Downloaded from hlayiso.com
NATIONAL
SENIOR CERTIFICATE
GRADE 12
DESIGN P1
(THEORY)
NOVEMBER 2017
MARKING GUIDELINES
MARKS: 100
These marking guidelines consist of 19 pages.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Skip to contentAll 2017 papers 





View all





Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC November 2017 Memo (English)
Grade 12 Design Paper 1 memorandum from the NSC November Exam 2017 (English), 19 pages. Read online or download the free PDF.
Design · Grade 12 · NSC November Exam · 2017. Memorandum, 19 pages. Read online or download the PDF.
- Subject
- Design
- Grade
- Grade 12
- Document type
- Memorandum
- Year
- 2017
- Exam period
- NSC November Exam
- Paper
- 1
- Curriculum
- CAPS
- Pages
- 19
- File size
- 809.0 KB
Free to read online, no sign-up needed
Loading document…
Loading document…
1 of 19
This exam
NSC November Exam 2017
Questions in this paper
Document textSearch extracted text and jump to a page.
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 2 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
SECTION A: DESIGN LITERACY
QUESTION 1: 'UNSEEN' EXAMPLES
Candidates answer EITHER QUESTION 1.1 OR QUESTION 1.2.
1.1 (10 marks in total)
1.1.1 (Allocate 8 marks: a maximum of 2 marks each per element/ principle)
• Rhythm: The use of a variety of repetitive geometric shapes creates a rhythmic
optical movement. The drawers are of equal size and shape, each with holes that
acts as handles; these holes create a rhythmic motion or movement. The
repeated vertical striped lines also create rhythmic motion. Repeated horizontal
rhythmic lines accentuate the elongated appearance of the product. The
repetitions of the drawers create rhythm.
• Texture: The furniture piece is made from a soft, smooth wood, which emphasises
a soft, silky effect. The painted patterns are smooth and flat that create the
impression of tactile texture. The repeated horizontal lines also give an illusion of
texture. The layered plywood of the drawers creates a tactile texture.
• Contrast: The eclectic historical motifs are responsible for the strongest contrast.
The varied Scandinavian inspired Marimekko patterns on the side of the drawers'
contrast strongly with the pattern on top or below it. The varnished wooden
draws are unadorned and contrast with the patterned surface designs seen on the
sides. The two-dimensional shapes contrast with the box like three dimensional
form of the piece of furniture. Colour contrasts of black and grey are visible in the
dominant monochromatic colour scheme. The warm orange dots, the pink
triangles and dots also contrast with the monochromatic colour scheme.
• Shape: The two sides are decorated from top to bottom with two-dimensional
shapes. These shapes are flat, stylised and geometric reminiscent of traditional
ethnic patterns. The shapes are repeated to form patterns, which are placed in
horizontal bands. These are stacked on top of each other to create a complex and
interesting patterned surface.
Credit any other valid statements.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 3 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
1.1.2 (Allocate 2 marks)
The term totemic refers to stacking or layering. In the furniture piece of FIGURE
A stacked patterns and drawers form the design. (It is a current Postmodernist
trend to create different pluralistic layers of interpretation or references.) The
traditional pole is also created from layed of wood that stacked on top of each other.
Each layer of wood reflects meaning and symbolic value.
Q1.1 COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL (10)
Lower Remember, Recall, 30% 1.1.1 1
order Recognise
Understand, Explain, 1.1.2 2
Describe
Middle Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 1.1.1 4
order
Higher Analyse, Compare, Interpret 1.1.1 1
order Evaluate, Reflect 30% 1.1.1 1
Synthesise, Justify 1.1.1 1
OR
1.2 (10 marks in total)
1.2.1 (Allocate 8 marks: a maximum of 2 marks each per bullet)
• Negative space: The illustration makes use of a dramatic balance between
negative and positive space by bold use of black and white contrast. The
composition is split in half and the left side is an inversion of the right side to
emphasis a duality in the image. We have to read the negative space of the
illustration to fully see the whole image. Some people might read or interpret the
use of the negative space as positive or vice versa which makes the experience of
the design more interesting and the meaning ambiguous. Closer inspection
reveals the face of a bird/wolf/jackal/dog or crocodile seen within the negative and
positive spaces. Additionally the shield and spear in the negative and positive
spaces in the middle are used to highlight the message of the design campaign.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 4 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
• Movement: Strong diagonal lines, geometric and stylised shapes are utilised
throughout the illustration to create movement. On the left hand side of the
background the illustrator makes use of diagonal slashes and on the right he uses
dots and squiggles to create dynamic movement. The middle of the composition
creates a strong vertical downward movement. Horizontal lines are emphasised in
the centre pattern, and along legs and jaws allowing the eye to move across the
picture plane. Patterns within the shield/spear create an optical movement with
the use of repetitive shapes. The tonal contrast creates an optical illusion.
