Downloaded from hlayiso.com
NATIONAL
SENIOR CERTIFICATE
GRADE 12
SEPTEMBER 2017
DESIGN P1 (THEORY)
MARKING GUIDELINE
MARKS: 100
This marking guideline consists of 39 pages.
Skip to contentAll 2017 papers 





View all





Design Grade 12 P1 Eastern Cape Mock 2017 Memo (English)
Grade 12 Design Paper 1 memorandum from the Eastern Cape Mock Exam 2017 (English), 39 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.
Design · Grade 12 · Eastern Cape Mock Exam · 2017. Memorandum, 39 pages. Read online or download the PDF.
- Subject
- Design
- Grade
- Grade 12
- Document type
- Memorandum
- Year
- 2017
- Exam period
- Eastern Cape Mock Exam
- Paper
- 1
- Curriculum
- CAPS
- Pages
- 39
- File size
- 650.8 KB
Free to read online, no sign-up needed
Loading document…
Loading document…
1 of 39
This exam
Eastern Cape Mock Exam 2017
Questions in this paper
Document textSearch extracted text and jump to a page.
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
2 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
SECTION A: DESIGN LITERACY (30 marks in total)
Understand design theory and use design terminology correctly.
The recognition of the characteristics of each movement in all four
categories of design.
Understand and interpret signs and symbols, stereotyping, bias and
prejudice in design.
QUESTION 1: ‘UNSEEN’ DESIGNS TESTING VISUAL LITERACY
1.1 1.1.1 (Allocate 2 marks)
The product seen in FIGURE A is suitable for the tourist market as
the national flower of South Africa, the Protea, is seen displayed as
the image on the bangle. Overseas visitors would delight in
purchasing a product which shows displays a national symbol of the
country of which they visit.
Any woman in South Africa who feels national pride and who
appreciates the flora of our country would feel proud to wear a
beautiful fashion accessory as seen in FIGURE A which displays the
Protea flower, South Africa’s national flower. (2)
1.1.2 (Allocate 8 marks)
Shape and form (element):
The image on FIGURE A makes use of flat, stylised, organic shapes
of a Protea flower with its petals and leaves the different sizes which
bring variety to the design.
Whilst the image of the Protea is flat and 2-dimensional, it is engraved
onto Perspex in the form of a 3-dimensional bangle for the purpose
of wrapping around the wearers’ arm.
Balance (principle):
Balance refers to the visual weight in design. The bangle seen in
FIGURE A shows asymmetrical balance as there is a contrast in size
of the engraved image, as on one side of the bangle the large head
of the Protea flower is shown visually balancing/creating an
equilibrium with the compacted petals and leaves on the other side of
the bangle. Unity with variety of visually balanced images create
harmony in the design.
Movement/rhythm (principle):
Rhythm is created through the repetition of the protea petals and
leaves creating a gentle flow in the design.
Implied movement is shown in this fixed image as it does not have
the ability to move, however a rhythmic movement is created with the
protea petals and leaves facing in the same direction, which creates
a continuous and harmonious feel to the design.
Rhythm is created through the repetition of similar images such as
the outer edges of the protea petals and leaves forming the shape of
the bangle which creates interest and variety in the design.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 3
Focal point/emphasis (principle):
The focus/emphasis is placed on the image of the Protea on the
bracelet, with the flower head and leaves, due to the fact that there is
a strong contrast of the striking gold linear image of the Protea against
the transparent Perspex of the bangle.
The focus/emphasis can also be said to be on the outline/contour
shape of the bangle as the edge of the Protea petals create the outer
edge of the bangle, which also creates a striking contrast to the very
flat Perspex material used to create the bangle.
The focus/emphasis of the image on the bracelet is the head of the
protea flower as it is larger and more dominant than the rest of the
image. It is also a very different shape to the petals and leaves shown
throughout the rest of the design. The effect created is the element of
surprise, by adding something different.
Credit any well-reasoned answer. (8)
[10]
Q1.1 COGNITIVE
WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL SKILLS
Lower Observation / Part of 1.1.1
30% 1+1
order Comprehension Part of 1.1.2
Middle
Application 40% Part of 1.1.2 5
order
Analysis
Higher Synthesis Part of 1.1.1
30% 1+2
order Evaluation / Part of 1.1.2
Deduction
OR
1.2 1.2.1 (Allocate 8 marks)
Tone/Tonal value:
A tone/tonal value of a colour is when a lighter or darker version of the
same colour is used. The white colour that dominates the design of
the lamp seen in FIGURE B is brought to life with the lamp lighting up.
A wide range of tonal values of white is seen as the light is illuminated.
This monochromatic range of whites create a gentle and sophisticated
harmony.
Unity and variety:
Unity is achieved due to the repetition of petal-like shapes. These
petal-like shapes, which open and close and resemble a lotus flower,
are varied in size as they are larger at the base of the lamp and
decrease in size towards the top of the lamp, which creates variety.
This unity, along with the variety, creates harmony in the design of the
lamp, as all the parts work together to achieve a coherence of the
whole creating harmony to form a successful whole.
Texture:
The lamp has tactile smooth quality as it appears to be made from
Perspex or plastic. This smooth surface brings a level of
sophistication and quietness to the design.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
4 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
Pattern:
Pattern occurs when shapes are repeated. In FIGURE B pattern is
evident in the bands of organic petal-like shapes being repeated to
create the overall form of a lotus flower. The repetition of these bands
of petal-like shapes around the form of the lamp gives the design
unity.
With the repeating of the same organic petal-like shapes throughout
the design of the lamp, all the parts work together to achieve a
coherence of the whole creating harmony to form a successful
whole.
The pattern of the lamp is very modular as it is composed of many
different parts/shapes which are repeated. This pattern appears to
resemble the petals of a flower turning a conventionally static object
into a playful, tactile experience as the petal-like shapes are able to
open up into what appears to be a flower in full bloom.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (8)
1.2.2 (Allocate 2 marks)
Bio-mimicry means imitate and is the practice of learning from and
then emulating natural forms to solve human problems and create
more sustainable designs. Bio-mimicry is therefore evident in
FIGURE B as the lamp is composed of petal-like shapes which are
able to open up/expand outwards revealing more illumination from the
lighting device which is central to the design. This mimics the
opening and full bloom of a flower.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (2)
[10]
Q1.2 COGNITIVE
WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL SKILLS
Lower Observation / Part of 1.2.1
30% 2+1
order Comprehension Part of 1.2.2
Middle Part of 1.2.1
Application 40% 4+1
order Part of 1.2.2
Analysis
Higher Synthesis
30% Part of 1.2.1 2
order Evaluation /
Deduction
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 5
QUESTION 2: COMMUNICATION THROUGH DESIGN
2.1 2.1.1 (Allocate 1 mark)
MESSAGE CONVEYED BY THE POSTER
The message conveyed in the poster is the social issue relating to the
danger of cyber bulling and how it could even lead to victims committing
suicide. Through the message of the poster there is an offer of advice
and guidance for young people who are affected by both cyber and offline
bullying, by allowing them to connect online with fully trained online
counsellors.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
2.1.2 (Allocate 4 marks)
Symbolically the centrally placed silhouette of the open hand shows
that the person/victim of cyber bullying is exposed, vulnerable and
feeling weak.
The layout shows a centrally placed silhouette on a black background
which symbolises that the victim does not have an identity, that this
is simply another unidentified person suffering from this form of abuse,
feeling emotionally empty. This simple, stylised image is bold and
dramatic showing the victim is isolated, surrounded by darkness and
in a seemingly empty black void.
All the bold text, diminishing in size the further away it is seen falling
away from the victims arm alludes to the victim being overweight as
words such as ‘fatty’, ‘lard ass’, ‘loser’, ‘pizza face’, et cetera are used.
This reinforces the message from bullies that they aim to diminish the
victim until they have completely faded away, just like the cruel
comments. This text of cruel comments is also seen in bold red
colour, symbolising danger and fear.
The red text across the wrist of the victim symbolically portrays that
the person is slitting his or her wrist and bleeding in an attempt to kill
the emotional pain or commit suicide.
Simple white and also red sans-serif typeface against a black
background effectively conveys the powerful message at the top of
the poster, with the slogan ‘Sticks and stones may break my bones,
but words can kill’. The clear and simple sans-serif text, then
changing to dramatic red colour, offers advice and guidance for young
people who are affected by both cyber and offline bullying, by allowing
them to connect online with fully trained online counsellors.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (4)
2.1.3 (Allocate 2 marks)
THE GESTALT PRINCIPLE OF FIGURE AND GROUND can be
applied as the silhouette of the hand is naturally perceived as figure
(object) while the surrounding area is perceived as ground
(background).
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (2)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
6 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
2.2 2.2.1 (Allocate 1 mark)
A stereotype is a fixed impression on groups of people or individuals
having certain characteristics, or fulfilling prescribed roles. Therefore
the possible stereotype that can be applied to the poster in FIGURE B
is seen in that it idealises Desmond Tutu as a peaceful and religious
icon, without taking into consideration that like every other human
being he has inherent human flaws.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
2.2.2 (Allocate 2 marks)
Desmond Tutu is seen wearing a cross (crucifix) on a chain, a symbol
of the Christian faith which he follows.
The white dove is seen on Desmond Tutu’s shoulder. This is a
stereotypical symbol and demonstrates the message of peace and
purity in the design.
