrial sites in the USA that have been severely affected by, for example,
mining or the dumping of rubbish. √ She explores the creative potential of these
degraded landscapes and alters them into regenerative landscapes. √ She
always retains something of the history of the site so that people remember what
happened to it. √ (2)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
22 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2018)
General characteristics of the designer/design agency/studio:
Her method is to first identify the site, and then with the help of a team of
historians, engineers, ecologists, artists, landscape architects and scientists,
begin the task of analysing the site for ‘rejuvenation’. √ Acid mine draining is
spilling into the streams and rivers and suffocates life forms – she reclaims such
polluted industrial sites. √ She designs landscapes that blend construction with
elements that represent the physical and cultural histories of the sites at which
she works. √ (2)
The title and a brief description of ONE major design/design project:
‘Testing the Waters’ is the transformation of a former coal mine into a park for
acid mine drainage and community recreation. √ The park consists of a landmass
carved into a passive acid mine drainage (AMD) treatment system which allows
the public to witness the cleansing of the polluted water physically √as it goes
through a series of retention basins and spillways and changes colour from
orange to green to blue-green. √The park also consists of a garden of
alternative rows of native trees and shrubs, as well as recreational amenities
such as picnic grounds, play areas and wildlife trails. √ (2)
Other international examples include: Francis Kéré; Martin Kruger. Credit
any other relevant designers.
SOUTH AFRICAN DESIGNER/DESIGN AGENCY/STUDIO
The name of the designer/design agency/studio AND the title of a product:
Porky Hefer, ‘Weaver Nest.’ √ (1)
How the designer/design agency or studio addresses environmental and/or
sustainable concerns in his/her/their design process:
Hefer focuses on a variety of three dimensional forms from public sculpture to
product and furniture design. √ He embraces Africa and the skills that are readily
available indigenously. He challenges our relationships with everyday objects,
inspiring us to look at in a different way. His ‘human nest’ designs are inspired by
biomimicry (the design and production of materials, structures and systems
based on nature). √ His designs copy the building techniques of weaver birds. √ (2)
General characteristics of the designer/design agency/studio:
Hefer’s woven nests are all handmade in South Africa using local materials and
craft techniques. √ The result is a human nest to be used outside hung in a tree
or inside. Sizes vary and nests can accommodate 1 to 4 people. √The majority
are woven using flexible plants stalks that wrap around steel frames, while some
are covered with leathery skins. √Hefer has explored different materials from
Port Jackson alien vegetation to Kubu cane to recycled plastic packaging straps,
looking for the most sustainable and effective solution. √ (2)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2018) DESIGN P1 23
The title and a brief description of ONE major design/design project:
The ‘Weaver Nest’ resembles the actual weavers’ bird’s nest found in nature. √
The structure is a massive woven structure around a steel frame, which can
house at least two adults and a child. √ The nest is constructed from invasive
plant species such as Port Jackson trees, which supports environmental initiatives
such as the removal of alien vegetation. √ Access to the nest is from the bottom of
the structure which hangs approximately 3 metres from the ground using a rope
ladder. √ (2)
Other South African examples include: Heath Nash; Joseph Diliza. Credit
any other relevant designers. [20]
Q6 LEVEL COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
Remember, Recall,
6.2 2
Recognise, Name
Lower order 30%
Understand, Explain,
6.1; 6.2 2+2
Describe, Classify
Middle order Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 6.1; 6.2 2+6
Analyse, Compare, Interpret 6.1; 6.2 1+1
Higher order Evaluate, Reflect, Judge 30% 6.2 2
Synthesise, Justify, Create 6.1; 6.2 1+1
TOTAL SECTION C: 40
GRAND TOTAL: 100
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Study this subject
Recommended for this subject

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 Eastern Cape Mock 2018 QP (Afr)

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC June 2018 Memo (English)

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC June 2018 Memo (Afrikaans)

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC November 2018 Memo (English)

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC November 2018 Memo (Afrikaans)

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC Supplementary 2018 Memo (Afrikaans)
More from Grade 12 Design

Annual teaching plan
Gr 12 Des ATP 2023 24

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2025 Question Paper (Eng)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2025 Question Paper (Afr)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 November 2024 NSC Question Paper (Eng)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 November 2024 NSC Question Paper (Afr)

Question paper