• Balance: At first glance the illustration is perceived as symmetrically balanced
conveying order. On closer inspection one finds slight differences on either side
of the design that could classify the design as asymmetrically balanced. On the
left side the bird's tongue hangs out and in his claws he is holding a dead snake.
On the right the bird presenting a diamond ring and a necklace or neckpiece.
These differences give the work more energy and support the male/ female
symbolic dichotomies (opposites) explored by the work. The equal weighting of
black and white creates a visual balance. The black and white colour usage also
creates a symbolic balance between life and death.
• Line: The illustrator makes use of bold, hard-edged, straight lines that creates a
clean design full of movement, textures and patterns. An illusion of line is
created through contrast that splits the composition vertically in half. Lines are
angular and that enhances the stylistic approach to the design. The use of
curved lines softens the hard-edged motifs.
Credit any other valid statements.
1.2.2 (Allocate 2 marks)
The term 'stylised' means to simplify and flatten reality, reduction of detail or
economy of detail. In FIGURE B the illustration is stylised through the use of
clean straight line, geometric, angular shapes and repeated scalloped patterns
to create a striking design with decorative appeal. Although reality has been
simplified the design is complex and has symbolic hidden meanings.
Credit any other valid statements.
Q1.2 COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL (10)
Lower order Remember, Recall, 30% 1.2.1 1
Recognise
Understand, Explain, 1.2.2 2
Describe
Middle Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 1.2.1 4
order
Higher Analyse, Compare, Interpret 1.2.1 2
order Evaluate, Reflect 30% 1.2.1 1
Synthesise, Justify
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 5 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
QUESTION 2: COMMUNICATION THROUGH DESIGN
2.1 (10 marks in total)
2.1 (Allocate 6 marks: a maximum of 2 marks each per symbol)
The microphone symbolises an amplified voice, a technological tool used to
convey speech in an audible manner.
The upside-down microphone symbolises a restricted, muted voice or opinion.
A bird in a cage symbolises imprisonment, building on the metaphor 'as free as a
bird'. The caged bird also represents a speaker whose thoughts are caged.
The cage symbolises the never-ending cycle of containment and the entrapment of
the speaker. The upside-down microphone symbolise the voice of people that
are not often heard.
2.2 (Allocate 2 marks)
In order of importance a bold black microphone is placed centrally against a
luminous yellow background of the poster, creating a bold contrast that leads the
viewer's eyes downwards. Additionally, the tapered shape of the microphone
leads the viewer eye to the focal point of the design. The cage housing the bird
like a prisoner is second in the hierarchy of importance. The image of the bird is
the last on the level of importance because it is placed lower on the page and is
tiny in size. Credit must also be given to learners that highlight the cultural
hierarchy when answering the question.
2.3 (Allocate 2 marks)
The bright, pure yellow attracts the eye and ensures that the black microphone
is accentuated which emphasises the denial of free speech. The colour yellow
conveys feelings of warmth, life and freedom whereas black symbolises death of
free speech.
Credit any other valid statements.
Q2.1 COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL (10)
Lower order Remember, Recall, 30%
Recognise
Understand, Explain, 2.1.1 3
Describe
Middle Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 2.1.1 3
order 2.1.2 1
Higher Analyse, Compare, 2.1.3 2
order Interpret 30%
Evaluate, Reflect
Synthesise, Justify 2.1.2 1
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 6 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
QUESTION 3 (10 marks in total)
Candidates answer EITHER QUESTION 3.1 OR QUESTION 3.2.
3.1 (Allocate 10 marks: a maximum of 2 marks each per aspect)
FIGURE D uses muted, earthy colours to create a relaxed mood whilst bright,
primary colours to create a youthful, energetic and cheerful scene dominate FIGURE
E. The colours in FIGURE D are natural, such as greys and different browns etc.
which is in contrast to the 'funky' colours in FIGURE E that are created by the plastic
decorations and the silver chrome of steel.
FIGURE D is influenced by the forms and materials of the organic African landscape
while FIGURE E shows the influence of contemporary urban life. . FIGURE D is
inspired by the calmness and the quietness of the wilderness unlike FIGURE E
that is inspired by the vibe of a fast cosmopolitan life. Figure E clearly shows an
eclectic style that is influenced by Pop and De Stijl. Figure D could be influenced
the Arts and Craft movement.
FIGURE D targets people who would want to relax, rest, be calm and be part of
nature. FIGURE E in contrast, targets young, urban people who like a vibrant,
quick life and fast foods. FIGURE D also targets tourists who want to explore and
experience South African wildlife unlike FIGURE E that targets people who eat fast
food.