Angels blowing their trumpets are seen in the top corners of the poster
design. This Christian symbol also supports the personal Christian
trait of Desmond Tutu which communicates the idea of goodness and
purity through his spiritual guiding of people.
Desmond Tutu’s hands are seen in the symbolic giving gesture. This
symbolic positioning of his hands demonstrates his open and giving
nature and how is he has a servant-attitude to the people that he
guides.
The entire illustration appears to represent Christianity. The beautiful
sinuous curved plant-like design in the background resembles a
Gothic stained-glass window, in the typical pointed arch style, as seen
in cathedrals. Gothic style font is used to display the name of
Desmond Tutu.
The all-seeing, all-knowing eye of God at the top of the poster design
is understood as a symbol of protection and healing, and guidance of
divine power.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (2)
[10]
Q2 COGNITIVE WEIGHTING
QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL SKILLS %
Observation / 2.1.1
Lower
Recall / 30% Part of 2.1.2 1+1+1
order
Comprehension Part of 2.1.3
Part of 2.1.2
Middle
Application 40% Part of 2.1.3 2+1+1
order
Part of 2.2.2
2.2.1
Higher Evaluation /
30% Part of 2.1.3 1+1+1
order Deduction
Part of 2.2.2
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 7
QUESTION 3
Answer EITHER QUESTION 3.1 or QUESTION 3.2.
3.1 (Allocate 10 marks)
The marking guideline has only been written in bullet form to facilitate
marking.
Candidates must write a single essay, without the use of bullets, to show
their ability to evaluate and compare through the application of factual
information.
MATERIALS:
The Xhosa bridal necklace in FIGURE A is made predominantly from glass
beads in a variety of colours, constructed with thread and also including a few
mother-of-pearl buttons. The Indian bridal necklace in FIGURE B is very lavish
and extravagant in comparison to the Xhosa beaded bridal necklace with semi-
precious stones such as rubies and pearls set in gold. Gold is considered an
essential ritual metal when it comes to weddings in India. The monetary value
of the Indian bridal necklace is much higher than the Xhosa bridal necklace due
to the high value of the materials used, yet both are very rich in their significance
and symbolism for the wedding ceremony. This does not mean that the Xhosa
bridal necklace’s value is inferior relative to that of the Indian necklace.
SHAPE AND PATTERN:
In FIGURE A, the traditional diamond-patterned bead collar-style decoration is
seen encircling the bride’s neck and falling gently onto her chest and shoulders.
On top of this, a long, narrow white beaded band with diamond shapes woven
into it, is also placed around the bride’s neck, with beaded tassels falling vertically
down the front of the bride’s chest. The shapes seen in the Xhosa bridal
necklace are all geometric, with the zig-zag formation of the beadwork in the
collar creating the diamond shapes. In FIGURE B the jewelled necklace is
composed of three rows of semi-precious stones set in gold, also fitting around
the bride’s neck, with a large pendant drop design falling vertically from the front
of the tiered necklace.
In the Indian bridal necklace paisley shapes are seen in the three tiers/rows
around her neck, with a rectangular shaped section at the front. From this hangs
an elaborate cluster consisting of a large paisley shaped stone with smaller
paisleys radiating out from this and edged with round pearls. Both FIGURE A
and FIGURE B show symmetrical designs with both sides of the bridal necklace
being the same, however the use of space with pattern of the Xhosa design is
less saturated/crowded than the pattern formations seen in the Indian design.
In both designs one sees shapes of either beads or semi-precious stones which,
when repeated, forms beautiful patterned designs.
UNITY:
Unity is achieved in the way that all the elements in the design are organised,
like the use of specific colours, the even distribution of colours, choice of
materials, shape, texture and line, as seen in both FIGURE A and also
FIGURE B.
In FIGURE A, both the collar of the Xhosa bridal necklace and also the long
overlay band contain diamond shapes, all consist of the same colours and both
sections of the necklace is made from glass beads, which unify the entire design.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
8 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
The overlapping of the two sections also unites the two into one design. Unity
and harmony are thus created through the organisation of all these elements.
In FIGURE B, the entire necklace is made from gold and set with paisley-shaped
segments and pearls which are distributed evenly throughout the design, which
unifies the design, creating a balanced and unified whole.
AESTHETIC APPEAL:
With both the Xhosa bridal necklace in FIGURE A and the Indian bridal necklace
seen in FIGURE B, the bead work communicates the wearer’s social status and
wealth. Both cultures use specific colours in their traditional bridal ceremonies
because by doing so the ritual performance or the tradition is retained. Xhosa
beadwork is also often sought after in the tourism market as many overseas
visitors purchase these items as mementos of their South African experience as
the beadwork offers authentic African origin and expression. The elaborate
Indian necklaces are often very valuable with the gold and semi-precious stones
and perhaps even diamonds. The wife will wear the necklace from the wedding
ceremony as long as she or her husband is alive as a sign of their love and
commitment to one another. The Xhosa bridal necklace is more simplified with
its geometric pattern formations compared to the elaborate, richly ornate Indian
bridal necklace, but each design represents of its own valuable culture through
the traditional bridal ceremony.
PRODUCTION TECHNIQUE:
FIGURE A shows a beaded Xhosa bridal necklace. This hand-made beaded
necklace is crafted by women. Their beadwork is a way of communicating
without words. This is done through patterns, styles and colours and each is
particular to a specific group. Therefore, the wedding necklace holds symbolic
meaning for this special occasion as messages are woven into decorative
geometric designs. FIGURE B shows a bridal necklace manufactured from
metal such as gold and inlaid with semi-precious stones, the hanging pendant
portion trimmed with pearls. These bridal necklaces are largely mass
produced unless a unique hand-crafted necklace made by a jeweller is
desired.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. [10]
Q3.1 COGNITIVE WEIGHTING
QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL SKILLS %
Knowledge /
Lower
Recall 30% Part of 3.1 3
order
Comprehension
Middle Application of
40% Part of 3.1 4
order elements
Analysis
Higher
Synthesis 30% Part of 3.1 3
order
Evaluation
OR
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 9
3.2 (Allocate 10 marks)
The marking guideline has only been written in bullet form to facilitate
marking.
Candidates must write a single essay, without the use of bullets, to show
their ability to evaluate and compare through the application of factual
information.
In this question, the candidate is expected to compare and should be
penalised for writing two separate essays, or for information supplied in a
table form (maximum 3 out of 10).
This comparative essay compares the SA Perm Building in FIGURE C
with the Pantheon Temple, a Classical Roman building. The candidate
may choose any other suitable example for the comparison.
CONTEXT:
The Roman Pantheon is an example of a Roman temple, whereas the SA
Perm Building is a contemporary public/secular building showing influences
and features of ancient Roman architecture.
PURPOSE/FUNCTION:
The purpose of the Pantheon is not known for certain but the name, porch
and pediment decoration suggest a temple of some sort. The Pantheon
may have been designed as a place where the emperor could make public
appearances in a setting, which reminded onlookers of his divine status as
equal to the other gods of the Roman Pantheon. The purpose of the SA
Perm Building is for the facility of banking investments and conducting
financial transactions.
LAYOUT/PLAN:
From the outside, both the Pantheon and the SA Perm Building appear as a
solid, closed collection of geometric forms.
The Pantheon is one solid, circular form under a coffered concrete dome, with
a central opening (an oculus of 8,3 m in diameter) to the sky. This oculus
floods natural light into the circular form, known as the rotunda. However,
although the SA Perm Building is not circular, but featuring rectangular interior
spaces, there is a large central skylight down the spine of the building which
floods natural light into the interior.
Both buildings have interior spaces filled with glowing light due to the vaulted
forms and the light flowing in from the light source overhead.
The Pantheon is fronted by a large portico/porch of large, vertical granite
Corinthian columns under a triangular pediment, almost appearing to be a
separate section attached to the rotunda, whereas the entrance of the SA
Perm Building is flush with the front façade of the building and features sturdy
concrete columns underneath an arch and a roof structure somewhat
reminiscent of a Greek pediment.
The large rotunda section allows for a large gathering of people and the SA
Perm Building allows access for a controlled amount of people to enter and
conduct their financial requirements.
The interiors of both the Pantheon and the SA Perm Building are encircled by
columns; marble Corinthian columns are set on either side of niches
containing statues of deities in the Pantheon, whilst the SA Perm Building’s
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
10 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
cast concrete columns are slender with plain capitals and seen forming
colonnades within the large entrance/foyer.
MATERIALS AND PRODUCTION TECHNIQUES:
The Pantheon, made from a Roman concrete known as mortar, is clad in
marble. The dome is coffered to help reduce its weight; it is 6,4 m thick at
the base and 1,2 m thick at the oculus. The bottom of the dome is made from
mortar/concrete, then lighter materials, ending off with light porous pumice
stone at the top. The downward thrust of the dome is carried by 8 barrel
vaults in the 6,4 m thick wall.
The SA Perm Building is constructed from red facebrick and reinforced
concrete, steel and glass. Modern machinery and technology was used for
construction of this contemporary building. Being a facility dealing with
substantial amounts of money, it would then have an integrated building
control system allowing for efficient and centralised operation programming,
including surveillance, alarm systems, electric systems, etc.
RELATION TO THE SITE:
The Pantheon dominates the site on which it was built, with streets on all
sides of the building. The SA Perm Building steps directly off the busy
pavement in High Street in Grahamstown, the main street of the town.
Credit any other well-reasoned information. [10]
Q3.2 COGNITIVE
WEIGHTING % QUESTION MARKS
LEVEL SKILLS
Lower Knowledge,
30% Part of 3.2 3
order Comprehension
Middle
Application 40% Part of 3.2 4
order
Analysis
Higher
Synthesis 30% Part of 3.2 3
order
Evaluation
TOTAL SECTION A: 30
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 11
SECTION B: DESIGN HISTORY
History of Design: Including Greece, Rome, Gothic, Baroque, Rococo,
Neoclassical, Victorian, Arts and Crafts, Art Nouveau, Bauhaus, Art Deco,
Scandinavian, De Stijl, Modernism, Popular Culture, Pop/New Age and Post
Modernism.
An overview of architecture, in which classical examples are compared with
contemporary works.
Visual Analysis (unseen examples of design): basic terminology that
describes and underpins design and characteristics, to be used with
confidence.
QUESTION 4 (30 marks)
4.1 (Allocate 20 marks in total)
LEARNERS MUST CHOOSE TWO FROM A POSSIBLE NINE DESIGN
MOVEMENTS/STYLES/TIME PERIODS.
NOTE:
For each of the styles or movements candidates must emphasise the
characteristics of that movement that reflect on the quote included.
The chairs as seen in FIGURE A are merely to assist the candidates with
recalling characteristics of the movements/styles. They may refer to any
architecture structures or products from the chosen movement/style.
‘The designer’s true role is to better the things which surround us not only in
terms of function, appearance, cost and material but also in terms of aspiration
and desire – in the dream of how good life might be.’ Terence Conran
BAUHAUS
The movement/style in context: (Allocate 1 mark)
The Bauhaus was founded in a time when the German zeitgeist turned from
emotional Expressionism to the matter-of-fact New Objectivity.
They tried to find solutions for the problems faced by the working classes
during the depression years of post-World War I Germany. They used
technology to create adequate housing and the development of high-quality,
useful, mass-produced consumer goods that were well made. In order to
improve their lifestyles, they desired to achieve aesthetically pleasing and
functional products.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Aims: (Allocate 1 mark)
To provide healthy housing for a growing urban population under difficult
economic conditions.
To take advantage of new technologies.
To achieve a breakthrough for rational and functional form in design
(rationalism and functionalism emphasised).
To make products affordable for the masses through cost-cutting industrial
mass production.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
12 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
Their main objective was to re-image the material world and to reflect the unity
of all the arts.
The Bauhaus school aimed to train their students to create designs that
reflected the machine age, so that designs were pure, simple and
functional.
They aimed to join all art and craft as a functional whole.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Influences: (Allocate 2 marks)
Bauhaus style was influenced by the simple unadorned furniture of the Arts
and Crafts movement.
By the Cubist movement which believed in reducing objects to their most
basic forms (the cube, cylinder and sphere).
By the De Stijl movement which created impersonal, abstract works of square
and rectangular blocks of primary colours separated by vertical and horizontal
lines of black or white; also by the smooth surfaces which looked as if created
by machine and were based on mathematics.
By the American architect Louis Sullivan through his quote: ‘Form Follows
Function’. This meant that objects adhered to the principle of purity and form
and were left unadorned.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (2)
Characteristics: (Allocate 5 marks)
Initially the focus was on hand production using natural materials, then the
focus shifted to incorporation of technology and industrial processes to create
modern design.
The Bauhaus can therefore be seen to be functionalist rather than expressive
and decorative. They encouraged design for mass production.
Design was modern, simple, quality focussed through production and
manufacturing, universal, and functional.
Bauhaus design shuns ornamentation and favours simplicity, function and
elegance.
They used asymmetry and regularity instead of symmetry.
Purity of form.
They stressed ‘truth to materials’ and ‘form follows function’.
Used new materials and technology like reinforced concrete.
They used geometric shapes.
Lines were mostly straight and forms geometric.
Colours were mostly the untreated colour of the materials, such as steel and
concrete and wood or pure, primary colours were used.
Surfaces were smooth, cold and impersonal.
They introduced different materials and techniques in simple, practical
projects.
Dematerialised the conservative forms of furniture – e.g. furniture must be in
its most basic and essential forms, stripped of decoration.
They produced prefabricated furniture.
They placed emphasis on examining the formal and physical properties of
materials.
Chairs were simple and unadorned; light tubular steel frames were used for
open structured chairs that could be mass produced.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 13
Architecture had many features such as: steel-frame construction, a glass
curtain wall, reinforced concrete, open-plan layout with moveable inside walls,
undecorated facades, all services concealed in a central core of the building,
reinforced concrete, cube-like structures, prefabricated units, machine-made
components, purity of form.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (5)
Designer and a work: (Allocate 1 mark)
Cantilever Chair – by Mies van der Rohe
Tubular Chair – by Mies van der Rohe
The Barcelona Chair – by Mies van der Rohe
Zig-Zag Chair – by Gerrit Rietveld
Wassily Chair – by Marcel Breuer
Tac Tea Pot – by Walter Gropius
‘Cradle’ – by Peter Keler
Tea-extract pot 1924 – by Marianne Brandt
‘Ceiling Lamp’ – by Marianne Brandt (1)
(20)
AND/OR
GOTHIC
The movement/style in context: (Allocate 1 mark)
After the fall of the Roman Empire, Europe was in a state of confusion and it
was during this period when disease, war, violence and starvation were
common.
The sense of fear that developed, superstitious beliefs grew and the Christian
church grew as the new authority replacing the Roman emperors.
The architectural style of the church developed into the Gothic style, with
features and design motifs which evoke a spiritual or mystical atmosphere.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Aims: (Allocate 1 mark)
The church had to tower above the village reaching towards heaven, to be
the central point of focus, to give all glory to God.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Influences: (Allocate 2 marks)
The state of confusion and fear experience during this period led the people
to be drawn to strong belief systems, hence the building of very large
churches and cathedrals.
The wealthy landowners, aristocrats, nobility and the Church
In architecture, the Roman basilica plan was adopted in the Gothic
churches.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (2)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
14 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
Characteristics: (Allocate 5 marks)
Architecture:
Due to this new triumphant phase of Christianity, the construction of
magnificent cathedrals was all important.
In a practical manner, the buildings were designed to provide more space and
use less building materials.
Main elements of Gothic architecture included pointed arches, flying
buttresses, ribbed vaults and stained glass windows.
Arches were pointed as the thrust of the pointed arch is downwards,
compared to the rounded arch from the Roman era with its sideward spread
of weight.
The flying buttresses transferred the weight of the upward rising roof down to
the ground – this allowed for large window spaces in the walls (in other words,
the walls did not have to be the only support for the roof).
The cathedral was also a museum of art – used to teach by art the history of
the world and Christianity.
The cathedral was also the sanctuary of the famous and illustrious dead. Their
tombs were its decoration and its pride.
Furniture:
Large and heavy, dark wooden furniture (Oak, Rosewood, Walnut)
The pointed arch, along with intricate carving, features on furniture designs.
Gothic upholstery displayed rich and dark colours, such as purple, ruby, black,
ochre, forest green and gold.
Fabric designs included geometrical and foliage patterns.
Gothic furniture was formal and not designed for comfort.
Illuminated manuscripts:
These are illustrated hand-produced books or manuscripts which had gold
leaf decoration added to the images or type. The gold leaf would reflect light
off the page creating the impression of illumination.
These manuscripts were mostly religious and were produced in monasteries;
decoration could include decorated initials, borders and miniature
illustrations.
Stained-glass windows:
These windows illuminated and added to the atmosphere of the Gothic
church.
They had a narrative function, often depicting biblical scenes.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (5)
Designer and a work: (Allocate 1 mark)
Architecture: Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris (1163-1250)
Architecture: Salisbury Cathedral in Britain (1220-1270)
Architecture: Chartres Cathedral in France (1140-1220)
Tapestry: ‘Lady with the Unicorn’ at Chateau Pierre d’Aubusson (1)
(20)
AND/OR
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 15
ART NOUVEAU
The movement/style in context: (Allocate 1 mark)
They were also against (like Arts and Crafts movement) the unrefined mass
produced articles of the late 19th century.
They created beautifully crafted objects but unfortunately failed to move
with the times as designs were difficult to mass produce. It was too
expensive.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Aims: (Allocate 1 mark)
It grew out of the Arts and Crafts movement so some of the aims were similar:
To establish close links between artists and craftsmen in the design of
products.
To revive the tradition of using skilled craftsmen.
However, they did not reject the idea of factory made goods, but instead they
wanted to transfer the quality of handmade products to factory made products
and made use of modern materials, e.g. metal and steel (wrought iron work)
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Influences: (Allocate 2 marks)
Nature: in their reference to the natural world such as peacocks, lilies and
trailing plants.
Japanese woodprints: with its simple, flowing decorative lines, stylised
forms, grid patterns of room interiors, decorative patterns, and flat coloured
shapes.
Alphonse Mucha: they were influenced by his paintings of women
Gustav Klimt: influenced by Klimt’s use of decorative pattern.
Celtic Art: with its elaborate, curving linear designs, and decorative twisting
ribbon-like patterns.
Viking designs: with their fine lines and spirals, lavish ornamentation and
romantic ideas.
Symbolism (an art movement of that time period): with its flat areas of colour,
organic curved outlines, and sensual designs with curves based on nature
and the female form.
The Arts and Crafts movement: with their natural flowing forms.