The environment in FIGURE D functions as accommodation for wealthy people
, especially tourists, who are on vacation, whereas FIGURE E is meant to
function as a fast food restaurant for everyone. Both are used for entertainment
and to celebrate special occasions.
Most of the materials used in FIGURE D are organic and natural whilst the
material in FIGURE E is mostly artificial, plastic and colourful. The material used
in FIGURE D gives the environment a peaceful feeling as opposed to the material
in FIGURE E that looks rigid, hard and angular. FIGURE E relies on artificial
lighting materials whereas FIGURE D utlises natural lighting sources.
Credit any other valid statements.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 7 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
Q3.1 COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL (10)
Lower Remember, Recall, Recognise 30% 3.1 1
order
Understand, Explain, Describe 3.1 2
Middle Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 3.1 4
order
Higher Analyse, Compare, Interpret 30% 3.1 2
order
Evaluate, Reflect
Synthesise, Justify 3.1 1
OR
3.2 (Allocate 10 marks: a maximum of 2 marks each per aspect)
Hadrian's Villa was constructed to function as a retreat from Rome for the Roman
Emperor Hadrian. The Palace of the Lost City can also be seen as a retreat, a
luxury hotel that offers an escape for city people from everyday demands into a
make-belief ancient royal residence. The visitor is transported back in time into an
opulent fantasy world of water features and jungle attractions. Hadrian also used
Hadrian’s villa later in his reign, to govern his empire. A large court had to be
accommodated there permanently with space for visitors and bureaucrats to be
entertained and temporarily housed on site. The Palace of the Lost City by
contrast is only used as a holiday destination.
One of the classical structures in Hadrian's Villa is the so-called 'Maritime theatre'
which included a library, heated baths, three suites with heated floors, an art gallery
and a large fountain. In concept this recreational space is very similar to the many
recreational spaces offered by the Palace of the Lost City as it also includes spa
baths, Jacuzzi's and saunas, restaurants, ballrooms and an auditorium used to
entertain to keep the masses occupied.
Hadrian's Villa's layout covers a vast area of land and includes many pools, baths,
fountains and classical Greek architecture. It is set in what would have been a
mixture of landscaped gardens, wilderness areas and cultivated farmlands. The
Palace of the Lost City also stretches over a vast area of land and also includes
many water features such as streams, waterfalls, fountains and pools. It also
consists of loose standing classical structures such as a triumphal arch. Whereas
the Palace of the Lost City has one large structure that dominates the site, Hadrian's
Villa consists of many different structures spread out in a natural layout, making it
less imposing to the site it occupies.
With regard to materials, both complexes make use of marble in their mosaic floors.
Hadrian's villa's buildings are constructed in travertine, brick, lime, concrete and
tufa (a very light stone). The Palace of the Lost City is largely constructed from
modern concrete and steel but on the exterior makes use of a lot of traditional
materials such as marble and wood.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 8 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
Hadrian's Villa was constructed in the picturesque, idyllic landscape around Tibur
(modern day Tivoli), a popular site for villas and retreats in that time. The site was
chosen due to its abundant waters and readily available aqueducts that passed
through Rome. The site of the Palace of the Lost City is far wilder as it is placed in
a dense African bushveld setting, away from urban living.
Hadrian's Villa shows the influence of many different architectural styles. The
Maritime theatre exhibits a classical Greek Ionic style, whereas the domes of the
main building show the influence of Roman architecture. A sanctuary that Hadrian
saw in Egypt influences the elongated canal and imitation of a grotto. The Palace
of the Lost City uses mosaics, frescoes, fountains and colonnaded arches which all
originate in Roman times. The many domed towers and roofs are reminiscent of
Byzantine or North African mosques or Zulu huts. Hand carved wooden furniture,
elephant tusks, wildlife carvings, a life-size bronze elephant, murals of the African
landscape, animals and birds all reflect the influence of
Africa.
Credit any other valid statements.