Late Gothic style: with its flamboyant lines and stained glass.
French Rococo Art Period: with their delicate lines and forms as well as the
light, playful atmosphere of movement influenced Art Nouveau.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (2)
Characteristics: (Allocate 5 marks)
Subject matter: animals, birds, plants. Very stylised roses (Rennie
Mackintosh), sunflowers, lilies and peacocks, as well as sensuous female
forms.
Products: textiles, ceramics, metal work, glassware, jewellery, furniture and
architecture.
Materials: exotic materials, e.g. mother-of-pearl, lapis lazuli, ivory, iridescent
coloured glass added to metal, ceramic jewellery ware and even furniture and
wrought iron. They used expensive materials like silk, velvet and
embroidery for textiles. They also used lacquered wood, inlaid with other
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
16 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
materials for furniture pieces. Mosaics and stained glass were also
popular.
Ornate and decorative.
Elements of Design:
Line: whiplash line or serpentine line. Curvilinear and languid lines that are
continuous and create stylised shapes.
Shape and Form: organic curvilinear shapes that reflect the rhythm of the
whiplash line.
Colour: for interior they used subtle and subdued pastel colours, e.g. pinks,
greens, yellows.
Colour: flat matt colour contained within curving outlines, generally used for
poster illustrations, e.g. Posters by Mucha.
Principles of Design:
Balance: predominantly asymmetrical
Contrast: large and small forms. Cool colours against warm ones.
Movement: the repetition of the whiplash line creates a sense of movement.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (5)
Designer and a work: (Allocate 1 mark)
Jewellery: ‘Dragonfly brooch’ by Rene Lalique
Art Nouveau brooch designed by Winifred Green
Lamps: ‘Lotus Tale Lamp’ by Louis Comfort Tiffany
Metal work: Cornet dragon gate by Antoni Gaudi
Interior: stairs in the Van Eetvelde House in Brussels by Victor Horta
Furniture: ‘Cabinet Vitrine’ by Gustave Serrurier-Bovy
Poster: ‘Pen’ poster by Alphonso Mucha
‘Job’ poster by Alphonso Mucha (1)
(20)
AND/OR
ARTS AND CRAFTS MOVEMENT
The movement/style in context: (Allocate 1 mark)
Multi-storey buildings, factories, bridges and railway lines started to appear
towards the end of the 19th century and rapid urbanisation often resulted in
slums.
Factories proved to be serious health risks so the period was the beginning
of socialism and protection of the rights of craftsmen.
This movement was a backlash against the forces of industrialisation in
Britain.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Aims: (Allocate 1 mark)
To encourage the production of handmade quality goods of visually aesthetic
value, as opposed to low quality, over fussy mass-produced products.
To improve the life of designers and crafters
To re-establish the value and involvement of the skilled craftsman and
designer.
To encourage the design of simpler, less decorative products.
To create and make products using undecorated, natural materials (e.g. wood
and stone). This was to reveal the natural beauty of the materials.
To bring back social order, stability and good Christian values.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 17
Influences: (Allocate 2 marks)
The Medieval Gothic style, a period associated with order, stability and
good Christian values. This was represented in designs by the use of the
pointed arch as well as the Quatrefoil and Trefoil motifs and included mythical
themes such as dragons.
The Rustic English cottage style – simple peasant or cottage style of
architecture and handmade furniture – that made use of local materials left in
their natural state (stone, wood), for example chairs with carved wood and
woven seats. Floorboards were left bare and roof beams left exposed to
reveal the natural beauty of the materials. This is known as ‘truth to
materials’.
Influenced by everyday life scenes (genre) from nature, e.g. animals and
flower motifs.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (2)
Characteristics: (Allocate 5 marks)
The Arts and Crafts movement revived an interest in handicrafts such as
embroidery, carving, block printing and stained glass windows.
Subject matter included plants, animals, birds and medieval design motifs
(e.g. the trefoil and quatrefoil)
Products: textiles, furniture, ceramics, handmade leather-bound books, metal
work and architecture.
Materials: natural materials such as wood and stone. They sourced local
materials where possible. They used cast iron as the standard components
in buildings as well as glass and steel.
Decoration: used to enhance the basic design – never for the sake of
decoration alone. Ornamentation kept to a minimum. They stayed ‘true
to materials’ in domestic arts (e.g. wood in furniture was not lacquered).
They mixed diverse elements such as turrets, pointed arches and Georgian
windows.
Use of Elements and Principles:
Shapes: were simple and austere without any additional decoration (e.g. as
seen in furniture). Textiles and ceramic designs were more organic due to
the influence of plant and animals.
Colour: they made use of flat areas of bold colour in different shades of blue,
yellow and red. They also made use of earth tones.
Balance: generally symmetrical due to the medieval Gothic influence of
stability and order.
Unity: usually achieved through the repetition of organic lines or subject
matter.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (5)
Designer and a work: (Allocate 1 mark)
Textile (tapestry): ‘The Strawberry Thief’ by William Morris
Furniture: Morris arm chair by William Morris
Architecture: The Red House by Phillip Webb (1)
(20)
AND/OR
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
18 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
SCANDINAVIAN
The movement/style in context: (Allocate 1 mark)
Scandinavian design developed during the 1950s in Denmark, Norway,
Sweden and Finland.
Immediately following World War II the availability of low-cost materials and
methods for mass production made the concept of creating beautiful and
functional everyday objects that could be afforded by everyone possible.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Aims: (Allocate 1 mark)
To create beautiful, visually aesthetic and functional everyday objects that
could be afforded by everyone.
To create simple, elegant designs without compromising on quality and
without losing grace and beauty which softened the interior without
cluttering it.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Influences: (Allocate 2 marks)
The Modernist and Bauhaus movements with their artistic innovation as well
as technological and social progress.
The evolution of modern furniture designs as art, technology and architectural
theories combined and progressed.
Social democracy which developed in the 1950s caused the start of this
movement.
Machinery, new technology and new materials that were available after World
War II influenced them.
Sometimes the Surrealist movement inspired them.
Long winters with few hours of sunlight inspired Scandinavian designers to
create bright, light and practical environments with clean lines.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (2)
Characteristics: (Allocate 5 marks)
Colour: light coloured wood; designs printed in exciting, bright and cheerful
colours.
Pattern: simple and artistic printed designs, using a lot of stylised florals, dots
and stripes.
Form/shape: soft rounded edges; simple often organic shapes;
biomorphic forms combined with harder-edged geometric forms, furniture
simple in shape with clean lines and smooth textures. They paid attention
to good craftsmanship and comfort.
Line: furniture had clean smooth lines with organic as well as straight lines;
fashion saw simple A-line skirts and dresses
New materials: fibreglass, wood, rubber, plastic, vinyl and plywood. Form-
pressed wood, anodised or enamelled aluminium or pressed steel.
They used modern materials such as plastics to create simple stack chairs.
Attention to detail and finish is emphasised.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (5)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 19
Designer and a work: (Allocate 1 mark)
3-D Product: Arne Jacobsen – Egg Chair or The Ant Chair
2-D Product: Maija Isola – Marimekko fabric design
Architecture: Aalvar Aalto – Helsinki Cultural Centre
Communication: Anders Beckman – Swedish Air Lines poster (1)
(20)
AND/OR
BAROQUE
The movement/style in context: (Allocate 1 mark)
The popularity and success of the Baroque style was encouraged by the
Catholic Church in response to the Protestant Reformation that the arts
should communicate religious themes in direct and emotional involvement.
The Baroque era is often thought of as a period of artistic style that used
exaggerated motion and clear, easily interpreted detail to produce drama,
tension, exuberance, and grandeur in sculpture, painting, architecture,
literature, dance, theatre and music. The style began around 1600 in Rome
and spread to most of Europe.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Aims: (Allocate 1 mark)
Characterised by austerity and was intended to impress; express power and
control.
The aim of Baroque architecture was to apply the architectural elements in
the most visually aesthetic manner to create a sense of greatness and
dramatic effect.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Influences: (Allocate 2 marks)
Baroque design and art is heavily influenced by the Counter Reformation:
This refers to the period in history when the Catholic Church reflects on
church practices and principles and implements positive changes.
The church used Baroque art and design to reach out to the people and
promote a rebirth of faith.
Baroque design also appealed to the wealthy and aristocracy who were drawn
to the drama, scale and ability to impress.
Stylistically Baroque borrowed from the Medieval and Renaissance styles.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (2)
Characteristics: (Allocate 5 marks)
Baroque buildings are colossal with dramatic proportions, displaying
massive staircases and columns and complicated, elaborate decorations.
Both buildings and furniture show angels, cupids and saints as sculptures,
figurines, wall décor and fountains.
Emphasis on the oval shape; sweeping and curved surfaces, ‘c’ and ‘s’ scrolls
and shell motifs.
Baroque style is also known as the ‘Heavy Style’
A variety of swelling rounded and curvy forms were used.
Designers made use of wealthy, glossy materials such as marble, gilding and
bronze.
There are dramatic combinations of architecture, sculpture, silver, silks, rich
tapestries and luxurious finishing.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
20 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
The furniture designs are imposing and are the work of sculptors not
carpenters.
The use of gold, precious metals, mirrors and marble predominates.
Examples of Baroque design have dynamic compositions, a sense of
drama (theatrical), strongly contrasting colour and interplay between light
and shadows. Strong emphasis is placed on drama and movement.
Many designs refer to religious content, a move away from the pure
Renaissance focus on logic and reason.
Emotional and dramatic themes.
Interiors dazzled with the lavishness of gold, silver, silks, rich tapestries and
luxurious furnishings.
Pompous facades with gables.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (5)
Designer and a work: (Allocate 1 mark)
Ceiling Fresco: Triumph of the Name of Jesus by G. Battista Gaulli (Rome)
(1672–85)
Interior: Hall of Mirrors at Versailles by Hardouin Mansart and Le Brun
(1678)
Architecture: Colonnade of St Peter’s by GIanlorenzo Bernini (Rome) (c.
1656)
Product: Baldacchino(Altar) in St Peters by Bernini, (Rome), (1624–1633)
Graphic: The Elderly Fool and His Cat by Alexander Voetll, (17th century) (1)
(20)
AND/OR
RENAISSANCE
The movement/style in context: (Allocate 1 mark)
It marked the beginning of objective scientific experimentation, research and
rational thinking.
Great thinkers, artists and designers like Michelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci
and Raphael gave visual expression to the ideals of the Renaissance.
They encouraged innovative thinking, some examples of which are:
1455 – The printing press with moveable metal type, by Johannes Gutenberg
which marked the beginning of printed information becoming available to all
those that could read.
1606 – The astronomical telescope invented by Galileo Galilei. It is the
beginning of objective experimentation as we know it.
1629 – The steam turbine by Govanni Brance.
1714 – The mercury thermometer by Gabriel Fahrenheit.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 21
Aims: (Allocate 1 mark)
Reasoning, questioning and the representation of the human figure as an
individual were important.
Humanism is the Renaissance philosophy which maintains that every
individual has the right to think, reason, question and decide their own
beliefs.
The word Renaissance means the revival/rebirth of something. In the 14th and
16th centuries it referred specifically to the return to classical ideals in art and
architecture as well as a return to reason, thought and objective
experimentation in science.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Influences: (Allocate 2 marks)
The Renaissance was a rebirth of the Roman traditions of design and
architecture.
Product design often features ornamentation inspired by Michelangelo and
Raphael.
Mythological and Biblical figures are often incorporated.
Artists from the early Renaissance period used the natural world as a
reference for their art and often art considerations were approached through
observation and systematic investigation.
The rational approach visualised by these artists differs greatly from the
purely faith-inspired artefacts, designs and art from the medieval and Gothic
periods.
There was a focus on direct observation and the accurate reflection of
nature.
There was also a focus on idealism and perfection.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (2)
Characteristics: (Allocate 5 marks)
Design during the period is characterised by naturalism; the organisation
of space; the use of perspective; a revival of classical ideals and
motifs.
Visual aesthetics was most important to the Renaissance artists and
designers, and architecture emphasises harmony and balance. This was
achieved through symmetry, mathematical geometry, scale and proportion in
the Greek tradition. Architecture of the time includes columns,
hemispherical domes and semi-circular arches.
Building designs were frequently square or rectangular with the emphasis on
symmetry. Facades were generally symmetrical around the vertical axis.
Furniture design is true to the purpose of the piece, and often incorporates
mythological or Biblical figures. Walnut was a common wood of choice.
Wooden chests and beds were key pieces of furniture during the
Renaissance.
Furniture design included inlaid panels of wood as well as detailed carving of
scenes from nature and everyday life.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
22 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
Rope beds consisting of an oblong-shaped framing of wood with interlocking
ropes were popular.
The Renaissance is also known for its very fine tapestries.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (5)
Designer and a work: (Allocate 1 mark)
Jewellery: Pendant designs by Hans Holbein (c. 1532–1543).
Architecture: St Peter’s Cathedral by Michelangelo, (Rome), (1546–1564)
Engraving: The temptation of St. Anthony by Schongauer, (c. 1480–1490)
Product: Canopied ceremonial bridal bed by Pieter Kolding, (c. 1640–1650)
Woodcut: Four horsemen of the Apocalypse by Albrecht Durer from 1498
Architecture: Dome of Florence Cathedral by Filippo Brunelleschi, (1420) (1)
(20)
AND/OR
ART DECO
The movement/style in context: (Allocate 1 mark)
Art Deco was about sensational, carefree modern living and daring new
designs.
They were fascinated by speed, technology and ancient cultures.
They tried to escape through the unreal environments they created.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Aims: (Allocate 1 mark)
To respond to the demands of the machine and of new materials as well as
the requirements of mass production.
To create a new style for a new century.
To create good-quality, practical, mass-manufactured pieces from innovative,
industrial materials.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (1)
Influences: (Allocate 2 marks)
Early 20th century painting movements, with particular reference to: -
- Cubism (abstraction, distortion and simplification) resulting in the use of
straight lines, the zig-zag and layered geometric shapes.
- Constructivism with its abstract shapes and use of non-traditional materials
(e.g. Perspex) and the industrial method of welding.
Speed and technology - the development of the machine, the motorcar and
aeroplane and the study of aerodynamics.
African art and the American Jazz culture.
Egyptian motifs (the lotus bud and the papyrus)
Aztec and red Indian motifs (stepped Aztec ziggurat shape)
The surface effects and techniques of Oriental art (layers of oriental lacquer,
e.g. shellac) and the use of inlays of pearl, tortoise shell, snakeskin and
sharkskin coverings.
The Russian ballet with their use of brilliant colours and patterns in their
theatre designs.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 23
The worldwide movement, Modernism, with its emphasis on non-
representational motifs, clean lines and pure geometric forms (later Art Deco
period).
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (2)
Characteristics: (Allocate 5 marks)
Themes: Egyptian motifs, anything popular and trendy and the Jazz Age
Motifs: Sunbursts, zig-zags
The art and sculpture of Africa with its strange distortions and jagged
planes.
Aeroplanes, trains, cars – a preoccupation with travel and speed.
The fashionable female figure in profile.
Shape: the emphasis was on flat, 2-D designs.
Forms: stylised and decorative, more angular.
Colour: flat, bold and exotic colours, with no tonal modelling of colour.
Strong emphasis on line – e.g. geometric fan motifs, sunbursts showing linear
rays of the sun.
Texture: rich with great attention being paid to the play of a variety of surface
textures – coarse textures contrasted with smooth and gleaming areas of
metallic sheen.
Art Deco furniture is streamlined in design. It has a modern and sleek look,
but was comfortable.
They used exotic woods e.g. Cuban mahogany, ebony and olive) and wood
was often highly lacquered.
They used inlaid work in furniture.
Art Deco uses symmetrical balance in design.
It is an eclectic style borrowing from past styles.
Art Deco often combined circular and angular shapes in furniture.
Jewellery: a vast range of jewellery was produced using precious and semi-
precious stones.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (5)
Designer and a work: (Allocate 1 mark)
Architecture: The Chrysler Building – designed by William van Alen
Poster: ‘Fast Forward’ by Cassandre
Poster: ‘Normandie’ by Cassandre
Furniture: Art Deco Club chair – by Donald Deskey
Textile: ‘Dalmations’ – by Violetta Janes
Teaset: ‘Morning Tea Set’ – by Clarice Cliff
Teaset: Art Deco silver tea set with ivory handles – designed by Edward
Vines (1)
Credit any other valid and supported facts (2 x 10) (20)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
24 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
Q4.1 COGNITIVE WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL SKILLS %
Observation /
Lower
Recall / Explain 30% Part of 4.1 6
order
Comprehension
Middle
Application 40% Part of 4.1 8
order
Analysis
Higher
Synthesis 30% Part of 4.1 6
order
Evaluation / Justify
4.2 4.2.1 (Allocate 2 marks)
FIGURE B represents De Stijl
FIGURE C represents Deconstructivism (2)
4.2.2 (Allocate 8 marks)
Candidates must answer in paragraphs and not in table form.
The marking guideline has only been written in bullet form to
facilitate marking. Candidates must write a single essay, without
the use of bullets, to show their ability to evaluate and compare
through the application of factual information.
BALANCE:
In FIGURE B only two of the primary colours, blue and yellow, are
used to block in minimal areas of the black grid on the white ground,
which is typical of De Stijl. The larger amount of white, visually
lighter space balances out the smaller, visually heavier areas of black
and the primary colours. De Stijl designers believed in balance,
harmony, order, logic and purity. Spaces are arranged in geometric
shapes which create balance and harmony. The De Stijl inspired
dress does not show equal divisions of space which could result in a
boring design, but rather the divisions of colour blocks are less equal
resulting in a harmonious balance or relationship between
sections.
In FIGURE C a visual tension is created between the fragmented and
unbalanced shapes of the garment. The nature of deconstruction
is not to ‘break down’ but rather to show the tension and relationship
between opposing forces. We generally believe that garments
should appear structured and secure on our bodies, not fragmented
and unstable which creates a feeling of uncertainty, unease or
anxiety. This Deconstruction garment typically shows a part of the
garment left unfinished and the traditional structure and production
method of a fashion item ignored. With regards to the garment
under the jacket, which hangs below the model’s knee in length, there
appears to be an imbalance as more of the model’s body is exposed
than one would expect from a long garment. Therefore, this
fragmented garment, aimed to create a visual style that represents
the invisible relations between opposing elements, leads the viewer
to experience a sense of spontaneity and surprise.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 25
PROPORTION/SCALE:
In FIGURE B proportional relationships can be seen in the distribution
of colour where the larger white proportion of the garment is
compared to the smaller areas of the black grid and primary colours.