Q3.2 COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL (10)
Lower Remember, Recall, Recognise 30% 3.2 1
order Understand, Explain, Describe 3.2 2
Middle Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 3.2 4
order
Higher Analyse, Compare, Interpret 3.2 2
order Evaluate, Reflect 30%
Synthesise, Justify 3.2 1
SECTION B: DESIGN HISTORY
4.1 (Allocate 20 marks)
Modernism
EXAMPLE: VW Beetle by Ferdinand Porsche
Modernism was the first movement that aimed to address the turmoil created by the
devastation of the war at the beginning of the 20th century and so rebuilt the
environments and changed the way people lived. Design became an important
means for countries that had been defeated by the cost of the war to re-establish
themselves in the world trade market. Individual countries combined design with
industry aimed to create an international style. A search for a 'style for the age'
resulted in a streamlined style that symbolised the present modern day and the
future. Modernist designers aimed to solve society's' problems. A good example
of one design that influenced people's actions and opinions was the Volkswagen
beetle car developed in Germany as means of providing cheap efficient transport
for the public. Designed in the 1930s as a small car that could transport two
adults and three children at 100 km/h the Volkswagen beetle became the
best-selling vehicle in the USA in the first half of the 20th Century.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 9 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
America became the design leader of the world because of its advanced attitude to
towards industry and the influx of designers from Europe after the war. The good
economy in America resulted in a style-conscious wealthy, mass market, eager to
buy and consume new products. New developments in aerodynamics and hydro
dynamics, and the modernist phenomenon of fast travel by train, automobile and
aeroplane influenced the streamlined shape that resulted from these experiments.
The streamlined style became extremely popular and was applied to a variety of
products from motor vehicles such as the Volkswagen beetle to toasters. Large
design companies were established that provided employment for many categories
of designers, marketing and public relations specialists. This style therefore
influenced the way people lived in a fast-paced modern world.
The influence of the analytical approach taken by the Bauhaus resulted in the
standardisation and simplification of designs, placing emphasis on mass-produced
goods using new technology and new materials. The development of new
materials such as aluminium a range of plastics which included Bakelite
improved the quality of design and the mass-production cost. Chromium was
used on the bumpers of the Volkswagen beetle an ideal finish as it was resistant to
corrosion.
The designers of the modernist age aimed to appeal to a worldwide mass market
that was eager to purchase stylish inexpensive products that functioned well.
A wide range of new kinds of products such as plastic stacking chairs and radios
and domestic appliances made people's lives easier. The Volkswagen beetle
took America by storm because it was economical and affordable to the masses.
Besides the shape, one other revolutionary feature included a rear-mounted
air-cooled engine. It was engineered to be mechanically simple which aimed to
keep the running costs of the vehicle very low.
The Modernists advocated the characteristic of abstraction and aesthetics thus they
often focussed on the essence of the structure. The distinctive characteristic
teardrop shape of the Volkswagen Beetle is good example of the curved shapes
used in early streamlining that became the ideal shape for transportation design,
affording the average working class the opportunity to own their own vehicle.
Improved technology had an impact on colour as new chemical dyes became
available, all made from man-made components as opposed to the previous animal
and vegetable dyes. The VW beetle was available in a wide range of colours and
often customised by its owners, most notably the painting of psychedelic patterns
during the 1960s.
Art Deco
EXAMPLE: Chrysler Building by William van Alen
The Art Deco movement began as a reaction to the deprivations caused by the 1st
World War. The style aimed to address the increased population of the cities as a
result of the Industrial Revolution and the increased demand for machine made
goods and entertainment. Machinery was extensively used to meet the day to day
needs of city dwellers. The need to escape the depression that surrounded them
was a major influence on Art Deco and design provided the answer. Many designers
turned to exotic influences taking their inspiration from antiquity, ancient Egypt and
Aztec civilizations, Cubism, Fauvism and Modernism. Design motifs were reduced
to their simplest form but maintained their refined sophisticated appearance. This
style was applied to architectural, interior, textile and graphic design. Art Deco
created exotic, theatrical environments padded with beautiful, luxurious tiles,
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 10 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
materials and wallpapers. This formed the means of escapism for the people of the
times which emphasised the way people lived during the era.
The Chrysler Building in New York is a classic example of Art Deco architectures'
characteristics and considered by many contemporary architects to be one of the
finest buildings in New York City it was designed by architect William van Alen for a
project of Walter P Chrysler. When the ground breaking occurred on
19 September 1928, there was an intense competition in New York City to build the
world's tallest skyscraper. The style of the building changed the shape of the New
York skyline and became a landmark epitomising the new modern era of
celebrating humanity. Walter Chrysler was the chairman of the Chrysler
Corporation intended to make the building into Chrysler's motor vehicles'
headquarters, meeting the high demand for motor vehicles. The machine age
had changed people's lives making travel faster than before. Speed became an
obsession and began to influence design. Various architectural details and
especially the building's gothic inspired gargoyles were modelled after Chrysler
automobile products like the hood ornaments of the Plymouth which exemplifies the
machine age in the 1920s.
The Chrysler Building is considered a leading example of Art Deco architecture.