This is a characteristic of De Stijl where they use of pure geometric
forms; designs are abstract and minimalist. The entire block-like
pattern design of the garment is large and dominant in proportion to
the short mini-dress, creating a dramatic, bold and striking
appearance. The proportion of white lace fabric is larger compared
to the smaller proportion of bold black and primary colours
incorporated in the grid pattern.
In FIGURE C the proportion of the over-garment/jacket is seen to
consist of more fabric and coverage than the under-garment/tunic
which is fragmented and hangs loosely to a length below the model’s
knee. The relationship between these two pieces of the outfit show
a typical characteristic of Deconstructivism where often opposing
ideas or relationships have an order/hierarchy. This
Deconstructivism characteristic aims to create a visual style that
represents the invisible relations between opposing elements. This
provokes a feeling of uncertainty, unease, shock and disruption.
MOVEMENT:
In FIGURE B the basic geometric shapes are combined in an
abstract, simple, unified manner, typical of De Stijl, yet static
movement is perceived where the viewer’s eye jumps from one block
of colour to the next with the use of bold, contrasting colours.
Creating visually powerful effect.
True to the nature of Deconstruction, the under-garment of
FIGURE C shows displaced, distorted shapes which are repeated,
thus creating implied movement. The theory of Deconstruction is
characterised by ideas of fragmentation and generally has the
appearance of ‘coming apart’. In Deconstruction, space seems to
be ‘cut’ with a diagonal focus, creating a sense of movement and
dynamism, and visual chaos.
FOCUS/EMPHASIS/DOMINANCE:
In FIGURE B the focus/emphasis falls on the black grid of vertical and
horizontal lines which are filled in with flat blue and yellow colours on
the dress, these pure geometric shapes being the typical subject
matter of De Stijl design. The colours are flat and strong in tonal
value, contrasted against the soft white lace background, as De Stijl
limited their colour palettes to pure primary colours plus black and
white. This strong contrast of colour and texture creates an overall
emphasis and focus on the grid pattern, although not having a central
focus point, indicating severity through the simplification of design
elements.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
26 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
In FIGURE C the fragmented, opened-up section of the garment
becomes the area of focus, emphasis and dominance as the viewer’s
eye tends to be drawn to this area immediately with the contrast of
the pale body of the model showing through the open sections of the
black clothing. This leads to the element of surprise or shock as the
‘opened-up’ garment is emphasised and unexpected.
Consider any other well-reasoned and supported facts. (8)
[10]
Q4.2 COGNITIVE WEIGHTING
QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL SKILLS %
Lower Recall Part of 4.2.1
30% 2+1
order Comprehension Part of 4.2.2
Middle
Application 40% Part of 4.2.2 4
order
Analysis
Higher
Synthesis 30% Part of 4.2.2 3
order
Evaluation
TOTAL SECTION B: 30
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 27
SECTION C: DESIGN IN A SOCIO-CULTURAL/ENVIRONMENTAL AND
SUSTAINABLE CONTEXT
Critically reflect on how design shapes the physical and social environment.
Choose THREE award-winning contemporary International designers whose
work demonstrates environmental responsibility.
An understanding of the ways in which design can be used to reinforce or
challenge social, cultural, environmental and ethical issues. Study THREE
two-AND/OR three-dimensional South African and African craft designs, past
and present whose work demonstrates social responsibility.
Demonstrate ways in which design can be used to benefit society.
QUESTION 5 (20 marks)
Answer EITHER QUESTION 5.1 or QUESTION 5.2.
5.1 5.1.1 (Allocate 2 marks)
Socially responsible design is design that is mindful of the designer’s role
and responsibility in society; and the use of the design process to bring
about social change.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (2)
(Allocate 4 marks)
The Bamboo homes seen in FIGURE A are sustainable as they are
built from bamboo which can be harvested without causing
environmental degradation, which ultimately safeguards mankind.
Bamboo naturally constantly regenerates itself with new shoots, even
with regular harvesting of mature timber, therefore making the
harvesting of bamboo sustainable for the earth and benefitting the
people.
The bamboo is locally sourced and inexpensive to harvest therefore
making it an affordable alternative building material for the majority of
the poorer community in Southeast Asia. They can be easily
assembled on site and are affordable.
Bamboo can be used for building purposes without the use of
dangerous toxic chemicals which could harm nature and mankind.
Bamboo comes from nature and is returned to nature in a natural
cycle making it a safe dwelling.
Bamboo is a natural anti-bacterial therefore it can be used as a
building material which ensures that it will not harbour sickness.
The homes seen in FIGURE A are designed to withstand the severe
flooding which is prevalent in Southeast Asia. Bamboo is water-
resistant therefore a suitable material for the construction of these
homes.
The strength, flexibility and light weight of bamboo also renders it a
suitable material for the construction of the homes which need to
withstand the severe flooding, with the rising and falling of incoming
waters, as safety is of prime importance for the people in this severe
flooding region.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
28 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
The use of bamboo for the building of these homes and also the re-
use of oil drums makes this a design with a low carbon footprint. No
major machinery is used for the construction of these homes resulting
in relatively low energy consumption and low pollution. This
construction also allows the homes to safely float during the flooding
season.
The architects have considered the comfort factor of the residents.
With the hot, humid climatic conditions of Southeast Asia the design
of the roof has triangular cut-outs which open up in every direction,
creating natural cross breezes and shade. When turbulent weather
comes, the residents can be protected inside the homes when the
roof pieces are closed up.
Residents are able to harvest their own crops on the vertical
suspended bamboo planters which are alongside their outside
walls.
Rainwater harvesting systems are in place which can be used for
the suspended vertical garden.
Credit any other well-reasoned responses. (4)
5.1.2 (Allocate a total of 14 marks for one essay on TWO designers.)
Candidates to choose a South African designer/design group AND an
International designer/design group. They must be concerned with
helping to bring about change in ANY social issue. Examples are:
poverty; capitalisation; gender issues; health issues; social injustices;
racism and marginalisation.
Note: A learner may use any example from an LTSM as
prescribed in the LPG (i.e. the Woolworths Book ‘Living
with Design Daily’ or ‘Craft Art in SA’ by E. Coetzee)
EXAMPLE OF A LOCAL DESIGNER/DESIGN GROUP
STREETWIRES (Design group)
THEY AIM TO:
Tackle the problems of unemployment and poverty in South Africa.
To create meaningful long-term employment for as many South
Africans as possible
Improve the quality of life of many previously destitute South Africans
by providing a workplace, permanent employment, a sense of
purpose and access to skills training and personal development.
SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY:
The company believes that the major hurdle facing our country is
unemployment:
- It is the leading cause of numerous social ills such as poverty.
- It hampers community growth and development.
- and to improve the life of South Africans by providing a
workplace, permanent employment, a sense of purpose and
access to skills training and personal development.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 29
Streetwires Training and Development’ is a non-profit company
established by Streetwires that specifically aims at uplifting
communities by providing skills training, development of individual
artists and creating outreach initiatives in orphanages, schools and
impoverished communities.
The business focuses on producing street wire art, a uniquely
Southern African genre. The most likely origins of this art form are
the rural areas of Maputuland and Zimbabwe where poor herd boys
created their own toys out of discarded hanger wire, tin cans and
whatever else they could find. New wire-art designs are being
created by a design team and once designs have been approved,
templates are made and passed on to the wire crafters who work as
a team to manufacture the product. The Cape Town studio reveals
a business based on quality control. To maintain a high standard, the
team leader ensures that the template design is adhered to exactly
and that the template design is passed through quality control before
being released.
Objects produced are both decorative and functional such as beaded
promotional items and gifts (e.g. key rings, paperclips with logo top,
business-card holders), working radios, various models of cars in wire
or beaded wire, and animal, bird and human sculptures. The
technique of wire art dominates, incorporating materials such as
beads, cut-up tins and bottle caps.
RANGES:
The shapes and forms of products are highly stylised and simplified,
incorporating an element of whimsy and humour. Bright colours
and simple, curvilinear outlines dominate. This can be seen in
examples such as: the beaded wire bust of Madiba/Hoopoo bird/Stork
bird/sheep/Nguni Cattle.
Streetwires produces five product ranges, namely:
- ‘Streetwires Custom’: unique product ranges for events and
corporate branding;
- ‘Streetwires Generic’: retail range which secures the largest
percentage of their income;
- ‘Streetwires Collection’: targets the high-end design and decor
market;
- ‘The Signature Range’: promotes the names of the company’s best
artists (e.g. master wire artist Elias Kahari, and designer Michaela
Howse) which is sold in up-market stores;
- ‘The Fine Art Collection’: solo exhibitions where collections are
showcased under their own names.
SHAPING/IMPACT ON SOCIETY:
The ranges above all contribute to the economy of South Africa in
their own unique way in that they target various markets. It creates
dynamic ways in which the country is promoted to the overseas
markets, thus promoting the crafts and skills of this country, ultimately
providing more jobs for the local community.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
30 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
EXAMPLE OF A WORK: ‘PROUDLY SOUTH AFRICAN LOGO’
TROPHY
The Proudly South African campaign is a South African 'buy local’
marketing campaign and logo.
In this Streetwires trophy creation it is displayed as a cupped hand,
which stands on a small plinth, holding the ‘Proudly South African
logo’.
The tick in the logo is the universal symbol of endorsement,
signifying quality and approval. The tick in the logo is the universal
symbol of endorsement, signifying quality and approval.
The colours display the colours seen in the South African flag. The
tick in the logo is the universal symbol of endorsement, signifying
quality and approval.
The organic shape of the hand contrasts with the geometric shapes
of the logo.
EXAMPLE OF AN INTERNATIONAL DESIGNER
BJ KRIVANEK (Designer)
HE AIMS TO:
Add public and poetic dimensions to the flood of commercial
messages in the modern urban landscape.
Krivanek integrates the written word into built environments.
SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY:
Designs monuments that celebrate groups who are ignored, shunned
or marginalised by society.
He gives a voice to ‘embattled and stigmatised urban/city
communities’ as a way of reaching out to them and give them
dignity.
INFLUENCES ON HIS WORK:
He draws the content of his project from the history of a site and also
through outreach to community members.
He revives the tradition of architectural inscription used on classical
public buildings that for centuries featured texts to commemorate and
instruct. The generously spaced classical inscriptions were usually in
capital letters and written by people in power or dominant social
groups.
METHODS:
He combines sculpture, architecture and design to make
environmental installations that commemorate the invisible outsider
rather than known people.
Krivanek uses phenomena such as light, reflection, shadows and
projections in works.
Materials such as glass, aluminium, stainless steel and concrete are
incorporated.
Krivanek’s text is generously spaced and carefully arranged in lines
to maintain the real value of the message.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 31
Font styles are in keeping with the surrounding architectural
structures to reflect the history and character of the site and to give
that area a voice.
His themes do not instruct; instead they reflect contemporary social
issues and his messages go against the official viewpoint of the
day.
He works with a team of collaborators.
SHAPING/IMPACT ON SOCIETY:
He enriches people’s experiences of the place they live in.
He increases people’s knowledge of the history of a place and the
events that have occurred in that place through single words.
He gets people to think critically about themselves and situations in a
positive way.
The architectural works always seem to have a deep emotional and
sensitive connection to the physical human being.
The works often encourage inward reflection from the viewer.
His environmental installations blend sculpture, architecture and
design to commemorate the invisible outsider rather than prominent
figures.
EXAMPLE OF A WORK: ‘THE 9/11 MEMORIAL, LAX AIRPORT’
AIM:
To commemorate the tragedy of the terrorist attacks on the United
States as three of the four hijacked airplanes were headed to LAX.
To reflect the community’s collective loss and the hope that has
sprung from the nation’s national identity.
METHOD:
Visitors to the memorial enter across a relational threshold inscribed:
‘Daughter, Neighbour, Citizen’, et al. to approach the entombed,
fortified fountain.
At its edge, visitors can move the floating, reflective dish, to activate
the interplay of national perceptions – inscribed: United We Stand,
‘Sea to Shining Sea, Home of the Brave’, et al. Versus core American
rights and ideals – inscribed: ‘Privacy, Habeas Corpus, Assembly’, et
al. suggesting the national dialogue triggered by the attacks.
Inscribed on the floating mirrored dish, reflected upward at night, are
the personal traits of the victims – inscribed: ‘Beloved, Equal, Strong,
Honest’, et al. – evidence of the diverse American citizenry and the
characteristics that form their national identity. As projections at
night, this constellation symbolises the residual afterlife of the
victims. On the plates in various languages are common American
phrases such as ‘American Dream’ that are known worldwide.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
32 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
The segmented plates also cause the division of these phrases
representing the shattering of American ideology caused by the
event.
The memorial was built on top of an existing fountain – the plates are
continuously moving due to the movement of the water on which the
plates float.
Credit any other relevant examples and information. (14)
[20]
Q5.1 COGNITIVE WEIGHTING
QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL SKILLS %
Observation /
Lower
Recall, 30% Part of 5.1.2 5
order
Comprehension
Middle Part of 5.1.1
Application 40% 4+5
order Part of 5.1.2
Analysis
Higher Part of 5.1.1
Synthesis 30% 2+4
order Part of 5.1.2
Evaluation
OR
5.2 5.2.1 (Allocate 2 marks)
FIGURE B is considered design.
In design, the designer strives to improve something or come up with
something new that would improve the quality of our lives. A designer
looks towards new methods or reinventing old methods to come up with
something new and innovative.
Craft can be defined as the making of individual items; the making of a
series of useful AND/OR decorative objects created mainly by hand,
using specific materials and developed skills.
The design The Crochet Lamp in FIGURE B is crafted from the age-old
skill/craft of crochet. However more than one of these lamps have more
than likely been made/manufactured and the crochet technique has
been utilised in a contemporary way therefore categorizing this product
as design.
Credit any other well-reasoned response. (2)
5.2.2 (Allocate 8 marks)
Candidates to choose to discuss either ONE of these traditional
crafts:
isiZulu basketry, isiZulu pottery, isiZulu beadwork, or isiXhosa
beadwork.
EXAMPLE: isiZULU BEADWORK
ORIGINS AND TRADITIONAL HISTORY:
Port Natal (now Durban) was one of the first areas where trading
between the North AbaNguni (amaZulu) and the British took place
around 1824.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 33
Most of the trading was done with amaZulus living outside the
kingdom of the amaZulu. Both Chaka and Dingaan controlled and
determined the trade of beads inside the kingdom. Dingaan had a
particular liking for red beads or otherwise white and dark blue.
IsiZulu beadwork is closely integrated with their social organisation,
the technology of specialised craftsmanship, religious belief,
educational objectives and communication.
The craft itself forms an intricate communication system devoted
entirely to the expression of ideas, feelings and facts related to
behaviour and relations between the sexes.
FUNCTIONS AND SOCIAL ROLE:
Beaded objects form an important part of traditional African dress.
It is worn for special occasions, such as weddings and festivals and
to tell others something of the spiritual power, status or stage of life
of the person wearing it.
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
In Africa seeds, nuts, shells, bones, claws, tusks, teeth, wood,
metal, stone and gold have been used to make beads.
Then glass beads from the East, brought to Southern Africa by
Indian and Arab traders in about the 2nd century AD, were used.
Beading is also recreational and usually done in groups as a social
activity.
Beadwork is made by women for themselves and their families.
Beadwork is a way of communicating without words. This is done
through patterns, styles and colours.
Messages are woven into decorative geometric designs, which have
particular significance.
This can be seen by the colour symbols and patterns. The meaning
is affected by the combination or arrangement of certain colours.
DESCRIPTION OF ONE EXAMPLE: isiZulu love letter
It consists of a narrow beaded band with a flap worn around the
neck. The flap contains a geometric design composed of triangles
in various combinations which relates to male/female
relationships.
The beaded love letter was used by women to communicate with
their men. Interpreting it is almost like understanding the Zulu
language. The code is however deceptively simple. It uses the
basic geometric figure of the Triangle and usually a maximum of
seven colours. The three corners represent father, mother and
child. Social conventions often influence the combinations or
arrangements, which determine the meaning of colours and the
geometric figures. White usually represents spiritual love, purity
and virginity. Red is especially an important colour and Zulu girls
include this in the beaded love letters they send to their
boyfriends.
Credit any other well-reasoned response. (8)
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
34 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
5.2.3 (Allocate 10 marks)
LADUMA NGXOKOLO – Knitwear designer, Port Elisabeth
Laduma Ngxokolo is an award winning knitwear designer who is
influenced by traditional isiXhosa beadwork.
Ngxokolo aimed to develop knitwear that reflects identity for
amaXhosa ‘amakrwalas’ after they have attended circumcision
schools where they are initiated into manhood.
He aims to support small black community farmers by using locally
sourced merino wool and mohair.
By utilising local mohair in his products, he aims to indirectly
contribute to the market share of locals.
He aims to produce knitwear, which is trendy and appealing to the
amakrwala, but can still be identified as part of the isiXhosa culture.
He aims to create opportunities for employment and business
ventures in the mohair, wool industry and knitting mills.
To export his ranges to other countries.
Through his careful attention to pattern and colour he aims to create
good quality, authentic South African designs.
INFLUENCES:
Ngxokolo was influenced greatly by his mother as he grew up doing
craftwork and beadwork with her.
Each year, hundreds of amaXhosa boys aged eighteen to twenty-
three attend the circumcision schools for their manhood initiation
ritual. The old clothes of the initiates, known as amakrwalas, are given
away as a sign of the end of their boyhood. At this time, their parents
are obliged to adhere to the custom and buy them the high-quality
geometric knitwear imported from the West. Having experienced the
isiXhosa initiation ritual himself, Ngxokolo felt that there were no
knitwear brands that bore any aesthetic resemblance to isiXhosa
traditions, and so he decided to develop a range of knitwear garments
specifically for amakrwala.
As beadwork forms such an important part of isiXhosa culture and of
his culture as a young umXhosa man, Ngxokolo explored isiXhosa
beadwork as a source of inspiration, which translates easily into
patterns for his unique knitwear.
Colour also plays an important role in the isiXhosa culture so
Ngxokolo considered the colours carefully in order that his knitwear
represent the isiXhosa culture.
CHARACTERISTICS:
He uses locally sourced merino wool and mohair for the knitwear.
isiXhosa beadwork is one of the most important practices of the
isiXhosa culture and essentially consists of geometric motifs such as
the arrow, axe, diamond and zigzag, which are all easily translated
into knitwear patterns.
The knitwear, with the geometric patterns, reflect the amaXhosa
traditional identity.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 35
Ngxokolo creates colour samples so that the wool and mohair could
be dyed to the correct colour specifications.