The corners of the 61st floor are graced with eagles; on the 31st floor, the corner
ornamentations are replicas of the 1929 Chrysler radiator caps. It is constructed
of masonry, with a steel frame, and metal cladding. The building currently contains
a total of 3 862 windows on its facades. Inside, there are four banks of 8 elevators
designed by the Otis Elevator Corporation. The building was declared a National
Historic Landmark in 1976, and a New York City Landmark in 1978 this shows how
design impacts on people's lives changing their opinions actions and the way they
live their lives. The Chrysler Building is also renowned and recognised for its
terraced crown, composed of seven radiating terraced arches, inspired by the
Egyptian pyramids and sunburst patterns of the Aztecs. Here the influence of
African and Egyptian art is evident in the emphasis on stylised forms which
contributed to the direct and simplified approach of the art Deco style.
Van Alen's design of the crown is a cruciform groin vault constructed into seven
concentric segments. The stainless-steel cladding is ribbed and riveted in a
radiating sunburst pattern with many triangular vaulted windows. The entire
crown is clad with silvery 'Enduro KA-2' metal, a stainless steel developed in
Germany.
Credit any other valid statements
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 11 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
Q4.1 COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL (10)
Lower Remember, Recall, 30% 4.1 4
order Recognise
Understand, Explain, 2
Describe
Middle Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 4.1 8
order
Higher Analyse, Compare, Interpret 4.1 2
order Evaluate, Reflect 30% 2
Synthesise, Justify 2
4.2 (Allocate 10 marks)
The bed in FIGURE H is inspired by the art and architecture of the Classical age.
The Renaissance period in Europe which aimed to represented a change of views,
beliefs and mind-sets showed a shift in focus to humanism and the rational mind.
The rise of humanism in the Renaissance period signified a return to reason,
individualism, logic thought, science and Classical ideals as seen in FIGURE H.
FIGURE I by contrast, represents the De Stijl movement which was heavily
influenced by the Dutch tradition of logic, severity and clarity, aimed at a style in
which content and subject were simplified to the basic building blocks of visual
expression developed as can be seen in the geometric shapes and primary colours.
The Classical ideals of harmony are seen in the symmetry, proportion and balance
of the bed in FIGURE H. The bed in FIGURE I shows how the De Stijl movement
used the fundamentally harmonious principle of geometry with the use of only
straight lines, squares, and rectangles, combined with a strong asymmetricality; the
predominant use of pure primary colours and black and white. Harmony is also
evident in De Stijl's' relationship between positive and negative elements in the
arrangement of non-objective forms and lines.
De Stijls' establishment of the use of pure abstraction to achieved universality is
evident in FIGURE I through a reduction to the essentials of form and colour.
They simplified their visual compositions to vertical and horizontal only and the use
of only black, white and the primary colours. In contrast to this the Renaissances
encouragement of observation direct from the natural source, encouraged an
accurate reflection of nature in form and colour and an aim to achieve idealism
and perfection. On the contrary De Stijl, finds its expression in the abstraction of
form and colour in the straight line and the clearly defined primary colour. De
Stijl only allows primary colours and black and white, only squares and rectangles,
only straight and horizontal or vertical lines.
The influence of Classical mythology is evident in the Renaissance in the use of
decorative motifs on the bed in FIGURE H. This richly decorated style of the
Renaissance known as grotesque, featured a combination of scrolling plants,
figures and fantastic creatures, based on ancient Roman frescos that were
discovered in Italy in the late 15th century. A popular feature of this decorative
Renaissance style incorporated into furniture design were carved busts of important
people or the patrons, mostly in profile and framed by elaborate circles of foliage
known as a roundel seen in FIGURE H which is thought to have been an influence
from ancient Roman coins.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 12 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
The De Stjjl bed in FIGURE I gives no recognition to individualism and ignores the
particulars of appearance, natural form and colour. The Renaissance
encouraged freethinking and commonly held beliefs that stemmed from medieval
times were questioned. The focus shifted to observation and research that
encouraged innovation and many new scientific discoveries including perspective,
and aerial perspective. The De Stijl movement was heavily influenced by the
theories of the Dutch philosopher Schoenmaekers, who believed that nature could
be reduced to binary opposites and basic lines forms and shapes. The artistic
philosophy that formed provided a basis for the De Stijl's work which is known as
neoplasticism—the new plastic art.
Credit any other valid statements.
Q4.2 COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL (10)
Lower Remember, Recall, Recognise 30% 4.2 2
order Understand, Explain, Describe 4.2 1
Middle Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 4.2 4
order
Higher Analyse, Compare, Interpret 4.2 1
order Evaluate, Reflect 30% 4.2 1
Synthesise, Justify 4.2 1
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 13 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
SECTION C: DESIGN IN SOCIO-CULTURAL/ENVIRONMENTAL AND
SUSTAINABLE CONTEXT
QUESTION 5 (20 marks in total)
Candidates answer EITHER QUESTION 5.1 OR QUESTION 5.2.