Ngxokolo named his brand ‘MaXhosa by Laduma’ because he
wanted to showcase the astonishing beauty of the Xhosa people &
translate it in a modern way that actually appeals to the current youth
that is influenced by international trends.
From all the brilliant designers in South Africa, Ngxokolo’s work was
selected as part of the collection of top South African designs to
represent South Africa at the showcase in Helsinki during the World
Design Capital celebrations in 2012.
Knitwear styles of cardigans, waterfall cardigans, v-necks, shawl
collar necks, pull-over’s & crew-neck jerseys are produced.
Inspired by his late mother, who was a great patriot of the Xhosa
heritage, he named his collection of 2013 'My Heritage My
Inheritance'. The garments are made using traditional materials &
with modern machinery in a factory in Cape Town.
In contemporary décor, Ngxokolo also collaborates with Interior
Decorators, e.g. with his knitted fabric on a stool which resembles an
African pot.
Recently Ngxokolo has branched out to include patterned rugs,
cushions and blankets.
He has now also expanded his brand even more by starting a
women’s line called ‘Buyele’mbo‘.
Credit any other factual and well-reasoned response. (10)
[20]
Q5.2 COGNITIVE WEIGHTING
QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL LEVELS %
Observation /
Lower Part of 5.2.2
Recall / 30% 3+3
order Part of 5.2.3
Comprehension
Part of 5.2.1
Middle
Application 40% Part of 5.2.2 1+3+4
order
Part of 5.2.3
Analysis Part of 5.2.1
Higher
Synthesis 30% Part of 5.2.2 1+2+3
order
Evaluation Part of 5.2.3
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
36 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
QUESTION 6 (Allocate 20 marks in total)
6.1 (Allocate 6 marks)
The design in FIGURE A can be said to be a good example of social and also
sustainable environmental design for the following reasons:
It is made from 100% recycled plastic shopping bags. Our dumpsites are
overflowing with non-biodegradable waste so these eco-friendly schoolbags,
which are made from plastic that has been previously used, provides a unique
solution in combating environmental problems.
The Rekatha Repurpose Schoolbags company, which currently employs
20 people, intends expanding production. In this manner employment
opportunities are available for the local community, thus addressing social
problems.
The schoolbags are made with a built-in solar panel on the outside flap of the
bag. The solar panel charges up during the day so that it can be attached to
a solar-jar lamp at night. In this way, the school pupils are able to do
homework at night, which assists their educational needs for extended study
time.
This solar-jar lamp may also be utilised by members of the family as electricity
may not be available in their homes, or the cost of electricity too high for them
to afford. This therefore assists children from low-income families.
The schoolbags are created with added retro-reflective material to increase
visibility of the children walking to and from school to motorists. This is very
important in a country where so many children, as pedestrians, are killed on
the roads.
The schoolbags should benefit the school children for a long period of time as
they are strong and durable.
Being made from 100% plastic, they are waterproof and the contents will not
get damaged. This is an advantage as many children have to walk to school
in wet weather.
The bags are trendy which offers dignity to the children as they are able to
feel worthy of possessing a good design product.
Low-income, disadvantaged schools in South Africa, where children lack
basic school supplies and walk long distances to school, are able to benefit
from these Rethaka Repurpose Schoolbags.
The community involvement in a project such as this creates Ubuntu, which
brings about positive change for people within low-income communities.
Credit any other well-reasoned answer. (6)
6.2 (Allocate a total of 14 marks for one essay on TWO designers)
Candidates to choose a South African designer/design agency AND an
International designer/design agency.
Their work must address environmental AND/OR sustainable issues.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 37
EXAMPLE OF A LOCAL DESIGNER/DESIGN AGENCY:
HEATH NASH
HOW THE DESIGNER/DESIGN AGENCY ADDRESSES ENVIRONMENTAL
AND/OR SUSTAINABLE CONCERNS:
Nash uses wire frames and old plastic bottles he found the notion of re-use
very exciting. Using the skills of a wire artist he created a range of re-purposed
post-consumer plastic, waste products. Heath allied himself with local
environmental organisations – footprints. The workers in this group were
trained to collect and wash the bottles thus cleaning up the environment.
Nash also formed a new company named Poise that collects washes, cuts and
creases the plastic flowers. Poise collects from sorting areas and Nash now
has a steady flow sustainable source of most colours. He also provides
employment for underprivileged people who collect plastic from dumps.
The plastic is die cut therefore no energy is used and no pollution results from
the process. The off cuts are then returned to recyclers for recycling.
THE TITLE AND A BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF ONE DESIGN WITH
PARTICULAR REFERENCE TO THE WAY IT ADDRESSES
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES:
‘FLOWERBALL’ LAMPSHADE:
The lampshade is functional, in that it houses a globe to light up a room. It
also has aesthetic value as it offers a pleasing visual experience and it
beautifies the interior in which it is hung.
It addresses the current environmental concerns in that it allows for the
recycling of scrap plastic for its production.
The lampshade is dominantly white giving a quiet, pure surreal quality to the
work. The shade is made of similar leaf and biomorphic petal shapes cut
from plastic that are creased to look like flowers. Some flowers have rounded
triangular petals which contrast with the elongated petal shapes. This creates
variety and interest in the surface pattern. The quietness brought about by
the simple spherical shape and the uninterrupted white colour is brought to life
by the movement created by the sharp points and different angles of the petal
shapes.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
38 DESIGN P1 (EC/SEPTEMBER 2017)
EXAMPLE OF AN INTERNATIONAL DESIGNER/DESIGN AGENCY
JULIE BARGMANN
HOW THE DESIGNER/DESIGN AGENCY ADDRESSES ENVIRONMENTAL
AND/OR SUSTAINABLE CONCERNS:
Julie Bargmann is internationally recognised as an innovative designer who
reclaims polluted industrial sites in the USA that have been severely polluted by
mining or the dumping of rubbish. A major focus is the treatment of AMD
(acid mine drainage) which spills into streams and rivers, thereby raising
acidity levels and suffocating life forms. She explores the creative potential of
these degraded landscapes and alters them into regenerative landscapes.
Bargmann applies her research from her small design practice, called
D.I.R.T. (Design Investigations Reclaiming Terrain/Dump It Right There). She
researches the effect of past and present industrial operations and urban
processes on ecological systems and communities and the relationship of
these to emerging technologies. Bargmann employs teams of architects,
artists, engineers, historians and scientists, to help her imagine the next ‘life’ of
landscapes such as closed quarries and abandoned coal mines.
Bargmann teaches ‘critical site-seeing’ which aims to explore the multiple
histories of a site in order to understand all the processes that led to its
degradation and to come up with a plan for its regeneration and to renew its
relationship with the community and the economy. She aims, ‘not only to
revive the landscape but also not to forget’, in other words, to leave a reminder
of what has happened at these sites. She wants to move away from the
common practice of completely disguising past elements of the site, under
green hills or recreation fields such as golf courses. In her words, this is like
‘putting lipstick on a pig’.
THE TITLE AND A BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF ONE DESIGN WITH
PARTICULAR REFERENCE TO THE WAY IT ADDRESSES
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES:
‘TESTING THE WATERS’:
Bargmann has transformed the site of a former coal mine in Vintondale,
Pennsylvania into a 45 acre park for acid mine drainage and community
recreation. Bargmann then designed the layout of the park by making the
existing shape of the landmass into the form of a passive AMD treatment
system. This is like a giant ecological washing machine. She invited the
public to come and witness the cleansing process physically as well as
symbolically.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
(EC/SEPTEMBER 2017) DESIGN P1 39
First, the AMD goes through a series of retention basins and, as polluted
water passes over this ‘Treatment Garden’, its colour changes from acidic
orange to pea green and then finally to alkaline blue-green. Each of these
colour changes are symbolic, and a physical change. The cleansing process
is symbolically shown in the ‘Litmus Garden’. The seasonal colours of the
bark, foliage and fruit of the alternating rows of indigenous trees and shrubs,
visually represent the treatment sequences, progressing from deep reds and
oranges to cooler hues of green and blue. The flood plain of the site’s creek
is reconstructed into a new marsh and additional wetlands for the final ‘rinse’.
After flowing through these wetlands areas, water returns to the local creek in a
purified state.
Consider any other factual and well-reasoned answer. (14)
[20]
Q6.1+6.2 COGNITIVE WEIGHTING
QUESTION MARKS
LEVEL SKILLS %
Knowledge / Part of 6.1
Lower order 30% 6
Comprehension Part of 6.2
Part of 6.1
Middle order Application 40% 8
Part of 6.2
Analysis
Part of 6.1
Higher order Synthesis 30% 6
Part of 6.2
Evaluation
TOTAL SECTION C: 40
GRAND TOTAL: 100
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Study this subject
Recommended for this subject

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 P1 Eastern Cape Mock 2017 Memo (Afrikaans)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 Eastern Cape Mock 2017 QP (Eng)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 Eastern Cape Mock 2017 QP (Afr)

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC November 2017 Memo (English)

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC November 2017 Memo (Afrikaans)

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC Supplementary 2017 Memo (Afrikaans)
More from Grade 12 Design

Annual teaching plan
Gr 12 Des ATP 2023 24

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC June 2025 Question Paper (Afrikaans)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2025 Question Paper (Eng)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2025 Question Paper (Afr)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 November 2024 NSC Question Paper (Eng)

Question paper