5.1
5.1.1 (Allocate 2 marks)
The design in FIGURE J shows sensitivity to the needs of the visually impaired.
Sesame seeds are placed on the burger to form braille so that the blind person can
feel and know what he/she is eating. It is rare that products are designed to
consider the experience of physically challenged people, especially about food.
Wimpy designed a braille menu for this.
5.1.2 (Allocate 2 marks)
In order to qualify as socially responsible designers, one should consider the needs
of all people including minorities and physically challenged that make up our
society. This practice of celebrating inclusivity changes mindsets in creating
harmony and tolerance among all people. The target market is made larger
through inclusive design practice. In this case blind people are given
independence to make their own choices.
5.1.3 (Allocate 2 marks)
Traffic lights that buzz for the blind pedestrians to signal when it is safe to cross
the road. Parking bays that are wider and situated at the entrances of malls
and shops for the physical challenged. Motion sensitive doors pads that will
automatically open for the blind and/or the physically challenged.
5.1.4 (Allocate 14 marks; 7 marks per designer: 1 mark for designer and design
product)
Example: A typical Streetwires product is Stack of cows
Streetwires is a local craft business and community development project,
established by Patrick Schofield, Winston Rangwana and Anthony Ressel. The
business focuses on producing street wire art, a uniquely southern African genre.
Its aim was to tackle the problems of unemployment and poverty in our
country.
In the beginning only two wire artists were employed on a part-time basis, using a
room in Schofield's house as their workspace. The business grew, resulting in
two larger premises. The Cape Town studio reveals a business based on quality
control. A design team is creating new wire-art designs and once designs have
been approved, templates are made and passed on to the wire crafters who work
as a collaboration to manufacture the product. To maintain a high standard the
team leader ensures that the template design is adhered to exactly and that it is
passed through quality control before being released.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 14 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
The company believes that the major hurdle facing our country is
unemployment. Not only is it the leading cause of numerous social ills such as
poverty, it also hampers community growth and development. With this in
mind, the aim is to create meaningful long-term employment for as many South
Africans as possible to improve the life of South Africans. This provides a
workplace, permanent employment, a sense of purpose and access to skills
training, development of individual artists and creating outreach initiatives in
orphanages, schools and impoverished communities.
Objects produced are both decorative and functional such as beaded promotional
items and gifts (e.g. key rings, paperclips with a logo top, business-card holders),
working radios, various models of cars in wire or beaded wire and animal, bird
and human sculptures. The shapes and forms are highly stylised and
simplified, incorporating an element of fantasy and humour. Bright colours and
simple, curvilinear outlines dominate. The technique of wire art dominates,
incorporating materials such as beads, cut-up tin cans and bottle caps.
The beaded work reflects simplicity, stylisation, whimsical, quirky, childlike and
naïve qualities. It is made out of wires and beads and recollects and reflects
the value of livestock in African cultures. The beads used are monochromatic
and ranges from dark coloured cow to a white cow. The horns are threaded
with red beads.
Allocate 7 marks: 1 mark for designer and design product
Jonathan Barnbrook is an International British Graphic designer and
typographer who uses his graphic design, fonts/typeface to respond to social,
cultural and political events and in that way to benefit the community.
He said in his 'First Things First 2000' manifesto that designers should be
conscious of the power that their crafted message can have on mass-media.
The Barnbrook studio is notable for its belief in the ability of graphic design to
facilitate social change. Barnbrook's output is deeply thought provoking, from
his corporate identity to his magazine work, his typeface, his industrial designs
and CD covers. In one of his projects Friendly Fire he confirmed that graphic
design is a social and political tool weapon. On a billboard in Las Vegas,
Barnbrook said: 'Stay away from corporations that want you to lie for them'. He
regularly responds to all the unfairness in this world and attempts to expose this
to society to 'benefit their lives'.
Some of his well-known fonts include Bastard, Exocet, False Idol, Infidel, Moron,
Sarcastic – many reflecting Barnbrook's emotive and provocative style and
themes.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 15 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
Example:
Most of his ideas, compositions and his typeface, designed to agitate the reader,
are captured in his first monograph, Barnbrook Bible. Designed to challenge, if
not agitate the reader, the book is so deliberately kinetic (movement in the lay-
out) and chaotic that it requires time and effort to decipher. Once the reader
has deciphered or decoded his lay-outs and style, the design can be appreciated
as a personal expression in the service of mass communication, usually
containing a social or political agenda. Barnbrook Bible's political
commentary is evident - American foreign policy and global corporatism are his
main targets. For example, he has combined Ronald MacDonald and Osama
Bin Laden into one single iconic character which is witty but also has a higher
purpose that encourages critical thinking. It is easy to dismiss Barnbrook's
political work as typographic cartooning but it is underpinned by serious social
commentary.
Credit any other valid statements.
Q5.1 COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL (20)
Lower Remember, Recall, 30% 5.1.1 2
order Recognise 5.1.2 1
5.1.4 2
Understand, Explain, 5.1.3 1
Describe
Middle Apply, Implement, 40% 5.1.2 1
order Organise 5.1.3 1
5.1.4 6
Higher Analyse, Compare, 5.1.4 2
order Interpret 30%
Evaluate, Reflect 5.1.4 2
Synthesise, Justify 5.1.4 2
5.2 (20 marks in total)
5.2.1 (Allocate 2 marks)
No, the traditional products in FIGURE K will not function with the same ease and
precision as modern products do. Technology has improved the materials that
contemporary products are made from in comparison to the materials used for
traditional products. Improved robot machines can produce a more accurate, finely
honed finish for cutting and grinding products.
Yes, the traditional products in FIGURE K are still useful today for people who wish
to remain true to their traditional roots. Many traditionalists believe that hand-
made craft products are far more superior in function and quality of material
compared to contemporary products made with cheaper materials and inferior
quality. The product is used for traditional, cultural and ceremonial purposes.
The product could be used in a modern context to decorate interiors. These
products are used for the tourist market.
Credit any other cultural and symbolic uses.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 16 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
5.2.2 (Allocate 8 marks)
Wall paintings by the Ndebele community (women).
To begin a wall painting, the craft artists divide the wall into sections and then
snap chalk lines diagonally across each section. The walls are originally
whitewashed limestone. The colours added to make the paintings were mostly
natural pigments consisting of browns, blacks, and ochres. The artists begin
painting the black outline of the design for each section. Painting is done
freehand, without a scale design layout done beforehand. Neither rulers nor
squares are used, and yet symmetry, proportion and straight edges are exactly
maintained. A black outline is set around colours, with white spaces offset
against painted areas. After the colour has been applied, the final step is to
repaint or touch up the black outlines. The earliest paintings were done with
earth pigments, whitewash and laundry bluing. Although commercial paints
have replaced the older pigments, the craft artists still use chicken feathers as
paintbrushes.
Ndebele painters distinguish styles and origins among different forms of mural
decoration. The walls are painted with patterns that are usually repeated
throughout their design with only a very slight variation and different colour choice.
The colour white is always used as the background because it makes the bright
patterns bold. These geometric patterns and shapes are first drawn with the
black outline and later filled in with colour. The patterns are grouped together
throughout the walls in terms of their basic design structure, creating the space for
accuracy and freedom. Most of the patterns were of a V shape and a very
simple triangle on a large shape of colour. There are five main colours
represented in the pattern: red, yellow, blue, green, and sometimes pink.
The patterns are one of the most important aspects in their communication
through painting. The colours give an intensified symbolic meaning to the
Ndebele. The vibrant symbols and expressions portray communications of
general messages.
Credit any other valid statements.
5.2.3 (Allocate 10 marks)
Ronel Jordaan. Ndebele tribal Chair
The work is a chair that looks like a big, pliable and collapsing grass basket but it
is made from felt. It is lying on its side with the lid forming a seat. The lines of
the weave technique form concentric circles. The colours are muted greys and
blues creating a cool effect. The weaving technique is similar to the grass mat
weaving technique used by indigenous cultures. She uses wool, which is dyed,
card combed and spun. To make the products, the cotton is brushed into thin
threads then hand-woven into an assortment of items.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 17 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
Ronel Jordaan's materials and work processes are ethical in which she considers
the environment and the user. The water she uses is known as waste grey water
because it is recycled into organic food gardens These lush sun drenched
gardens grow in containers on the factory grounds situated in a small industrial
suburb in Johannesburg South Africa. The vegetables, mainly morogo and
spinach are for the women to take home or sell.
Ronel uses soap from South Africa that is fully biodegradable. Although the
dyes are imported from Germany, they have been specifically chosen because
they are lead free and meet European Eco-Standards. The wool Ronel uses
does not undergo a process called carbonization. The Ronel Jordaan™ label is
equally harmonious with nature. The processes implemented in the workshop are
all eco-friendly.
Credit any other valid statements.
NO marks should be given for repetition of designer(s) and their work used
in this question paper.
Q5.2 COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL (20)
Lower order Remember, Recall, 30% 5.2.3 1
Recognise
Understand, Explain, 5.2.1 1
Describe 5.2.2 2
5.2.3 2
Middle Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 5.2.1 1
order 5.2.2 2
5.2.3 5
Higher Analyse, Compare, Interpret 5.2.2 4
order Evaluate, Reflect 30% 5.2.3 1
Synthesise, Justify 5.2.3 1
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 18 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
QUESTION 6 (20 marks in total)
6.1 (Allocate 6 marks)
Water conservation is emphasised by building this house using recycled plastic
bottles that conserves water, as opposed to traditional building materials like
concrete that require more water usage. The use of these water bottles to build
ensures that they do not find their way into our oceans, rivers and dams. The use
of recycled plastic in FIGURE L enhances the importance of water conservation by
highlighting the use of recycled water bottles.
Energy efficiency is maximised by the use of non-traditional building materials like
water bottles. This technique of building minimises the use of electrical tools that
will conserve energy. The use of water bottles insulated the building that will
prevent the need for additional heating and cooling.
CO² reduction is enhanced by the reduction of the use of machinery and electrical
equipment that will pollute the environment. The building will have minimal impact
on the environment, as the materials used in the building process do not impact on
air pollution.
Credit any other valid statements.
6.2 (Allocate 2 x 7 = 14 marks) 7 marks per designer: 1 mark for designer and
design product
The South African design team The Joinery founded by sisters Natalie and Kim
Ellis designed the My Office collection. The Joinery is an ethical Fashion label
created to provide an alternative to the traditional and hazardous methods of
production. The My Office collection features laptop bags for Mac and PC users
made from the luxurious-looking, sustainable fabric shown in a nude brown and
pale grey colour. The collection is designed in conjunction with a South African-
based industrial plastic recycling plant and polyester fibre manufacturer through the
conceptualisation of a lightweight felt-like fabric that is PET (polyethylene
terephthalate) chip-derived from discarded plastic bottles collected around Cape
Town.
Copyright reserved Please turn over
Downloaded from hlayiso.com
Design/P1 19 DBE/November 2017
NSS – Marking Guidelines
The Joinery's general characteristics are defined by form follows function,
minimalistic approach that shows clean, craftsmanship approach echoing
Scandinavian ideals. The final products are targeted at a higher income user and
most probably business people but also someone who is an avid collector of new
and innovative designs.
The Joinery focus is on methods of production that contribute to local community
growth and partnerships with sewing co-operatives in local townships. In this
regard The Joinery was inspired by the ecological call by the design community to
discover and utilise materials for sustainable textile production. The Joinery's
choice of material reduces CO 2 emissions by recycling plastic bottles that would
have been discarded in landfills. This initiative by The Joinery has also created
numerous job opportunities for local seamstresses and informal plastic collectors.
International designer, Phillippe Starck and Emeco created the Broom Barstool,
a chair that is reclaimed, repurposed, biodegradable and durable, 90% industrial
waste, 75% waste polypropylene and 15% reclaimed wood. The material is ground
(soil) and compressed into pellets before being mixed with glass fibres and melted
so it can be injected into a mould. The Broom Chair is durable, comfortable,
fashionable, colourful and suitable for in-and outdoor use.
The Broom Barstool design considered limited space at a bar in a restaurant or
hotel, reducing stool width but maintaining the comfort. The curving shell of the
chair has been translated into a seat with softer edges that merge with the legs of
the stool.
Starck's general characteristics include the use of waste materials, technology
ensuring excellent quality with a long life, and energy conservation in production
and transportation.
Credit any other valid statements.
Q6 COGNITIVE SKILLS WEIGHTING QUESTIONS MARKS
LEVEL (20)
Lower order Remember, Recall, Recognise 30% 6.1 2
Understand, Explain, Describe 6.2 4
Middle order Apply, Implement, Organise 40% 6.1 2
6.2 6
Higher order Analyse, Compare, Interpret 6.2 2
Evaluate, Reflect 30%
Synthesise, Justify 6.1 2
6.2 2
TOTAL SECTION C: 40
GRAND TOTAL: 100
Copyright reserved
Study this subject
Recommended for this subject

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 Paper 1 NSC November 2017 Memo (Afrikaans)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2017 Question Paper (Afr)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2017 Question Paper (Eng)

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 P1 Eastern Cape Mock 2017 Memo (Afrikaans)

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 P1 Eastern Cape Mock 2017 Memo (English)

Memorandum
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC Supplementary 2017 Memo (Afrikaans)
More from Grade 12 Design

Annual teaching plan
Gr 12 Des ATP 2023 24

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC June 2025 Question Paper (Afrikaans)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2025 Question Paper (Eng)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 NSC November 2025 Question Paper (Afr)

Question paper
Design Grade 12 P1 November 2024 NSC Question Paper (Eng)

Question paper